User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Coaches - ideas for them to spend money on (and other ideas)
Page:
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Here is another suggestion.

Before implementing coaches, test their effects on the test server. For instance, create 2 equal teams. Give 1 team 10 coaches, and the other team 0 coaches. Then test by altering the players on both teams as if they were influenced by different coaching effects.

Try it with 20 sp per coach
50 sp per coach
100 sp per coach

Run several different allocations of those sp


So what you're saying is that the losers should get the feature before the winners? Absolutely not.
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
So what you're saying is that the losers should get the feature before the winners? Absolutely not.


NO.

There are teams in the minors that have won a championship every season.

There are teams in the Pros that have never won a championship. You could have a pro team that has never won a playoff game.

What I'm saying is implement coaching slowly, and don't give a handful of teams a huge competitive advantage from the get go.

1 coach with only a few coaching sp isn't going to make a huge difference.
10 coaches with a handful of coaching sp could
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage
Here is another suggestion.

Before implementing coaches, test their effects on the test server. For instance, create 2 equal teams. Give 1 team 10 coaches, and the other team 0 coaches. Then test by altering the players on both teams as if they were influenced by different coaching effects.

Try it with 20 sp per coach
50 sp per coach
100 sp per coach

Run several different allocations of those sp


Originally posted by Ken1
So what you're saying is that the losers should get the feature before the winners? Absolutely not.


Also, I think you quoted the wrong suggestion
 
Quas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Staz
That just makes sense to me. Very rarely do you see a player leave in the middle of his career to become a "coach". If you want your PLAYER to become a COACH, isn't it best to let him play out his career? Coaches will have more of a behind the scenes style approach and will work in conjunction with the players. Those guys on the field will inevitably determine the outcome of the game. Those Season 4, 5, 6 players will rise to the top while those S1 players "decay" and eventually become coaches. However, they'll still have to train and what not to become WORTH anything. They won't automatically become a top notch addition to the front office. Just like the players, too, those who become coaches later on in the game will have more information available to them and will be able to build better coaches. S1 guys will always be the guinea pigs, and you will no doubt see changes in how coaches perform.

Not sure what the big deal is...


Really you don't see players leave early and become a coach? I'd take you to task on that and say there are far more coaches that never played into their 30's then there are players who finished a career, then decided to coach. Heck most coaches NFL coaches never played Pro Ball.
 
Fenrir
offline
Link
 
If I already have a retired player can I convert him to coach in the future?
 
Staz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Quas
Originally posted by Staz

That just makes sense to me. Very rarely do you see a player leave in the middle of his career to become a "coach". If you want your PLAYER to become a COACH, isn't it best to let him play out his career? Coaches will have more of a behind the scenes style approach and will work in conjunction with the players. Those guys on the field will inevitably determine the outcome of the game. Those Season 4, 5, 6 players will rise to the top while those S1 players "decay" and eventually become coaches. However, they'll still have to train and what not to become WORTH anything. They won't automatically become a top notch addition to the front office. Just like the players, too, those who become coaches later on in the game will have more information available to them and will be able to build better coaches. S1 guys will always be the guinea pigs, and you will no doubt see changes in how coaches perform.

Not sure what the big deal is...


Really you don't see players leave early and become a coach? I'd take you to task on that and say there are far more coaches that never played into their 30's then there are players who finished a career, then decided to coach. Heck most coaches NFL coaches never played Pro Ball.


I agree most coaches never played, but if you're in the league, you're not going to retire early to coach. You get paid more, on average, to play than to coach.

Later on I agree with the option to create a coach, but suggest making "Players turned coaches" with more options and abilities.
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Quas
Really you don't see players leave early and become a coach? I'd take you to task on that and say there are far more coaches that never played into their 30's then there are players who finished a career, then decided to coach. Heck most coaches NFL coaches never played Pro Ball.


How many players leave early and become an NFL coach right away?

Most end up going back and coaching either small colleges or they get jobs as position coaches at their Alma Matter or for the coach they played for in college.

Also,

In a few seasons, season 4/5/6 players that want to be coaches will have to start out in the minor leagues. Nobody knows how long they will have to wait to move up either. If season 1 coaches aren't willing to do 2 seasons in the minors when they know they can go to WL or Pro and coach at the end of those 2 seasons, then how many season 4/5/6 players would be willing to become coaches after retirement when they would spend god knows how long in the minors and may never get a coaching job above AA?
 
Link
 
Funny. I was at first excited about this feature. the more you talk, Ken1, the more I begin to question that excitement. I do have a couple great ideas for how to prove loyalty, though.

