Originally posted by cbarge
Originally posted by AFCesc4
I can see where you are going with this, and I believe you are right. But are these dogs evolving into anything other than dogs? I don't think that a dog will ever be anything other than a dog. Dogs may be changing, but if the only place a dog could get food was at the top of a tree, I doubt that these dogs would eventually grow wings and fly to the top of this tree. I can't even see is being able to climb the tree to get it's food.
Well in that ridiculous example, the evolutionary consequence would be the extinction of dogs.
Incidentally, billions of species have gone extinct in our planet's history for similar reasons (albeit slightly less dramatic).
Ok, so the example was a bit drastic, but forget the example and focus on the first part... are these dogs evolving into anything other than dogs? I don't think that a dog will ever be anything other than a dog. The dog may look different over time, and I will agree that dogs have changed over time, but have dogs, with all their different traits, ever turned into something other than a dog? No, they just turn into a different looking dog. Not something entirely different like evolution would lead you to believe.
Originally posted by AFCesc4
I can see where you are going with this, and I believe you are right. But are these dogs evolving into anything other than dogs? I don't think that a dog will ever be anything other than a dog. Dogs may be changing, but if the only place a dog could get food was at the top of a tree, I doubt that these dogs would eventually grow wings and fly to the top of this tree. I can't even see is being able to climb the tree to get it's food.
Well in that ridiculous example, the evolutionary consequence would be the extinction of dogs.
Incidentally, billions of species have gone extinct in our planet's history for similar reasons (albeit slightly less dramatic).
Ok, so the example was a bit drastic, but forget the example and focus on the first part... are these dogs evolving into anything other than dogs? I don't think that a dog will ever be anything other than a dog. The dog may look different over time, and I will agree that dogs have changed over time, but have dogs, with all their different traits, ever turned into something other than a dog? No, they just turn into a different looking dog. Not something entirely different like evolution would lead you to believe.






























