User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > XP bonus for playing at or above your level
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by kinglehr
Originally posted by SteelCity Mafia

Originally posted by kinglehr


Originally posted by SteelCity Mafia



Originally posted by kinglehr




Originally posted by thunderdoozer





kinglehr, how are you missing this?

My league lost 2 GREAT teams and gained 2 AWFUL teams. On top of that, at least 2 more teams were gutted.

I dare you to use your almighty math knowledge to explain to me how my team is not getting FUCKED.


No.

You lost two winning teams, and gained two losing teams. Winning and losing is not a reflection of levels. The champion for my league for example was the 7th or 8th seeded (I forget) team.


You're in AA and have a level 10 and 12. Obviously your players are going to make out.


How am I making out? There is no bonus for being a low level player. Did you check Bort's announcement?

And you're talking about my players being low, you've got Level 15s. In my league that is just the median... in your league, your median will probably be Level 14. What definition of "way too high" do you get that makes you think you would get punished???


I'm speaking more so for the team I GM, the Silver Knights. We have the highest level players in our league. Plus if they count all of SE Asia AA, Half of the league is brand spankin' new.


Same situation. Yes you've got the Level 18s and 19s, but the top half of that league has Level 15s and 16s spotted all over the place. Even the 9th and 10th teams listed has Level 13s and 14s.

It's like I said, we don't even know where the "way too high" is. Maybe instead of complaining you should tell us what would be a reasonable gap before the punishment takes effect.


The highest players on the game are 22 (besides 1 solo K). Those 18's and 19's are gonna take a hit in the AA league. The wholes Asia league (besides the new teams that just came out) was created at the same time. The teams who recruited better are being punished.
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kinglehr
HOW ABOUT SUGGESTING THE REASONABLE GAP?

My suggestion:

For example, get a formula so that if the median was 5, "way too high" = 10... but if the median is 15, "way too high" = 22... and if the median is 20, "way too high" = 30.

Not necessarily those numbers, but you know the "way too high" number incrementally increases as the median increases.


This is a bad idea. Period.

It either has so little effect it is irrelevant (as you seem to be suggesting),

or it IS relevant and tens of thousands will be punished unfairly.
 
kinglehr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelCity Mafia
The highest players on the game are 22 (besides 1 solo K). Those 18's and 19's are gonna take a hit in the AA league. The wholes Asia league (besides the new teams that just came out) was created at the same time. The teams who recruited better are being punished.


That argument doesn't fly.

Did that one Level 22 really come to your team, because you had better recruiting? Or because he saw he could beat up some Level 13s and pile up some stats?

See.

Now if he has been with you since the beginning and just boosted way too much, then it's a pity... But sometimes, these things happen. It's beta.

 
Link
 
Originally posted by kinglehr
Originally posted by SteelCity Mafia

The highest players on the game are 22 (besides 1 solo K). Those 18's and 19's are gonna take a hit in the AA league. The wholes Asia league (besides the new teams that just came out) was created at the same time. The teams who recruited better are being punished.


That argument doesn't fly.

Did that one Level 22 really come to your team, because you had better recruiting? Or because he saw he could beat up some Level 13s and pile up some stats?

See.

Now if he has been with you since the beginning and just boosted way too much, then it's a pity... But sometimes, these things happen. It's beta.



Yeah, he boosted too much. You're retarded dude.
 
kinglehr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
Originally posted by kinglehr

HOW ABOUT SUGGESTING THE REASONABLE GAP?

My suggestion:

For example, get a formula so that if the median was 5, "way too high" = 10... but if the median is 15, "way too high" = 22... and if the median is 20, "way too high" = 30.

Not necessarily those numbers, but you know the "way too high" number incrementally increases as the median increases.


This is a bad idea. Period.

It either has so little effect it is irrelevant (as you seem to be suggesting),

or it IS relevant and tens of thousands will be punished unfairly.


How? I look at it this way... there is a Level 15 CB on my team, ahead of a Level 18. Clearly, a 3-level gap is not a difference maker in the game. In games, a 3-level gap has resulted in plenty of upsets. So clearly, a 3-level gap isn't the advantage we are trying to eliminate.

