User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > GLB Insider: The truth behind all the teams leaving.
Page:
 
tttbrian
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Seth0194
Originally posted by D-will

i still don't see why people stereotype 13 year olds. There like in glb's most wanted.


Because if you have 10 13 year olds, only about 2 are going to be reliable in this game. Case in point my son who is 13 startd this game, wanted money for flex points let him buy a 1000 points, now his players sit gathering dust along with about 200 flex points.



you should merge his account into yours
 
horizon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Turd Ferguson
Bottom line is teams are too cheap. Kids are not paying to play and they are creating multiple accounts to get flex points. (speculation of course) I think there should be a league where only people who pay actual money are allowed to play. It would make team ownership much easier.

When you have a group of guys that all have something invested it makes it much easier to get you point across as an owner. The players that are active in the forums are generally the ones that have something invested.


I can't speak for everyone else...but why would I spend my hard earned cash on a game that is:

Still in beta.
A stat system that is constantly changing, making my "specific" build useless one week, and a God-send the next.
A FA system that owners complain the players have too much power.
A FA system that players complain the owners have too much power.


Once Bort and co get the bugs worked out, decided what stats should affect what, and basically get this game to the point of "almost release"/released, I dont plan on spending a dime.

It is a great game, and I do enjoy playing my single character. I do send out the referral link out to other guys and gals I know would enjoy this game, so dont think Im some kind of hater, just causing waves.
 
PatrolzCat
offline
Link
 
Why are people leaving?

I think it's because you have a lot of whiny, cry babies here. Who have this assumption, because they spent a couple of dollars, it gives them the right to bitch about every single problem they come across.

Now I think the tweaking, nerfing, etc.. Is the main problem in people leaving. There needs to be time spent on fixing the bugs of the game, not constantly changing the format. Which just leads to even more bugs. Go with what it is for a few seasons, give people the benefit of knowing, there player won't become completely useless due to the fact the powers that be, decided to "nerf" everything. The 4th full season is almost complete, at some point, you have to set a solid foundation for all players, and go with it. If it is constantly changing, people will continue to get irritated by this, and the decline will just continue.
 
greengoose
offline
Link
 
Part of the problem is we are trying to play the game and test the game at the same time - and the environment in which you play and test continuously changes. Those are two conflicting issues.

If you are playing - you really don't want the environment to change. You want to know what the rules are and what that environment is so you can plan accordingly (in both player development and gameplanning strategy).
 
FBGProfessor
offline
Link
 
This is a great post. Lost of good points in this thread but I think Bort needs to start with the economy. The winning teams get too many advantages and it makes it difficult to achieve competitive balance. Originally posted by Ramius
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder


That point being, if you can't win anything by the time you start to run out of cash, you're doing something wrong. Teams cost about 1.5-2 mil in salary a year, and yet even at their lowest, teams will make 6-8 mil a year. With responsible money-management, money shouldn't be a problem.


I'm not sure where you are getting this. My fringe playoff team carries a salary of 4.2 million per season, and i am paying most of my players not much above the minimum salaries. Only teams with players level 2-8 can run a team on only 1.5-2 mil per season.

The game economics are broken horrendously. Sure, i know how to run my team and i make sure i have enough left over. But take a top team versus a middle team over the course of 2 seasons (same stadium size, same team salary, etc), and the top team will bank 50-80 million while the middle tier will bank 20 million. Top teams get more fan support and thus can charge insane ticket prices, making money, and they also get huge bonuses for hosting playoff games.

The game really is broken in that both from an economic and a player standpoint, it is all but impossible to rise from the middle tiers to the top tiers. Good teams stay good, and bad teams stay bad. Dont try and say otherwise. 3 seasons in my South America AAA league, and every season, there are the same 4-5 great teams, the same 6 or so teams fighting for the final playoff spots, and the same 4-5 absolute crap teams.


 
- L -
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by greengoose
Part of the problem is we are trying to play the game and test the game at the same time - and the environment in which you play and test continuously changes. Those are two conflicting issues.

If you are playing - you really don't want the environment to change. You want to know what the rules are and what that environment is so you can plan accordingly (in both player development and gameplanning strategy).


well we're both beta testers and also "investors" in the game, as it give bort funding to keep the servers and stuff online.

It would be nice if we got to be recognized as beta testers or if we somehow got a return on our investments
 
NickS
offline
Link
 
Everyone who invests even $1 is contributing.

There seems to be this 'urgent' rush to get to some GLB Nirvana.

There are frustrations, but time will see these things get resolved. As far as the 'kids' thing goes, these are the people that make up our teams and provide fresh enthusiasm for the game. There are in fact also the future...so they may not have the $$ now, but they will have for the future and that's very important.

