User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Free for All > Do you believe in Evolution?
Page:
 
cbarge
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AFCesc4


You're right, we have tamed jackals and wolves and cross breed them for generations upon generations to be domesticated. But they are still DOGS! They have never been anything other than dogs! Dogs is all they are and dogs is all they will ever be!


There never were dogs before humans bred them. You missed the point. I just demonstrated what you were saying about dogs but with jackals.

Jackals evolved into dogs. This is just one of several thousand well-documented examples of evolution.
 
rams78110
ROIT
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cbarge
Originally posted by AFCesc4



You're right, we have tamed jackals and wolves and cross breed them for generations upon generations to be domesticated. But they are still DOGS! They have never been anything other than dogs! Dogs is all they are and dogs is all they will ever be!


There never were dogs before humans bred them. You missed the point. I just demonstrated what you were saying about dogs but with jackals.

Jackals evolved into dogs. This is just one of several thousand well-documented examples of evolution.


afc thinks humans created dogs? wow i figured he would say god did that
Last edited Jun 11, 2008 21:18:08
 
AFCesc4
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cbarge
Originally posted by AFCesc4

You're right, I didn't. Excellent observation, but the chances are so small, and I'm not talking about Greece winning the 2004 Euros either, I'm talking about an astronomically small chance of this happening.

Let me give you an example and you tell me if this seems logically possible to you.

Lets suppose that the chair I am sitting in is made of only two things: oak wood, and iron (for the nails to hold it together). Ok, two things. Iron, and oak. Simple enough. Lets take a forest full of only oak trees, and I mean a ton of oak trees along with tons and tons of iron ore in its purest form sitting on the forest floor. Then, you take a tornado and run it through that forest full of only oak trees and iron ore. Would you ever expect that that tornado could even remotely possibly "create" a chair equivalent to that of a skilled craftsman? I mean does that make logical sense to you? Or would it be easier for you to believe that, hey, maybe it was created on purpose, with a design, by an intelligent human?

Which makes more sense?


Even though the analogy is largely irrelevant for reasons far too technical to go into here, I will oblige.

As a mathematician I can tell you that probabilistically, given 13 billion years, you'd be surprised at what becomes nigh-certainty.


My point is chance. Chance makes no sense to me. On the other hand intelligent design does, and that is the point of the illustration. In this instance chance makes no sense, even if you add 13 billions of years into the equation. A chair would never be created from that chaos, yet evolutionists are willing to believe that life (whatever life is) was created by chance in the form of a single celled organism that is infinitely more complex than any oak chair. That's my point.
 
cbarge
offline
Link
 
Here's something else that might be compelling to "non-believers"

A bacteria has evolved that can consume nylon, a product invented only in 1935. Prior to the evolution of this organism, nothing on Earth could break down the chemical structure of nylon.
 
001brow
offline
Link
 
Evolution in a nutshell. (Once you read it, try making the boat something living)

I have a boat, and over time some parts of it do not work as well as before (because of the weather), so I get parts that I can attach to the boat so it will work better, these new parts work well, so I keep them on the boat. Then after a longer period of time another part of my boat becomes less than useful, so I get a new part, but this makes my boat to heavy, so I either have to remove the part or sink. I find a better, lighter part that does the same job, so I attach that to my boat. I keep adding more and more parts onto my boat so that it becomes as good as it can for where I am. Can you not see that the boat would not be the same boat I started with, it had evolved into a boat that was needed as what was started with did not work for the conditions.

Sorry for the crappy analogy, but it's the best I could come up with without going overboard. Feel free to add to it (see it evolve in front of your eyes!) or poke holes in it.
 
cbarge
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AFCesc4

My point is chance. Chance makes no sense to me.


Well there's your problem. Probability can be very counter-intuitive and confusing. Just because you don't understand it, that doesn't mean it's wrong.
 
rams78110
ROIT
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cbarge
Here's something else that might be compelling to "non-believers"

A bacteria has evolved that can consume nylon, a product invented only in 1935. Prior to the evolution of this organism, nothing on Earth could break down the chemical structure of nylon.


