Originally posted by IggyWH
Originally posted by tcl
pitch plays are still much less effective than they used to be.
here's a few more examples. also note the defense is not exactly
a good team (they lost 51 in a row until recently).
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=93810&pbp_id=6797345
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=93810&pbp_id=6802009
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=93810&pbp_id=6803006
in the first one: why does the hb step backwards after turning the
corner?
in the second and third, we have the problem of the guard pulling,
following the playcall, but the hb hesitates running the called play.
these are both scenarios that (at least i saw) happened far, far
less before the latest updates (and adjustments) set.
It's posts like this where people nitpick is the reason why Bort doesn't want to do updates and hear people bitch.
So you found 3 plays where your HB didn't get 10 yards? Have you ever watched a football game before? Things like this happen in real life all the time. er, well, ok. if you can point out where you think i'm "bitching", that would be helpful.
and no, not 3 plays. i gave many more examples a few pages ago, and bort agreed that pitches
weren't working as intended, and gave it more tweaking. if he wants to come in and say that
how it's working now is what's intended, that's fine, but i think it's still a bit off.
we got 3.2 ypc on pitches vs an extremely weak team. our average on games before the changes
for pitches vs all teams, not just weak ones, was...well, i didn't do the math, but much, much
higher (yes, probably too high). i'm not complaining about not doing well -- we did fine. and
3.2 isn't a bad figure in the grand scheme of things, but 3 out of 10 being tackles for loss
kind of is, vs this team's defense at least. and for reference, we had 6.6ypc overall. i'm
saying there's a vast difference in pitch plays before and after. it's up to bort to decide if
this is where he wants it or not. it's not just my team, tho. i can find many more examples
from others if it'd help.
as for real life examples, the appropriate comparason here would probably be something like the
san diego chargers playing central indiana state's red shirts. yeah, i'd expect ldt to do a bit
better on outside runs than how we performed today (yesterday now). if it was a remotely evenish
glb match, then i'd be more inclined to agree. alas, it was not, no offense to nj.
personally, if i call a pitch play, i want my back to run outside. the amount of times this
actually happens now without the back stalling and observing the field is pretty low. it should
be pretty high, with stalling for visual observation being the exception, not the rule. shrug.
just providing data. like valakar said, it's discussion, not complaining.