User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > ATTN: Tying Flex Points to Contracts as an Incentive or Condition
Page:
 
morgan3
offline
Link
 
I just read the last like 7 pages and would like it to be known I have a level 27 player, non alpha who is in USA Pros. I have never received FP from a USA Pro team nor has any offered me any (I was a free agent last offseason recruited by 5-7 USA Pro teams).

This rule will only be good as awesome, steelersinsider, oldskool, and many others have said, Either allow all FP transactions with players or none. There is no in between because thats where loop holes begin. Why can one team give their players FP as a gift, but another team who just recruited a player can't give him FP? You are paying them FP to keep them with your team if they already are on your team. Don't say you are doing it and don't care if they leave after the year because you know you are doing it so they stay with the team.
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
There is a fix for the whole alpha/mods vs. everyone else issue. Just do a total reset. Let everyone start off on equal footing. It won't matter who gutted teams in the past. It won't matter some people have higher level players. It won't matter some people knew the game better. Relegation and promotion will actually mean something as everyone will be starting off with equal level teams.
 
1VBChaos
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by morgan3
Why can one team give their players FP as a gift, but another team who just recruited a player can't give him FP?


I can give you the SIMPLE answer to that.

Because one team will either be owned by, GMed by or include players whos agents are Mods or Alpha testers.

Yet, without exception, they continue to deny any wrongdoing, produce BS excuses, try to deflect blame or try to liken apples with oranges when making comparisons.

I would like to add that I think one or two of the mods/alphas are trying to do the 'right' thing - but many more of them (and I include their legions of arse kissing hangers on in this) are simply out for screwing the game over, using their supposed 'positions' to justify, or at least camouflage, what they are doing.

Just like ANY other online game, there will always be those who HAVE to win at any cost.

They see nothing wrong with exploiting loopholes and think of it as good gaming. If they can push a rule to the point of breaking, then they will.

The sad thing is, Bort and his team have entrusted some of these people to make this game better. What's actually happening is that these people will be the reason why the game dies a death quicker than it maybe otherwise would......

But it'll all be worth it for the little icon that they display in their home pages!!

Personally, I'd rather lose with my honour and integrity intact than win at any cost......
 
1VBChaos
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wombat killer
There is a fix for the whole alpha/mods vs. everyone else issue. Just do a total reset. Let everyone start off on equal footing. It won't matter who gutted teams in the past. It won't matter some people have higher level players. It won't matter some people knew the game better. Relegation and promotion will actually mean something as everyone will be starting off with equal level teams.



Now THAT would be fun!!

I've got a big chunk of money that says if that did happen, most of the current mods/senior players would leave, as without their ill-gotten advantages, I'd wager that most would be less than ordinary - and we all know how much hackers hate losing!!

Bring it on, just for the comedy value!!
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wombat killer
There is a fix for the whole alpha/mods vs. everyone else issue. Just do a total reset. Let everyone start off on equal footing. It won't matter who gutted teams in the past. It won't matter some people have higher level players. It won't matter some people knew the game better. Relegation and promotion will actually mean something as everyone will be starting off with equal level teams.


Sorry buddy, that idea makes too much sense. Instead, we will have a convoluted mess of rules and regulations scattered throughout the site that you are expected to be able to find and have memorized, along with the acceptable exceptions to the rules in order to play this game. Since you got here a little late, you won't be able to compete for the USA Pro championship for a calendar year. Not to worry, though. After you have spent about $50/player boosting them each season to stay competitive, there is a chance in one calendar year that they might be recruited to a USA Pro team as the current higher level players will begin to decline in rankings at that time.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
OK, you want to ignore it, let's try again.
Originally posted by oldskool
Why does nobody have any fucking answers?

- If the admins are ok with this why have none of them posted; didn't we JUST add a fourth one to help with shit like this? I really hate to be one of those "I don't believe it until it's from an admin's mouth" jerks, but for god's sake this is a RULE and it involves BANNING, I'd like to see something more official than "Well uh Bort says it's ok", especially considering the following points.

