User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Playoff Profit sharing...
Page:
 
Tito716
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Groucho
Originally posted by Tito716

http://goallineblitz.com/game/stadium.pl?team_id=3298

This is the stadium of the #1 team in my league. No we are not an expansion league.

I hope the #8 seed enjoys their 250,000 shared revenue...


This is exactly why revenue sharing is a bad idea. Under the old system, they had a financial incentive to win. Now their financial incentive is to throw games so that they can be matched up against teams with better stadiums.


My point was that lots of teams with small stadiums got that way through their own actions and choices. This as true for the example I posted as it is for teams that wind up in the 5-8 spots every year.
 
Crushr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tito716
Originally posted by Groucho

Originally posted by Tito716


http://goallineblitz.com/game/stadium.pl?team_id=3298

This is the stadium of the #1 team in my league. No we are not an expansion league.

I hope the #8 seed enjoys their 250,000 shared revenue...


This is exactly why revenue sharing is a bad idea. Under the old system, they had a financial incentive to win. Now their financial incentive is to throw games so that they can be matched up against teams with better stadiums.


My point was that lots of teams with small stadiums got that way through their own actions and choices. This as true for the example I posted as it is for teams that wind up in the 5-8 spots every year.


I just don't agree with either of these statements. You think that a team owner should sit on his team 3 seasons to build his stadium first? Who buys anything to sit on it 3 seasons? And as for the statement by Groucho that this gives them incentives to lose to be paired against a team with a bigger stadium, Thats absurd. So out of touch with reality its not even funny. First, they would have to scout the leagues stadiums.. Easy enough. Then they have to figure out what place that team is going to finish in (in other words how many they will lose and win) and also how many games they would have 'toss' to matchup with them WITHOUT missing the playoffs. And you think that a team barely making the playoffs can afford to chance that? Seriously, neither argument either of you put forth here has any merit.
Last edited Oct 2, 2008 10:07:44
 
Crushr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tito716
Originally posted by Groucho

Originally posted by Tito716


http://goallineblitz.com/game/stadium.pl?team_id=3298

This is the stadium of the #1 team in my league. No we are not an expansion league.

I hope the #8 seed enjoys their 250,000 shared revenue...


This is exactly why revenue sharing is a bad idea. Under the old system, they had a financial incentive to win. Now their financial incentive is to throw games so that they can be matched up against teams with better stadiums.


My point was that lots of teams with small stadiums got that way through their own actions and choices. This as true for the example I posted as it is for teams that wind up in the 5-8 spots every year.



And furthermore, My point is that teams with smaller stadiums got that way because they tried to build a winning/competitive team because they have players who expect to play on a team that has a shot at doing something other than getting pounded 128-0 week after week. The current playoff payout has handicapped them financially when they didnt' hit 1-4. So now not only are they strapped for cash but the teams who were better than them now have even more cash to build an even larger advantage by adding more seating than they do and acquiring more/better FA's in the offseason. Its a simple reality of the current situation and all of these red herring arguments about how it encourages losing, takes 'entitled' money away from 1-4 seeds etc etc on down list, just don't cut the mustard in my opinion.
Last edited Oct 2, 2008 10:13:09
 
Soul31
offline
Link
 
Why not just increase the playoff incentive across the board, it's not like this is real money and needs to "come from somewhere". You don't have to rob Peter to pay Paul when you live in Fantasy land.

If you make the playoff incentive $1m per team per game (rather than the pedestrian amount it is now), then the team that makes $4m per playoff game from seating, gets bumped to $5m. An extra 25% for them, that's nice and they're happy. But the visitor gets $1m too, an extra $1m they wouldn't get normally, they're very happy.

Call it Television Revenue or whatever...

