User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Season 4 changes ARE going to cost this game alot of dedicated players.
Page:
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chief31
Originally posted by oldskool

If you exploit a bug (regardless of intent or knowledge on the subject), and then whine about it when that bug is fixed so that exploit is no longer dominant, you deserve to be torn into. Nobody with half a brain could think that 90 speed/10 agility was a "correct" build for a football simulation.


I'll try one more time... Do you have any idea how many of those that were complaining about SPEED being too effective you have ripped into for being "whiners" in the past?

All I have seen you do is rip people for any little question/concern/complaint that they have. So I really am guessing that you ripped alot of people for whining about the over-effectiveness of SPEED before the changes. Am I wrong?


Wrong.

I recognized speed was ridiculous, said nothing until admins posted because I didn't really care (I had half the players I do now; why would I care about speed with the likes of a lowbie HB, an OT, a DT, a DE & a K on my homepage?), found that admins were already aware & working on the fix, and went about my business.
 
chief31
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by chief31


If you were to put this all in terms of real football...

You have eleven guys on the field who are average tacklers, but very slow. (45 TACKLING, 30 SPEED) and I bring eleven guys who are poor tacklers, with good SPEED. (25 TACKLING, 50 SPEED)

What is gonna happen? We are gonna win. Every time your guys have the ball, my fast guys will be all over him. You might break some tackles, but there will be more fast guys there immediately. Because they are fast, and your guys are slow.


Nope, because they'll be there but they'll never tackle my guys. The team with 25 Tackling, 50 Speed should be the one that a power back runs through everyone on the team and gets a TD most of the time.

In real life, the LB's #1 job is to tackle. The secondary has to be very fast. But a LB who can't tackle is worthless in real life.

You used an imbalance and are complaining because it was fixed.


Lets not assume that you have a 50 on STRENGTH here with that HB, unless you want to assumwe that he has 25 SPEED and 20 CARRYING.

In which case, he will be hit with countless tackle attempts, and eventually trip over one of the missed tackles, or fumble because he has no CARRYING.

But, with my SPEED players, your just are not going to be able to catch them, when they have the ball.

If you don't believe that that is how it would work, then why is it that that is how it worked for three seasons here?

I know, it was some kind of bug. Don't we all say that when things don't go our way?

This argument had already been played-out on the field, but the losers didn't like the results, and demanded that it be changed. And so it was.

Here is a simple way for you to get a second shot at that, involving the real world.

Go to some Pee-Wee football games and have a look. Considering that this the least football-talented group that you can watch playing the game, that seems appropriate with this discussion.

Do you know what happens at Pee-Wee football games? The team with the fastest kid wins! Not every single game, but a huge majority of those early level games are won by the team that has the most SPEED.

Where does the power HB fit in? He generally just runs into alot of other kids, and falls down, unless he has more speed than the rest.

Everyone makes these comparisons for the realism of this game, to the NFL. Well, for the first couple of seasons, it should be compared to JFL. Where a passing game is some kind of freak-show, and the fastest kid wins.

The reason I say that we should be compared with JFL, then HS, then College, is because they start our players with such low numbers for skills.

If you are building a player from the nothing that GLB starts you out with, then start with SPEED. It has been proven here, and it gets proven at all beginning levels of football every single year.
Last edited Aug 15, 2008 01:47:36
 
chief31
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
Originally posted by chief31

Originally posted by oldskool


If you exploit a bug (regardless of intent or knowledge on the subject), and then whine about it when that bug is fixed so that exploit is no longer dominant, you deserve to be torn into. Nobody with half a brain could think that 90 speed/10 agility was a "correct" build for a football simulation.


I'll try one more time... Do you have any idea how many of those that were complaining about SPEED being too effective you have ripped into for being "whiners" in the past?

All I have seen you do is rip people for any little question/concern/complaint that they have. So I really am guessing that you ripped alot of people for whining about the over-effectiveness of SPEED before the changes. Am I wrong?


Wrong.

I recognized speed was ridiculous, said nothing until admins posted because I didn't really care (I had half the players I do now; why would I care about speed with the likes of a lowbie HB, an OT, a DT, a DE & a K on my homepage?), found that admins were already aware & working on the fix, and went about my business.


