User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Speed De's Deserve an Answer Bort
Page:
 
Jason Cash
offline
Link
 
has it even bee implimented yet? I know Bort said he was putting it into the D-League first to see if it worked or not. Either way.... Shouldnt be doing that much longer
 
vikingspwr
offline
Link
 
I'm Not getting Irate or anything, i was just hoping it would be fixed by our 2nd game, thats all i want...lol i know he is working hard to fix it and my hats off to him for all his hard work.
 
Jason Cash
offline
Link
 
it should be. Hell I didnt even know about it till one of my LBers asked me what his pass rusher setting should be.
 
Guru25
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AnTiNiNjA


OTS don't make contact and hold it in football. They get in the path of the blocker and keep the player from getting past them. Making contact and grabbing them is called holding, and is a penalty.

If you want to see unrealistic, the NT would be on the qb quicker than anyone else, since you take distance from the qb during the snap...

Its not our problem if people think just blocking and strength makes a good blocker, which they do. A blocker than can hardly move that is.


What are you talking about? Of course OTs make contact in football. What do you think a pancake is? There is more contact between the cbs and wrs on that play than the DE and OT.

 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Guru25
Originally posted by Bort

Example of what "elusive" can help you do:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=88491&pbp_id=910050

Of course, magnus is pretty good. I'm still making minor adjustments to make sure it's not overpowering.


This would never happen in a real game of football- where a DE runs right around the OT. The OT starts out a foot away from the DE. There is no way that someone could just run around the OT. The DE should have to make contact and do a spin/swim/bull-rush move to get past an OT. If more of these plays start cropping up it will show how people can make a completely unrealistic person and be successful. Speed + Agility will be the only thing you need in order to make a successful DE. So to counter people will make Speed + Agility OTs that are weak and unrealistic just to beat these overpowered DEs.


He's still tweaking it so it isn't overpowered, but an OT who's very slow and isn't fairly agile (say, lacking agility at least close to 30 and lacking speed at least approaching 20) ought to have a lot of trouble stopping fast, agile DE's.

The counterbalance is that on run plays if someone goes just for speed and agility in a DE, the DE will get pancaked by the stronger OT, and take a morale hit. "Shock Block" should also be quite effective for a much stronger OT if he can catch the DE.
 
mpowell
offline
Link
 
I have to say that the idea of speed non-strength DE as a pass rusher is completely unrealistic. The whole point of being able to put a hand down on the rush is that you have to bring some serious strength to the table. An outside LB in a 3-4 can afford to be quite a bit weaker, but if you're getting a lot of pressure on the QB, you're still at least as strong as your average LB. And if a LB is going to need 30-40 strength, any kind of decent DE should require 40 strength. The whole problem here is the blocking skill of the OT is being ignored. First of all, he doesn't have to move very far compared to the DE to get to the QB. Secondly, the OT is really strong, so a hand chuck against a weak player is generally sufficient. Basically, no amount of humanly realistic speed will get you around an OT that knows what he is doing and can move his feet (think 30-40 agility). The speed rush only works when you have enough strength that the OT is challenged to move quickly enough without losing his balance and strength advantage. The other thing to keep in mind is that even top NFL speed rushers aren't good at run defense because they give up something on strength. And those guys are generally 'exceptional'. In GLB, there shouldn't really be exceptional builds since nobody has more skill points than anyone else. So a really effective speed rusher really should be a liability in the run game.

But the only way to get this right is to have very good realistic OT AI, and I recognize that is quite difficult. I thought the sim last season actually did a pretty reasonable job on the matter, considered in balance. There were some guys with lots of sacks, but the 'threat level' of the top DEs against appropriately matched teams seemed to match the NFL well. Also, keep in mind that we run more plays per game than the NFL.
 
vikingspwr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by Guru25

Originally posted by Bort


Example of what "elusive" can help you do:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=88491&pbp_id=910050

Of course, magnus is pretty good. I'm still making minor adjustments to make sure it's not overpowering.


This would never happen in a real game of football- where a DE runs right around the OT. The OT starts out a foot away from the DE. There is no way that someone could just run around the OT. The DE should have to make contact and do a spin/swim/bull-rush move to get past an OT. If more of these plays start cropping up it will show how people can make a completely unrealistic person and be successful. Speed + Agility will be the only thing you need in order to make a successful DE. So to counter people will make Speed + Agility OTs that are weak and unrealistic just to beat these overpowered DEs.


