what im going to do is pick up another back up to rotate in and out.. see if this helps
Forum > Announcements > Proposed Energy Changes
bombizzy
offline
offline
Originally posted by chuckmoyers
what im going to do is pick up another back up to rotate in and out.. see if this helps
Same here chuck...already working on it
what im going to do is pick up another back up to rotate in and out.. see if this helps
Same here chuck...already working on it
PP
offline
offline
Originally posted by TrevJo
If you put too much into stamina, then you will still get tired because your other attributes are so low, you are having to work hard to compete with other players that are stronger, faster, etc. A good balance of attributes and good sub settings are the key to energy management.
Sure, there has to be a balance, but very few players do it. Instead, they slap almost everything into glamour skills and almost ignore stamina...And then are upset because they don't get enough plays or their energy #s are low. I seriously doubt that out of the more than 80,000 players here, even 10 put too much into stamina to the point that it hurt their energies more than helped because their skill points were so much lower for their LVL than they should be.
If you put too much into stamina, then you will still get tired because your other attributes are so low, you are having to work hard to compete with other players that are stronger, faster, etc. A good balance of attributes and good sub settings are the key to energy management.
Sure, there has to be a balance, but very few players do it. Instead, they slap almost everything into glamour skills and almost ignore stamina...And then are upset because they don't get enough plays or their energy #s are low. I seriously doubt that out of the more than 80,000 players here, even 10 put too much into stamina to the point that it hurt their energies more than helped because their skill points were so much lower for their LVL than they should be.
oldskool
offline
offline
An important thing to note is that the number of plays per game isn't going to change that much as you level up. Dropping the full 40 energy from, say, 50 plays at 30 stamina sounds like a lot, but you've still got 70 points of stamina that you can increase while the 50 plays/game average is going to stay around the same.
TrevJo
offline
offline
To me, there's one thing that's broken about energy and it's this. As far as I can tell, players regain energy very quickly during the game, but very slowly in between games. That causes the following problem:
-Player A plays 30 starts with 100 energy and plays in the first half, and sits out the entire second half. By halftime he is down to 60 energy or so but by the end of the game he is back up to maybe 90 or even 100. It takes him a couple days of Normal or Intense training to get back to 100 energy.
-Identical player B plays the same 30 plays, but he plays them in the second half. At the end of the game he is down to 60 energy or so. It takes him a couple of days of Relaxed training just to get even close to 100 energy.
So the same two players could have the same workload but it seems to make a great difference as to how close to the end of the game it was.
If I am wrong, I would be happy for the admins to correct me. If I'm right, there should be some adjustment so that this doesn't happen.
-Player A plays 30 starts with 100 energy and plays in the first half, and sits out the entire second half. By halftime he is down to 60 energy or so but by the end of the game he is back up to maybe 90 or even 100. It takes him a couple days of Normal or Intense training to get back to 100 energy.
-Identical player B plays the same 30 plays, but he plays them in the second half. At the end of the game he is down to 60 energy or so. It takes him a couple of days of Relaxed training just to get even close to 100 energy.
So the same two players could have the same workload but it seems to make a great difference as to how close to the end of the game it was.
If I am wrong, I would be happy for the admins to correct me. If I'm right, there should be some adjustment so that this doesn't happen.
TrevJo
offline
offline
The above is obviously an exaggerated example. But for many players who back up multiple positions, their # of plays can easily be very large in the second half compared to the first half. Also if a team happens to end a game with a 15-play drive or something, even a starter can find themselves suddently extremely worn out at the end of the game.
karma99
offline
offline
I agree banan.. I mean TrevJo 
It does seem to be this way, which is far from ideal. Hopefully now Bort has stuck to his guns and made Energy have more meaning these are the things that can be Beta'd into line.

It does seem to be this way, which is far from ideal. Hopefully now Bort has stuck to his guns and made Energy have more meaning these are the things that can be Beta'd into line.
lawdog
offline
offline
Originally posted by TrevJo
To me, there's one thing that's broken about energy and it's this. As far as I can tell, players regain energy very quickly during the game, but very slowly in between games. That causes the following problem:
-Player A plays 30 starts with 100 energy and plays in the first half, and sits out the entire second half. By halftime he is down to 60 energy or so but by the end of the game he is back up to maybe 90 or even 100. It takes him a couple days of Normal or Intense training to get back to 100 energy.
-Identical player B plays the same 30 plays, but he plays them in the second half. At the end of the game he is down to 60 energy or so. It takes him a couple of days of Relaxed training just to get even close to 100 energy.
So the same two players could have the same workload but it seems to make a great difference as to how close to the end of the game it was.
