User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Free for All > Do you believe in Evolution?
Page:
 
AFCesc4
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cbarge
Originally posted by AFCesc4

I can see where you are going with this, and I believe you are right. But are these dogs evolving into anything other than dogs? I don't think that a dog will ever be anything other than a dog. Dogs may be changing, but if the only place a dog could get food was at the top of a tree, I doubt that these dogs would eventually grow wings and fly to the top of this tree. I can't even see is being able to climb the tree to get it's food.


Well in that ridiculous example, the evolutionary consequence would be the extinction of dogs.

Incidentally, billions of species have gone extinct in our planet's history for similar reasons (albeit slightly less dramatic).


Ok, so the example was a bit drastic, but forget the example and focus on the first part... are these dogs evolving into anything other than dogs? I don't think that a dog will ever be anything other than a dog. The dog may look different over time, and I will agree that dogs have changed over time, but have dogs, with all their different traits, ever turned into something other than a dog? No, they just turn into a different looking dog. Not something entirely different like evolution would lead you to believe.
 
cbarge
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AFCesc4

Ok, so the example was a bit drastic, but forget the example and focus on the first part... are these dogs evolving into anything other than dogs? I don't think that a dog will ever be anything other than a dog. The dog may look different over time, and I will agree that dogs have changed over time, but have dogs, with all their different traits, ever turned into something other than a dog? No, they just turn into a different looking dog. Not something entirely different like evolution would lead you to believe.


Your nomenclature is the problem. It's not "dogs turning into something other than dogs." There are thousands of species of dogs, how do you think we got the ones that weren't around before? In fact, the existence of dogs themselves is an example of forced evolution. We tamed jackals and wolves and cross bred them for generation upon generation to be domesticated.

"A dog turning into a different looking dog" is not a flaw in the theory, it's a flaw in the way you think about the theory.
Last edited Jun 11, 2008 21:01:45
 
cowboys2.5
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zithers
I suppose I should go start the popcorn and get the lawn chair.


: join zithers: :thanks for the popcorn:
 
FoF
offline
Link
 
ok i havent read all of the pages sincwe m,y last post but everyone keeps on talking about all of the proof that supports evolution.
but nobody has said any. because there really isnt any..
what some people think is proof really isnt proof at all and doesnt mean anything
 
cbarge
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fistofreak
ok i havent read all of the pages sincwe m,y last post but everyone keeps on talking about all of the proof that supports evolution.
but nobody has said any. because there really isnt any..
what some people think is proof really isnt proof at all and doesnt mean anything


Keep telling yourself that. You're no scientist.
 
FoF
offline
Link
 
i am not going ot argue this anymore cause i dont have enough free time
 
FoF
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cbarge
Originally posted by fistofreak

ok i havent read all of the pages sincwe m,y last post but everyone keeps on talking about all of the proof that supports evolution.
but nobody has said any. because there really isnt any..
what some people think is proof really isnt proof at all and doesnt mean anything


Keep telling yourself that. You're no scientist.


well all of the facts that you have noone has said because there arent any
 
rams78110
ROIT
offline
Link
 
ok, seriously i have proof of evolution, is ther anyone who wants to hear it?
 
cbarge
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fistofreak
Originally posted by cbarge

Originally posted by fistofreak


ok i havent read all of the pages sincwe m,y last post but everyone keeps on talking about all of the proof that supports evolution.
but nobody has said any. because there really isnt any..
what some people think is proof really isnt proof at all and doesnt mean anything


Keep telling yourself that. You're no scientist.


well all of the facts that you have noone has said because there arent any


I'll take you through it if you wish. You have to promise to read a few pages and be open minded though.
 
AFCesc4
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cbarge
Originally posted by AFCesc4

I though it took millions of years to evolve? That would have to be an extremely lucky .01% that survived those millions of years so it could get one of those positive mutations. If you were a betting man, and you might be, would you bet for that .01%? Aren't the odds are against that .01% by quite a bit? Again, all evolution is is chance.


Nothing you said is an argument against evolution. The point is that it is very difficult to survive. Ever hear the term "survival of the fittest?"


You're right, I didn't. Excellent observation, but the chances are so small, and I'm not talking about Greece winning the 2004 Euros either, I'm talking about an astronomically small chance of this happening.

Let me give you an example and you tell me if this seems logically possible to you.

