User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Provide a Refund to the Nashville Team in USA AA#1
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Originally posted by Clinton Esquire

So there is no chance anything was ever written into the initial "code" that changed when the variable was "regular season" vs. "playoffs"?

I don't want to get into some "I'm a bigger asshole than you" contest, because I'll win that regardless of whether or not I win the initial argument - but I think you made a slight jump there assuming what Bort said initially?

Bort, goddamnit, come back here for some clarification.

Bort: I can neither confirm nor deny the presence of nuclear weapons aboard this submarine.


If we needed Bort to come in and clarify the question any more, then there is a problem. Half of this discussion revolves around the QB's confidence - Bort Chimes in and agrees that it is a confidence thing, and very clearly states that the code is the same. If there was a difference between what is supposed to happen during a Playoff game, with respect to confidence, and what was supposed to happen during a Regular Season game - I would expect that Bort would have said that there is a difference and he would make sure the decimal was in the right spot for the Playoff game. Or if Bort wanted to be sneaky and not reveal too much information about whether there is a difference or not - I'd expect him to NOT say that the code is the same. He said it is the same, in the context of confidence, and I'll take his words at that.



Oh I'm sure you're nothing but 100% right that you always know what to "expect" from Borts words.

But you are assuming he was talking about confidence in the context of playoffs vs. regular season.

Originally posted by Bort

Yes, 10 INT's is a lot, but it's not impossible. Some of them could have been PD's or incompletions, but the random number generator didn't go your way.

One selected game out of over 1000 per day does not mean everything is broken; everybody runs on the same code, same server.


He never even mentions the playoffs having a greater, or less of an effect with confidence... in fact what he is talking about is this one particular game in the context of over 1000 simmed per day might have been the statistical outlier, but that doesn't mean it couldn't happen somewhere else, or tomorrow, or next season.

He didn't even address the question of playoffs vs. regular season confidence.

Your argument is lacking and based on "what you expect."
 
Link
 
Originally posted by MichN18
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader

Originally posted by Pariah


Originally posted by Ken1



To me he is still whining about a problem that effects everyone.



My
"whining" started at approximately the halfway point of the season.
That "whining" included a respectfully worded warning that it would be
a MISTAKE to not fix the problems associated with the offensive side of
the football. That "whining" pointed out that there would likely be a
LOT of unhappy people were the playoffs turn out to be "no go" zone for
offenses.

Review your win today--your offense averaged only 3.4
yards per rush and only 5.0 yards per pass. Show me a real-life example
where a team wins 45-0 while doing virtually nothing of note on the
offensive side of the ball.

Today was in truth merely the latest
and most absurd example of a problem that myself and others have been
discussing for some time.



No doubt the sim needs some work... But you and your teammates have some sense of entitlement.

You do not deserve a refund.

You did not deserve the explanation of your loss that Bort gave you.

Personally I find it outrageous that Bort would discuss any specifics of your opponent's gameplan, builds, etc. You should be ashamed of yourself for crying about this until he did.



I won't be asking your permission any time I seek an explanation. I'm a customer--a paying one. Also, I've defended the game on countless occassions while also pointing out what I believed to be a significant flaw.

In short, I don't give a damn what your opinion is of my actions here, and I'm certainly not ashamed of them.
Last edited Jul 14, 2008 19:46:52
 
Pariah
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by Pariah

Originally posted by Ken1


but also some assholes who enjoyed sadistically taunting me.

Bort came in and explained how the O/D balance should be fixed for Season 4, and I was okay.

I tell you one thing though, the assholes really made it a bad experience for me for no good reason. We're all human here. We need to act like it, and understand that behind each person there are emotions.


WOW! Its a GAME man!!! G-A-M-E. Thats kind of scary.



When I put hundreds of dollars and lots and lots of time into it, it becomes something worth melting down over.


So when you get glitched on a video game to you demand EA sports refunds your money?
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by MichN18

Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader


Originally posted by Pariah



Originally posted by Ken1




To me he is still whining about a problem that effects everyone.