Soul
 
Groucho
offline
Link
 
As for the "rich getting richer" argument, I think we should wait and see what happens with the new rules surrounding sold teams before putting this in. I think the accelerated promotion/relegation process will take care of this problem without any additional "revenue sharing" needed. Why? In many conferences, more than one team will promote up, meaning that the 5-8 teams have a better shot at that money the next year (assuming they continue to play well).
 
jdros13
offline
Link
 
If teams built a winning/competitive team they wouldn't have neglected their stadium because it is only through stadium expansion that you can pay your players a decent amount of money and take care of their upper level equipment upgrades. My team is in it's 3rd year and we have lost a total of 5 regular season games in 3 seasons and lost in the conference semi's year one to the eventual league champ and conference finals year 2. I think we would qualify as winning/competitive. 75% of our players have been with us from the start and are being paid handsomely due to the fact that we have been able to build our stadium up to over 47,000 seats going into our 3rd season. I didn't sell off a stable of players to generate cash, I simply played by the spirit of the rules and sold the tickets I could sell and sold hot dogs and jerseys to make my money. Other teams have been able to do even better.

Why in the world should I subsidize another team that is ignoring the extremely simple financial portion of this game and has fallen behind as a result? If finances are not supposed to be part of the equation and a means for differentiating teams then why even include it?
 
Crushr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdros13
If teams built a winning/competitive team they wouldn't have neglected their stadium because it is only through stadium expansion that you can pay your players a decent amount of money and take care of their upper level equipment upgrades. My team is in it's 3rd year and we have lost a total of 5 regular season games in 3 seasons and lost in the conference semi's year one to the eventual league champ and conference finals year 2. I think we would qualify as winning/competitive. 75% of our players have been with us from the start and are being paid handsomely due to the fact that we have been able to build our stadium up to over 47,000 seats going into our 3rd season. I didn't sell off a stable of players to generate cash, I simply played by the spirit of the rules and sold the tickets I could sell and sold hot dogs and jerseys to make my money. Other teams have been able to do even better.

Why in the world should I subsidize another team that is ignoring the extremely simple financial portion of this game and has fallen behind as a result? If finances are not supposed to be part of the equation and a means for differentiating teams then why even include it?



Why do you insist on making blanket statements about ALL teams that finish 5-8. And how are YOU subsidizing anything. The cash is not coming from your pocket. I believe the idea is adding new revenue. Yet another red herring 'your taking money from my pocket'.. How about owners that took over gutted teams? Do you think that they just 'are ignoring the financial aspects of the game'??? Why do you insist on getting 30 times the payout that teams 5-8 do? Do you honestly think thats a fair payout? Look at any sport and show me one that has that kind of disparity between playoff team payouts. You won't because no respectable league actually think that will work. You are not entitled to anything other than a fair payout.. Thats all I am asking for.
 
Groucho
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Crushr
And how are YOU subsidizing anything. The cash is not coming from your pocket. I believe the idea is adding new revenue.


To be fair, nobody knows how this is going to be implemented, but the very term "revenue sharing" implies that they'll be some sort of Robin Hood approach.

 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
How ticked would people be if they had to pay property tax and upkeep on their stadiums and had to purchase the concessions from vendors at wholesale prices in order to have them to sell. Then on top of that you should get taxed on your revenue, the more you make, the higher percentage you have to pay.
 
Tito716
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Crushr
Originally posted by jdros13

If teams built a winning/competitive team they wouldn't have neglected their stadium because it is only through stadium expansion that you can pay your players a decent amount of money and take care of their upper level equipment upgrades. My team is in it's 3rd year and we have lost a total of 5 regular season games in 3 seasons and lost in the conference semi's year one to the eventual league champ and conference finals year 2. I think we would qualify as winning/competitive. 75% of our players have been with us from the start and are being paid handsomely due to the fact that we have been able to build our stadium up to over 47,000 seats going into our 3rd season. I didn't sell off a stable of players to generate cash, I simply played by the spirit of the rules and sold the tickets I could sell and sold hot dogs and jerseys to make my money. Other teams have been able to do even better.

