I've seen some strange conspiracies here, but this has to be one of the strangest. I'm not sure which part of it is the craziest to address so I'll try to hit as many points as possible:
1) Not all Mods were Alpha Testers, not all Alpha Testers are close to the Mods. Just glancing at the Mod list over on the GLB forums, I think only about half the Mods were here in Alpha. I really don't know why people keep associating the 2.
2) Many people think of US Pro as the "top" league (please don't fight about that here, I'm just saying that many people think this). If you own a team in what many think of as the "top" league, why on earth would you need to go to such extremes as paying FP to attract people to your team?
As Serenity said, I've never paid anyone who is, or ever was on my team FP. Not to come there, not to stay there, not even for random fun contests people have talked about. Even if I wanted to, I'd stay away from it because of the fact that I'm a Mod and it would be way too easy to have any action like that taken the wrong way and start, well, what people are trying to start here.
3) This is not bragging, but the times where I have publicly recruited, my Inbox was flooded, many of which were VERY good people. In fact, I'm not even recruiting right now and I have 3 PMs in my Inbox which I haven't gotten to yet which are people who have said they have level 23-26 players who would like to come to my team. If that's happening, why would I ever pay someone FP? It makes no sense.
4) The teams who feel the need to pay FP to attract teams are ones which have trouble recruiting. Mostly lower-level teams. Again, if you already have a higher level team, you'll have people who want to go there to just be a part of a higher-level team. It would make no sense to have to pay FP to get that.
5) This whole conspiracy falls apart here:
Originally posted by awesome
9. One option that they have is to send FP "gifts" to these players so they can continue to boost and help the team.
Do you know what another option is? Do what I did, tell people that a requirement to be on your team is to boost. If they do not boost, then in 1-2 seasons, they will fall behind on levels, and you replace them with others who are then higher level. In fact, using US Pro as an example, that's actually a better option, since, as mentioned, high-level people are a limited resource. If I can manage to recruit a higher-level player from my opponent, that is one less higher-level player I need to worry about facing in the future. It's like getting 2x the strength out of one player. Doesn't that make more sense than spending real money to recruit people?
6) Originally posted by awesome
Then why are FP "gifts" still allowed?
Believe it or not, there are actually people who legitimately want to give a gift to a friend. The wording of this rule is to attempt to leave enough wiggle-room where we aren't forced, by rules we made, to punish someone who was not trying to do anything immoral.
That said, there's been discussion on the Mod forum about possibly having to change the rule to outlaw any FP transfers at all, because there has been some confusion about the current working of this rule. That's still being debated and I'm not sure where it's going to go, but the thought is out there.
7) And finally, if Bort wanted to wipe everyone clean and start over, I'd say bring it on. I played right through that once (with Alpha ending, we lost all our players) and would happily do it again. Do you know why? I've learned quite a bit more about player building since I made my first players and could do an even better job on my next go-around. I can guarantee you that, without any cheating, bending/breaking rules, or illegal activity of any sort that a) The Pushovers would stay together as a team and b) We'd still be one of the top US Pro teams. In fact, you could even start us in a lower league, I guarantee you we'd move up quickly and go back to being one of the top teams pretty quickly.
Now can we please get off this stupid conspiracy and back to some semblance of a discussion of this rule?