User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Announcements > Defense AI Interface
Page:
 
demonicangel
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Themuffinman
Originally posted by Concinnity

Originally posted by jprietman


Originally posted by demonicangel



Originally posted by jprietman




Originally posted by Sinyen





Maybe there could be some way to save presets to an external file? This would allow Coordinators to take their designs/playbooks with them if they ever decide to leave. The downside being that this would allow for possibility of playbook theft, but really not any different then taking screenshots of the playbook, it would just make it less work to steal. hmm


I think there already is a way to load and save your presets... But you also bring up "Playbook theft" which does seem like it would be a big concern. I wouldn't want to spend countless hours building up my playbook, only for it to be stolen by some untrustworthy GM if I decide to use it with another team. There should be a way to password-protect the file you save.

I have a feeling that playbook theft is going to be a big problem in this game. There's a lot of work that is gonna be going into these tactics.

Maybe only the defensive coordinator should be allowed to view the Defense AI page. An owner should have to make himself a GM and Defensive Coordinator if he wants to view the page.


I agree about theft being a super problem. Im not the Owner of the team, but Im a Gm.
We have a Dc. I trust them all, but not everyone has the same trust levels as we got. After 5 hours of playing with the tactics, Ive gotten about 300 diffrent plays and senerios, and Im not even half way done yet, with what I am wanting to do. Someone steals my plays, and Im going to be pissed off.


I wonder if Bort has something in mind. If my playbook gets stolen, I'm going to whine and complain a LOT.



Yea I'd be pretty pissed if I was brought in to DC then I get treated unfairly and my playbook gets stolen. Maybe owners shouldn't get access to it unless they were the DC.


come on an owner not knowing how his own defense is run? thats bull and thats coming from a DC. Theres a solution to this...its called not being an idiot. Owners shouldnt just simply give someone the DC position they should prove to the owner they are all about the team succeding ect ect and If DCs get an offer as DC they should get feedback from the owner's team's players to see if hes a good owner or not but not allowing an owner to see how his own defense is run is flat out unfair.


Not really. When a DC "interviews" for a job. He lets the owner know what he brings to the table. I doubt a H.C. being interviewed hands a owner his playbook and says here ya go bud, tell me what you think.
 
Ronin
offline
Link
 
Sorry I don't want to read through 25 pages of this, but I have a question:

Looking at formations, why are there no 2 or 1 LB options, and why no mention of safeties? All it says is 4-3 or 3-4 and how many CBs.
 
bashman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ronin
Sorry I don't want to read through 25 pages of this, but I have a question:

Looking at formations, why are there no 2 or 1 LB options, and why no mention of safeties? All it says is 4-3 or 3-4 and how many CBs.


There are Dime, Nickel, GL and Quarter packages
 
Link
 
Another question, looking at how this is set up, it's all reactionary (as most defenses are). In terms of, half of the time your Input is going to be based on the Offenses formation. For example, you'll have a specific Defense to defend against Shotgun Trips.

However, flipping it over to the offense for a moment, if it's the same sort of system, is the offense going to be reactionary too? As in, will there be options to have Inputs based on defensive formations? For example, you have an offensive set for when the D is in Goal Line (not determined by yards or score).

If that's the case, what happens when both the Offensive and Defensive Inputs are set to react to the other's formation? Who blinks first?

Sorry for the crazy question, just trying to get a handle on things.

Thanks in advance

FDC
 
bashman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Fat Daddy Cash
Another question, looking at how this is set up, it's all reactionary (as most defenses are). In terms of, half of the time your Input is going to be based on the Offenses formation. For example, you'll have a specific Defense to defend against Shotgun Trips.

However, flipping it over to the offense for a moment, if it's the same sort of system, is the offense going to be reactionary too? As in, will there be options to have Inputs based on defensive formations? For example, you have an offensive set for when the D is in Goal Line (not determined by yards or score).

