Originally posted by bhall43
Originally posted by Seric
It has all the relevance. You obviously don't know what a signing cap is.
I find it funny, that you seem to pick up the attitudes of others but don't seem to have your own. One person has stated something to the effect of "people care about the minors?" and now it's LOLminors for you. Someone stated something, so you quote them as if that's what you've been saying when it's not.
Get your own platform. Stop using others.
You telling me that I dont know what a signing cap is...is not relevant. lol...its just something you continue to do...like the english statement...you just keep saying things that aren't relevant.
The argument is that because of the signing cap, people aren't allowed to sign players to the same level as the players coming into these leagues. Therefore its a flaw in the system.
I wouldn't keep repeating it if you actually understood it.
A signing cap means you can't sign a player who is over the cap. It has NOTHING to do with players that are ALREADY on the team.
Originally posted by Grr8WhiteHype
The promoting is inconsistent and by far the biggest problem with the game.
For example I OC/DC a team in cap 14. We were cap 14 last season and started with all level 1's except 4-5 guys at level 4 or 5. At the end of the season we finished in the bottom two of the league. That makes us automatically stay in cap 14. However the level 4 and 5 guys were level 15-18. We got informed that because we had a handful of guys over cap 14 we had to go to cap 18. We ended up cutting those guys and requesting to be put back down in cap 14 which they did.
So if a team based on promotion rules should stay down but wasn't allowed do to having players over the cap then why the hell do they allow teams with almost every player over the cap to promote to a level beneath them (like the team in the OP)?
It's inconsistent and quite honestly B.S. If you want to end this crap then build a computer check (relatively easy to do) that looks at every team's average level (not effective level) and automatically bump all teams to a cap that is at or above that average number. This doesn't completely eliminate the problem but paired with the rules already in place 99% of the cases would be eliminated. You can then take on two or three volunteers (plenty would be willing) who run a support like system where people can report cases of people purposefully trying to skew and cheat the system (like a cap 30 team that has 37 guys lvl 40 and 18 players lvl 1).
Originally posted by http://goallineblitz.com/demotion_faq.html
How does promotion and demotion work in the Minor Leagues?
The minor leagues are set up in a level capped system, which is designed to grow with the normal level progression of players. There is no forced demotion in the minor leagues.
- All teams who make the playoffs are promoted up by 2 level caps.
- The two teams who made the championship game may request to move up 3 level caps by selecting the option via their team's "edit profile" page.
- The bottom two teams in each conference remain in the same level cap, unless the players on the team are above that cap, in which case the will go up by 1 level cap.
- The rest of the teams in the league move up 1 level cap.
States it right there.
As for why they make it happen, because unlike the teams that finished 15 and 16th, the teams that missed the playoffs actually put the effort out to win (unless you're building a slow build team which I could see being 15 or 16.) but not all the teams that end at 15 or 16 are slow build teams.
Originally posted by Seric
It has all the relevance. You obviously don't know what a signing cap is.
I find it funny, that you seem to pick up the attitudes of others but don't seem to have your own. One person has stated something to the effect of "people care about the minors?" and now it's LOLminors for you. Someone stated something, so you quote them as if that's what you've been saying when it's not.
Get your own platform. Stop using others.
You telling me that I dont know what a signing cap is...is not relevant. lol...its just something you continue to do...like the english statement...you just keep saying things that aren't relevant.
The argument is that because of the signing cap, people aren't allowed to sign players to the same level as the players coming into these leagues. Therefore its a flaw in the system.
I wouldn't keep repeating it if you actually understood it.
A signing cap means you can't sign a player who is over the cap. It has NOTHING to do with players that are ALREADY on the team.
Originally posted by Grr8WhiteHype
The promoting is inconsistent and by far the biggest problem with the game.
For example I OC/DC a team in cap 14. We were cap 14 last season and started with all level 1's except 4-5 guys at level 4 or 5. At the end of the season we finished in the bottom two of the league. That makes us automatically stay in cap 14. However the level 4 and 5 guys were level 15-18. We got informed that because we had a handful of guys over cap 14 we had to go to cap 18. We ended up cutting those guys and requesting to be put back down in cap 14 which they did.
So if a team based on promotion rules should stay down but wasn't allowed do to having players over the cap then why the hell do they allow teams with almost every player over the cap to promote to a level beneath them (like the team in the OP)?
It's inconsistent and quite honestly B.S. If you want to end this crap then build a computer check (relatively easy to do) that looks at every team's average level (not effective level) and automatically bump all teams to a cap that is at or above that average number. This doesn't completely eliminate the problem but paired with the rules already in place 99% of the cases would be eliminated. You can then take on two or three volunteers (plenty would be willing) who run a support like system where people can report cases of people purposefully trying to skew and cheat the system (like a cap 30 team that has 37 guys lvl 40 and 18 players lvl 1).
Originally posted by http://goallineblitz.com/demotion_faq.html
How does promotion and demotion work in the Minor Leagues?
The minor leagues are set up in a level capped system, which is designed to grow with the normal level progression of players. There is no forced demotion in the minor leagues.
- All teams who make the playoffs are promoted up by 2 level caps.
- The two teams who made the championship game may request to move up 3 level caps by selecting the option via their team's "edit profile" page.
- The bottom two teams in each conference remain in the same level cap, unless the players on the team are above that cap, in which case the will go up by 1 level cap.
- The rest of the teams in the league move up 1 level cap.
States it right there.
As for why they make it happen, because unlike the teams that finished 15 and 16th, the teams that missed the playoffs actually put the effort out to win (unless you're building a slow build team which I could see being 15 or 16.) but not all the teams that end at 15 or 16 are slow build teams.
Edited by Seric on May 23, 2010 22:36:55
Edited by Seric on May 23, 2010 22:33:49





on so many levels























