"100 STR, 70 CAR, 50/60ish Spd/Agi
8-10 in Power Through and Lower Shoulder type skills
15 in +brk tackle VA's
perhaps some AEQ with +brk tackle type stuff too"
_______________________________________________________________
Just to throw out some values I'd consider fair:
100 STR, 70 TCK, 50/60ish Spd/Agi: 99% tackles made, 95% no additional yardage
(= player build to stop the guy)
90 STR, 50 TCK, 60/90ish Spd/Agi: 87% tackles made, 25% for small additional gains, 10% for 2-4 yards after tackle
(="DT")
70 STR, 70 TCK, 60/70ish Spd/Agi: 95% tackles made, 30% for small additional gains, 20% for 2-4 yards after tackle
(=MLB almost entirely focussed on run defense)
60 STR, 60 TCK, 65/75ish Spd/Agi: 90% tackles made, 50% for small additional gains, 30% for 2-4 yards after tackle
(="balanced MLB")
50 STR, 50 TCK, 75/80ish Spd/Agi: 85% tackles made, 50% for small additional gains, 50% for 2-4 yards after tackle
(="balanced OLB / DE")
40 STR, 45 TCK, 80/100ish Spd/Agi: 80% tackles made, 40% for small additional gains, 60% for 2-4 yards after tackle
(=FS)
25 STR, 35 TCK, 80/100ish Spd/Agi: 70% tackles made, 20% for small additional gains, 80% for 2-4 yards after tackle
(=CB)
So basically: to shut this back down, you need to hit him early - and preferrably by 2 or more defenders. Even a pass focussed defense can stop him once in a while (but it's rather a lucky roll to keep him to less than 3.5 yards three times in a row).
Most guys get so upset because of missed tackles, but honestly: I'd even consider a 70% broken rate good when a weak guy of like 20 strength and 20 blocking tries for it (you don't find that horrible tacklers in any league). The thing that might need some adjustment then: broken tackles shouldn't hurt morale much. A CB taking on a powerback won't mind the missed attempt as much as the MLB.