If that's the case, what happens when both the Offensive and Defensive Inputs are set to react to the other's formation? Who blinks first?

Sorry for the crazy question, just trying to get a handle on things.

Thanks in advance

FDC


That's not how football works in real life! Defense adjusts to the offense not vice versa (at least most of the times)

 
Link
 
Originally posted by demonicangel
Originally posted by Themuffinman

Originally posted by Concinnity


Originally posted by jprietman



Originally posted by demonicangel




Originally posted by jprietman





Originally posted by Sinyen






Maybe there could be some way to save presets to an external file? This would allow Coordinators to take their designs/playbooks with them if they ever decide to leave. The downside being that this would allow for possibility of playbook theft, but really not any different then taking screenshots of the playbook, it would just make it less work to steal. hmm


I think there already is a way to load and save your presets... But you also bring up "Playbook theft" which does seem like it would be a big concern. I wouldn't want to spend countless hours building up my playbook, only for it to be stolen by some untrustworthy GM if I decide to use it with another team. There should be a way to password-protect the file you save.

I have a feeling that playbook theft is going to be a big problem in this game. There's a lot of work that is gonna be going into these tactics.

Maybe only the defensive coordinator should be allowed to view the Defense AI page. An owner should have to make himself a GM and Defensive Coordinator if he wants to view the page.


I agree about theft being a super problem. Im not the Owner of the team, but Im a Gm.
We have a Dc. I trust them all, but not everyone has the same trust levels as we got. After 5 hours of playing with the tactics, Ive gotten about 300 diffrent plays and senerios, and Im not even half way done yet, with what I am wanting to do. Someone steals my plays, and Im going to be pissed off.


I wonder if Bort has something in mind. If my playbook gets stolen, I'm going to whine and complain a LOT.



Yea I'd be pretty pissed if I was brought in to DC then I get treated unfairly and my playbook gets stolen. Maybe owners shouldn't get access to it unless they were the DC.


come on an owner not knowing how his own defense is run? thats bull and thats coming from a DC. Theres a solution to this...its called not being an idiot. Owners shouldnt just simply give someone the DC position they should prove to the owner they are all about the team succeding ect ect and If DCs get an offer as DC they should get feedback from the owner's team's players to see if hes a good owner or not but not allowing an owner to see how his own defense is run is flat out unfair.


Not really. When a DC "interviews" for a job. He lets the owner know what he brings to the table. I doubt a H.C. being interviewed hands a owner his playbook and says here ya go bud, tell me what you think.


They type of defense you run and the setting would be part of what you bring to the table as DC the DC shouldnt completely leave the owner out of it and not tell him what he's doing because its the owners team and if the owner wants to know all aspects of his team he should be able too after all he paid for the team not the DC.
 
Buchholz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bashman
Originally posted by Fat Daddy Cash

Another question, looking at how this is set up, it's all reactionary (as most defenses are). In terms of, half of the time your Input is going to be based on the Offenses formation. For example, you'll have a specific Defense to defend against Shotgun Trips.

However, flipping it over to the offense for a moment, if it's the same sort of system, is the offense going to be reactionary too? As in, will there be options to have Inputs based on defensive formations? For example, you have an offensive set for when the D is in Goal Line (not determined by yards or score).

If that's the case, what happens when both the Offensive and Defensive Inputs are set to react to the other's formation? Who blinks first?

Sorry for the crazy question, just trying to get a handle on things.

Thanks in advance

FDC


That's not how football works in real life! Defense adjusts to the offense not vice versa (at least most of the times)




Well, we could have the defense reacting to the offensive formation, but the Offense plays reacting to the defense. Think of it as an audible.
Last edited Jun 17, 2008 17:19:50
 
bashman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Buchholz
Well, we could have the defense reacting to the offensive formation, but the Offense plays reacting to the defense. Think of it as an audible.