He's still tweaking it so it isn't overpowered, but an OT who's very slow and isn't fairly agile (say, lacking agility at least close to 30 and lacking speed at least approaching 20) ought to have a lot of trouble stopping fast, agile DE's.

The counterbalance is that on run plays if someone goes just for speed and agility in a DE, the DE will get pancaked by the stronger OT, and take a morale hit. "Shock Block" should also be quite effective for a much stronger OT if he can catch the DE.


i have an OT and a DE and i built my DE to get past any OT so his Strength should be better if not better than most OT's he will face at his level, he has 2.5 to 1 Agility over my OT as well. and my OT is no slouch, he was built at the same time to combat DE's...lol
 
Darkstrand
offline
Link
 
the tactics are fine the problem is people move too fast in this game for there weight.

A 270 lb DE with 70 speed should be MUCH MUCH MUCH slower than a 200 lb WR with 70 speed and that just isn't the case in GLB.

If they made the game like that then the magnus play wouldn't matter by the time he finished executing his long roundabout route the ball would be out.
Last edited Aug 3, 2008 01:23:57
 
cober
offline
Link
 
One the issues is players are recognizing type of play far to quickly is there any example of DE running to outside on an elusive blitz on a run play. Totally opening up his side of the line ?


I know that vision would be primary statistic for this situation. And fact remains in NFL in obvious passing situation teams often bring in their speed rushers. Think Cris Wilson for the Redskins. Basically only gets on the field on 3rd and long recorded 4 sacks and weighs only 245.

If DE is taking the elusive route all game he should be opening up his side of the line to the run. Currently the speed these DE are traveling at they could get around the OT and snuff the HB running to other side of the line in the backfield

I like options being given to player but i would like to see options given to OT QB

Example give the OT the option of where his first step should be

Outside - More effective vs speed rushers
Backwards - More effective vs Power Rushers
Reactive - Relies on vision deciding which is more effective.

As you see rather then having balanced i would like to have the option set to rely on players vision.

And same applies to my DE. Rather then having 3 options Power Elusive and balanced. I would prefer to have scale from 0 percent to 100%

I might set it to 70% elusive 30% power knowing that if my vision is wrong elusive may leave that side vulnerable to the run. Running to outside is generally more effective yet leaves you more exposed if your wrong.
Last edited Aug 3, 2008 02:26:36
 
prochazka
offline
Link
 
 
slipknottin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Darkstrand


A 270 lb DE with 70 speed should be MUCH MUCH MUCH slower than a 200 lb WR with 70 speed and that just isn't the case in GLB.


Why? In his rookie season Justin Tuck caught up to and tackled LaDanian Tomlinson after Tomlinson broke away and was free out in the open. So its completely possible for a 275+ guy to be every bit as fast as a lighter smaller one.
 
vikingspwr
offline
Link
 
Look at Kevin Williams 2 Touchdown INT's last season, No One could catch him for those long runs...lol
 
t-money
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Guru25
Originally posted by Bort

Example of what "elusive" can help you do:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=88491&pbp_id=910050

Of course, magnus is pretty good. I'm still making minor adjustments to make sure it's not overpowering.


This would never happen in a real game of football- where a DE runs right around the OT. The OT starts out a foot away from the DE. There is no way that someone could just run around the OT. The DE should have to make contact and do a spin/swim/bull-rush move to get past an OT. If more of these plays start cropping up it will show how people can make a completely unrealistic person and be successful. Speed + Agility will be the only thing you need in order to make a successful DE. So to counter people will make Speed + Agility OTs that are weak and unrealistic just to beat these overpowered DEs.


This happens all of the time. Did you play football? Have you every watched real football? Sheesh.
 
dfitzo53
offline
Link
 
To be honest, a lot of the effectiveness of an elusive rush depends on the other four linemen and the quarterback. If there's a decent pocket for the QB to step up into, he can buy himself an extra second or two against a speed rush. That only works if he has the pocket to begin with and has the poise to step up into it.

Bull-rushing, when successful, minimizes that by collapsing the pocket in the first place. (Although in that case, a fleet QB can sometimes get the outside of a bullrush and dump the ball off while rolling out.)

I'm not saying GLB necessarily needs to take things that far this season, but the effectiveness of a rush is not always about one DE versus one OT.
 
chaotic646
offline
Link
 
Ok Im not going to read 25 pages but I noticed the DE's on my team always went to the inside in our first game - has there been an update to this problem? They both have their settings on combo, switch it up between evasive and power.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.