User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Playoff Profit sharing...
Page:
 
Knightman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BP

a low seed getting 100K bonus League (GLB)...hell, have the game give you $1,000,000..but not at the expense of the home team. Maybe Bort needs to come up some with type of TV/CABLE revenue and then both teams can split that every game and make the concessions a little more realistic....but giving the away team ticket revenue doesn't make a lot of sense to me..


My point exactly. Give money to the lower seeds--just don't reduce the revenue traditionally given to the higher seeds to get it.
 
Tito716
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/stadium.pl?team_id=3298

This is the stadium of the #1 team in my league. No we are not an expansion league.

I hope the #8 seed enjoys their 250,000 shared revenue...
 
Knightman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Crushr
Originally posted by Tito716

OK. They need more money. Why does this money have to come from the higher seeds?

Better question is why do you feel that it has to come from somewhere else? Why do the 1-4 seeds need an extra 3-8 million(or more) than the other teams in their league? I guess you've been getting that much up until now and feel entitled. Remember that this is a Beta game and things will change as we have already seen. How much you get in the playoffs should change as well.


LOL. You were the poster who said he didn't want to tell teams how to spend their money, yet you're here saying that higher seeded teams NEED (i.e., the game needs to mandate) that they spend what traditionally has been THEIR money on their lower seeded colleagues.

But to answer your question more directly, I think it should come from somewhere else for a few reasons:
(1) It keeps league winners on an even financial playing field with past league winners who DID get the whole pie.
(2) There is a way to reduce the discrepancy between lower and higher seeds WITHOUT reducing the payout to higher seeds. If the objective is to reduce the discrepancy, then doing it with as little disruption as possible to other teams is preferable (IMO). Give the lower seeds a Jumbotron option or a merchandising option or just give them a (much) bigger playoff bonus outright, I don't care. All of these address the disparity, all are customizable so that they can reduce the differential to whatever degree that the Admins want, and all leave everyone else alone. A much cleaner, neater solution to the whole thing.
(3) I maintain that there should be no reward for "participation" for the non-playoff teams. We're not having Field Day for First Graders. Rewards should be for achievement, and if people want to try to demonize that sentiment by trying to pigeonhole it with political rhetoric (as some have done) that's fine. I stand by the position that first place rewards should go to teams that *gasp!* finish in first place!!!
(4) As equipment upgrades become more and more expensive, the amount of money from the playoffs will not be an exorbitant amount. See one of my earlier posts re: L40 equipment for more details.
(5) Revenue sharing could turn into a logistical nightmare. Say we give the lower seed a percentage of the sales. Then, as has been pointed out, some higher seeds may engage in gamesmanship by setting ticket prices low in order to screw the lower team since the lower team will be more affected by the loss of revenue (presumably) than the higher seed. If you allow the lower seed a certain allotment of tickets in the higher seed's stadium, how exactly do you do that? The two stadiums are probably not equivalent, so if you give them 1/4 of the higher seed's Level 2 End Zone seats, but the lower seed doesn't HAVE any end zone seats, where does he input the ticket prices? Do you give him access to the higher seed's stadium so he can change ticket prices? Not on my team!!! Not if I can help it!!! Do you create a special one time end zone section for the stadium so the lower seed can sell tickets? VERRRRRY complicated compared to just letting the lower seeds do their thing and the higher seeds keep their money.


So, there are logistical practical and philosophical reasons why I would support generation of new revenue to address the lower seeds getting ripped off in the current system, as opposed to "revenue sharing." It really amazes me that for some people it's not enough to give the lower seeds their due--they won't be satisfied unless they can take something AWAY from somebody!!!

And, BTW, we all know it's a BETA game and things change. The rest of us are debating the best OPTION for that change. Trying to imply that anyone who disagrees with you supports the status quo is misleading, counterproductive, and just plain lame.
Last edited Oct 1, 2008 16:03:20
 
wsdp
offline
Link
 
Knightman, when you say jumbotron you're on to something... what about a stadium viewing party for lower seed so they can sell tickets at a fraction of the price ($5-$10) and earn a cool $500k + $150k or so in concessions for a nearly fully build stadium, etc.

