User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Announcements > Recent Upgrades(discussion)
Page:
 
IggyWH
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
They were probably working universally too well before, but now the HB's are hesitating, running backwards, etc., way too often.


...as they do in real life. How many times have you watched a football game and said "if that RB would have just hit the hole instead of dancing, he'd still be running?"
 
Link
 
Last edited Aug 28, 2008 00:02:07
 
valakar
offline
Link
 
Now this is just my observation. The changes recently implemented only took one problem and turned it into many more. Blocking has basically been nerfed instead of turned down. I feel this adjustment only went to the opposite side of the problem and added more. I am in an Western Europe A League and my team hits a block and the defender is gone in a split second. The DE's and LB's are going crazy. Combine this with the stutter problem is still present and the outside pitch plays do not work.

Now does some of this actually happen in real football games, absolutely. Did there need to be changes due to the obscene broken tackles in power backs, absolutely. I am just proposing a small shift back somewhere in between where it is now and where it was before this recent update.

I apologize if I repeated things but did not go through the whole thread and I am not trying to 'bitch' but wanted to have a discussion about this and see if others are seeing the same thing.
 
Nixx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Chief Bootnaka
1) What is the Season 5 cap for second year teams?

2) What is the hit for having more than 3 of your own player's on your team, and does it effect you less if they are not starter's?

3) Are the creators of the game ever going to reward good offense and defense (because if you hold the other team to 3 and outs, and the offense controls the ball, then your D player's don't get the snaps they need for Max XP)?


1: Will be raised to 20 at the end of this season, and might be raised in the middle of next season, then removed at the end of season 5.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=674861

Level cap FAQ, #9a for more information.

2: Nothing, sportsmanship hasn't been implemented yet: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=355508

3: There have been suggestions and discussions about that, so it is possible that how XP works will be changed. Probably not soon, though.
 
tcl
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by IggyWH
Originally posted by tcl

pitch plays are still much less effective than they used to be.
here's a few more examples. also note the defense is not exactly
a good team (they lost 51 in a row until recently).

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=93810&pbp_id=6797345
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=93810&pbp_id=6802009
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=93810&pbp_id=6803006

in the first one: why does the hb step backwards after turning the
corner?

in the second and third, we have the problem of the guard pulling,
following the playcall, but the hb hesitates running the called play.

these are both scenarios that (at least i saw) happened far, far
less before the latest updates (and adjustments) set.


It's posts like this where people nitpick is the reason why Bort doesn't want to do updates and hear people bitch.

So you found 3 plays where your HB didn't get 10 yards? Have you ever watched a football game before? Things like this happen in real life all the time.


er, well, ok. if you can point out where you think i'm "bitching", that would be helpful.

and no, not 3 plays. i gave many more examples a few pages ago, and bort agreed that pitches
weren't working as intended, and gave it more tweaking. if he wants to come in and say that
how it's working now is what's intended, that's fine, but i think it's still a bit off.

we got 3.2 ypc on pitches vs an extremely weak team. our average on games before the changes
for pitches vs all teams, not just weak ones, was...well, i didn't do the math, but much, much
higher (yes, probably too high). i'm not complaining about not doing well -- we did fine. and
3.2 isn't a bad figure in the grand scheme of things, but 3 out of 10 being tackles for loss
kind of is, vs this team's defense at least. and for reference, we had 6.6ypc overall. i'm
saying there's a vast difference in pitch plays before and after. it's up to bort to decide if
this is where he wants it or not. it's not just my team, tho. i can find many more examples
from others if it'd help.

as for real life examples, the appropriate comparason here would probably be something like the
san diego chargers playing central indiana state's red shirts. yeah, i'd expect ldt to do a bit
better on outside runs than how we performed today (yesterday now). if it was a remotely evenish
glb match, then i'd be more inclined to agree. alas, it was not, no offense to nj.

personally, if i call a pitch play, i want my back to run outside. the amount of times this
actually happens now without the back stalling and observing the field is pretty low. it should
be pretty high, with stalling for visual observation being the exception, not the rule. shrug.

just providing data. like valakar said, it's discussion, not complaining.
 
valakar
offline
Link
 
I like how people want to dismiss some of these important points (during this discussion) as "Well, it happens in real football." Problem is, like tcl pointed out it is like a high school team's defensive front 7 won't push around the San Diego Chargers offensive line. That's the talent discrepancy I have seen in some of my sims and our O-line still only 'holds' blocks for a split second and our HB's still do not run outside on pitch plays without a stutter or hesitation.