If I am wrong, I would be happy for the admins to correct me. If I'm right, there should be some adjustment so that this doesn't happen.
That is a very good observation.
To me, there's one thing that's broken about energy and it's this. As far as I can tell, players regain energy very quickly during the game, but very slowly in between games. That causes the following problem:
-Player A plays 30 starts with 100 energy and plays in the first half, and sits out the entire second half. By halftime he is down to 60 energy or so but by the end of the game he is back up to maybe 90 or even 100. It takes him a couple days of Normal or Intense training to get back to 100 energy.
-Identical player B plays the same 30 plays, but he plays them in the second half. At the end of the game he is down to 60 energy or so. It takes him a couple of days of Relaxed training just to get even close to 100 energy.
So the same two players could have the same workload but it seems to make a great difference as to how close to the end of the game it was.
If I am wrong, I would be happy for the admins to correct me. If I'm right, there should be some adjustment so that this doesn't happen.
That is a very good observation.
PP
offline
offline
Originally posted by TrevJo
The above is obviously an exaggerated example. But for many players who back up multiple positions, their # of plays can easily be very large in the second half compared to the first half. Also if a team happens to end a game with a 15-play drive or something, even a starter can find themselves suddently extremely worn out at the end of the game.
I think that mimics real FB. During games, players play through all sorts of pulls and strains, only to miss the next game entirely. A HB that sits out 1 series comes back into the game full of juice again, but may miss the week's practice time because he has a minor sprain.
You are right that long drives wear players out, but is that really that much different than in the NFL? Sure, the QB doesn't get gased, but all the rest of the guys on O and the entire D can on a long drive. If what you are saying about the ending drive is true (and it very well might be) and players really do pay for being in on that drive for the entire week, you have a point there. However, my O racked up around twice as many plays as my D had to be on the field, I go no more than 1 deep at any position (except DB) and less than 1 deep on the OL & DL, but I didn't have a single player come out of last game at less than 77 energy (haven't yet in 9 games as owner). If you have good player builds and use the sub correctly, I don't see any of this as being an issue at all. On the other hand, if you didn't take stamina seriously enough, have no depth to speak of (no excuse for this when there are CPU players that can be signed) or use the sub #s poorly, you'll have issues...As you should
The above is obviously an exaggerated example. But for many players who back up multiple positions, their # of plays can easily be very large in the second half compared to the first half. Also if a team happens to end a game with a 15-play drive or something, even a starter can find themselves suddently extremely worn out at the end of the game.
I think that mimics real FB. During games, players play through all sorts of pulls and strains, only to miss the next game entirely. A HB that sits out 1 series comes back into the game full of juice again, but may miss the week's practice time because he has a minor sprain.
You are right that long drives wear players out, but is that really that much different than in the NFL? Sure, the QB doesn't get gased, but all the rest of the guys on O and the entire D can on a long drive. If what you are saying about the ending drive is true (and it very well might be) and players really do pay for being in on that drive for the entire week, you have a point there. However, my O racked up around twice as many plays as my D had to be on the field, I go no more than 1 deep at any position (except DB) and less than 1 deep on the OL & DL, but I didn't have a single player come out of last game at less than 77 energy (haven't yet in 9 games as owner). If you have good player builds and use the sub correctly, I don't see any of this as being an issue at all. On the other hand, if you didn't take stamina seriously enough, have no depth to speak of (no excuse for this when there are CPU players that can be signed) or use the sub #s poorly, you'll have issues...As you should
Last edited Apr 28, 2008 16:21:55
avsfan21
offline
offline
One thing that I think is that if the energy settings do stay we should have a bye week sometime during the season to have a break to regain some energy instead of just playing 16 straight weeks.
PhireHawk
offline
offline
Originally posted by avsfan21
One thing that I think is that if the energy settings do stay we should have a bye week sometime during the season to have a break to regain some energy instead of just playing 16 straight weeks.
NO!
I like the idea, but I don't wanna have to wait 4 days to play a game - it's bad enough waiting 2.
No, I think the problem is the changes were dumped on us too fast and without enough information. Had we known the changes would be as dramatic as they clearly are, I think we would have been able to plan for them better when we boosted our players at the beginning of the season.
Instead, we only had last seasons results to base our understanding on. Now, most of us are screwed.
One thing that I think is that if the energy settings do stay we should have a bye week sometime during the season to have a break to regain some energy instead of just playing 16 straight weeks.
NO!
I like the idea, but I don't wanna have to wait 4 days to play a game - it's bad enough waiting 2.
