User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Wide Open Incompletion Case Study - Intended to answer Borts questions about the frequency of this error
Page:
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MrMoose
For what its worth, Bort, one of my WRs ( http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=69719 ) doesn't seem to be having this issue nearly as often as other WRs. So you can take a look at him and see if there's anything that stands out with his build compared to others.


For what its worth, most WR's (that I see regularly in recruiting and what not) are lacking some key items...

1 - jumping (hard to actually catch those balls over your head or to your left or right, or that will fall in front of you, or that are going past your fingertips without a good leap of faith.

2 - vision (read, react -- get in position to make the catch a lot better)

3 - possession SA's...I'd say route run, sticky hands, jumping catch and diving catch are all quite useful after you upgrade both of those attributes. One-hand catch is a nice to have down the line.
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
This happened 4 or 5 times again today.

A fix would be nice...we've spent all season with this problem. Some of my WRs are getting impatient.
 
tsherr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
For what its worth, most WR's (that I see regularly in recruiting and what not) are lacking some key items...

1 - jumping (hard to actually catch those balls over your head or to your left or right, or that will fall in front of you, or that are going past your fingertips without a good leap of faith.

2 - vision (read, react -- get in position to make the catch a lot better)

3 - possession SA's...I'd say route run, sticky hands, jumping catch and diving catch are all quite useful after you upgrade both of those attributes. One-hand catch is a nice to have down the line.


But this is a sudden increase in incompletions over last season. The QBs and WRs didn't get worse. They can't. They got better and the problems occured, so while it's nice to try "it's your build" argument (and it would actually be nice if it were a build problem, because that's something we can fix ourselves) this time it doesn't hold water.

T
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tsherr
Originally posted by SCACE

For what its worth, most WR's (that I see regularly in recruiting and what not) are lacking some key items...

1 - jumping (hard to actually catch those balls over your head or to your left or right, or that will fall in front of you, or that are going past your fingertips without a good leap of faith.

2 - vision (read, react -- get in position to make the catch a lot better)

3 - possession SA's...I'd say route run, sticky hands, jumping catch and diving catch are all quite useful after you upgrade both of those attributes. One-hand catch is a nice to have down the line.


But this is a sudden increase in incompletions over last season. The QBs and WRs didn't get worse. They can't. They got better and the problems occured, so while it's nice to try "it's your build" argument (and it would actually be nice if it were a build problem, because that's something we can fix ourselves) this time it doesn't hold water.

T


I'm not picking on anyone's build in particular...I'm picking on the build of the majority. There could have been tweaks to the code in between seasons to the passing game...whether Bort admits it or not, this site always keeps things a mystery at times, so it could very well have happened.

WR's get faster in between seasons, but I know many QB's stop at the first soft cap for strength and started working on pump fake because it was "all the rage". All of a sudden, maybe 50 strength isn't enough to hit 90 speed on fly routes consistently?

Bort also had admitted that there was some change in the code -- QB's are able to throw to an area where only the WR has a good chance at making the catch...but maybe that is throwing it higher, or to the left or right, or on a comeback route throwing short...but the fast CB's don't have the jumping or the proper vision or the proper specials to make these catches.

There are tons of possibilities...err....probabilities as to why this is an issue this season -- you're just looking for the easy way out. It can be fixed by adjusting a build, but at the higher levels, that can't be done quickly -- just like power backs were ridiculous until defenders improved strength & tackling, taking about a season to catch up, I'd guess that those who invest into jumping and vision and the possession tree will see their drops fall and completion %'s rise.

For those waiting for the answer on a silver platter...each day you wait, your build falls behind.
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Originally posted by tsherr

Originally posted by SCACE


For what its worth, most WR's (that I see regularly in recruiting and what not) are lacking some key items...

1 - jumping (hard to actually catch those balls over your head or to your left or right, or that will fall in front of you, or that are going past your fingertips without a good leap of faith.

2 - vision (read, react -- get in position to make the catch a lot better)

3 - possession SA's...I'd say route run, sticky hands, jumping catch and diving catch are all quite useful after you upgrade both of those attributes. One-hand catch is a nice to have down the line.


But this is a sudden increase in incompletions over last season. The QBs and WRs didn't get worse. They can't. They got better and the problems occured, so while it's nice to try "it's your build" argument (and it would actually be nice if it were a build problem, because that's something we can fix ourselves) this time it doesn't hold water.

T


I'm not picking on anyone's build in particular...I'm picking on the build of the majority. There could have been tweaks to the code in between seasons to the passing game...whether Bort admits it or not, this site always keeps things a mystery at times, so it could very well have happened.