Why then would a 5-gap be the unreasonable choice? Or maybe it's the increasing gap you don't like... well then maybe you should give your own suggestion, since Bort has said XP Penalties WILL COME.
 
kinglehr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelCity Mafia
Originally posted by kinglehr

Originally posted by SteelCity Mafia


The highest players on the game are 22 (besides 1 solo K). Those 18's and 19's are gonna take a hit in the AA league. The wholes Asia league (besides the new teams that just came out) was created at the same time. The teams who recruited better are being punished.


That argument doesn't fly.

Did that one Level 22 really come to your team, because you had better recruiting? Or because he saw he could beat up some Level 13s and pile up some stats?

See.

Now if he has been with you since the beginning and just boosted way too much, then it's a pity... But sometimes, these things happen. It's beta.



Yeah, he boosted too much. You're retarded dude.


I am looking at everything through the new rules being set-up, which Bort has said WILL HAPPEN.

I'm not retarded. You're polemic.
 
Maksim
offline
Link
 
STOP THIS NOW!

Bad idea - it stops people who spend time and $$$ on player having advantage

it helps level 1 scrubs beat a level 20 player within a few seasons by paying $0

Lots of people are leaving because of it, I am not leaving but wont spend FP if I can get level with alpha testers for free!
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kinglehr

well then maybe you should give your own suggestion, since Bort has said XP Penalties WILL COME.


Read this thread over again.
 
kinglehr
offline
Link
 
Have you been to the front page lately and checked Bort's announcement?
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=355508

Whatever you suggested earlier is no longer in effect. It's about what to do about the XP Penalties now that they are definitely going to happen as it was declared. The only question is what "way too high" is and when it will actually take effect.
Last edited Jun 10, 2008 03:06:59
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kinglehr
Have you been to the front page lately and checked Bort's announcement?


Um, hello?

That's why I'm so angry.
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Fact:

Team stackers will benefit most from this rule. They don't need to recruit, they already have a posse. Now that no one will be able to recruit, the stackers will dominate wherever they go, because they don't give a SHIT about this rule. They'll level more slowly, sure... then they'll just find a lower league the next season and dominate again.
 
kinglehr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
Originally posted by kinglehr

Have you been to the front page lately and checked Bort's announcement?


Um, hello?

That's why I'm so angry.


If you've read it, then what word in "well then maybe you should give your own suggestion, since Bort has said XP Penalties WILL COME" didn't you understand? And saying "don't do it" is not a suggestion because that is the one thing Bort eliminated as a possibility.
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kinglehr
Originally posted by thunderdoozer

Originally posted by kinglehr


Have you been to the front page lately and checked Bort's announcement?


Um, hello?

That's why I'm so angry.


If you've read it, then what word in "well then maybe you should give your own suggestion, since Bort has said XP Penalties WILL COME" didn't you understand? And saying "don't do it" is not a suggestion because that is the one thing Bort eliminated as a possibility.


OK.

When you tell me you WILL commit suicide, I'll remember not to talk you out of it.
 
kinglehr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
Fact:

Team stackers will benefit most from this rule. They don't need to recruit, they already have a posse. Now that no one will be able to recruit, the stackers will dominate wherever they go, because they don't give a SHIT about this rule. They'll level more slowly, sure... then they'll just find a lower league the next season and dominate again.


It should not even be about that. The fact of the matter is they can dominate if they want, but they shouldn't get experience for doing it. Whether you play "in good spirit " or not, you shouldn't get experience for playing against much lower competition. An NFL player don't gain anything from beating on high school kids. That's the idea.

Forget the cheaters.

You know when players leave college or high school early for the pros, people say it's because they can't develop any farther in those leagues.
Last edited Jun 10, 2008 03:32:43
 
kinglehr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
Originally posted by kinglehr

Originally posted by thunderdoozer


Originally posted by kinglehr



Have you been to the front page lately and checked Bort's announcement?


Um, hello?

That's why I'm so angry.


If you've read it, then what word in "well then maybe you should give your own suggestion, since Bort has said XP Penalties WILL COME" didn't you understand? And saying "don't do it" is not a suggestion because that is the one thing Bort eliminated as a possibility.


OK.

When you tell me you WILL commit suicide, I'll remember not to talk you out of it.


And I'd thank you, because you talking to me might push me to do it earlier.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.