Originally posted by Nats Kule
So now someone who disagrees is lazy. I've read the majority of the arguement, this season, last season, the season before and the season before that.
The game doesn't need more money inserted into it. Home teams getting all of the playoff revenue was ridiculous as there would be no game without the other team.
This isn't the first time the "Jumbotron" idea has been brought up. It is getting hyped now because revenue sharing in the playoffs is going to happen and GREEDY owners that want ALL of the playoff revenue, think this is a great idea because they don't lose any money.
I happen to disagree, and think that it is asinine that when 2 teams play only 1 team gets paid, as it has been in the past.
No, someone who disagrees is not lazy by definition. Someone who mindlessly adheres to an ideological position to the point that they don't acknowledge or consider other viewpoints is lazy. The post you had before this one was pretty closed minded when you characterized everyone who disagreed with YOUR position as "greedy". When you did that, it did raise my hackles a bit because that's a gross oversimplification and an unfair characterization as well. I just responded in kind. Just as it surely and understandably irritated you to be called lazy because you disagreed with me, it irks me to be called greedy and have my motivations challenged just because I disagreed with you.
But...
This last post shows that clearly you HAVE looked at this, even though we disagree, so my calling you "lazy" was clearly wrong. For that I apologize.
However, I would maintain that the characterization of being "greedy" is also inaccurate. The money that is earned by home playoff teams is not as much of a windfall as you and many others seem to think. Think about the fact that revenue from stadiums is capped at roughly $60 million a year once the stadium is fully built. Then consider that at L40 equipment upgrades are going to cost somewhere in the neighborhood of $3.2 million-$4 million PER PLAYER. For just a 40 player roster, that could be $160 MILLION! Even assuming concessions covers all salary expenses, you'd have to save for 3 seasons to pay for all your upgrades, but it will only take a little over 2 seasons (boost for 3, 1 season's worth of XP for 2, then boost again for 3) to get from L32 to L40. With these numbers in mind, the additional money from the playoff games is not as much of an excess (IMHO) as many believe it to be. And this says nothing about what's going to happen when players reach L48!!!
So I don't see this as greed. I see this as financial planning for the future and successful teams, if they're run responsibly, trying to save as much as they can to prepare for the expenditures that they KNOW are coming in the future. It's like saving for retirement. If you have, say, $100,000 in your 401k now, does that mean you're "greedy" if you don't want the government to take away your tax advantage? It may seem like a lot right now when you are thinking in terms of paying for a plasma TV or a new computer, but when you look at it from the perspective of living expenses for 20+ years, it doesn't look like quite so much. Wanting to keep every bit of that $100k THAT YOU EARNED isn't "greedy" in my book.
I understand and agree that it's ridiculous how the lower seeds have been compensated (or rather, NOT compensated) to this point. However, the analogy of using part of the stadium revenue, while it seems to translate well from the NFL or NCAA, is actually pretty flawed. Those teams don't see their operating expenses (equipment) quadruple or even quintuple in 2-3 seasons. They also have additional revenues to split (e.g., TV) and other sources of revenue completely separate from the playoff game itself (e.g., merchandising). For that reason, I don't think it's so horrible to preserve the home team's revenue as it stands.
One final attempt to make my point: I wouldn't have a philosophical problem with splitting revenue if, for example, all teams--whether in the playoffs or not--had an alternative way to generate revenue such as merchandising. If we had a merchandising vehicle where more successful teams would generate more money than losing teams in merchandise sales then that would reward good teams and serve as yet another incentive for bad teams to improve. This additional source of funds for the home playoff teams (as well as all the other teams) would offset the loss of ticket revenue from the game itself for the home team, would provide additional revenue from both tickets and merchandising for the lower seeded teams, and would more closely mirror "real life". However, implementing such a system would be VERRRY complicated, so for the sake of practicality, at least for now, I prefer a cleaner system like the Jumbotron. Lots less programming involved in that one and it addresses what is MY major concern of getting some more money into the hands of the lower seeds. Taking money away from the higher seeds on principle is less of a priority for me than it is for you.
Oh, and as an aside, if this idea would be conceptually acceptable to you too, then you have to concede that the argument that the Jumbotron option dumps excessive amounts of money into the GLB Universe (put forth by some proponents of revenue sharing) is not a valid one since merchandising would also be dumping money into the system. Whether the money came from Jumbotron or extra merchandise sales, it's still "new" money that hasn't been there before.