User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Demotion Ideas for the WPL
Page:
 
Galkuris
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Hikariu
Giving a Choice of Divisions = Good Teams always picking the weakest division hoping they can make it back to the pros. You should always send them back to where they started. At least for the first few seasons of WL


Right, send them to the best divisions so an even worse team gets to move up from the weak leagues instead of them.. Makes perfect sense.
 
walker1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by walker1
Here is what I would do:

Season 11
Take the top 4 teams from each region that made the conferance championship game. Alpha teams play in the Alpha league, Zeta teams play in the Zeta league.

Teams staying

16 playoff teams.

Teams demoted
16 non playoff team.

Promotion
Conference champions

Demotion

Balance it out. 17-32 go to region A, 18-31 to region B, 19-30 to region C, etc. Let the top teams choose what region they want to go in. The bottom teams (25-32) can swap regions if the both agree on it.


This way all the Pro, AAA and AA teams that deserve to stay in their leagues stay.


Any thoughts on this?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist

The ITS plan

Teams that stay
The 16 playoff teams

Teams that go
The 16 non-playoff teams.

Promotion
The league conference participants from each league promote. If a team guts, the promotion is taken based on league tie breaker.

Relegation
All 16 teams relegate that did not make the playoffs.
-Bort provides an option list for area's to relegate for each demoted team. If spot is available you must return to your original league. Team with worst record gets first choice. Until all regions are filled. (or let the team with best record moving down choose first...that may actually be best).

Gutting
If a team guts in the World League, and was a playoff team then they get treated like a non playoff team. Team that didn't make the playoffs w/ best record/tiebreakers stays

Edited by ImTheScientist on Jul 27, 2009 20:16:32
Edited by ImTheScientist on Jul 27, 2009 20:16:02
 
Galkuris
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Hikariu
Originally posted by PackMan97

Originally posted by lukin83



My team has wanted to play in USAPL since Day 1 but never had that option. Why should teams in "inferior leagues" not have a fair shot?


The should! I'm not arguing against that.

My plan.

* Top 2 teams from each region (league championship participants)
* Take the remaining 16 from the Elite 8 of the PWT and Hazy's. Those are active teams looking to make GLB better and promote competition against the best.
* If not up to 32, take from the teams with the highest ranking in LARS and Colley's compute ranking systems.

That gives every league an initial two teams minimum and gives the WL a true best of the best representation. If it's heavy toward one league or another it's because of their exploits on the field and their involvement in the community.


You can't use PWT or Hazy's a ton of teams don't even bother with scouting AI in scrimmages.


In the PWT, almost all of them do. If you don't why enter?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by beenlurken
Originally posted by HombreSinNombre2

Really don't see what the problem w/ taking the top 4 from each league and having the non-playoff teams demoted to their original league. (think originally it was garts idea) Then the 2 conference champions from each pro league move up. You might have to demote some teams down but w/ cpu teams and teams starting over, it shouldn't be a problem. Also should help w/ the parity since free agents will go towards the path of least resistance and improve the lower leagues.


You assume that of the 16 non-playoff teams there will be two of each region to go back to their respective region. Inevitably you will have teams losing league affiliation with this idea. You cant demote Pro teams down to AAA that earned the right to remain in their respective Pro leagues to demote teams from the WPL.


Actually that's what I like about it. Eventually you can have like 6 uspl 4 cpl teams and down the road. That's why you might eventually have to demote some extra teams from the pro league back down to the AAA. Purely hypothetical, but say at the end of the first season you have 4 uspl, 3 cpl, 2 apl, 2 eepl, 2 sapl, 2 wepl, 1 seapl and 0 opl teams make the playoffs.

USPL - 0 demotions, 2 conference champs get promoted, total of 6 teams in WL. Will have two promote two extra teams from AAA to fill the void in the pro league.

