User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > ATTN: Tying Flex Points to Contracts as an Incentive or Condition
Page:
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed

Yes, there's a small group of people who are theoretically impossible to catch, but if someone on my team stops being one of those people and falls behind, then it would be better for me to go out to, say, the Mustangs, the Nasty, the Coyotes, etc., and try to take away from their talent pool than for me to spend real money to temporarily keep that player or 2 boosted.


What makes that better? You agree that this replacement player would be a lower level than the original, correct?

This may be what *you* would do in that situation, but it doesn't mean that *everyone* would do the same thing. By allowing FP "gifts," my scenario is still a possibility.

Originally posted by Jed
After that incident, new rules were put in place to make sure nothing like that happens again.


The difference here is that the new rules don't do anything to make sure that nothing like FP transfers happen again. The new rule only prevents FP contracts. This exacerbates the problem. Before this rule was in place, lower-level team owners had a fighting chance to land the highest level players because they could offer the same FP bonuses that the current owners could offer them. Now, this rule has taken away the new owners' ability to offer FP to potential recruits. Thus, these players are not going to go anywhere as long as they can continue to receive FP from their current owners.
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by morgan3
Bring it on Jed, Lets start a server restart so people can stop complaining about not being able to catch the boosters, then when the boosters boost people will complain again. It will all be a vicious cycle, but hey my player would be better since I know more


Certainly not my decision, and Bort has said he doesn't want to do another reset. I just wanted to make it publicly clear that, if there was a reset (which I would assume would come with a FP refund), I wouldn't mind one bit. If it's ever brought up as an option, I certainly won't vote against it.

Originally posted by morgan3
Jed also, is a 7 day forum ban the worst you can do? I mean come on they are still going to be able to recruit and use these antics and get the players. It requires a permanent account ban if you guys don't want this rule to be a joke


Personally, I agree, there could be harsher penalties, but this is an attempt to hopefully stop this from happening before having to go that far. Recruiting or finding a team is tougher to do without forum access, and no one likes to lose their posting privilages.

If you're right and this doesn't seem to deter people (or if the movement grows, just more underground than it is now), more harsh penalties may have to be put in place.

I know this isn't realistic, but in an ideal situation, we would just say "please don't do this, it's against the rules" and people wouldn't. The penalty shouldn't be the reason this doesn't happen, it should be because it's against the rules.
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Side note: I also support a complete reset.
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
I guarantee you we'd move up quickly and go back to being one of the top teams pretty quickly.


The old guarantee of something that can never be tested. Nice.
 
morgan3
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed


Personally, I agree, there could be harsher penalties, but this is an attempt to hopefully stop this from happening before having to go that far. Recruiting or finding a team is tougher to do without forum access, and no one likes to lose their posting privilages.


When you are banned from the forums you can still view forums you just cant post. How is this going to stop an owner from sending a PM saying we will give you FP. I mean all the posts in the forums seem to be like PM sent or, Contract Offered. So all your doing to them is stopping them from bumping a thread, but they are still allowed to continue this act.

P.S. I know what you can or can't do with a forum ban because I have had 2, I had to PM everyone on my new team I got because I couldn't post in the forums!!!
Last edited Jul 14, 2008 14:20:02
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by awesome
Originally posted by Jed


Yes, there's a small group of people who are theoretically impossible to catch, but if someone on my team stops being one of those people and falls behind, then it would be better for me to go out to, say, the Mustangs, the Nasty, the Coyotes, etc., and try to take away from their talent pool than for me to spend real money to temporarily keep that player or 2 boosted.


What makes that better? You agree that this replacement player would be a lower level than the original, correct?

This may be what *you* would do in that situation, but it doesn't mean that *everyone* would do the same thing. By allowing FP "gifts," my scenario is still a possibility.


No, I'm talking about recruiting someone else the same level from an opponents' team. That would leave me in an equal situation as before and my opponent would be worse off for it. That means it's a much larger win than me paying for a player's boost.

Originally posted by awesome
Originally posted by Jed

After that incident, new rules were put in place to make sure nothing like that happens again.


The difference here is that the new rules don't do anything to make sure that nothing like FP transfers happen again. The new rule only prevents FP contracts. This exacerbates the problem. Before this rule was in place, lower-level team owners had a fighting chance to land the highest level players because they could offer the same FP bonuses that the current owners could offer them. Now, this rule has taken away the new owners' ability to offer FP to potential recruits. Thus, these players are not going to go anywhere as long as they can continue to receive FP from their current owners.


Maybe it's not clear, but we fully intend to punish teams who are proven to be using FP to keep players on their team as much as we are going to punish owners who are trying to get new players. For this rule, signing a contract is signing a contract, it doesn't matter if it's with a current or new team.
 
1VBChaos
offline
Link
 
You make good points Jed - and you're a million miles away from the name calling that's gone before from your 'colleagues'.