AI has been a great introduction and no doubt will strengthen GLB immensly. As for it's complexity dissauding people from taking teams forward...well I'm not coaching for New Orleans, so I'll have a stab at it here...

I agree with all the points regarding team ownership. Great responsibility lies with owners to ensure that teams are run correctly, with ethics and in support of players/agents (especially those newbies in the Sub Lv 13 bracket).

I have an issue soon where some of the players on teams I GM for will get left behind as they don't boost or buy CE...I think we need to review the CAP scenario for the low end teams...

An interesting thought that comes to mind is whether 'gutted' teams should automatically FA all the players and return as a CPU team for at least a season. Owners taking such action should face a 2 season block from ownership and a Flex fine (they would have to pay or be banned) should they take such action during Days 1-20 odd...

This would remove the less-serious owner from the current 'rat-race'...

Nick
Last edited Aug 30, 2008 05:59:22
 
Raves
offline
Link
 
I think it simply becomes too expensive... i would like to see a cost cut on how much it costs to buy a team as well as to extend. The same with boosting. The amount of money it costs to stay competitive is simply ridiculous and will cause a lot of player to want to leave. Heck I'm havign slight concerns if I can even keep up with it and will have to drastically cut down my players, which I normally make to help out friends which is the fun part of the game, due to the cost of constantly paying $100+ every 1 1/2 months to boost.
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Raves
I think it simply becomes too expensive... i would like to see a cost cut on how much it costs to buy a team as well as to extend. The same with boosting. The amount of money it costs to stay competitive is simply ridiculous and will cause a lot of player to want to leave. Heck I'm havign slight concerns if I can even keep up with it and will have to drastically cut down my players, which I normally make to help out friends which is the fun part of the game, due to the cost of constantly paying $100+ every 1 1/2 months to boost.


Is the truth.

And then to be told at the end that your $100 is only worth $70...

The game costs are skewed in terms of maintaining the game long term. Bort originally envisioned a small elect dedicated clique, and GLB has instead spread like wildfire; but he's never changed his business plan to incorporate the casual gamer.
 
Revv
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tito716
Originally posted by Revv

Originally posted by Haavoc


Originally posted by phthalatemagic




Create special non-boosting leagues, and players that exist on that database or league must stay there.


That's the one thing that would make me quit. What's the point to buying flex if I can join a league where I can stay competitive without it?


I like the idea. It helps people like myself that can't afford to spend tons of money to boost multiple players yet want to be able to mess around with other types of players.


GLB = A business

Nonboost leagues = bad business model

Idea = forget about it


There are ways around that. Monthly fee. I would pay a monthly fee of 10 to 20 just so all my players are on an equal playing field. They would still get flex money for custom equipment and creating players.
 
karma99
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bdogg13
Well it is crystal clear there is a problem with good owners just up and quitting lately and adding more teams WILL NOT help solve the problem. I have been a member of some great teams and the owner's just lost interest and got fed up. It sucks as a player because now I have to find a new team that I like (which is just as difficult as a GM recruiting if you ask me). I even tried to buy a team on was on to keep the group together and was denied. Things like that bug the crap out of me for the simple fact that I have the interest of a TEAM in mind yet that means absolutely nothing. Sad if you ask me.


It is worrying that seemingly permanant members of GLB are drifting away. It took me 2 seasons to find the perfect home for my CB but now the owner (who is the most stand up guy I've met here) is just so burnt out he is dropping the team at the end of this season. He's not fed up with the game it's just all too much and I think a lot of owners are feeling the same if they've been here for 3 seasons.
I'm now filled with dread at the thought of Day 41. 2 seasons ago my level 17 CB got me 150 PM's (plus blind offers I didn't even count) in 5-6 days which took an age to narrow down and then finally pick a team. What's a boosting level 30 gonna get?!

I get the feeling that the GLB "Beta" should have had a player limit until they worked things out (like a real Beta!) and not just this hybrid "Release Prices, Release Player Numbers, Beta Content" that we have now. This many players with the inevitable beta to release changes/fixes (for full price) is a recipe for disaster, and I think GLB is now reaping the consequences.

Sadly it feels more like a Get Rich Quick game that came, scored tens of thousands of players, made a few bucks and is now starting to die out as it's flaws become apparant to the masses. Beta should be limited, controlled, focused on finding and fixing bugs and adding needed/desired features that become apparant with a number of players.
The minute you take money for it, in a competitive enviroment, you have lost all chance of controlled testing. It's the same issues as releasing a game before it's ready, and there are many games (especially MMO's) that have died due to early release to the general public when the Beta testers were screaming that it wasn't ready. GLB didn't even have a Beta, other than in name.
 