No, I think the problem is the changes were dumped on us too fast and without enough information. Had we known the changes would be as dramatic as they clearly are, I think we would have been able to plan for them better when we boosted our players at the beginning of the season.
Instead, we only had last seasons results to base our understanding on. Now, most of us are screwed.
TrevJo
offline
offline
Originally posted by PP
Originally posted by TrevJo
The above is obviously an exaggerated example. But for many players who back up multiple positions, their # of plays can easily be very large in the second half compared to the first half. Also if a team happens to end a game with a 15-play drive or something, even a starter can find themselves suddently extremely worn out at the end of the game.
I think that mimics real FB. During games, players play through all sorts of pulls and strains, only to miss the next game entirely. A HB that sits out 1 series comes back into the game full of juice again, but may miss the week's practice time because he has a minor sprain.
You are right that long drives wear players out, but is that really that much different than in the NFL? Sure, the QB doesn't get gased, but all the rest of the guys on O and the entire D can on a long drive. If what you are saying about the ending drive is true (and it very well might be) and players really do pay for being in on that drive for the entire week, you have a point there. However, my O racked up around twice as many plays as my D had to be on the field, I go no more than 1 deep at any position (except DB) and less than 1 deep on the OL & DL, but I didn't have a single player come out of last game at less than 77 energy (haven't yet in 9 games as owner). If you have good player builds and use the sub correctly, I don't see any of this as being an issue at all. On the other hand, if you didn't take stamina seriously enough, have no depth to speak of (no excuse for this when there are CPU players that can be signed) or use the sub #s poorly, you'll have issues...As you should
You're missing the point. I'm not focusing on long drives or streaky playing time. I agree that long drives and streaky playing time should affect stamina more than frequent short drives or consistent playing time with consistent rest.
The point is, end-game energy seems to be drastically affected by whether a player's plays occurred late in the game, or early in the game. To use the same example regarding a long drive, let's say Player A has 80 energy then has a 15-play drive late in the game and that ends the game, dropping him to 60 energy. Player B has 80 energy then has a 15-play drive late in the game, dropping him to energy, but then is back on the bench for the last 15 plays, he ends the game with 80 energy. Player B should not end the game with so much more stamina than Player A just because he got a little rest at the very end of the game. But, it seems that he does.
To clarify one other aspect of my point. I am not suggesting that anyone should have their sub settings and depth chart to allow anyone to get down to 60 energy. But the same argument applies at higher energy as well. The difference between finishing the game with 77 energy or 87 energy may not have anything to do with # of plays, intensity of plays, or substitution patterns, but rather merely a matter of whehter the player was on the field at the end of the game.
Originally posted by TrevJo
The above is obviously an exaggerated example. But for many players who back up multiple positions, their # of plays can easily be very large in the second half compared to the first half. Also if a team happens to end a game with a 15-play drive or something, even a starter can find themselves suddently extremely worn out at the end of the game.
I think that mimics real FB. During games, players play through all sorts of pulls and strains, only to miss the next game entirely. A HB that sits out 1 series comes back into the game full of juice again, but may miss the week's practice time because he has a minor sprain.
You are right that long drives wear players out, but is that really that much different than in the NFL? Sure, the QB doesn't get gased, but all the rest of the guys on O and the entire D can on a long drive. If what you are saying about the ending drive is true (and it very well might be) and players really do pay for being in on that drive for the entire week, you have a point there. However, my O racked up around twice as many plays as my D had to be on the field, I go no more than 1 deep at any position (except DB) and less than 1 deep on the OL & DL, but I didn't have a single player come out of last game at less than 77 energy (haven't yet in 9 games as owner). If you have good player builds and use the sub correctly, I don't see any of this as being an issue at all. On the other hand, if you didn't take stamina seriously enough, have no depth to speak of (no excuse for this when there are CPU players that can be signed) or use the sub #s poorly, you'll have issues...As you should
You're missing the point. I'm not focusing on long drives or streaky playing time. I agree that long drives and streaky playing time should affect stamina more than frequent short drives or consistent playing time with consistent rest.
The point is, end-game energy seems to be drastically affected by whether a player's plays occurred late in the game, or early in the game. To use the same example regarding a long drive, let's say Player A has 80 energy then has a 15-play drive late in the game and that ends the game, dropping him to 60 energy. Player B has 80 energy then has a 15-play drive late in the game, dropping him to energy, but then is back on the bench for the last 15 plays, he ends the game with 80 energy. Player B should not end the game with so much more stamina than Player A just because he got a little rest at the very end of the game. But, it seems that he does.