Taking it from the high seed makes no sense and I'd hope the admins have figured that out and are just holding off on announcing that.
 
Knightman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tito716
http://goallineblitz.com/game/stadium.pl?team_id=3298

This is the stadium of the #1 team in my league. No we are not an expansion league.

I hope the #8 seed enjoys their 250,000 shared revenue...


Wow. Just wow.
 
wsdp
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Joe_B
You are giving up revenue, allowing other teams a cut of ticket sales from YOUR stadium means that YOU ARE NOT receiving all the revenue from that game played at ,again, YOUR STADIUM. Personaly i don't agree that other teams, my competition, should benefit from my fanacial planning. I've balanced and juggled my money for 5 seasons to max my stadium. It's not fair.


+1
 
Knightman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wsdp
Knightman, when you say jumbotron you're on to something... what about a stadium viewing party for lower seed so they can sell tickets at a fraction of the price ($5-$10) and earn a cool $500k + $150k or so in concessions for a nearly fully build stadium, etc.

Taking it from the high seed makes no sense and I'd hope the admins have figured that out and are just holding off on announcing that.


Can't take credit for Bort's idea. But you pretty much summarized it in a nutshell and I do like it.
 
lafCowboy
offline
Link
 
So now the argument isn't that the 5-8s were financial idiots but that it started this way, so it can't be changed?
 
Sigmaforce
offline
Link
 
http://sports.espn.go.com/nfl/news/story?id=2781759
 
Nats Kule
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Joe_B
Something i posted in another forum, i'll post it again here


*************************************************

You are giving up revenue, allowing other teams a cut of ticket sales from YOUR stadium means that YOU ARE NOT receiving all the revenue from that game played at ,again, YOUR STADIUM. Personaly i don't agree that other teams, my competition, should benefit from my fanacial planning. I've balanced and juggled my money for 5 seasons to max my stadium. It's not fair.

Here is something else that is not fair about it,
I will make more than 5 mil from a playoff home game this season, lets say i'm the #1 seed and that the revenue sharing is 25%, with me being the #1 seed that means the #8 seed would get, at a 25% share of revenue, with my max stadium and ticket pricing the ticket sales would be more than 5 mill and the #8 seed will get more that 1.25 mil.

Now lets assume that the # 2 seed is the warpath from my confrence, http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=390
they don't have a fully upgraded stadium and only do 4mil in ticket sales, that means the #7 seed would get a only 1 mil, again at 25% of home team revenue.

So the lower seed (the 8 seed) makes more money (than the 7th seed)...what is fair about that.


*****************************


the playoff revenue sharing from ticket sales is not a good idea, it's not even fair to the lower seeds. It definatly isn't fair to the higher seeds. It's MY STADIUM, if any profits are going to a lower seed from my stadium, i will set the ticket prices so low they won't make much money.



How about the 8 and 7 seeds don't go to the playoffs. Give 1 and 2 a bye. Then they don't have to share as there is no game.

Bottomline, the visiting team should have received revenue the first season, what team in their right mind would play a game for free? Oh the bonus, well that covers one day of salary, so I guess the players don't practice playoff week because they aren't getting paid.

The only folks that think it is wrong are those that don't want to give some up. Use a bit of common sense and give the team that is helping you fill your stadium a little. It's only the playoffs, it's not like the whole regular season is being shared, quit being so greedy.
 
Knightman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nats Kule


How about the 8 and 7 seeds don't go to the playoffs. Give 1 and 2 a bye. Then they don't have to share as there is no game.

Bottomline, the visiting team should have received revenue the first season, what team in their right mind would play a game for free? Oh the bonus, well that covers one day of salary, so I guess the players don't practice playoff week because they aren't getting paid.

The only folks that think it is wrong are those that don't want to give some up. Use a bit of common sense and give the team that is helping you fill your stadium a little. It's only the playoffs, it's not like the whole regular season is being shared, quit being so greedy.