Like I said, I was guessing. Because you rarely seem to just mind your own business like that.

 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chief31
Originally posted by Ken1

Originally posted by chief31



If you were to put this all in terms of real football...

You have eleven guys on the field who are average tacklers, but very slow. (45 TACKLING, 30 SPEED) and I bring eleven guys who are poor tacklers, with good SPEED. (25 TACKLING, 50 SPEED)

What is gonna happen? We are gonna win. Every time your guys have the ball, my fast guys will be all over him. You might break some tackles, but there will be more fast guys there immediately. Because they are fast, and your guys are slow.


Nope, because they'll be there but they'll never tackle my guys. The team with 25 Tackling, 50 Speed should be the one that a power back runs through everyone on the team and gets a TD most of the time.

In real life, the LB's #1 job is to tackle. The secondary has to be very fast. But a LB who can't tackle is worthless in real life.

You used an imbalance and are complaining because it was fixed.


But, with my SPEED players, your just are not going to be able to catch them, when they have the ball.

If you don't believe that that is how it wopuld work, then is it that that is how it worked for three seasons here?

I know, it was some kind of bug. Don't we all say that when things don't go our way?


It was ridiculous. And I don't care about what happens in Pee-Wee. As far as I'm concerned, players start out as High Schoolers, by Level 8 they're Juco/Division 3 college, by level 16 Division 1 college, and by Level 24 NFL rookies.

Does anyone really want to play a Pee-Wee Football sim? If you want to coach Pee-Wee Football all you have to do is volunteer.

So, now instead of Wrap-Up making it so a LB on a team I GM had 20 Tackling and missed 2 tackles through all of Season 3, now if you're a LB with 20 Tackling you can't tackle, and the agent used his boosts to get his Tackling up.

You also actually now need Catching to catch the ball, etc..

This sim is a million times better than the old sim, half the bugs people attribute to it existed before it, and even with the bugs it's a million times better.

Go find a track and field simulation of you want Speed to rule all. It never should have, and the only thing I can fauly Bort for at all is not fixing it sooner.
 
Night Dragon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by chief31

Originally posted by oldskool


If you exploit a bug (regardless of intent or knowledge on the subject), and then whine about it when that bug is fixed so that exploit is no longer dominant, you deserve to be torn into. Nobody with half a brain could think that 90 speed/10 agility was a "correct" build for a football simulation.


I'll try one more time... Do you have any idea how many of those that were complaining about SPEED being too effective you have ripped into for being "whiners" in the past?

All I have seen you do is rip people for any little question/concern/complaint that they have. So I really am guessing that you ripped alot of people for whining about the over-effectiveness of SPEED before the changes. Am I wrong?



People were complaining "Balance the game!" before.

Now it's different because people are complaining, "Damn you for balancing the game! My minmaxing, unrealistic football players should have ruled forever! And while you're at it, what happened to those fun 9-3 games? TD's are for wimps!"


Sigh

The assumptions made by some people here are getting unbelievable anymore. It's not even about any of that. We just want to know about changes in a timely manner. Before you go on this rant about we were told about speed, the original poster didn't even care about speed as much but was using it as an example. Things are fluid without knowing whats going on. That was his main point. I want the game to be better like the next guy, but we just want some insight on what changes are being made.

As an example, (and has nothing to do with the current state of the game) if zone coverage is better than man coverage, then logic would dictate that using it 100% of the time would be the wisest choice. Is that real football? No. Obviously Bort would need to make changes to make man cov more viable. The problem is none of us are told that he made changes. If some thinks he made a change to man cov, they run it the next game and at the same time, Bort didn't like his implementations and reverted back to the old system. Those teams get burned by a lack of updated knowledge.

We had a dominant pass rusher for the pass couple of seasons. He lead in a lot of categories previous seasons. You can tell by his bars he isn't built poorly.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=102949
Game one he gets 8 sacks. Complete absurd, I agree. Some kind of change was made and now he can't even get pressure on the QB.
Then there is this guy:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=123897
Bars are all low, yet he is completely unblockable and is dominating the entire league. He might be soft capped at str, agi, and speed, but how in the hell can he be superior to a majority of the league. If bars are the only thing we have to tell us how to make the proper build and that isn't true, then what are we supposed to do? Is this guy using an exploit the minority only know about? Is it even an exploit? I'm not trying to have his build torn down in anyway, because I enjoy challenges. The problem is, not understanding what is going on from day to day. My D-end is built to be a bull rusher, but it seems that has been nerfed in favor of the elusive one. Then tomorrow their will be a secret change that nerfs the elusive one in favor of the bull rusher. The problem with the previous sentence is the word secret.