Why in the world should I subsidize another team that is ignoring the extremely simple financial portion of this game and has fallen behind as a result? If finances are not supposed to be part of the equation and a means for differentiating teams then why even include it?



Why do you insist on making blanket statements about ALL teams that finish 5-8. And how are YOU subsidizing anything. The cash is not coming from your pocket. I believe the idea is adding new revenue. Yet another red herring 'your taking money from my pocket'.. How about owners that took over gutted teams? Do you think that they just 'are ignoring the financial aspects of the game'??? Why do you insist on getting 30 times the payout that teams 5-8 do? Do you honestly think thats a fair payout? Look at any sport and show me one that has that kind of disparity between playoff team payouts. You won't because no respectable league actually think that will work. You are not entitled to anything other than a fair payout.. Thats all I am asking for.


Crushr, you keep talking about owners that took over resold teams, or that are 5-8 seeds. That's me. I have never hosted a playoff game, I have never won a playoff game. When I say that I am finally in position to host a playoff game and don't want to give up the rewards I've spent 3 years earning, you tell me that I'm greedy.

Revenue-sharing does no imply a new revenue stream, but that revenue is redistributed from wealthier teams to poorer teams. Shared, if you will.

So, given that the term "revenue sharing" was used by Bort, I tend to believe that money will be taken away from the host teams.

And yes, fairness is all relative.

Is it fair that #1-4 make millions and #5-8 make hundreds of thousands? maybe, maybe not.

Is it fair that I had to build a team to compete against teams that were making millions when I was making hundreds of thousands, and now that I am ready to make millions, I have to give money away because someone else with a team thats been around longer than mine couldn't build a team as well as me? maybe, maybe not.
 
Tito716
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
How ticked would people be if they had to pay property tax and upkeep on their stadiums and had to purchase the concessions from vendors at wholesale prices in order to have them to sell. Then on top of that you should get taxed on your revenue, the more you make, the higher percentage you have to pay.


LOL. Yeah, real sports teams don't pay that stuff either.

Property taxes are generally waived by local and state jurisidictions.

Upkeep is generally publicly financed.

Concessions are generally contracted out. In reality the team owners don't care how much stuff sells, they get paid a flat rate by the concession sellers for the right to occupy the stadium contractually.

Last edited Oct 2, 2008 10:52:46
 
Crushr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tito716
Originally posted by Rage Kinard

How ticked would people be if they had to pay property tax and upkeep on their stadiums and had to purchase the concessions from vendors at wholesale prices in order to have them to sell. Then on top of that you should get taxed on your revenue, the more you make, the higher percentage you have to pay.


LOL. Yeah, real sports teams don't pay that stuff either.

Property taxes are generally waived by local and state jurisidictions.

Upkeep is generally publicly financed.

Concessions are generally contracted out. In reality the team owners don't care how much stuff sells, they get paid a flat rate by the concession sellers for the right to occupy the stadium contractually.




You might be able to say that about concessions but certainly not team logo'd items. Still you have not contradicted my point. I believe that playoff profit sharing will increase the level of competition and the stability of teams and leagues. Its just hard to see how it will adversely affect anything. I have yet to hear any argument against it that shows how this is detrimental to GLB.
 
Tito716
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Crushr
Originally posted by Tito716

Originally posted by Rage Kinard


How ticked would people be if they had to pay property tax and upkeep on their stadiums and had to purchase the concessions from vendors at wholesale prices in order to have them to sell. Then on top of that you should get taxed on your revenue, the more you make, the higher percentage you have to pay.


LOL. Yeah, real sports teams don't pay that stuff either.

Property taxes are generally waived by local and state jurisidictions.

Upkeep is generally publicly financed.

Concessions are generally contracted out. In reality the team owners don't care how much stuff sells, they get paid a flat rate by the concession sellers for the right to occupy the stadium contractually.