My most recent loss was to the top team so I am in no way saying I lost because of these changes. I am just noticing a big shift and believe it just needs to slightly shifted back the other direction (as far as changes in blocking) and as was posted continue to look into the stutter situation.
Last edited Aug 28, 2008 00:58:31
 
tcl
offline
Link
 
ok, so i did the math after all. game by game, pitch play (and pitches ONLY)
production for 1 of my HBs, including the record (now) of the opposing team:

game1 vs 7-6: 6.5 ypc
game2 vs 9-4: 5.83333333333333
game3 vs 6-7: 6.53571428571429
game4 vs 10-3: 8.1
game5 vs 8-5: 9.0
game6 vs 12-1: 5.35
game7 vs 2-11: 10.2857142857143
game8 vs 7-6: 8.71428571428571
game9 vs 0-13: 26.5
game10 vs 13-0: 5.3
08/23/2008, game11 vs 1-12: 18.7272727272727
* this is when the updates were made
scrimmage on 08/24/2008 vs an 8-5 team: 1.10714285714286
* this is when the updates were tweaked
08/25/2008, game12 vs 5-8: 11.7 (minus a lucky run: 1.75)
08/27/2008, game13 vs 2-11: 2.0

obviously, you're going to point to game12 as pitching still working, but
you remove a lucky run and it becomes 1.75ypc. and you can note the quality
of opponents above.

before the updates, overall/combined: 9.82905982906 ypc
after the updates, combined: 1.5 ypc

again, pitches ONLY.

can do this with a few other teams if desired.
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
On the other side of the ledger, and with the qualifier that it was a friendly so it's possible that the other team had wonky tactics, the pitches looked fine in this game: http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=127451&mode=pbp Note that the team we played slightly out-ranked us on the matchup screen.

That's coming after the first game post-Bort's changes when the pitches were a complete disaster for us. I don't know if things are perfect now, but they are much better than before.
 
Guppy, Inc
offline
Link
 
I hate how the new changes has destroyed the KRS. We have the 3 wedge guys all just standing around doing nothing basically turning the ST into 8on11 contests. Is the return average more realistic? Proabably except that powerhouse return teams SHOULD be getting big returns against weaker teams. I spend alot of time doing ST for
5 teams making sure I have good matchups but now, the critical wedge has been removed from KOs and punt blocking is a joke. I dont mind well tested fixes being implement but I see the game plagued by a come IT problem of changes being rushed in and then creating more problems then were solved. And in this case, to break blocking and ST this close to playoffs is inexcusable. Bort has basically turned the playoffs into a crapshoot where even the weakest team has a chance not because they can stop the powerful teams but because Bort has.
 
IggyWH
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tcl
ok, so i did the math after all. game by game, pitch play (and pitches ONLY)
production for 1 of my HBs, including the record (now) of the opposing team:

game1 vs 7-6: 6.5 ypc
game2 vs 9-4: 5.83333333333333
game3 vs 6-7: 6.53571428571429
game4 vs 10-3: 8.1
game5 vs 8-5: 9.0
game6 vs 12-1: 5.35
game7 vs 2-11: 10.2857142857143
game8 vs 7-6: 8.71428571428571
game9 vs 0-13: 26.5
game10 vs 13-0: 5.3
08/23/2008, game11 vs 1-12: 18.7272727272727
* this is when the updates were made
scrimmage on 08/24/2008 vs an 8-5 team: 1.10714285714286
* this is when the updates were tweaked
08/25/2008, game12 vs 5-8: 11.7 (minus a lucky run: 1.75)
08/27/2008, game13 vs 2-11: 2.0

obviously, you're going to point to game12 as pitching still working, but
you remove a lucky run and it becomes 1.75ypc. and you can note the quality
of opponents above.

before the updates, overall/combined: 9.82905982906 ypc
after the updates, combined: 1.5 ypc

again, pitches ONLY.

can do this with a few other teams if desired.


All your data shows is pitches were WAY too effective and now they're a little more realistic. I do think they were tweaked a little too much but it's a heck of a lot better than before.
 
tcl
offline
Link
 
thanks to smoy686 for allowing a run on JL Picard:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=289646

here's the raw data, i'm not going to list the games but it's in order
for his team's regular season. t = total yards on pitches. c = number
of pitch plays. t/c = ypc.
t = 9
c = 1
t/c = 9

t = 120.5
c = 2
t/c = 60.25

t = 34.5
c = 2
t/c = 17.25

t = 67
c = 4
t/c = 16.75

t = 16.5
c = 4
t/c = 4.125

t = 2.5
c = 1
t/c = 2.5

0 pitch plays this game

t = 16.5
c = 2
t/c = 8.25

0 pitch plays this game

t = 48.5
c = 2
t/c = 24.25

t = 67
c = 6
t/c = 11.1666666666667

** glb updates here

t = 3.5
c = 5
t/c = 0.7

** glb tweak here

t = 30.5
c = 5
t/c = 6.1

0 pitch plays last game


before the changes: 15.9166666667 ypc
after: 3.4 with the 8/24 game, 6.1 without

unfortunately this back has limited data for post-tweak (and most do,
only a couple games since then), but i think it's pretty clear there
was a drastic change.