WR's get faster in between seasons, but I know many QB's stop at the first soft cap for strength and started working on pump fake because it was "all the rage". All of a sudden, maybe 50 strength isn't enough to hit 90 speed on fly routes consistently?

Bort also had admitted that there was some change in the code -- QB's are able to throw to an area where only the WR has a good chance at making the catch...but maybe that is throwing it higher, or to the left or right, or on a comeback route throwing short...but the fast CB's don't have the jumping or the proper vision or the proper specials to make these catches.

There are tons of possibilities...err....probabilities as to why this is an issue this season -- you're just looking for the easy way out. It can be fixed by adjusting a build, but at the higher levels, that can't be done quickly -- just like power backs were ridiculous until defenders improved strength & tackling, taking about a season to catch up, I'd guess that those who invest into jumping and vision and the possession tree will see their drops fall and completion %'s rise.

For those waiting for the answer on a silver platter...each day you wait, your build falls behind.


Then why aren't they fixed on your team?

A quick glance from YOUR most recent game:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=143775&pbp_id=8285299
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=143775&pbp_id=8285589
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=143775&pbp_id=8288610
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=143775&pbp_id=8291450

Tell us, oh wise one, why is your team having the same EXACT problem?

You must be waiting for your answer on a silver platter... Right??

But remember; each day you wait, your build falls behind.
Last edited Oct 17, 2008 14:00:27
 
Cruzi
offline
Link
 
Love how productive these threads become.
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cruzi
Love how productive these threads become.


Well.. If we had some kind of update - we wouldn't be having this problem.
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
SCACE again.. this has nothing to do with your jumping, your one handed catching or your diving catches. Diving catches are actually a completely useless SA per how Bort describes the order of the checks on a thrown ball.

In each tic, the Sim checks to see if during that slice of time, the ball will hit the ground. If the answer is yes. Play stops. IMMEDIATELY. This is how Bort coded the game. He says so right in the responses to this thread.

So no matter how good your jumping, no matter how good your dicing catch, no matter how good your one handed catch in EVERY INSTANCE where the ball would hit the ground in that tic, the ball is going to hit the ground and no catch will be attempted.

Making those SA's and attributes useless.

 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Have we covered TE's being overthrown constantly yet?
 
tsherr
offline
Link
 
Another day with no fix. Will this be done for the playoffs, or should we assume that the passing game is broken for the season and hope the fix will be done during off season? This really does make a difference, as passing teams are at a disadvantage going into the playoffs right now.

T
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=145721&pbp_id=8672609

 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Bukowski - take the douche bag off your eyes and actually read. It takes time to correct or balance a build out. Posting replays is great and all, but I never once said my team had completed the work on all of their builds -- the higher the level, the longer it takes to fix things...thought you had been around long enough to realize that.

Enkidu - you make my case. Sure, if the ball is going to hit the ground, the play will stop as the ball will hit the ground...but in the previous "tick", maybe the ball is about to hit the ground, but it won't on that tick...queue diving catch. Jumping catch & 1-handed catch have nothing to do with the ball being anywhere near the ground.
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
All Season Long.

Unbelievable.

How can he tell us, that after many weeks, he finally found a fix - then not come back to the thread.

I really don't understand.

Are we not paying customers?

Does it not matter that teams with High Speed WRs, that like to pass the ball, are at a complete disadvantage this year?

Does the sanctity of the game not even matter, anymore?

Seriously. All teams that were built to run the ball heavily and had slow, possession WRs - are at a huge advantage over the teams that built their WRs to be Speed based.

This entire game is a constant moving target; every season its something new.

If a player is good in Season 4, he should be good in Season 5.

If a Passing game is good in Season 2, 3 and 4 - it should be good in Season 5.

I don't get it.
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Bukowski - take the douche bag off your eyes and actually read. It takes time to correct or balance a build out. Posting replays is great and all, but I never once said my team had completed the work on all of their builds -- the higher the level, the longer it takes to fix things...thought you had been around long enough to realize that.


Hey.. Its not my fault you don't watch your teams' replays.

Try watching the game more often, you might learn something.

 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bukowski
Originally posted by SCACE

Bukowski - take the douche bag off your eyes and actually read. It takes time to correct or balance a build out. Posting replays is great and all, but I never once said my team had completed the work on all of their builds -- the higher the level, the longer it takes to fix things...thought you had been around long enough to realize that.


Hey.. Its not my fault you don't watch your teams' replays.

Try watching the game more often, you might learn something.



I watch every game, but thanks. We noticed the problem earlier. We're working towards what we think is the way to correct it. You don't have to agree...you can keep waiting for the answer on a silver platter. It is people like you that drive discussion out of threads because you can't handle any opinion but your own -- closed mind.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.