The only thing I still take issue with is whether any of the previous actions have been 'illegal'. I think we'd all concede that they didn't break any 'rules' that were in place - however, I'd contest that they contravened the spirit of the game.

Your stance - where you've policed yourself to not get involved in anything that MIGHT be viewed as wrong (whether it strictly is or isn't against the rules) is commendable.

All I'm saying is it's a shame that the rest can't be like that, because this place would be FAR easier to police if it was.

Right now, you've got some players simply emulating what they've seen some testers/mods doing - or in SI's case, doing what a mod told him would be within the rules as they currently stand, albeit not strictly sanctioned....so who's most at fault??

Anyway - hopefully you can knock some sense into a couple of the others and I reckon we'd all be happy....
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed


Maybe it's not clear, but we fully intend to punish teams who are proven to be using FP to keep players on their team as much as we are going to punish owners who are trying to get new players. For this rule, signing a contract is signing a contract, it doesn't matter if it's with a current or new team.


Then you will have to ban all FP transactions between team members. The whole reason that team members would give each other FP is so they will stay together and be competitive. This is inherently tied with signing a contract.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by awesome
Originally posted by Jed
Maybe it's not clear, but we fully intend to punish teams who are proven to be using FP to keep players on their team as much as we are going to punish owners who are trying to get new players. For this rule, signing a contract is signing a contract, it doesn't matter if it's with a current or new team.


Then you will have to ban all FP transactions between team members. The whole reason that team members would give each other FP is so they will stay together and be competitive. This is inherently tied with signing a contract.


Ding ding ding.

Originally posted by lame excuse that apparently is acceptable and will not result in punishment
I'm going to paypal everyone on my GMed team $10. Because they're all my friends! That's why they always re-sign with me year after year, we're buddies like that. I love my friends.

Oh uh, that new guy we just signed? Also my friend. That's why he got $10. Because I love my friends. Remember?


Congratulations on another obvious loophole.
 
morgan3
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool

Originally posted by lame excuse that apparently is acceptable and will not result in punishment

I'm going to paypal everyone on my GMed team $10. Because they're all my friends! That's why they always re-sign with me year after year, we're buddies like that. I love my friends.

Oh uh, that new guy we just signed? Also my friend. That's why he got $10. Because I love my friends. Remember?


Congratulations on another obvious loophole.


Wait you mean we cant pay people on our team? Thats not a rule! Thats an assumption!

This is what you will hear from everyone who gets banned for paying a player on their team already, or joins their team and gets FP at the end of the year.
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
And in those cases, we'll examine the evidence the best we can to decide if that's the case. And before you ask, no, I'm not going to define the EXACT criteria we're going to use, because that would just invite people to try to work around those criteria to beat the system. Just know we're aiming to stop people from giving out FP contracts, not to stop the actual honest people.
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
And in those cases, we'll examine the evidence the best we can to decide if that's the case. And before you ask, no, I'm not going to define the EXACT criteria we're going to use, because that would just invite people to try to work around those criteria to beat the system. Just know we're aiming to stop people from giving out FP contracts, not to stop the actual honest people.


And there is the whole problem. You will be deciding on whether yourselves violated the rule that yourselves drafted. I think it is a foregone conclusion as to the outcome of this inquiry.
 
1VBChaos
offline
Link
 
Sorry - but you'll have to forgive me this one comment....

Does your actual 'honesty' depend on who you know??
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
And in those cases, we'll examine the evidence the best we can to decide if that's the case. And before you ask, no, I'm not going to define the EXACT criteria we're going to use, because that would just invite people to try to work around those criteria to beat the system. Just know we're aiming to stop people from giving out FP contracts, not to stop the actual honest people.


OK, we'll roleplay.
Given my example PM:

Originally posted by lame excuse that apparently is acceptable and will not result in punishment
I'm going to paypal everyone on my GMed team $10. Because they're all my friends! That's why they always re-sign with me year after year, we're buddies like that. I love my friends.

Oh uh, that new guy we just signed? Also my friend. That's why he got $10. Because I love my friends. Remember?

...is this person suspended? Banned? Reprimanded?

Conspiracy theory alert: the test for whether or not you're an "honest person" when it comes to offering FP is whether or not there's black bold letters under your forum avatar.

You have still done NOTHING to make any of us believe that is not the case beyond empty "We'll punish them!" threats that are completely cancelled out by "We the moderators will determine whether or not to punish the moderators using a rule the moderators drew up" rhetoric.
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool


Originally posted by Some GM on one of YOUR teams

I'm going to paypal everyone on my GMed team $10. Because they're all my friends! That's why they always re-sign with me year after year, we're buddies like that. I love my friends.

Oh uh, that new guy we just signed? Also my friend. That's why he got $10. Because I love my friends. Remember?

...is this person suspended? Banned? Reprimanded?



 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.