You might be able to say that about concessions but certainly not team logo'd items. Still you have not contradicted my point. I believe that playoff profit sharing will increase the level of competition and the stability of teams and leagues. Its just hard to see how it will adversely affect anything. I have yet to hear any argument against it that shows how this is detrimental to GLB.


I have yet to see how giving lower seeds more money is beneficial to GLB given that teams will have the latitude to spend the money however they see fit. Sure, some will invest in their stadium, like they should have been doing all along. But, others will just spend the money overpaying players more and making certain "hard-to-find" FAs like WRs even more overpaid and hard to find.
 
Crushr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tito716
Originally posted by Crushr

Originally posted by jdros13


If teams built a winning/competitive team they wouldn't have neglected their stadium because it is only through stadium expansion that you can pay your players a decent amount of money and take care of their upper level equipment upgrades. My team is in it's 3rd year and we have lost a total of 5 regular season games in 3 seasons and lost in the conference semi's year one to the eventual league champ and conference finals year 2. I think we would qualify as winning/competitive. 75% of our players have been with us from the start and are being paid handsomely due to the fact that we have been able to build our stadium up to over 47,000 seats going into our 3rd season. I didn't sell off a stable of players to generate cash, I simply played by the spirit of the rules and sold the tickets I could sell and sold hot dogs and jerseys to make my money. Other teams have been able to do even better.

Why in the world should I subsidize another team that is ignoring the extremely simple financial portion of this game and has fallen behind as a result? If finances are not supposed to be part of the equation and a means for differentiating teams then why even include it?



Why do you insist on making blanket statements about ALL teams that finish 5-8. And how are YOU subsidizing anything. The cash is not coming from your pocket. I believe the idea is adding new revenue. Yet another red herring 'your taking money from my pocket'.. How about owners that took over gutted teams? Do you think that they just 'are ignoring the financial aspects of the game'??? Why do you insist on getting 30 times the payout that teams 5-8 do? Do you honestly think thats a fair payout? Look at any sport and show me one that has that kind of disparity between playoff team payouts. You won't because no respectable league actually think that will work. You are not entitled to anything other than a fair payout.. Thats all I am asking for.


Crushr, you keep talking about owners that took over resold teams, or that are 5-8 seeds. That's me. I have never hosted a playoff game, I have never won a playoff game. When I say that I am finally in position to host a playoff game and don't want to give up the rewards I've spent 3 years earning, you tell me that I'm greedy.

Revenue-sharing does no imply a new revenue stream, but that revenue is redistributed from wealthier teams to poorer teams. Shared, if you will.

So, given that the term "revenue sharing" was used by Bort, I tend to believe that money will be taken away from the host teams.

And yes, fairness is all relative.

Is it fair that #1-4 make millions and #5-8 make hundreds of thousands? maybe, maybe not.

Is it fair that I had to build a team to compete against teams that were making millions when I was making hundreds of thousands, and now that I am ready to make millions, I have to give money away because someone else with a team thats been around longer than mine couldn't build a team as well as me? maybe, maybe not.



Well there have been numerous ideas supported here and Bort himself proposed the tv revenue sharing as the means by which to add additional cash into the system. Sorry if you did not see that but it seems to have been the spur to the discussion about adding revenue instead of taking cash away from the 1-4 seeds. Also, good job with what you've done. But I just gotta say that when you own 17 of the players on your team, it sure makes it easier than having to recruit individual players. Not only do you save a LOT of cash by not needing as many players through FA or trades but you know game to game that all of your players at least are set and ready. So your situation is not indicative of what I believe a majority of the teams I am referring to are in. No knock on your team, I just don't feel its a fair comparison. If I had that many of my players on my team, I sure would be in a lot better position now.
 
wsdp
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard

How ticked would people be if they had to pay property tax and upkeep on their stadiums and had to purchase the concessions from vendors at wholesale prices in order to have them to sell. Then on top of that you should get taxed on your revenue, the more you make, the higher percentage you have to pay.


non playoff teams and 5-8 seeds would lose their minds
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.