User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Coaches - ideas for them to spend money on (and other ideas)
Page:
 
Link
 
I'm creating a private forum that will include a Agent Petition against coaches. PM me for an invite.
 
dviss1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
I'm creating a private forum that will include a Agent Petition against coaches. PM me for an invite.


Please invite me. I think this is a STUPID idea.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by dviss1
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader

I'm creating a private forum that will include a Agent Petition against coaches. PM me for an invite.


Please invite me. I think this is a STUPID idea.



Invite sent.
 
Jonny do good
offline
Link
 
OOOOOORRRRR we could just add coaches as a new position instead of retireing..
 
butler312
offline
Link
 
Can we keep coaches out of the casual leagues? That way I can take all of my players there...
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
BORT PLEASE IMPLEMENT A POLL BEFORE DOING ANY MORE WORK ON COACHES

if majority wants it, do it, if majority is against it. SCRAP IT.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Robbnva
BORT PLEASE IMPLEMENT A POLL BEFORE DOING ANY MORE WORK ON COACHES

if majority wants it, do it, if majority is against it. SCRAP IT.


 
coachtabales
offline
Link
 
I have a whole different beef with this coaching thing in that they serve no real purpose other than to offer bonuses to the teams. You could accomplish the same thing by just selling the bonuses individually to the teams for flex.

What I mean is that over the last 6 seasons that I’ve been playing I have seen NUMEROUS posts of players just wanting GM status for the purposes of getting trophies, but really serve no purpose whatsoever in the development of the teams that they are on. This is an ongoing problem seeing how the game is getting more and more time consuming to manage, yet most agents just want the pros and none of the cons.

This coaching thing feeds exactly that, where teams are just going to stock pile coaches for the bonuses in the hopes of getting something more out of them. The hope is to get more out of them (like help on the scouting front) other than the bonuses, or at least I will. Believing that ALL these “coaches” are actually going to contribute to improve a lesser graded team, other than just adding their bonuses, is a pipe dream; ludicrous at best and delusional at worst.

In the beginning they are only going to cling on to teams that have a stacked roster, and trust me, they will do as little as possible afterwards. It’s not going to be all of them, but it’s going to happen a lot and most owners are probably not going to give a crap. This is problematic because it takes away from the “realism” that Bort is seeking.

To combat this I offer up an idea. If the coach goes inactive then that coach’s bonuses will not be applied. Furthermore, if the owner of the team fires that coach because of his inactive status, then that will work against that coach in the form of some kind of penalty as opposed to bonus. Other owners will see this and will second guess “hiring” this coach for their team if they aren’t going to be getting squat out of him.

The harder and more detailed Bort makes this game, the harder and more time consuming it’s going to get. I’m OK with that, but the freeloaders should be penalized for manipulating the system.
 
iv82much
offline
Link
 
I hate this idea. Been playing since middle of season 2.

Why not try cleaning up the game code? Of course it is possible, look at Madden (before they turned it into an arcade game)

The Unofficial GLB Draft has been a huge success. Why not try to make that part of the official game?

I fail to see how this coach thing is a good business move for GLB.

Coaches sound really boring and an unfair advantage to teams.



This game is supposed to follow the career of a football player from pewee to NFL. Why not have more appropriate playbooks for what level the team is at? How many Pewee teams use he same playbook as the NFL. I mean come on Bort/Admins. This game has so much potential and it seems like you are trying to piss it away because you forgot to use some common sense.
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Staz
That just makes sense to me. Very rarely do you see a player leave in the middle of his career to become a "coach". If you want your PLAYER to become a COACH, isn't it best to let him play out his career?


Actually, it happens all the time...players get career ending injuries or aren't good enough - they disappear from most people's sight and then one day they pop up as a coach someplace - after learning their craft in college or the minors.
 
Time Trial
offline
Link
 
Are they even going to test this out on the test server, or are we then worried about TestServer-gate all over again?

I'm jumping to serious conclusions here about how much a coach can alter the game, perhaps if they selected a group of NON SEASON ONE agents who will not actually be able to use what they learn and give them free reign to try some of this stuff out and see what will actually happen when coaches are put into place.
 
PING72
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by coachtabales
You could accomplish the same thing by just selling the bonuses individually to the teams for flex.


That is exactly right, and that is why this idea sucks SO BAD!!!
 
dawgs1235
offline
Link
 
Bort.

These are questions that needed to and should have been asked BEFORE programing. After development it needs EXTENSIVE TESTING and SHOULD BE 100% ACCESSIBLE TO THE ENTIRE POPULATION.

Seriously, stop holding up older players (myself being one of them) with crutches.

jesus.
 
dawgs1235
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by iv82much
I hate this idea. Been playing since middle of season 2.

Why not try cleaning up the game code? Of course it is possible, look at Madden (before they turned it into an arcade game)

The Unofficial GLB Draft has been a huge success. Why not try to make that part of the official game?

I fail to see how this coach thing is a good business move for GLB.

Coaches sound really boring and an unfair advantage to teams.



This game is supposed to follow the career of a football player from pewee to NFL. Why not have more appropriate playbooks for what level the team is at? How many Pewee teams use he same playbook as the NFL. I mean come on Bort/Admins. This game has so much potential and it seems like you are trying to piss it away because you forgot to use some common sense.


QFT
QFT
QFT
QFT
QFT
QFT
QFT
QFT
QFT
QFT
QFT
QFT
QFT
QFT
QFT
QFT
 
butler312
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by coachtabales
I have a whole different beef with this coaching thing in that they serve no real purpose other than to offer bonuses to the teams. You could accomplish the same thing by just selling the bonuses individually to the teams for flex.

What I mean is that over the last 6 seasons that I’ve been playing I have seen NUMEROUS posts of players just wanting GM status for the purposes of getting trophies, but really serve no purpose whatsoever in the development of the teams that they are on. This is an ongoing problem seeing how the game is getting more and more time consuming to manage, yet most agents just want the pros and none of the cons.

This coaching thing feeds exactly that, where teams are just going to stock pile coaches for the bonuses in the hopes of getting something more out of them. The hope is to get more out of them (like help on the scouting front) other than the bonuses, or at least I will. Believing that ALL these “coaches” are actually going to contribute to improve a lesser graded team, other than just adding their bonuses, is a pipe dream; ludicrous at best and delusional at worst.

In the beginning they are only going to cling on to teams that have a stacked roster, and trust me, they will do as little as possible afterwards. It’s not going to be all of them, but it’s going to happen a lot and most owners are probably not going to give a crap. This is problematic because it takes away from the “realism” that Bort is seeking.

To combat this I offer up an idea. If the coach goes inactive then that coach’s bonuses will not be applied. Furthermore, if the owner of the team fires that coach because of his inactive status, then that will work against that coach in the form of some kind of penalty as opposed to bonus. Other owners will see this and will second guess “hiring” this coach for their team if they aren’t going to be getting squat out of him.

The harder and more detailed Bort makes this game, the harder and more time consuming it’s going to get. I’m OK with that, but the freeloaders should be penalized for manipulating the system.


I pretty much agree with you. I like the idea of coaches, but they should NOT just be giving teams bonuses or equipment or anything like that. Coaches should just be given extra weapons to help them actually coach a team.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.