Let's subtract the account's total inactive time from the player's total age. After all, anyone not active is not loyal, right? Some would take a pretty hefty hit, I bet. There would definitely be "whining" if some day 1 guy wasnt allowed to be the first coach because he took a vacation this summer.

Even better, let's do a "Total time logged in" cutoff. spending time doing things, whether it's setting tactics, scouting, or bein a board troll shows a certain level of loyalty. Huge "whining" from this idea from those oh so revered season 1 guys who log in 10 minutes every 2 or 3 days, or even worse, once a season to boost and maybe a few times during the season. are they out there? I cant say there are, other than a few on my own team. I can hear "hey not fair! I cant log in from work!" eching through these halls.

Even betterer, let's do a "Total money spent" cutoff. What better way to show loyalty than to spend real money on a free game? Anyone who has spent X amount of money on flex gets to make a coach. Lot's of "whining" in store for that idea too. Some folks havent spent any. Are there any season 1 guys left out there that have never spent any flex? I cant give you an asnswer to that. I know I've showed a lot more loyalty to this game than those folks, if they exist. Silly amounts of loyalty in a few seasons

Ooh but imagine the windfall Bort would make if he said "Ok, this is gonne be determined by how much money you've sent me. I still aint decided on the total needed. I'll decide next week, though"

Think those are silly? how about a player's total age cutoff, conicidentally the same day they start to really decline as a player? Oh wait...

Tongue in cheek humor, so dont get all upset, please. Get my point? Total number of days a player is alive is no test of loyalty to the game.

All games struggle with hard core gamers who were there early, tryin to find new and cool things to do, and some have neglected those who are either more casual or came in later to their financial sorrow. Belated updates to re-interest the casuals and late comers suddenly appear, usually in a panic, usually with flaws in them. Causal league! It's the hard core gamers with short attention spans that usually quit a game and move on, regardless of the carrots. and usualy in a snit over a sense of entitlement. to this I say, "it's pixels, brother"

it's the casual and late comers who become the bread and butter in nearly every game out there that is still goin. Those that can satisfy both the hard core set and the casuals are the truly successful ones.

I predict this will become somethin Bort will look back on and say "oops" unless he makes it less of a carrot for a small few who logged in first and treats it as something that makes the game richer and better for everyone, regardless of when they started the game.

that's my 200 flex.

Jack.
 
Draxius
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jack Kilbourne
I predict this will become somethin Bort will look back on and say "oops" unless he makes it less of a carrot for a small few who logged in first and treats it as something that makes the game richer and better for everyone, regardless of when they started the game.
Jack.


 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Another suggestion

Don't make players wait until day 440 to retire (thus giving all the alpha testers a huge jump on coaching)

Make the amount of time something like 320 days (8 seasons), and allow previously retired players who exceeded that age before retirement and kept their name to be brought back to coach. (no bringing back the players now named retired player)

This brings more coaches in immediately, and doesn't provide a huge advantage to a handful of agents.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
It's simple: In basically every MMO, characters don't age. Even though I'm for aging in GLB and always was, it would probably be a good thing if that argument could be brought back just to show you what the alternatives are. It can't be, as non-aging is on the NGTH list (and I'm one of those who lobbied to have it put on that list).

Now, when a player ages, you can either say "screw you" to the agent, or you can provide some other means of letting the character go on, one which allows other players to become the best players but leaves the owner with something to enjoy that, if he hadn't had this player, he couldn't.

Since you don't say "screw you, and forget what promises I made" to long-term players because of jealous whiners, you find the other way to let them enjoy the game, which is the coach class.

Remember, aging itself used to be debated. The promise that coaching or something else when aging made a player feel forced to retire made aging a lot more palatable to people (I was pro-aging with or without it, but liked very much giving players the ability to continue on in some way that did not take away from every player cohort having its own period at the top).

I think, though, that if you're going to say that 440 day old players should get nothing younger players can't have, you have to address the fact that pretty much every MMO in existence gives the best stuff to those around the longest. And this isn't the best stuff, as having a top player will always be better than having a top coach.
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1


I think, though, that if you're going to say that 440 day old players should get nothing younger players can't have, you have to address the fact that pretty much every MMO in existence gives the best stuff to those around the longest. And this isn't the best stuff, as having a top player will always be better than having a top coach.


You mean pretty much every MMO in existence gives the best stuff to those who

1. spend the most money
2. spend the most time
(or vice versa)

and reach higher levels through that combination.