I don't care about speed not being associated with acceleration and previous speed guys were using exploits. I don't care that this is or isn't a Beta. I don't care that Bort is on the Money magazines top list for one of the richest men alive. All I want is a simple text that takes less than one minute of Bort time to say what changes he made for the days sims and why he made it.
Last edited Aug 15, 2008 02:13:45
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zadith
[
I did not say there are not some good things about the "never going to happen" list and but some of the things on there are obviously never going to happen.

As for saying there will never be a draft or non-boosting leagues...those are good things to "never" have?!? Please explain that to me...

Bort could charge a certain amount of money to join a non-boosting league or a certain amount a month for players that dislike having to boost every season and would rather put more pressure on building your players and everyone being around the same level. Same thing with a league that drafts...


If the non-boosting leagues cost as much as fully boosting leagues cost, I wouldn't have a problem with them. But I'd hate to think I was paying money to boost players that would go to subsidize freeloaders who could have their own free, non-boosting league where others wouldn't rocket past them with boosts. again, if they pay as much as I am, I'd have no problem.

That's not what most people who want non-boosting leagues want. They want to freeload without the negative of people jumping ahead of them.

As far as drafts, what I like is knowing that I can create players and know that I'll never be forced into going to a team I don't choose. Again, "leagues that draft" isn't what most who call for a draft desire. They want to require all players to go through a draft.
 
chief31
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by chief31

Originally posted by Ken1


Originally posted by chief31




If you were to put this all in terms of real football...

You have eleven guys on the field who are average tacklers, but very slow. (45 TACKLING, 30 SPEED) and I bring eleven guys who are poor tacklers, with good SPEED. (25 TACKLING, 50 SPEED)

What is gonna happen? We are gonna win. Every time your guys have the ball, my fast guys will be all over him. You might break some tackles, but there will be more fast guys there immediately. Because they are fast, and your guys are slow.


Nope, because they'll be there but they'll never tackle my guys. The team with 25 Tackling, 50 Speed should be the one that a power back runs through everyone on the team and gets a TD most of the time.

In real life, the LB's #1 job is to tackle. The secondary has to be very fast. But a LB who can't tackle is worthless in real life.

You used an imbalance and are complaining because it was fixed.


But, with my SPEED players, your just are not going to be able to catch them, when they have the ball.

If you don't believe that that is how it wopuld work, then is it that that is how it worked for three seasons here?

I know, it was some kind of bug. Don't we all say that when things don't go our way?


It was ridiculous. And I don't care about what happens in Pee-Wee. As far as I'm concerned, players start out as High Schoolers, by Level 8 they're Juco/Division 3 college, by level 16 Division 1 college, and by Level 24 NFL rookies.

Does anyone really want to play a Pee-Wee Football sim? If you want to coach Pee-Wee Football all you have to do is volunteer.

So, now instead of Wrap-Up making it so a LB on a team I GM had 20 Tackling and missed 2 tackles through all of Season 3, now if you're a LB with 20 Tackling you can't tackle, and the agent used his boosts to get his Tackling up.

You also actually now need Catching to catch the ball, etc..

This sim is a million times better than the old sim, half the bugs people attribute to it existed before it, and even with the bugs it's a million times better.

Go find a track and field simulation of you want Speed to rule all. It never should have, and the only thing I can fauly Bort for at all is not fixing it sooner.


Pee-wee football is relative, because you start with 8s and 10s on so many attributes. I don't like that either, but the way they start with player builds is not consistent with high school players.

High school players already have more than what would translate to an 8 in any skill.

The way you align GLB levels with levels of football is completely awkward. How many players can get from high school to the pros in a season and a half? That's ludacris.

They said that the lifespan of a GLB player will be ten years, before attrition, because that is a long lifespan for an NFL player. But is a level one GLB player, going against a level 40 GLB player going to be equivelant to an NFL rookie going against a veteran?