Yes. Peyton Manning offense!
Last edited Jun 17, 2008 17:22:10
 
Link
 
Is there anyway to make my LB go to DE in certain formations?
 
jprietman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Fat Daddy Cash
Another question, looking at how this is set up, it's all reactionary (as most defenses are). In terms of, half of the time your Input is going to be based on the Offenses formation. For example, you'll have a specific Defense to defend against Shotgun Trips.

However, flipping it over to the offense for a moment, if it's the same sort of system, is the offense going to be reactionary too? As in, will there be options to have Inputs based on defensive formations? For example, you have an offensive set for when the D is in Goal Line (not determined by yards or score).

If that's the case, what happens when both the Offensive and Defensive Inputs are set to react to the other's formation? Who blinks first?

Sorry for the crazy question, just trying to get a handle on things.

Thanks in advance

FDC


It is a good question, because offenses do adjust to defenses via audibles. I don't think audibles are going to be implemented in this game, however, I would safely bet that the offenses tactics will be very comprehensive, to the point where it will effectively counter-balance the input/output system that the defense has.

If a defense is found using a lot of cover two, I'm sure an offense will be able to exploit that by designing plays for the TE to constantly attack the middle of the field. I'm sure you'll be able to do that easily, by setting your TE to favor post routes a certain percentage of the time.

In other words, I believe offenses will do most of their adjustments before the game, to adapt to what the defense does every game. I believe this alone should counter-balance the complex Defense AI feature.
 
demonicangel
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PERSON_OF_DOOM
Is there anyway to make my LB go to DE in certain formations?


nope not yet
 
Themuffinman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PERSON_OF_DOOM
Is there anyway to make my LB go to DE in certain formations?


no...but bort said he would put that in a little bit down the road. formation packages or something.
 
jprietman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RolandDeschain
Originally posted by demonicangel

Originally posted by Themuffinman


Originally posted by Concinnity



Originally posted by jprietman




Originally posted by demonicangel





Originally posted by jprietman






Originally posted by Sinyen







Maybe there could be some way to save presets to an external file? This would allow Coordinators to take their designs/playbooks with them if they ever decide to leave. The downside being that this would allow for possibility of playbook theft, but really not any different then taking screenshots of the playbook, it would just make it less work to steal. hmm


I think there already is a way to load and save your presets... But you also bring up "Playbook theft" which does seem like it would be a big concern. I wouldn't want to spend countless hours building up my playbook, only for it to be stolen by some untrustworthy GM if I decide to use it with another team. There should be a way to password-protect the file you save.

I have a feeling that playbook theft is going to be a big problem in this game. There's a lot of work that is gonna be going into these tactics.

Maybe only the defensive coordinator should be allowed to view the Defense AI page. An owner should have to make himself a GM and Defensive Coordinator if he wants to view the page.


I agree about theft being a super problem. Im not the Owner of the team, but Im a Gm.
We have a Dc. I trust them all, but not everyone has the same trust levels as we got. After 5 hours of playing with the tactics, Ive gotten about 300 diffrent plays and senerios, and Im not even half way done yet, with what I am wanting to do. Someone steals my plays, and Im going to be pissed off.


I wonder if Bort has something in mind. If my playbook gets stolen, I'm going to whine and complain a LOT.



Yea I'd be pretty pissed if I was brought in to DC then I get treated unfairly and my playbook gets stolen. Maybe owners shouldn't get access to it unless they were the DC.


come on an owner not knowing how his own defense is run? thats bull and thats coming from a DC. Theres a solution to this...its called not being an idiot. Owners shouldnt just simply give someone the DC position they should prove to the owner they are all about the team succeding ect ect and If DCs get an offer as DC they should get feedback from the owner's team's players to see if hes a good owner or not but not allowing an owner to see how his own defense is run is flat out unfair.


Not really. When a DC "interviews" for a job. He lets the owner know what he brings to the table. I doubt a H.C. being interviewed hands a owner his playbook and says here ya go bud, tell me what you think.