Seth0194
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tttbrian
Originally posted by Seth0194

Originally posted by D-will


i still don't see why people stereotype 13 year olds. There like in glb's most wanted.


Because if you have 10 13 year olds, only about 2 are going to be reliable in this game. Case in point my son who is 13 startd this game, wanted money for flex points let him buy a 1000 points, now his players sit gathering dust along with about 200 flex points.



you should merge his account into yours


I thought you couldnt do this any longer.


 
bushidobard
offline
Link
 
First time, long time here...

Just some things that I dont think have been suggested...

1. An in-game X factor (not player X factor), that could lead to upsets. In football, in video games, in RPGs, highest level (or most power) shouldn't - and usually doesn't - result in a 100% chance of winning. Here it sure seems to.

I've been playing and reading league forums since season 2. I can't remember EVER in that time seeing a post like, "Oh sh*t! I can't believe X just beat Y!"

It happens with teams of near equal rank, but I cant remember a time mid season where a sub .500 team beat a Top 3 team.

This creates a lot of the futility that people are mentioning.

And before you post, "hey just last season in one of my leagues, one of my teams beat the champion", think about how often this happens in real football and in other games. You always hafta have a *chance*.

Will this piss off some uber-owners when their undefeated team loses to a clearly lesser opponent (but NOT to a gutted team or anything ridiculous)? Yes.

Is that person as likely to leave as the 100 newer or less hard core players on losing teams? NO! They're already hooked!

2. More education about $ issues. I GM 2 teams. Have for a while. Last season, early, we took over a busted BBB team. Made the playoffs. This season, we're in 4th place at 12-2 and will make the playoffs again.

Med & High income fan support are TERRIBLE!

Should someone fix it for me? No. Should I, as an intelligent (admittedly not math-oriented) individual who avidly reads the forums have a really good idea how to fix it myself? Yup.

Should I have recourse to do so? YES!

3. Ease vs Complexity

Balance the complexity of offensive AI and defensive AI.
Add situational complexity to depth charts (eg 3rd down offense uses different HB1)
Supply a plain text alternative to football noobs that cloaks (but doesn't dismiss) advanced settings.

E.g.
When my opponent passes, I prefer to <pick one> Go after the QB at the risk of.. etc
My overall risk-taking on passing plays should be <1-10>
Our best pass rusher is <>
Our best goal line back is <>
etc

Everyone's happy and everyone has a good chance of facing a prepared team.

4. Yeah...SAs....

Something to show it has been enacted. Please. Even if the SA isn't successful.

We like our +1 swords to glow, our special fighting moves to look cool, etc. Makes us feel like...well, they're special.

...and this could be combined with...

5. ...more ways to track / see / read about *my* player.

Not sure exactly what this entails, but being a backup is - for the average player - boring. I can't even find the plays I was in on easily.

It may sound silly, but even a more animated play-by-play would help keep people interested.

A crushing tackle by...
A deadly pass by...
so-and-so jukes by...

If your goal is to keep more, and not just the hard core, players...you have to cater to them a bit. If most people are gonna spend at least some time as back ups, it should be more fun and there should always be that little tiny chance of the crushing play or upset.

I also agree with a lot of what has already been written in regards to parity, CPU players being boosted a bit, and especially leveling.

Go all the way back to the success of the computer RPG Diablo.

People like to level up and get more stuff. Repeat.
Last edited Aug 30, 2008 09:23:05
 
Hybrid1486
offline
Link
 
I don't know if this was mentioned already, since I read the first post and then am making this one, but one thing I think would help greatly is to make the CPU players as good as their human counterparts.

It's no secret that a L20 CPU player will be outperformed by a L20 human player. if we eliminate the gap in quality there then it will make it easier for teams with poor recruiting skills to compete, thus reducing sell-off. This is the main reason I gave up my team (Buffalo Bearcats of USA AAA 2) to one of the co-GMs, and it's one of the reasons he's now selling the team at season's end.

And before anybody brings it up, this would not eliminate the need for recruiting. There could still be a slight gap in ability, one that would allow CPU teams to be competitive but not eliminate the need for human players altogether, Plus, we all know that one of the big things you want on a team is an active forum, and better, more experienced buys will see that and will want to go to teams with more humans on them.

I know I suck at wording things, but how does that sound so far?
 
djfivenine
offline
Link
 
I agree with 1 5 and 7.
GLB started with a game that you can once every other day for a hour or so.
But now, to be a good owner or GM, you are required to do HOURS of work on here everyday.
Scouting the teams, keeping your own players happy, setting tactics.

And don't get me started about free agency...
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.