- Shouldn't an ADMIN be posting about rule changes in, I don't know, ANNOUNCEMENTS, rather than a mod running around posting ATTENTION in three separate forums? The admins haven't even MENTIONED it, and most people would be warned for starting the same thread in three separate places.

- If all moderators and admins signed off on this, why did Thorn basically tell me this rule is unclear because it's incomplete, and flat-out tell me the rule is being worked on? Did you all really sign off on it, or are you just throwing shit against the wall to see what sticks under the guise of "Bort's divine will"?

- If all moderators and admins signed off on this why are there SO many completely obvious loopholes?

- Why are these loopholes not being addressed, let alone closed? Why does the answer to one inquiry into a loophole usually end up either leaving the loophole as completely open as it already was (if not more), or actively opening a new one for use?
I'm usually not one for conspiracy theories but when I see person after person citing alpha and moderator favoritism coupled with this display of complete incompetence in rule formulation and loophole closure, it just SCREAMS "alpha good, beta bad" when it comes time for one of those 'case by case' evaluations.

- Why is LJ telling us to "stop looking for loopholes"? Only positive feedback allowed? What is this, eBay? "GR8 RUL D00DZ, WUD FOLLOW AGAIN! A+++++++++"

- Why are norsemanvike, Jed & LJ implying that anyone who questions this rule in any form is a rule violator?


And now, oldskool's estimated Chain of Events:

1) Bort & norsemanvike have a chat, via PM or mod forum, about outlawing FP contracts officially. norseman offers to make a rule so mods can have something to point to upon enforcement, Bort says "go for it"

2) norsemanvike throws together this disaster and puts it on the mod forum for a vote. Bort scans it quickly, sees it harshly punishes people for offering/accepting FP contracts and gives it a vote of approval; everyone else sees the primary coder's vote, scans the rule twice as fast as he did and votes the affirmative as well.

3) norsemanvike posts the rule all over the damn place.

4) I start pointing out obvious loopholes. norseman looks for help from his comrades but receives a harsh yet fair "It's your rule, you defend it." response as they try to cover their own asses in the "Why didn't any of you tell me these loopholes were there" inquisition; thus explaining why norseman is pretty much the only person to put any effort in responding to a loophole's inquiry.

5) norseman pleads again for assistance and finally receives some in the form of LJ pulling a forum nazi in accusing anyone who questions the rule as a rule violator themself, as well as a direct order to "stop looking for loopholes". This, as is rapidly becoming the usual, completely backfires.

6) norseman disappears from the thread while leaving several incredibly dumb loopholes in the rule. People begin calling moderator and alpha tester favoritism regarding the rule's loopholes.

7) Several people suggest completely outlawing any form of FP transaction between players. These suggestions, while considerably harsher than the asinine rule that currently 'stands', are completely ignored, thus fueling the favoritism fire.

Aside: I love how moderators start to get pissy about being accused of favoritism and cheating "without proof" or "based on one incident", yet so many of them have absolutely no qualms about accusing people such as myself, awesome, Rage Kinard and others of being rule violators and cheaters with equal amounts of proof (none) and even less incidents (also none) to point to.
 
1VBChaos
offline
Link
 
Glad you're back - my head hurts from beating it against the brick wall all day.

You know what, perhaps the reason these 'moderators' are getting their arses all over the place is that the might be worried that between me, you and a couple of other sensible souls, we might actually do a better job of this than they are - and that would mean less to brag about at school for them............

I know I started out thinking you were involved in all this FP malarky, but you've convinced me otherwise. I'm with you all the way on this..........
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
Glad you're back - my head hurts from beating it against the brick wall all day.

You know what, perhaps the reason these 'moderators' are getting their arses all over the place is that the might be worried that between me, you and a couple of other sensible souls, we might actually do a better job of this than they are - and that would mean less to brag about at school for them............

I know I started out thinking you were involved in all this FP malarky, but you've convinced me otherwise. I'm with you all the way on this..........