My
"whining" started at approximately the halfway point of the season.
That "whining" included a respectfully worded warning that it would be
a MISTAKE to not fix the problems associated with the offensive side of
the football. That "whining" pointed out that there would likely be a
LOT of unhappy people were the playoffs turn out to be "no go" zone for
offenses.

Review your win today--your offense averaged only 3.4
yards per rush and only 5.0 yards per pass. Show me a real-life example
where a team wins 45-0 while doing virtually nothing of note on the
offensive side of the ball.

Today was in truth merely the latest
and most absurd example of a problem that myself and others have been
discussing for some time.



No doubt the sim needs some work... But you and your teammates have some sense of entitlement.

You do not deserve a refund.

You did not deserve the explanation of your loss that Bort gave you.

Personally I find it outrageous that Bort would discuss any specifics of your opponent's gameplan, builds, etc. You should be ashamed of yourself for crying about this until he did.



I won't be asking your permission any time I seek an explanation. I'm a customer--a paying one. Also, I've defended the game on countless occassions while also pointing out what I believed to be a significant flaw.

In short, I don't give a damn what your opinion of my actions here, and I'm certainly not ashamed of them.


Didn't figure you would be lol
 
Pariah
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader

In short, I don't give a damn what your opinion of my actions here, and I'm certainly not ashamed of them.


Well we got one thing in common then
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Pariah
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader

Originally posted by Pariah


Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader



Originally posted by Pariah




Originally posted by Ken1





To me he is still whining about a problem that effects everyone.



My "whining" started at approximately the halfway point of the season. That "whining" included a respectfully worded warning that it would be a MISTAKE to not fix the problems associated with the offensive side of the football. That "whining" pointed out that there would likely be a LOT of unhappy people were the playoffs turn out to be "no go" zone for offenses.

Review your win today--your offense averaged only 3.4 yards per rush and only 5.0 yards per pass. Show me a real-life example where a team wins 45-0 while doing virtually nothing of note on the offensive side of the ball.

Today was in truth merely the latest and most absurd example of a problem that myself and others have been discussing for some time.



Defense wins championships. See 2008 NYGs for example.




Pay attention. This isn't about feeding egos on the defensive side of the football. As Ken can readily backup, the AVERAGE NFL team averages 6.9 yards per pass and 4.0 yards per rush. They generate these AVERAGES without the luxary of 116-ZERO walkover games.

Goal Line Blitz can make no such claim--the best teams average far less than the NFL averages, and even those that come close do so ONLY by padding stats against 116-ZERO walkover wins.


Again - WOW!!! This is not the NFL. It is a SIM GAME - in its early stages. Its not REAL!!!



That's a pretty weak argument to hide behind. I would think that something that calls itself a "sim" would be interested in...drum roll please...SIMULATING American style football. 10 picks in a playoff game doesn't "sim" much of anything.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Pariah
Originally posted by Ken1

Originally posted by Pariah


Originally posted by Ken1



but also some assholes who enjoyed sadistically taunting me.

Bort came in and explained how the O/D balance should be fixed for Season 4, and I was okay.

I tell you one thing though, the assholes really made it a bad experience for me for no good reason. We're all human here. We need to act like it, and understand that behind each person there are emotions.


WOW! Its a GAME man!!! G-A-M-E. Thats kind of scary.



When I put hundreds of dollars and lots and lots of time into it, it becomes something worth melting down over.


So when you get glitched on a video game to you demand EA sports refunds your money?


Have you seen me anywhere demand a refund, or say that Larry should get one?

Heck, I'm still looking to Season 4 with real belief that Bort will have at least mostly fixed O/D balance.
Last edited Jul 14, 2008 19:49:35
 
otto_g_2k8
offline
Link
 
I have to weigh in ... the most points EVER scored by one team in an NFL game was indeed the 73 scored by Chicago. Cleveland vs. Cincinnatti last year was the second highest scoring game ever by TWO team. That ANY team EVER scores 100 points by itself proves something is not right with the SIM. Part of this comes down to having ridiculously disparate teams in the same leagues as each other. Part of it comes down to details of programming (which I admit I know nothing about) I have also noticed that QBs oerform VERY porrly. MANY teams have starting QBs with absolutely horrible stats. Hopefully this will be adressed in season four updates.