GLB doesn't allow someone who joined in season 2 to constantly train or find pick up games for their players so they can level up faster and catch older players. Almost every other MMO, if someone plays 3-4 hours a day more than someone created earlier, they will eventually catch them.

I am not against coaching class. I am for it. However, the proposed implementation just plain sucks.

There is no reason to make someone wait until day 440 to retire to create a coach. Hell, a season 1 player created on day 16 now has to sit in limbo until day 16 to become a coach. He can't retire him until day 16 so he won't get the flex back for other uses at the beginning of the season. He could join a team, but then he has to make sure the owner will release him so he can retire and become a coach. How many owners want to use up a roster spot and take the chem hit for that? So he has to hold onto a player for 16 days, not on a team, not coaching, just sitting there as a flex holder. Meanwhile because someone else joined the game 2 weeks earlier, they are seeing their players get a jump start on coaching.

Other problems with it

Too many coaches per team
stupid shit like crafting


The currently planned implementation of coaching is simply going to bring more imbalance to the SIMs at a time when the biggest problem GLB is facing is the inability to maintain parity in leagues.




 
Outlaw Dogs
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Originally posted by Ken1



I think, though, that if you're going to say that 440 day old players should get nothing younger players can't have, you have to address the fact that pretty much every MMO in existence gives the best stuff to those around the longest. And this isn't the best stuff, as having a top player will always be better than having a top coach.


You mean pretty much every MMO in existence gives the best stuff to those who

1. spend the most money
2. spend the most time
(or vice versa)

and reach higher levels through that combination.

GLB doesn't allow someone who joined in season 2 to constantly train or find pick up games for their players so they can level up faster and catch older players. Almost every other MMO, if someone plays 3-4 hours a day more than someone created earlier, they will eventually catch them.

I am not against coaching class. I am for it. However, the proposed implementation just plain sucks.

There is no reason to make someone wait until day 440 to retire to create a coach. Hell, a season 1 player created on day 16 now has to sit in limbo until day 16 to become a coach. He can't retire him until day 16 so he won't get the flex back for other uses at the beginning of the season. He could join a team, but then he has to make sure the owner will release him so he can retire and become a coach. How many owners want to use up a roster spot and take the chem hit for that? So he has to hold onto a player for 16 days, not on a team, not coaching, just sitting there as a flex holder. Meanwhile because someone else joined the game 2 weeks earlier, they are seeing their players get a jump start on coaching.

Other problems with it

Too many coaches per team
stupid shit like crafting


The currently planned implementation of coaching is simply going to bring more imbalance to the SIMs at a time when the biggest problem GLB is facing is the inability to maintain parity in leagues.





[X] Too many coaches
[X] Stupid shit like crafting

I would agree with you on these two as I see them as the biggest issues. I would rather Bort wait another season, get it completely tested, then go with 400 days of active as the standard. That way three seasons of players will be able to turn coaches first, we'll have a lot of the bugs worked out already and hopefully he'll see that he should limit it to 3-4 coaches per team, and limit what they can do for a team to something like play recognition, or buying AEQ for their players. If Bort K.I.S.S. it then he'll have a better product that people would get behind.
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Outlaw Dogs

[X] Too many coaches
[X] Stupid shit like crafting

I would agree with you on these two as I see them as the biggest issues. I would rather Bort wait another season, get it completely tested, then go with 400 days of active as the standard. That way three seasons of players will be able to turn coaches first, we'll have a lot of the bugs worked out already and hopefully he'll see that he should limit it to 3-4 coaches per team, and limit what they can do for a team to something like play recognition, or buying AEQ for their players. If Bort K.I.S.S. it then he'll have a better product that people would get behind.


I can agree with the last couple of posts. Item crafting is just ridiculous and the amount of coaches per team is even more ridiculous. I don't like the idea at all. Takes the game further way from the players. It can already be argued that OC's and DC's make the player, now it's going to be OC/DC crafted gear and build penalization that will turn the game completely away from the players and into a management sim.
 
rams7267
offline
Link
 
we just have to watch out for the rich getting ritcher problems

i sugest that coaches should be limited to a max of three at the lowest lvls. then as your team advances up the food chain in lvl thtat each lvl opens up a new coach...like going from a cap 13 to 16 gets another coaching position opened up and all the way to getting all 10.

plus i sugest a min. amount of coaches for each lvl so teams have to use this. and another suggestion would be thatif two teams are playing and one team has their min and another has their max coaches only the ones who match up will count for each game.that way you cant buy too much of a bonus cause you have money..

we really dont want to start more problems than we solve

open for other additions here
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.