It's funny, if TH and the others became moderators because they "outworked" everybody else in alpha, what position will people like me get when they realize that in this thread alone I outworked the entire moderating team as well as all the admins on a rule they signed off on?
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
I've seen some strange conspiracies here, but this has to be one of the strangest. I'm not sure which part of it is the craziest to address so I'll try to hit as many points as possible:

1) Not all Mods were Alpha Testers, not all Alpha Testers are close to the Mods. Just glancing at the Mod list over on the GLB forums, I think only about half the Mods were here in Alpha. I really don't know why people keep associating the 2.

2) Many people think of US Pro as the "top" league (please don't fight about that here, I'm just saying that many people think this). If you own a team in what many think of as the "top" league, why on earth would you need to go to such extremes as paying FP to attract people to your team?

As Serenity said, I've never paid anyone who is, or ever was on my team FP. Not to come there, not to stay there, not even for random fun contests people have talked about. Even if I wanted to, I'd stay away from it because of the fact that I'm a Mod and it would be way too easy to have any action like that taken the wrong way and start, well, what people are trying to start here.

3) This is not bragging, but the times where I have publicly recruited, my Inbox was flooded, many of which were VERY good people. In fact, I'm not even recruiting right now and I have 3 PMs in my Inbox which I haven't gotten to yet which are people who have said they have level 23-26 players who would like to come to my team. If that's happening, why would I ever pay someone FP? It makes no sense.

4) The teams who feel the need to pay FP to attract teams are ones which have trouble recruiting. Mostly lower-level teams. Again, if you already have a higher level team, you'll have people who want to go there to just be a part of a higher-level team. It would make no sense to have to pay FP to get that.

5) This whole conspiracy falls apart here:

Originally posted by awesome
9. One option that they have is to send FP "gifts" to these players so they can continue to boost and help the team.


Do you know what another option is? Do what I did, tell people that a requirement to be on your team is to boost. If they do not boost, then in 1-2 seasons, they will fall behind on levels, and you replace them with others who are then higher level. In fact, using US Pro as an example, that's actually a better option, since, as mentioned, high-level people are a limited resource. If I can manage to recruit a higher-level player from my opponent, that is one less higher-level player I need to worry about facing in the future. It's like getting 2x the strength out of one player. Doesn't that make more sense than spending real money to recruit people?

6) Originally posted by awesome
Then why are FP "gifts" still allowed?


Believe it or not, there are actually people who legitimately want to give a gift to a friend. The wording of this rule is to attempt to leave enough wiggle-room where we aren't forced, by rules we made, to punish someone who was not trying to do anything immoral.

That said, there's been discussion on the Mod forum about possibly having to change the rule to outlaw any FP transfers at all, because there has been some confusion about the current working of this rule. That's still being debated and I'm not sure where it's going to go, but the thought is out there.

7) And finally, if Bort wanted to wipe everyone clean and start over, I'd say bring it on. I played right through that once (with Alpha ending, we lost all our players) and would happily do it again. Do you know why? I've learned quite a bit more about player building since I made my first players and could do an even better job on my next go-around. I can guarantee you that, without any cheating, bending/breaking rules, or illegal activity of any sort that a) The Pushovers would stay together as a team and b) We'd still be one of the top US Pro teams. In fact, you could even start us in a lower league, I guarantee you we'd move up quickly and go back to being one of the top teams pretty quickly.

Now can we please get off this stupid conspiracy and back to some semblance of a discussion of this rule?
 
1VBChaos
offline
Link
 
Jed - you seem like a decent sort and I like the idea that you'd never contemplate doing anything that could be viewed as being 'dodgy' BECAUSE of your moderator status. I'm assuming you see the link between moderating and being accused of having a vested interst, hence the concious decision you've made to be whiter than white.

The thing is, people like TH have done stuff IN SPITE of them being an alpha tester/moderator - and I'm sure there are others who've muddied the waters and used their 'status' to gain an advantage.

And once someone does that AND GETS AWAY WITH IT - and then has the bare faced stupidity to keep flouting his previous rule bending, then I'm afraid you ALL get tarnished with the image that is portrayed.
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
"In fact, using US Pro as an example, that's actually a better option, since, as mentioned, high-level people are a limited resource. If I can manage to recruit a higher-level player from my opponent, that is one less higher-level player I need to worry about facing in the future. It's like getting 2x the strength out of one player."

