First time, long time here...
Just some things that I dont think have been suggested...
1. An in-game X factor (not player X factor), that could lead to upsets. In football, in video games, in RPGs, highest level (or most power) shouldn't - and usually doesn't - result in a 100% chance of winning. Here it sure seems to.
I've been playing and reading league forums since season 2. I can't remember EVER in that time seeing a post like, "Oh sh*t! I can't believe X just beat Y!"
It happens with teams of near equal rank, but I cant remember a time mid season where a sub .500 team beat a Top 3 team.
This creates a lot of the futility that people are mentioning.
And before you post, "hey just last season in one of my leagues, one of my teams beat the champion", think about how often this happens in real football and in other games. You always hafta have a *chance*.
Will this piss off some uber-owners when their undefeated team loses to a clearly lesser opponent (but NOT to a gutted team or anything ridiculous)? Yes.
Is that person as likely to leave as the 100 newer or less hard core players on losing teams? NO! They're already hooked!
2. More education about $ issues. I GM 2 teams. Have for a while. Last season, early, we took over a busted BBB team. Made the playoffs. This season, we're in 4th place at 12-2 and will make the playoffs again.
Med & High income fan support are TERRIBLE!
Should someone fix it for me? No. Should I, as an intelligent (admittedly not math-oriented) individual who avidly reads the forums have a really good idea how to fix it myself? Yup.
Should I have recourse to do so? YES!
3. Ease vs Complexity
Balance the complexity of offensive AI and defensive AI.
Add situational complexity to depth charts (eg 3rd down offense uses different HB1)
Supply a plain text alternative to football noobs that cloaks (but doesn't dismiss) advanced settings.
E.g.
When my opponent passes, I prefer to <pick one> Go after the QB at the risk of.. etc
My overall risk-taking on passing plays should be <1-10>
Our best pass rusher is <>
Our best goal line back is <>
etc
Everyone's happy and everyone has a good chance of facing a prepared team.
4. Yeah...SAs....
Something to show it has been enacted. Please. Even if the SA isn't successful.
We like our +1 swords to glow, our special fighting moves to look cool, etc. Makes us feel like...well, they're special.
...and this could be combined with...
5. ...more ways to track / see / read about *my* player.
Not sure exactly what this entails, but being a backup is - for the average player - boring. I can't even find the plays I was in on easily.
It may sound silly, but even a more animated play-by-play would help keep people interested.
A crushing tackle by...
A deadly pass by...
so-and-so jukes by...
If your goal is to keep more, and not just the hard core, players...you have to cater to them a bit. If most people are gonna spend at least some time as back ups, it should be more fun and there should always be that little tiny chance of the crushing play or upset.
I also agree with a lot of what has already been written in regards to parity, CPU players being boosted a bit, and especially leveling.
Go all the way back to the success of the computer RPG Diablo.
People like to level up and get more stuff. Repeat.