User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Endorsements - What I am thinking
Page:
 
bossinthe831
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by bossinthe831

Originally posted by bossinthe831


Only calculate stats of games within 50-75 points. Any game of more than a 75+ point differential, just throw it out.


in case it was missed


So that folks will now spend their time game planning to keep the score closer...punting on first down when up by 70.

Bad idea.


If they are punting when up 70 then they aren't running up the score and compiling insane stats.
 
Hikariu
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TxSteve
isn't the system of giving out awards 4 games in; 8 games in; etc -

going to place an AWFUL lot of importance on schedules??


totally ignoring 'gut jobs' - there will still be a big problem -

i know scouting bars are garbage - but say i'm a 57 team

in my first 4 teams; i play 4 - 54 teams - under most circumstances - guaranteed wins by a decent margin - but maybe not cruise control worthy (depending)

on the other hand a team (a 60) plays 4 - 60 rated teams to start the season - (or a 54 team plays 4 60's)

now you're basing awards off of stats - and the playing field isn't equal - it is slanted to whoever has the optimum schedule in the optimal window


The local awards aren't good enough to really matter. Just fun.
 
Nuge20
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by Nuge20

My compiled suggestion (For Pro Leagues):
MVP Endorsements: Huge endorsements that give +1 to both trees and +15% to something and +10 to attributes (3 MVPs only)
Large Endorsements: Like the current endorsements. Give it to top 2 of each positions MVP (or sim of top 10). +1 to a tree +15% to something and +8 to attributes. (1 per position per Conference)
Medium Endorsements: Give it to a random sim of the top 20 of positional MVPs. +1 to 3 SAs, +10% to something +5 to attributes 2 per position per conference)
Small Endorsements: Random sim of positions in top 50 of positional MVPs +1 to 1 SA, +5% to something, and +3 to attributes (5 per position per conference)
Mini Endorsements: Random sim of all in the league gives +2 to attributes...give to 10% of the league.

Oh and this could use any other factors you want to weight the randomness
For lower leagues just shift down 1...maybe have Pro/AAA start at large, AA and A start at Medium, BBB and casual start at small, and pee wee start at mini...except MVP would be similar for each league but MVPs would have to be within suggested levels.




And how would you assure that those endorsements don't all go to players on top teams?


Maybe have a limit of 5 per team but start by awarding all normally then if more than 5 are given to a team then random sim to see who loses theirs...then give it to someone else
 
TxSteve
Not A Mod
offline
Link
 
on defense they would be...
 
butler312
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by bossinthe831

Originally posted by bossinthe831


Only calculate stats of games within 50-75 points. Any game of more than a 75+ point differential, just throw it out.


in case it was missed


So that folks will now spend their time game planning to keep the score closer...punting on first down when up by 70.

Bad idea.


So what about this then:

Originally posted by butler312
I didn't read everything, so sorry if this was posted, but is there a way to code it so there is a cap on stats that go towards counting for this MVP formula. This might help with the gutted team problems. For example, maybe you could cap it at 5 rushing TDs and 2 KR TD or something like that. So that if you do play a gutted team and score 20 TDs, it doesn't matter, because only 6 of them will count in the formula. Make the caps equal to about the best day you could have against an equally matched opponent. It will still give a player who plays more gutted teams an advantage, but the difference wouldn't be insane or anything.

 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nuge20
Originally posted by Iceman16

Originally posted by Nuge20


My compiled suggestion (For Pro Leagues):
MVP Endorsements: Huge endorsements that give +1 to both trees and +15% to something and +10 to attributes (3 MVPs only)
Large Endorsements: Like the current endorsements. Give it to top 2 of each positions MVP (or sim of top 10). +1 to a tree +15% to something and +8 to attributes. (1 per position per Conference)
Medium Endorsements: Give it to a random sim of the top 20 of positional MVPs. +1 to 3 SAs, +10% to something +5 to attributes 2 per position per conference)
Small Endorsements: Random sim of positions in top 50 of positional MVPs +1 to 1 SA, +5% to something, and +3 to attributes (5 per position per conference)
Mini Endorsements: Random sim of all in the league gives +2 to attributes...give to 10% of the league.

Oh and this could use any other factors you want to weight the randomness
For lower leagues just shift down 1...maybe have Pro/AAA start at large, AA and A start at Medium, BBB and casual start at small, and pee wee start at mini...except MVP would be similar for each league but MVPs would have to be within suggested levels.