Another poster who's too lazy to read the thread. There have been numerous posts that provide a mechanism for lower seeds to get paid, and quite handsomely, without taking money from the higher seeds. It's laughable that people like this ask others to use "common sense" when they set up these false dilemmas. This "logic" boils down to:


(i) If you don't have to share your whole season's revenue, you're being greedy.

This degree of exaggeration is ridiculous. It boils down to "Since we're not asking for EVERYTHING, we're entitled to whatever portion of your stuff we DO ask for--and if you complain, then you're GREEDY!!!!" "Greedy" is the term have-nots use to try to invoke a moral argument to justify their envy. If you wish to spend your entire paycheck on YOUR family instead of giving some to mine, then are you being greedy? Apparently this poster thinks so, unless I ask him to give me ALL of his paycheck.


(ii) "What team in their right mind would pay for free?"

Ignoring the fact that GLB is NOT a perfect simulation of the NFL, nor can it every be unless the NFL suddenly expands to 4,800 teams, there is some validity to the idea that the lower seeds are getting shafted. However, a solution that provides the lower seeds a very nice revenue generating option has been posted here numerous times, but this poster apparently just doesn't want to read it, whether it be laziness, ignorance, or outright denial. Uncouple the unfairness of underpaying the lower seeds from your desire to punish the successful for having the audacity to BE successful.


I also don't agree with reducing the number of playoff teams. This will eliminate a LOT more teams from meaningful games towards the latter part of the season. If the problem is that lower seeds aren't getting enough, rather than destroying the playoff format and removing 25% of the playoff field, why not just give the lower seeds a way to make more money? Leave everybody else alone and give the 5-8 seeds some way to generate cash and everybody's issues are solved except those who have a pathological case of wealth envy.
Last edited Oct 1, 2008 22:45:16
 
Nats Kule
offline
Link
 
So now someone who disagrees is lazy. I've read the majority of the arguement, this season, last season, the season before and the season before that.

The game doesn't need more money inserted into it. Home teams getting all of the playoff revenue was ridiculous as there would be no game without the other team.

This isn't the first time the "Jumbotron" idea has been brought up. It is getting hyped now because revenue sharing in the playoffs is going to happen and GREEDY owners that want ALL of the playoff revenue, think this is a great idea because they don't lose any money.

I happen to disagree, and think that it is asinine that when 2 teams play only 1 team gets paid, as it has been in the past.
 
Knightman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nats Kule
So now someone who disagrees is lazy. I've read the majority of the arguement, this season, last season, the season before and the season before that.

The game doesn't need more money inserted into it. Home teams getting all of the playoff revenue was ridiculous as there would be no game without the other team.

This isn't the first time the "Jumbotron" idea has been brought up. It is getting hyped now because revenue sharing in the playoffs is going to happen and GREEDY owners that want ALL of the playoff revenue, think this is a great idea because they don't lose any money.

I happen to disagree, and think that it is asinine that when 2 teams play only 1 team gets paid, as it has been in the past.


No, someone who disagrees is not lazy by definition. Someone who mindlessly adheres to an ideological position to the point that they don't acknowledge or consider other viewpoints is lazy. The post you had before this one was pretty closed minded when you characterized everyone who disagreed with YOUR position as "greedy". When you did that, it did raise my hackles a bit because that's a gross oversimplification and an unfair characterization as well. I just responded in kind. Just as it surely and understandably irritated you to be called lazy because you disagreed with me, it irks me to be called greedy and have my motivations challenged just because I disagreed with you.

But...

This last post shows that clearly you HAVE looked at this, even though we disagree, so my calling you "lazy" was clearly wrong. For that I apologize.

However, I would maintain that the characterization of being "greedy" is also inaccurate. The money that is earned by home playoff teams is not as much of a windfall as you and many others seem to think. Think about the fact that revenue from stadiums is capped at roughly $60 million a year once the stadium is fully built. Then consider that at L40 equipment upgrades are going to cost somewhere in the neighborhood of $3.2 million-$4 million PER PLAYER. For just a 40 player roster, that could be $160 MILLION! Even assuming concessions covers all salary expenses, you'd have to save for 3 seasons to pay for all your upgrades, but it will only take a little over 2 seasons (boost for 3, 1 season's worth of XP for 2, then boost again for 3) to get from L32 to L40. With these numbers in mind, the additional money from the playoff games is not as much of an excess (IMHO) as many believe it to be. And this says nothing about what's going to happen when players reach L48!!!