It looks more like the scenario that I gave you of the level 1 being a child.

I understand that noone wants to compare their level 7 HB to a JV player, but that is about what it boils down to.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Re: Night Dragon, I'll agree with you that I'd like to know more about significant changes to the game that are made, and more (without knowing enough that minmaxers can easily minmax) about what abilities do. It's just not make or break for me; but I'd like to know more, too.

That isn't what I see people complaining about, though. They're complaining about Speed no longer dominating, people breaking tackles, that their player misses tackles or gives up completions or drops passes, etc.. And how dare a change be made that allows that? Those are the complaints that drive me nuts.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
I too would like to know more, but the playerbase won't allow it.

The only way he could do it would be something basic, i.e. "Nerfed power running style"; and that leads to widespread panic because we don't know HOW power running was nerfed or WHY it was nerfed or why it was nerfed when it was or what skills/SAs it affects, so the forums are full of people asking about it.

Multiply that panic times the number of times Bort tweaks the sim (hint: it's a lot) and you've got yourselves a clusterfuck.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chief31
Originally posted by Ken1

Originally posted by chief31


Originally posted by Ken1



Originally posted by chief31





If you were to put this all in terms of real football...

You have eleven guys on the field who are average tacklers, but very slow. (45 TACKLING, 30 SPEED) and I bring eleven guys who are poor tacklers, with good SPEED. (25 TACKLING, 50 SPEED)

What is gonna happen? We are gonna win. Every time your guys have the ball, my fast guys will be all over him. You might break some tackles, but there will be more fast guys there immediately. Because they are fast, and your guys are slow.


Nope, because they'll be there but they'll never tackle my guys. The team with 25 Tackling, 50 Speed should be the one that a power back runs through everyone on the team and gets a TD most of the time.

In real life, the LB's #1 job is to tackle. The secondary has to be very fast. But a LB who can't tackle is worthless in real life.

You used an imbalance and are complaining because it was fixed.


But, with my SPEED players, your just are not going to be able to catch them, when they have the ball.

If you don't believe that that is how it wopuld work, then is it that that is how it worked for three seasons here?

I know, it was some kind of bug. Don't we all say that when things don't go our way?


It was ridiculous. And I don't care about what happens in Pee-Wee. As far as I'm concerned, players start out as High Schoolers, by Level 8 they're Juco/Division 3 college, by level 16 Division 1 college, and by Level 24 NFL rookies.

Does anyone really want to play a Pee-Wee Football sim? If you want to coach Pee-Wee Football all you have to do is volunteer.

So, now instead of Wrap-Up making it so a LB on a team I GM had 20 Tackling and missed 2 tackles through all of Season 3, now if you're a LB with 20 Tackling you can't tackle, and the agent used his boosts to get his Tackling up.

You also actually now need Catching to catch the ball, etc..

This sim is a million times better than the old sim, half the bugs people attribute to it existed before it, and even with the bugs it's a million times better.

Go find a track and field simulation of you want Speed to rule all. It never should have, and the only thing I can fauly Bort for at all is not fixing it sooner.


Pee-wee football is relative, because you start with 8s and 10s on so many attributes. I don't like that either, but the way they start with player builds is not consistent with high school players.

High school players already have more than what would translate to an 8 in any skill.

The way you align GLB levels with levels of football is completely awkward. How many players can get from high school to the pros in a season and a half? That's ludacris.

They said that the lifespan of a GLB player will be ten years, before attrition, because that is a long lifespan for an NFL player. But is a level one GLB player, going against a level 40 GLB player going to be equivelant to an NFL rookie going against a veteran?

It looks more like the scenario that I gave you of the level 1 being a child.

I understand that noone wants to compare their level 7 HB to a JV player, but that is about what it boils down to.


8s and 10s in attributes that aren't needed for a position (and never get raised by players anyway)? I'm sure there are NFL Pro Bowl players with 8's in Punting (they just aren't punters).

Once you get a starting build based on position and add the 15 points, you have a high school freshman, IMO. I pegged each increase to eq upgrade levels, as it fits that the higher the level one plays at the better eq one has.