They type of defense you run and the setting would be part of what you bring to the table as DC the DC shouldnt completely leave the owner out of it and not tell him what he's doing because its the owners team and if the owner wants to know all aspects of his team he should be able too after all he paid for the team not the DC.


While the owner did pay for the team, he doesn't control or know what each player's individual tactics are. Each player even has the ability to hide their attributes from the owner.

There's a certain amount of privacy that goes with each function in the game.

What good is a great DC if someone else has his playbook? He's more or less equal.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by jprietman
Originally posted by Fat Daddy Cash

Another question, looking at how this is set up, it's all reactionary (as most defenses are). In terms of, half of the time your Input is going to be based on the Offenses formation. For example, you'll have a specific Defense to defend against Shotgun Trips.

However, flipping it over to the offense for a moment, if it's the same sort of system, is the offense going to be reactionary too? As in, will there be options to have Inputs based on defensive formations? For example, you have an offensive set for when the D is in Goal Line (not determined by yards or score).

If that's the case, what happens when both the Offensive and Defensive Inputs are set to react to the other's formation? Who blinks first?

Sorry for the crazy question, just trying to get a handle on things.

Thanks in advance

FDC


It is a good question, because offenses do adjust to defenses via audibles. I don't think audibles are going to be implemented in this game, however, I would safely bet that the offenses tactics will be very comprehensive, to the point where it will effectively counter-balance the input/output system that the defense has.

If a defense is found using a lot of cover two, I'm sure an offense will be able to exploit that by designing plays for the TE to constantly attack the middle of the field. I'm sure you'll be able to do that easily, by setting your TE to favor post routes a certain percentage of the time.

In other words, I believe offenses will do most of their adjustments before the game, to adapt to what the defense does every game. I believe this alone should counter-balance the complex Defense AI feature.


You're probably right. And I'm not at all bashing the system just trying to predict it. If it's the same Input/Output system there will inevitably be times when both Inputs are set to react to the other and I was just curious as to what would happen then. Aside from the Space-Time-Continuim collapsing that is

I'm excited for these changes. It will make the game a lot more about skill and strategy than luck.
 
Themuffinman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Fat Daddy Cash
Originally posted by jprietman

Originally posted by Fat Daddy Cash


Another question, looking at how this is set up, it's all reactionary (as most defenses are). In terms of, half of the time your Input is going to be based on the Offenses formation. For example, you'll have a specific Defense to defend against Shotgun Trips.

However, flipping it over to the offense for a moment, if it's the same sort of system, is the offense going to be reactionary too? As in, will there be options to have Inputs based on defensive formations? For example, you have an offensive set for when the D is in Goal Line (not determined by yards or score).

If that's the case, what happens when both the Offensive and Defensive Inputs are set to react to the other's formation? Who blinks first?

Sorry for the crazy question, just trying to get a handle on things.

Thanks in advance

FDC


It is a good question, because offenses do adjust to defenses via audibles. I don't think audibles are going to be implemented in this game, however, I would safely bet that the offenses tactics will be very comprehensive, to the point where it will effectively counter-balance the input/output system that the defense has.

If a defense is found using a lot of cover two, I'm sure an offense will be able to exploit that by designing plays for the TE to constantly attack the middle of the field. I'm sure you'll be able to do that easily, by setting your TE to favor post routes a certain percentage of the time.

In other words, I believe offenses will do most of their adjustments before the game, to adapt to what the defense does every game. I believe this alone should counter-balance the complex Defense AI feature.


You're probably right. And I'm not at all bashing the system just trying to predict it. If it's the same Input/Output system there will inevitably be times when both Inputs are set to react to the other and I was just curious as to what would happen then. Aside from the Space-Time-Continuim collapsing that is

I'm excited for these changes. It will make the game a lot more about skill and strategy than luck.


probably whoever has the highest lvl players. if they are even probably best builds
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.