To clarify one other aspect of my point. I am not suggesting that anyone should have their sub settings and depth chart to allow anyone to get down to 60 energy. But the same argument applies at higher energy as well. The difference between finishing the game with 77 energy or 87 energy may not have anything to do with # of plays, intensity of plays, or substitution patterns, but rather merely a matter of whehter the player was on the field at the end of the game.
Last edited Apr 28, 2008 17:28:38
TrevJo
offline
offline
Originally posted by PhireHawk
Originally posted by avsfan21
One thing that I think is that if the energy settings do stay we should have a bye week sometime during the season to have a break to regain some energy instead of just playing 16 straight weeks.
NO!
I like the idea, but I don't wanna have to wait 4 days to play a game - it's bad enough waiting 2.
No, I think the problem is the changes were dumped on us too fast and without enough information. Had we known the changes would be as dramatic as they clearly are, I think we would have been able to plan for them better when we boosted our players at the beginning of the season.
Instead, we only had last seasons results to base our understanding on. Now, most of us are screwed.
Agreed. Bye weeks are a terrible idea.
Originally posted by avsfan21
One thing that I think is that if the energy settings do stay we should have a bye week sometime during the season to have a break to regain some energy instead of just playing 16 straight weeks.
NO!
I like the idea, but I don't wanna have to wait 4 days to play a game - it's bad enough waiting 2.
No, I think the problem is the changes were dumped on us too fast and without enough information. Had we known the changes would be as dramatic as they clearly are, I think we would have been able to plan for them better when we boosted our players at the beginning of the season.
Instead, we only had last seasons results to base our understanding on. Now, most of us are screwed.
Agreed. Bye weeks are a terrible idea.
Tracker
offline
offline
Originally posted by DPGDawg
Originally posted by pez35
Originally posted by lawdog
Originally posted by thehazyone
Yes, I was just thinking game 1 - you all are right, if someone starts with 90 energy, they can go down to 50.
Crap...which is it!!!!!!
That guy is correct, the previous poster was wrong... There is no resetting of your energy to 60 after the game. Your energy could possibly end up 0 if you allow it to sink that low.
Theres an easy way to find out.
Everybody has played the 1st game by now.
Does ANYONE have lower than 60 energy ?
I have 2 CB's on my team that are sitting below 60 right now.
It is kind of like flying blind. I really wish the devs would outline exactly how the mechanics of energy is supposed to work and what they represent. This way we can make educated decisions as to how to manage that resource.
Trying to read thought 365+ posts of speculation and hot air does not help the players or help the devs get the feedback they need to fine tune this game. Especially on a message board that loads this slow.
I honestly think there needs to be an expanded FAQ section that is more like a users guide. Relying on other players, some of which are helpful and other that are, well let’s just say inaccurate is not an ideal situation for anew and experienced players.
A perfect example is, it is impossible to tell how quickly your starting players reach that point where they are subbed and how long it takes them in the game to be able to get back in. The game is instantly simulated and you can’t watch in game performance as it “relates to stamina” or how stamina is affecting that player’s performance or what the real difference is between playing hard or normal.
My bet is 90% of all GMs and owners set the sub setting with their best educated guess and hope for the best.
Originally posted by pez35
Originally posted by lawdog
Originally posted by thehazyone
Yes, I was just thinking game 1 - you all are right, if someone starts with 90 energy, they can go down to 50.
Crap...which is it!!!!!!
That guy is correct, the previous poster was wrong... There is no resetting of your energy to 60 after the game. Your energy could possibly end up 0 if you allow it to sink that low.
Theres an easy way to find out.
Everybody has played the 1st game by now.
Does ANYONE have lower than 60 energy ?
I have 2 CB's on my team that are sitting below 60 right now.
It is kind of like flying blind. I really wish the devs would outline exactly how the mechanics of energy is supposed to work and what they represent. This way we can make educated decisions as to how to manage that resource.
Trying to read thought 365+ posts of speculation and hot air does not help the players or help the devs get the feedback they need to fine tune this game. Especially on a message board that loads this slow.
I honestly think there needs to be an expanded FAQ section that is more like a users guide. Relying on other players, some of which are helpful and other that are, well let’s just say inaccurate is not an ideal situation for anew and experienced players.
A perfect example is, it is impossible to tell how quickly your starting players reach that point where they are subbed and how long it takes them in the game to be able to get back in. The game is instantly simulated and you can’t watch in game performance as it “relates to stamina” or how stamina is affecting that player’s performance or what the real difference is between playing hard or normal.
My bet is 90% of all GMs and owners set the sub setting with their best educated guess and hope for the best.
Last edited Apr 28, 2008 18:44:42
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