what i'm seeing most is that pitch plays used to have too big of a
chance to break into a huge run. i think it's a good idea for that
to have been tuned down. now, however, it seems that pitch plays are
a small chance for a huge run, and a very large chance that it's a
tackle for loss, even against very weak defenses. so basically they're
a much, much riskier play.

probably should be riskier than between the tackles, but i'm not
convinced where it's at now is where the balance should be. and
making the hb stall rather than run outside (in effect, making it
not a pitch play, but an inside run without a guard (since the guard
pulled)) seems like a strange way to solve overpowered pitch plays.
i digress.

anyone have a back who's been pitch-heavy since the updates (and before)?
i have an idea of where i can find another example or two -- stay tuned.
 
rocomo
offline
Link
 
the total data is not enough to really be a large enough sample to determine much.

I've seen the same thing with several different team that were dominating with the run before. I think that the main thing that that tweaks did were make the results of the games more predictable, ie more in line with matchup.
 
Sledge
offline
Link
 
Here is a pitch play with an interesting behavior.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=106032&pbp_id=6822757

I dont see any hesitation...stutter stepping with the back ...but as you can see the end of the play is interesting...The only thing I can think of is that the back decided to go behind the wr who would block for him.

Oh should note the back has high agility. Maybe its a factor with the stutter step.

Okay went back an looked some more...here is another pitch..But this time to the strong side. There is some muted stutter. Just looks like the back is deciding what to do.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=106032&pbp_id=6824526

Has anyone found the stutter behavoir on a weak side pitch ??? Could it be limited to just one side of the formation. Another thing to check in the code would be to see if the back is trying to headfake/juke the enemy. Could be that the distance when trying to perform a headfake/juke needs to be lowered.
Last edited Aug 28, 2008 10:03:24
 
Wolfe42
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sledge
Here is a pitch play with an interesting behavior.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=106032&pbp_id=6822757

I dont see any hesitation...stutter stepping with the back ...but as you can see the end of the play is interesting...The only thing I can think of is that the back decided to go behind the wr who would block for him.

Oh should note the back has high agility. Maybe its a factor with the stutter step.


no that looks like abug, very similar to this play
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=96458&pbp_id=6868302

I think some of these changes bort are making is making this game less fun for everyone. We build players on what is set up then changes are made that makes our player build use less. I know that if these chanes keep happening he will be losing at least one customer
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by IggyWH
Originally posted by tcl

ok, so i did the math after all. game by game, pitch play (and pitches ONLY)
production for 1 of my HBs, including the record (now) of the opposing team:

game1 vs 7-6: 6.5 ypc
game2 vs 9-4: 5.83333333333333
game3 vs 6-7: 6.53571428571429
game4 vs 10-3: 8.1
game5 vs 8-5: 9.0
game6 vs 12-1: 5.35
game7 vs 2-11: 10.2857142857143
game8 vs 7-6: 8.71428571428571
game9 vs 0-13: 26.5
game10 vs 13-0: 5.3
08/23/2008, game11 vs 1-12: 18.7272727272727
* this is when the updates were made
scrimmage on 08/24/2008 vs an 8-5 team: 1.10714285714286
* this is when the updates were tweaked
08/25/2008, game12 vs 5-8: 11.7 (minus a lucky run: 1.75)
08/27/2008, game13 vs 2-11: 2.0

obviously, you're going to point to game12 as pitching still working, but
you remove a lucky run and it becomes 1.75ypc. and you can note the quality
of opponents above.

before the updates, overall/combined: 9.82905982906 ypc
after the updates, combined: 1.5 ypc

again, pitches ONLY.

can do this with a few other teams if desired.


All your data shows is pitches were WAY too effective and now they're a little more realistic. I do think they were tweaked a little too much but it's a heck of a lot better than before.


Because his data is limited to one player, and has only two games after the change, it doesn't show much of anything.

But if his player is typical, it would show that pitches were, in fact, WAY too powerful before the change but also WAY too weak after the change-- meaning something in between would be needed.

Combine this with the fact that fewer tackles are missed now than before, and the running game has been nerfed, both for power guys (better inside runners) and for speed guys.

Running averages were about 0.5 ypc too high, so I can somewhat understand it. However, my view of it was that a great deal of that was due to the low Tackling of opponents.

If it were up to me, I'd make it harder for the DLine to tackle again (which is, as far as I can tell, the main cause of the large decline in broken tackles) and end the stupid hesitation, running backwards, etc., at least for backs with solid Vision.

On the other hand, I'd keep some lower level of decrease in how long blocks can be held and retain the smarter behavior of defenders (who, if they read the run, now go through the hole created by the pulling guard to go for the carrier, as that only makes sense; I might make Vision a key to make that read, though).

Last edited Aug 28, 2008 12:30:45
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.