Originally posted by Rodion
Originally posted by Mercaptopropyl
Originally posted by Rodion
Originally posted by Mercaptopropyl
"The WL should have the top 32 teams" is jst a vision. The sim changes from year to year, teams change from year to year.
"This system will replace the 17th best team of the game for a team on the 30s-40s. And that is what I consider unfair."
What you are proposing is a system that's going to keep causing problems each and every season. Bring us a better idea first before suggesting one like this. We've already come up with something that has a built-in method of guaranteeing the World League not only stays fresh and exciting but as competitive as possible.
I can't see it. I'm seeing some top 32 teams being replaced by bubble teams simply because those bubble teams are the best of what once was a true Pro league, since the good teams have left it.
Originally posted by Mercaptopropyl
"not by simply winning it all in the inferior tier." You do realize that you are talking about teams that win their Pro League not being deserving of only one guaranteed season in the World League, don't you?
I'm afraid you're not seeing the whole picture here. You are thinking very highly of a Pro Conference champion. You know why? Because Pro champions are currently the best thing there are in the game. Problem is as soon as you make a World League, being a Pro Champion loses most of its meaning. What's the value of winning SAPL without the Benitos or the Monkeys there? What's the value of winning CPL without Drinkin, Drygerian or Marblehead there? What's the value of winning EEPL without Emmaus there? You say "Pro Champion"? I say "big deal".
I don't know why you are so focused on the idea that the World League has to have the #1-32 teams in the game every season. You should know as well as I do that by the time we get in the 17th-32nd range that you'll have a harder time figuring out what teams fit there than you might with ranking #1-16.
Even if we came up with 32 teams that made you happy, there would be people who weren't happy with those teams.
The World League is supposed to add something new to the game, not just become the new "top tier on the pyramid"
What harm is there if a team in the 33-48 range is allowed one season in the World League? Does that really ruin the World League's integrity?
Why not have teams in USA Pro that haven't gutted and are facing relegation play the teams coming up from AAA first before those AAA teams earn a chance to prove themselves in USA Pro? It's an even worse situation than the World League, because they only have to finish 14th to stay in Pro rather than make the playoffs. And they might be taking some spot away from a team that deserves it more because they are already in USA Pro.
If you started suggesting conference champions had to beat a team relegating from the league they are moving up to people would be up in arms over it.
The weak teams you are so worried about "ruining" the World League are given only a single season, (or every single season if they prove not to be so weak) to prove themselves before getting sent back down. Having a 16 team turnover rate means that staying in the World League for consecutive seasons is going to be almost impossible for many great teams. The "weaker" team that you are so worried about is going to be sent back down after just a single season. I don't really care if they aren't truly one of the League's top 32 teams, they earned the privilege to at least have a chance to prove themselves. If it turns out they are wasting the World League's time they won't be wasting it for very long.
The point here is simple: if they're truly better than the teams they want to replace, they should have no problem winning a best of three (or 5 or 7) against the said team.
But yeah, I do see your point that having a top 45 team in the WL is not absolutely hideous and this way you'll give the little guys a chance and make more people happy.
I still don't like it. We'll just have to agree to disagree, I suppose.
I agree, they should be able to win a Best of 3 (or w/e kind of series) if they are the better team, but think about it this way as well. If a team misses the playoffs, and then manages to win the play-in game and remain in the World League, it means the team that lost the play-in series would have to not only win their Pro League conference the next season to reach the World League, but also have to win a play-in series as well. Two Pro League trophies but no shot at playing in the World League?
Maybe they aren't as good as the other team, but if that's the case, if the worse team can win back-to-back trophies then shouldn't the better team have a great chance at winning a trophy when they fall back down? They'd have a one season lay-over back in Pro and then be right back with another chance to prove themselves. I'm going to guess that having a season out of the World League to remember missing the playoffs is more likely to get a better performance out them when they return to the World League than you would get if they just hung on for a couple seasons by winning play-in series.
If I can manage to stick around by winning a play-in series, then you've just made that series more important than their entire season. At that point my team could decide in Week 1 to not gameplan our entire season and take the year off if we feel confident enough in winning whoever we might face in a play-in series.
It's going to be much more interesting and entertaining to watch a World League that is different from season to season rather than watching the same teams over and over. If a stronger team like Emmaus were sent down for a weaker one, if Emmaus ever returned to the World League don't you think there'd be a lot of discussion started on how they were going to do this time? Plus if one of the weaker teams ever comes out of nowhere and surprises everyone that's a lot more exciting than letting a team finish in 10th again.
I think teams should look at the World League as a reward or opportunity. You are always only one bad season away from dropping back down, and so every team would be smart to remember their Pro League is their real home. Of course some teams will be able to hang on to that reward for a much longer time, but most won't be able to. So as far as just about every team is concerned, the World League is just a place to further prove themselves, not a new home that is "above" their Pro League.