You go through the low levels very fast for the same reason adventure MMORPGs let people go through newbieness fast: It's condensed because it would be no fun otherwise. So, you rocket to major college pretty fast, before slowing down...and even college takes a year or two or so if you boost. It's to keep the game enjoyable.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
I too would like to know more, but the playerbase won't allow it.

The only way he could do it would be something basic, i.e. "Nerfed power running style"; and that leads to widespread panic because we don't know HOW power running was nerfed or WHY it was nerfed or why it was nerfed when it was or what skills/SAs it affects, so the forums are full of people asking about it.

Multiply that panic times the number of times Bort tweaks the sim (hint: it's a lot) and you've got yourselves a clusterfuck.


True about changes...but if, say, zone defenses were dominant (as the other poster gives as a hypothetical example) and Bort balanced it, then people ought to know so they could stop playing 100% zone.

More to the point, everyone should know the answer to the question "Does X affect Y?" where X is an attribute or a SA and Y is an outcome-- not exact formulas of course, but if I want my WR to win more ball fights, where do I put points? That sort of thing.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by oldskool
I too would like to know more, but the playerbase won't allow it.

The only way he could do it would be something basic, i.e. "Nerfed power running style"; and that leads to widespread panic because we don't know HOW power running was nerfed or WHY it was nerfed or why it was nerfed when it was or what skills/SAs it affects, so the forums are full of people asking about it.

Multiply that panic times the number of times Bort tweaks the sim (hint: it's a lot) and you've got yourselves a clusterfuck.


True about changes...but if, say, zone defenses were dominant (as the other poster gives as a hypothetical example) and Bort balanced it, then people ought to know so they could stop playing 100% zone.

More to the point, everyone should know the answer to the question "Does X affect Y?" where X is an attribute or a SA and Y is an outcome-- not exact formulas of course, but if I want my WR to win more ball fights, where do I put points? That sort of thing.


Every time it happens, shit starts. Look at the "Blocking for defense? BALDERDASH!" topics of a couple seasons ago. If anybody cared about special teams it'd be "Jumping for kickers/punters? HOGWASH!".

Would it be nice, of course it would, but considering the backlash they get every time they leak any information at all that's not "common knowledge", I can see why they don't.
 
Night Dragon
offline
Link
 
I appreciate both of your cantor. Sometimes you two can come off as very demeaning.

Old, I see what you are saying. I counter that Bort has to have thicker skin and ignore it with the understanding he is making the game better. He knew what he was getting into. People will always be upset. I wasn't exactly happy with some of the new changes, but was willing to adapt because I understand the grand scheme for the betterment of the game. I just hate feeling like I have a clue about something, but I might as well throw that in the garbage the next day. Feeling clueless all the time makes this game less fun by the day.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
Originally posted by Ken1

Originally posted by oldskool

I too would like to know more, but the playerbase won't allow it.

The only way he could do it would be something basic, i.e. "Nerfed power running style"; and that leads to widespread panic because we don't know HOW power running was nerfed or WHY it was nerfed or why it was nerfed when it was or what skills/SAs it affects, so the forums are full of people asking about it.

Multiply that panic times the number of times Bort tweaks the sim (hint: it's a lot) and you've got yourselves a clusterfuck.


True about changes...but if, say, zone defenses were dominant (as the other poster gives as a hypothetical example) and Bort balanced it, then people ought to know so they could stop playing 100% zone.

More to the point, everyone should know the answer to the question "Does X affect Y?" where X is an attribute or a SA and Y is an outcome-- not exact formulas of course, but if I want my WR to win more ball fights, where do I put points? That sort of thing.


Every time it happens, shit starts. Look at the "Blocking for defense? BALDERDASH!" topics of a couple seasons ago. If anybody cared about special teams it'd be "Jumping for kickers/punters? HOGWASH!".

Would it be nice, of course it would, but considering the backlash they get every time they leak any information at all that's not "common knowledge", I can see why they don't.


Well, I have a punter, and I'm glad he revealed about Jumping being needed as a support ability or I'd never have trained it as I have. I just wish I knew what it helped (distance, hang time, what?)
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Let's not forget the ignorance factor, though: look how many posts there have been about the security change, about "change it back so i don't have to log on every time"...there's a topic right in Announcements (two, even) that clearly state what went on, how it's fixed, what changes were made and why.

More information's good, but it doesn't solve the problems we all wish it'd solve.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.