Originally posted by IggyWH
Originally posted by tcl
pitch plays are still much less effective than they used to be.
here's a few more examples. also note the defense is not exactly
a good team (they lost 51 in a row until recently).
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=93810&pbp_id=6797345
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=93810&pbp_id=6802009
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=93810&pbp_id=6803006
in the first one: why does the hb step backwards after turning the
corner?
in the second and third, we have the problem of the guard pulling,
following the playcall, but the hb hesitates running the called play.
these are both scenarios that (at least i saw) happened far, far
less before the latest updates (and adjustments) set.
It's posts like this where people nitpick is the reason why Bort doesn't want to do updates and hear people bitch.
So you found 3 plays where your HB didn't get 10 yards? Have you ever watched a football game before? Things like this happen in real life all the time. I've mostly defended the sim changes, and I don't want Bort to be afraid to make them; but I do think that pitch plays have been weakened too much. And people should be able to point out errors when they seem to exist.
A good counterexample, if I'm wrong would be a game in which pitches worked really well in a fairly even matchup.
They were probably working universally too well before, but now the HB's are hesitating, running backwards, etc., way too often.