Someone will say "god made it do that"

i know its coming
 
cbarge
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rams78110
Originally posted by cbarge

Here's something else that might be compelling to "non-believers"

A bacteria has evolved that can consume nylon, a product invented only in 1935. Prior to the evolution of this organism, nothing on Earth could break down the chemical structure of nylon.


Someone will say "god made it do that"

i know its coming


Either way it weakens any theory of intelligent design. They might as well say that the intelligent designer is the one who controls evolution.
 
rams78110
ROIT
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cbarge
Originally posted by rams78110

Originally posted by cbarge


Here's something else that might be compelling to "non-believers"

A bacteria has evolved that can consume nylon, a product invented only in 1935. Prior to the evolution of this organism, nothing on Earth could break down the chemical structure of nylon.


Someone will say "god made it do that"

i know its coming


Either way it weakens any theory of intelligent design. They might as well say that the intelligent designer is the one who controls evolution.


And they blindly follow the creator of intelligence... makes them all the more smarter
 
AFCesc4
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cbarge
Originally posted by AFCesc4


My point is chance. Chance makes no sense to me.


Well there's your problem. Probability can be very counter-intuitive and confusing. Just because you don't understand it, that doesn't mean it's wrong.


You misunderstood me then, I understand chance, that's why evolution makes no sense. Evolution is dependent on chance, which isn't anything to base science on.

Because evolution depends on chance, evolution makes no sense to me. If it had its basis in something a little more substantial, it might work in my mind.
 
AFCesc4
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 001brow
Evolution in a nutshell. (Once you read it, try making the boat something living)

I have a boat, and over time some parts of it do not work as well as before (because of the weather), so I get parts that I can attach to the boat so it will work better, these new parts work well, so I keep them on the boat. Then after a longer period of time another part of my boat becomes less than useful, so I get a new part, but this makes my boat to heavy, so I either have to remove the part or sink. I find a better, lighter part that does the same job, so I attach that to my boat. I keep adding more and more parts onto my boat so that it becomes as good as it can for where I am. Can you not see that the boat would not be the same boat I started with, it had evolved into a boat that was needed as what was started with did not work for the conditions.

Sorry for the crappy analogy, but it's the best I could come up with without going overboard. Feel free to add to it (see it evolve in front of your eyes!) or poke holes in it.


Excellent example, but again, this boat didn't turn into a plane did it? Or a car? Or a dirtbike? Or anything else... it's still just a boat. I understand things changing for the better, but to change into something other than what it is makes no sense to me logically.
 
cbarge
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AFCesc4
Because evolution depends on chance, evolution makes no sense to me. If it had its basis in something a little more substantial, it might work in my mind.


Lots of scientific principles are founded on the mathematical principles of probability theory. That doesn't make them any less true. You don't hear people clamoring to remove Quantum Mechanics from physics textbooks, and that involves just as much probability as evolution does.

Evolution makes no sense to you. Let's leave it at that. I'm obviously not going to convince you and that isn't my goal, I love science and I will always love discussing science even to the least receptive of audiences.
 
nit2wnit
offline
Link
 
There can't be evolution without creation first. You can't evolve from nothing. You can't make crack without cocaine. Crack evolved from Cocaine. The coca plant yields the cocaine. A seed grows into the plant. Where does the seed come from?
 
rams78110
ROIT
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nit2wnit
There can't be evolution without creation first. You can't evolve from nothing. You can't make crack without cocaine. Crack evolved from Cocaine. The coca plant yields the cocaine. A seed grows into the plant. Where does the seed come from?


where does whatever "created" everything come from?

=D
 
cbarge
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nit2wnit
There can't be evolution without creation first. You can't evolve from nothing. You can't make crack without cocaine. Crack evolved from Cocaine. The coca plant yields the cocaine. A seed grows into the plant. Where does the seed come from?


Amino acids and geothermal/solar energy

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miller-Urey_experiment
Last edited Jun 11, 2008 21:33:40
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.