So I don't see this as greed. I see this as financial planning for the future and successful teams, if they're run responsibly, trying to save as much as they can to prepare for the expenditures that they KNOW are coming in the future. It's like saving for retirement. If you have, say, $100,000 in your 401k now, does that mean you're "greedy" if you don't want the government to take away your tax advantage? It may seem like a lot right now when you are thinking in terms of paying for a plasma TV or a new computer, but when you look at it from the perspective of living expenses for 20+ years, it doesn't look like quite so much. Wanting to keep every bit of that $100k THAT YOU EARNED isn't "greedy" in my book.

I understand and agree that it's ridiculous how the lower seeds have been compensated (or rather, NOT compensated) to this point. However, the analogy of using part of the stadium revenue, while it seems to translate well from the NFL or NCAA, is actually pretty flawed. Those teams don't see their operating expenses (equipment) quadruple or even quintuple in 2-3 seasons. They also have additional revenues to split (e.g., TV) and other sources of revenue completely separate from the playoff game itself (e.g., merchandising). For that reason, I don't think it's so horrible to preserve the home team's revenue as it stands.

One final attempt to make my point: I wouldn't have a philosophical problem with splitting revenue if, for example, all teams--whether in the playoffs or not--had an alternative way to generate revenue such as merchandising. If we had a merchandising vehicle where more successful teams would generate more money than losing teams in merchandise sales then that would reward good teams and serve as yet another incentive for bad teams to improve. This additional source of funds for the home playoff teams (as well as all the other teams) would offset the loss of ticket revenue from the game itself for the home team, would provide additional revenue from both tickets and merchandising for the lower seeded teams, and would more closely mirror "real life". However, implementing such a system would be VERRRY complicated, so for the sake of practicality, at least for now, I prefer a cleaner system like the Jumbotron. Lots less programming involved in that one and it addresses what is MY major concern of getting some more money into the hands of the lower seeds. Taking money away from the higher seeds on principle is less of a priority for me than it is for you.

Oh, and as an aside, if this idea would be conceptually acceptable to you too, then you have to concede that the argument that the Jumbotron option dumps excessive amounts of money into the GLB Universe (put forth by some proponents of revenue sharing) is not a valid one since merchandising would also be dumping money into the system. Whether the money came from Jumbotron or extra merchandise sales, it's still "new" money that hasn't been there before.

Last edited Oct 2, 2008 01:15:19
 
Nats Kule
offline
Link
 
Didn't mean to call you greedy, my apologies. Some owners haven't even thought about the issue as a whole and don't even have a budget, there case is it is mine and I don't want to share. You have obviously thought about the issue. Just always irks me when folks start their rampage against any playoff profit sharing because they have earned it and if anybody wants apiece then they also have to earn it. The home team earned the right to host it but both teams earned an additional game and some revenue for their efforts as it takes two to play the game.

My only concern with throwing more money in, is it really start creating a gap between the top 8 and the rest. As you have already stated the equipment increases at a much faster rate than any revenue base, as once the stadium is build, fan support is maxed and the climb to Pro is over the revenue is flat. Money will become very important in recruiting, it already has to a degree. Bort has to level off equipment and/or create new revenue streams, but that is a different discussion.

I have always believed that playoff revenue should be shared with playoff teams, with more to the teams that host the events. If they are playing then they are earning. If we start adding money than it should be shared amongst the league and while it could be called TV revenue or whatever, it is more to create an economic balance in the game with the escalating costs.
 
Groucho
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tito716
http://goallineblitz.com/game/stadium.pl?team_id=3298

This is the stadium of the #1 team in my league. No we are not an expansion league.

I hope the #8 seed enjoys their 250,000 shared revenue...


This is exactly why revenue sharing is a bad idea. Under the old system, they had a financial incentive to win. Now their financial incentive is to throw games so that they can be matched up against teams with better stadiums.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.