ONE SUGGESTION for season FOUR:
Probably VERY hard to do, but so worth it ...
Re-organize the leagues so that teams that are in leagues they don't belong in get moved. I have seen many instances of teams in A or AA leagues that were across the board higher levels than some pro league teams. If this were addressed, we wouldn't see these GA Tech vs. Cumberland College like scores.

That said ... I love everything else about this game except for how primitive the game replays look. (would be nice if it looked a little better than the 1979 "trac-ball" football video game) Even just assigning numbers to players and having those numbers show so you can more easily follow the action would be nice.
 
Pariah
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by Pariah

Originally posted by Ken1


Originally posted by Pariah



Originally posted by Ken1




but also some assholes who enjoyed sadistically taunting me.

Bort came in and explained how the O/D balance should be fixed for Season 4, and I was okay.

I tell you one thing though, the assholes really made it a bad experience for me for no good reason. We're all human here. We need to act like it, and understand that behind each person there are emotions.


WOW! Its a GAME man!!! G-A-M-E. Thats kind of scary.



When I put hundreds of dollars and lots and lots of time into it, it becomes something worth melting down over.


So when you get glitched on a video game to you demand EA sports refunds your money?


Have you seen me anywhere demand a refund, or say that Larry should get one?


The Point of this whole thread is about a refund due to dissatisfaction.
 
MichN18
offline
Link
 
Larry, wake up and smell the roses. It simulates your distinctly substandard QB getting owned by a much better secondary.

The real question is how did your QB avoid throwing 10 INTs before now.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MichN18
Larry, wake up and smell the roses. It simulates your distinctly substandard QB getting owned by a much better secondary.

The real question is how did your QB avoid throwing 10 INTs before now.


They ran the ball.
 
hambone77us
offline
Link
 
the highest level hasnt even reached thirty yet we are in the midget leagues here guys even for the best out there. level twenty five is not a nfl level i wouldnt think
 
Pariah
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader

That's a pretty weak argument to hide behind. I would think that something that calls itself a "sim" would be interested in...drum roll please...SIMULATING American style football. 10 picks in a playoff game doesn't "sim" much of anything.


Its a simulation GAME! I think its a pretty strong argument and I STAND behind it - not hide behind it. GAME man GAME - take a deep breath then repeat it a few times, it might help.

 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Pariah
Originally posted by Ken1

Originally posted by Pariah


Originally posted by Ken1



Originally posted by Pariah




Originally posted by Ken1





but also some assholes who enjoyed sadistically taunting me.

Bort came in and explained how the O/D balance should be fixed for Season 4, and I was okay.

I tell you one thing though, the assholes really made it a bad experience for me for no good reason. We're all human here. We need to act like it, and understand that behind each person there are emotions.


WOW! Its a GAME man!!! G-A-M-E. Thats kind of scary.



When I put hundreds of dollars and lots and lots of time into it, it becomes something worth melting down over.


So when you get glitched on a video game to you demand EA sports refunds your money?


Have you seen me anywhere demand a refund, or say that Larry should get one?


The Point of this whole thread is about a refund due to dissatisfaction.


As to the refund, I don't think he should get it. I'll agree with you there.

If it becomes clear that Bort isn't going to end up making this a realistic sim in terms of O/D balance (I believe him when he says he will, but if), then I'd leave, I'd melt down over money I spent that would have been wasted, but I still won't expect it back.

I know the risks when paying for a game.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by hambone77us
the highest level hasnt even reached thirty yet we are in the midget leagues here guys even for the best out there. level twenty five is not a nfl level i wouldnt think


That argument doesn't work either. Due to the increasing costs of "build" (two points for one and three points for one required to update attributes that are already highly built), the slowing pace of XPs from games and training, and the fact that we have completed three of only 10 "peak" seasons, the players we are seeing now already have "spent" somewhere between 50 and 75% of the points they will ever spend upon their build. To compare that to "midget leagues" is a disservice to the game.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.