Lets suppose that the chair I am sitting in is made of only two things: oak wood, and iron (for the nails to hold it together). Ok, two things. Iron, and oak. Simple enough. Lets take a forest full of only oak trees, and I mean a ton of oak trees along with tons and tons of iron ore in its purest form sitting on the forest floor. Then, you take a tornado and run it through that forest full of only oak trees and iron ore. Would you ever expect that that tornado could even remotely possibly "create" a chair equivalent to that of a skilled craftsman? I mean does that make logical sense to you? Or would it be easier for you to believe that, hey, maybe it was created on purpose, with a design, by an intelligent human?

Which makes more sense?
 
hoshdude7
offline
Link
 
Both evolution and Christianity are retarded. Both are seriously flawed.
 
rams78110
ROIT
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by hoshdude7
Both evolution and Christianity are retarded. Both are seriously flawed.


explain the flaws of evolution.
 
cbarge
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AFCesc4
You're right, I didn't. Excellent observation, but the chances are so small, and I'm not talking about Greece winning the 2004 Euros either, I'm talking about an astronomically small chance of this happening.

Let me give you an example and you tell me if this seems logically possible to you.

Lets suppose that the chair I am sitting in is made of only two things: oak wood, and iron (for the nails to hold it together). Ok, two things. Iron, and oak. Simple enough. Lets take a forest full of only oak trees, and I mean a ton of oak trees along with tons and tons of iron ore in its purest form sitting on the forest floor. Then, you take a tornado and run it through that forest full of only oak trees and iron ore. Would you ever expect that that tornado could even remotely possibly "create" a chair equivalent to that of a skilled craftsman? I mean does that make logical sense to you? Or would it be easier for you to believe that, hey, maybe it was created on purpose, with a design, by an intelligent human?

Which makes more sense?


Even though the analogy is largely irrelevant for reasons far too technical to go into here, I will oblige.

As a mathematician I can tell you that probabilistically, given 13 billion years, you'd be surprised at what becomes nigh-certainty.
 
iMan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Captain Planet!
Evolution started when the universe, which was so small. exploded. the dust, debirs from the BIG BANG created Stars. And eventually, Planets.

Microscophic orginasms were boren on Earth. and after MILLIONS of Years. deveolped into Dinosaurs. which went extinct from a Asteroid impact. And the surviving
mammals, devolped through MILLIONS of years into Neandrothauls (Spelling?) and eventually, they evolved into...well....US.

anyone who disagrees with this is clearly delusional.


well you got the idea right but your specific info are pretty wrong

evolution didnt start when the universe formed, it started when the first life form underwent a mutation and reproduced. this variation is the trigger to evolution
microscopic organisms werent born cuz technically you need a parent to be borned. lets just use the word formed, easy to understand and more accurate than born.
Also most of the heavy elements in the world were created by Supermassive stars that existed in the early years of the universe. those elements became the building blocks for life. so we are pretty much products of dead stars.

Neanderthals (pronounced Knee-an-der-thal) coexisted with us but became competitively excluded and extinct since we beat them. we didnt evolve from neanderthals, we evolved from another Homo species.
 
AFCesc4
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cbarge
Originally posted by AFCesc4


Ok, so the example was a bit drastic, but forget the example and focus on the first part... are these dogs evolving into anything other than dogs? I don't think that a dog will ever be anything other than a dog. The dog may look different over time, and I will agree that dogs have changed over time, but have dogs, with all their different traits, ever turned into something other than a dog? No, they just turn into a different looking dog. Not something entirely different like evolution would lead you to believe.


Your nomenclature is the problem. It's not "dogs turning into something other than dogs." There are thousands of species of dogs, how do you think we got the ones that weren't around before? In fact, the existence of dogs themselves is an example of forced evolution. We tamed jackals and wolves and cross bred them for generation upon generation to be domesticated.

"A dog turning into a different looking dog" is not a flaw in the theory, it's a flaw in the way you think about the theory.


You're right, we have tamed jackals and wolves and cross breed them for generations upon generations to be domesticated. But they are still DOGS! They have never been anything other than dogs! Dogs is all they are and dogs is all they will ever be! I agree with you, dogs can be forced into change, and they can change naturally, that makes sense to me, but for something to turn into something completely different doesn't make sense to me.

With all the different kinds of birds and fish... I don't think they will ever become anything other than what they are. They may change, but they will never become another species entirely.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.