In USA Pro, you start out with the highest level players. Under this rule, you can pay real money to keep them. Everyone else is shut out from this opportunity.

Sure, you could get lower level players to join your team, and I'm sure they are banging down the door to join. But the fact of the matter is that a lvl. 26 player will NEVER reach the same level as a current lvl. 28 player if both boost. Thus, it is to your benefit to not let the lvl. 28 player go and, instead, pay for them to continue to boost.
Last edited Jul 14, 2008 13:55:52
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
The thing is, people like TH have done stuff IN SPITE of them being an alpha tester/moderator - and I'm sure there are others who've muddied the waters and used their 'status' to gain an advantage.


OK, but here's the thing: you can certainly make the argument that unethical things were done and I won't argue. It was definite gray area. But at that time, absolutely NOTHING illegal was done.

After that incident, new rules were put in place to make sure nothing like that happens again.

Compare that to this case: we're not saying that anything will be done to anyone, whether they were the first alpha tester, or signed up 20 minutes before this rule was put out publicly, if they violated this rule in the past. But now that we saw it was a real issue, we're trying to get the right rule with the right wording in place to make sure nothing like this happens again.

I think that completely keeps in line with how rules/punishment have worked here and think that's fair.

One other thing I noticed, people are saying that this rule leaves open a loophole for people to pay FP in order to get people to resign or to keep them on the team. The rule is intentionally vague so that if we do see people trying to change the wording in the way the FP is given in order to get around it, we can still use it as a reference point to hand out punishment. The only other real option, as mentioned before, is to flat-out ban all FP transactions. That may happen in the future, just not yet.

Originally posted by awesome
In USA Pro, you start out with the highest level players. Under this rule, you can pay real money to keep them. Everyone else is shut out from this opportunity.

Sure, you could get lower level players to join your team, and I'm sure they are banging down the door to join. But the fact of the matter is that a lvl. 26 player will NEVER reach the same level as a current lvl. 28 player if both boost. Thus, it is to your benefit to not let the lvl. 28 player go and pay for them to continue to boost.


Yes, you're right, many of us there started Season 1, Day 0. If someone plays optimal minutes and boosts just the right way every game of every season, it'll be impossible to catch up 100% of the way. But look at many of the other top teams in the league. Hell, look at the starting LOT on my team.

There's proof that builds mean more than level.

And actually, my biggest point about that resource being so scarce is still valid with what you said. Yes, there's a small group of people who are theoretically impossible to catch, but if someone on my team stops being one of those people and falls behind, then it would be better for me to go out to, say, the Mustangs, the Nasty, the Coyotes, etc., and try to take away from their talent pool than for me to spend real money to temporarily keep that player or 2 boosted.
 
morgan3
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed

7) And finally, if Bort wanted to wipe everyone clean and start over, I'd say bring it on. I played right through that once (with Alpha ending, we lost all our players) and would happily do it again. Do you know why? I've learned quite a bit more about player building since I made my first players and could do an even better job on my next go-around. I can guarantee you that, without any cheating, bending/breaking rules, or illegal activity of any sort that a) The Pushovers would stay together as a team and b) We'd still be one of the top US Pro teams. In fact, you could even start us in a lower league, I guarantee you we'd move up quickly and go back to being one of the top teams pretty quickly.


Bring it on Jed, Lets start a server restart so people can stop complaining about not being able to catch the boosters, then when the boosters boost people will complain again. It will all be a vicious cycle, but hey my player would be better since I know more
 
morgan3
offline
Link
 
Jed also, is a 7 day forum ban the worst you can do? I mean come on they are still going to be able to recruit and use these antics and get the players. It requires a permanent account ban if you guys don't want this rule to be a joke
 
The_Kirk
offline
Link
 
I think I deserve some FP for reading this. (Granted, not the whole thing, but the 1st and last page) So who's sending me some FP.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.