Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by chief31
Originally posted by oldskool
If you exploit a bug (regardless of intent or knowledge on the subject), and then whine about it when that bug is fixed so that exploit is no longer dominant, you deserve to be torn into. Nobody with half a brain could think that 90 speed/10 agility was a "correct" build for a football simulation.
First, I never had SPEED without AGILITY. (Early in their build, as I build one att at atime.) So this argument isn't even about me.
Secondly, tell me what actual player would be labeled as 90 SPEED, and run a 6.20 40-time?
Is it reasonable to assume that a real person who qualifies as 90 SPEED would run a good 4.-something?
NO. We are supposed to assume that guys with 90 SPEED will be slower than everyone else. Right?
Gotta go. Work.
Oh they could run all right, they couldn't carry the ball, cut to change lanes, see the lanes to cut into,
But hell, they can run,
Yea, ya got me there, helluva football player.
Because it is some peoples (not all) opinion that Speed should be separated from acceleration, that makes it a bug?
Sure, if they had low CATCHING, they should drop the ball more, but then, everybody had low CATCHING. 30, 17, what's the difference there? How does a 30 CATCHING look now?
If a LB had 20 TACKLING in season two, then he was pretty much just behind the pace. But how does that look now?
Originally posted by sjmay
LMFAO you expect Bort to PM everyone about something that should have been obvious from the get go?
It seems like the "obviousness" is rather debatable, to say the absolute least.
Originally posted by sjmay
Again, I ask you, who in the hell builds a running back, with speed only and ignores, strength, agility, vision, carrying?
My son. I am baffled by how anyone would build them any other way. At least for the firast several levels. Then worry about adding other skills.
The first thing that an NFL scout wants to know about a HB is his speed (40-time). The next thing would probably be his agilty, ability to make cuts. Then, I would think his awareness would be next. And then toughness, and durabilty, recieiving skills, blocking.
How is it cheating, to build a player in one area at a time? Do you build an OT with a fair balance of AGILITY right away? I don't. I want him to be able to block before anything else.
If you have a WR, what attribute do you build first? A weak case could be made for CATCHING, but when all WRs are gonna have 25-25 catching, you can leave it 20 and expect to be comparable with the pack, while building SPEED.
If you ask me, the bug was in CATCHING and TACKLING, not SPEED. But I assume that bug was semi-intentional, so that low-level players would be able to be useful right away.
If you were to put this all in terms of real football...
You have eleven guys on the field who are average tacklers, but very slow. (45 TACKLING, 30 SPEED) and I bring eleven guys who are poor tacklers, with good SPEED. (25 TACKLING, 50 SPEED)
What is gonna happen? We are gonna win. Every time your guys have the ball, my fast guys will be all over him. You might break some tackles, but there will be more fast guys there immediately. Because they are fast, and your guys are slow.
When I have the ball, your guys aren't going to be able to catch the fast ones.
When there is only so much football per player, Speed would actually be the biggest advantage.
Now, when they start to reach levels to where they have much higher quantities of football skills, overall, then 25 CATCHING or TACKLING will make you a totally worthless player, because everyone else will be in the 50-90 range.
But we are just starting to get to that point. We are in season four, of a ten-year career (assumed) for the highest levels of players. Which means we likely have around twenty more levels for guys to be at full skill level.
I accept that acceleration should be packaged-in with AGILTY. As I stated, I don't have, nor did I have, players with high SPEED and low AGILTY.
But when you change the rules so drastically, by selling me SPEED that includes acceleration, then take that acceleration away after I have been sold on the product, you might lose some of my respect, and possibly my business.
And by selling me SPEED. when I go to add SP to my player, and SPEED is there, under current standards, that is selling it.
You don't have to come and advertise something to me, to be selling it. Most gas stations don't do it. But they are selling it.
Generic brands of all sorts of products bypass advertising, but they still sell it.