CPL - 1 demotion, 2 conference champs get promoted, total of 5 teams in WL. The one team getting demoted goes back to the conference it's from taking the place of one of the promoted teams and to fill in the last slot promote an extra team

APL, EEPL, SAPL, WEPL - 2 demotion, 2 conference champs get promoted, total of 4 teams in WL. Fairly simple, the two demoted teams fill the 2 spots from the conference champs.

SEPL - 3 demotion, 2 conference champs get promoted, total of 3 teams in WL. You will need to demote an extra team from the pro league down to AAA to make room.

OPL - 4 demotion, 2 conferencce champs, total of 2 teams in WL. Same thing as above except having to demote an extra team down.

 
Link
 
Bort easiest way to demote teams would be to eliminate regions from the game. Just have 8 Pro leagues so no one can bitch about what league they get sent down to.
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lukin83

It is still not an equal opportunity for the inferior regions and leaves USAPL as the cream of the crop league (which it should not be).


How is that? BTW - If they are inferior? should they receive equal representation in a "Best of the best" league? as long as every region promotes the top two teams every season that's equal opportunity.

The current solution only gives inferior teams a chance in the World League as oppose to those teams that have helped build the GLB community.
 
jamz
offline
Link
 
We must try harder, folks. Bort is not impressed by any of our ideas, thusfar.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gabrosin
Bort... no comment on divisions? Or maybe I missed it? Or maybe you're implementing it right now? C'mon, throw a little CSS together, add a database field, we're good to go! Problem solved!


I dunno if I like divisions. It's more NFL-y, but NFL scheduling is kinda confusing if you're not familiar with how it works.

If we do a set number of teams from each region it makes it easy to deal with, but we aren't ensured the best of the best year in and year out, which I see as a desirable feature of the world league.

I'm personally currently leaning most towards the system where we have to demote extra teams.
 
Link
 
There are usually enough teams either going cpu or rebuilding and going down the ladder to make up the extra teams being demoted right?
 
jamz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by UsCtRoJaNs1820
Bort easiest way to demote teams would be to eliminate regions from the game. Just have 8 Pro leagues so no one can bitch about what league they get sent down to.


Been suggesting this for pages.

Seriously, who cares any more, the clouds took the bottom half away, just leave the middle ladders there remove region affiliation.

Then shuffle. Truffle Shuffle.
 
turnit643
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Gabrosin

Bort... no comment on divisions? Or maybe I missed it? Or maybe you're implementing it right now? C'mon, throw a little CSS together, add a database field, we're good to go! Problem solved!


I dunno if I like divisions. It's more NFL-y, but NFL scheduling is kinda confusing if you're not familiar with how it works.

If we do a set number of teams from each region it makes it easy to deal with, but we aren't ensured the best of the best year in and year out, which I see as a desirable feature of the world league.

I'm personally currently leaning most towards the system where we have to demote extra teams.


Agree on all counts.
 
the man of doom
Miracles happen
offline
Link
 
comment on soccer idea?
 
kwankwan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Gabrosin

Bort... no comment on divisions? Or maybe I missed it? Or maybe you're implementing it right now? C'mon, throw a little CSS together, add a database field, we're good to go! Problem solved!


I dunno if I like divisions. It's more NFL-y, but NFL scheduling is kinda confusing if you're not familiar with how it works.

If we do a set number of teams from each region it makes it easy to deal with, but we aren't ensured the best of the best year in and year out, which I see as a desirable feature of the world league.

I'm personally currently leaning most towards the system where we have to demote extra teams.


That is the whole deal right here. Once you make your choice, it should be much easier to figure out.
 
beenlurken
offline
Link
 
Fuck it... obviously no decision is going to be made until USA is happy. Promote them (they deserve it... they are the uber league) to the WPL for season 11. Realign the USA league to make up for this. For season 12, relegate the non-playoff teams to where ever. They shouldnt care... all of their friends/rivalries are still in WPL (they had their chance to stay their). From there we promote 2 conference champions from each league and demote 16 teams to where ever (again the USA whiners had there chance and are split everywhere now). Repeat.....
Edited by beenlurken on Jul 27, 2009 20:24:20
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.