And how would you assure that those endorsements don't all go to players on top teams?


Maybe have a limit of 5 per team but start by awarding all normally then if more than 5 are given to a team then random sim to see who loses theirs...then give it to someone else


Well make sure to add that in. All the endorsements going to the top teams is one of the main reasons that I think Bort is re-thinking this whole thing.
 
cowtesticles2001
udder pressure
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RTJakarta
Originally posted by cowtesticles2001

Originally posted by Iceman16


Originally posted by cowtesticles2001



....so Bort....the ones that were given out yesterday are still active?


Didn't the announcement say they are inactive?


Yeah but my C that got one still has it equipped... o_O


This is a truthful statement.


I never lie....

Bort....whatever you decide to do will be cool with me...I gave ideas yesterday staying up until 5 am....was just wondering about my original post in this quote pyramid....thanks....
 
bossinthe831
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by tautology

Originally posted by bossinthe831


Originally posted by bossinthe831



Only calculate stats of games within 50-75 points. Any game of more than a 75+ point differential, just throw it out.


in case it was missed


So that folks will now spend their time game planning to keep the score closer...punting on first down when up by 70.

Bad idea.


This. Good example of why fixes > band-aids.


All last night I posted in the endorsement thread saying that exact same thing. The fact is look, we're having yet another band-aid, might as well make it a good band-aid.
 
Nuge20
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rezlov
More or less took my idea Nuge.


improved your idea and posted it neatly for bort to see tbh
 
ChuckTaylor
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TxSteve
isn't the system of giving out awards 4 games in; 8 games in; etc -

going to place an AWFUL lot of importance on schedules??



Yes. and it will boil down to the luck of the schedules
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by butler312
I didn't read everything, so sorry if this was posted, but is there a way to code it so there is a cap on stats that go towards counting for this MVP formula. This might help with the gutted team problems. For example, maybe you could cap it at 5 rushing TDs and 2 KR TD or something like that. So that if you do play a gutted team and score 20 TDs, it doesn't matter, because only 6 of them will count in the formula. Make the caps equal to about the best day you could have against an equally matched opponent. It will still give a player who plays more gutted teams an advantage, but the difference wouldn't be insane or anything.



That's still a band-aid, not a fix.
 
Weather
offline
Link
 
I'm heading off to bed.

Have fun endorse-a-brainstorming.

Looks like it's goin good
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bossinthe831
Originally posted by tautology

Originally posted by bossinthe831


Originally posted by bossinthe831



Only calculate stats of games within 50-75 points. Any game of more than a 75+ point differential, just throw it out.


in case it was missed


So that folks will now spend their time game planning to keep the score closer...punting on first down when up by 70.

Bad idea.


If they are punting when up 70 then they aren't running up the score and compiling insane stats.


They are for their punter (special teams is a category)

And their defense (many more tackles, sack opportunites, int opportunities).

 
Rezlov
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nuge20
Originally posted by Rezlov

More or less took my idea Nuge.


improved your idea and posted it neatly for bort to see tbh

If you call that an improvement, you're clinically retarded. Still requires a script to determine top players, which will not be done effectively. Not to mention you are giving out WAY to much of a boost.
 
Nuge20
offline
Link
 
My compiled suggestion (For Pro Leagues):
MVP Endorsements: Huge endorsements that give +1 to both trees and +15% to something and +10 to attributes (3 MVPs only)
Large Endorsements: Like the current endorsements. Give it to top 2 of each positions MVP (or sim of top 10). +1 to a tree +15% to something and +8 to attributes. (1 per position per Conference)
Medium Endorsements: Give it to a random sim of the top 20 of positional MVPs. +1 to 3 SAs, +10% to something +5 to attributes 2 per position per conference)
Small Endorsements: Random sim of positions in top 50 of positional MVPs +1 to 1 SA, +5% to something, and +3 to attributes (5 per position per conference)
Mini Endorsements: Random sim of all in the league gives +2 to attributes...give to 10% of the league.

Oh and this could use any other factors you want to weight the randomness
For lower leagues just shift down 1...maybe have Pro/AAA start at large, AA and A start at Medium, BBB and casual start at small, and pee wee start at mini...except MVP would be similar for each league but MVPs would have to be within suggested levels.

Limit 4 Large Endorsements per team, 6 medium per team, and 10 small per team...unlimited mini because it is more random
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.