Look, I like this game. We all do, that's why we're here. But when something doesn't make sense, people have the right to speak and get responses, especially when they're spending good money.
Originally posted by Jed
3) Not really a debate, it's Beta. It's plastered everywhere.Originally posted by bovineblitzkrieg
3) When's the final version come out? Beta is a phase in testing a program. So... when's beta over? Just because you use the word beta doesn't mean it's a beta. You're calling an apple an orange.Originally posted by Jed)3) When Bort and DigitalDaggers decide the game is finished being made, tested, and debugged. At that point, only very small bugs should pop up (if any at all) and only minor changes should be made to the game.
5) NO U (that's really what that one is boiling down to)[/quote
On this topic, it doesn't boil down to "you, no you" arguing. It's a semantic disagreement.
http://www.wisegeek.com/what-is-a-beta-release.htmA beta release is a new version of a software program that has not yet been fully tested for bugs. Once a beta release is tested to the satisfaction of the writer, owner or organization, it is released as the newest stable version of the software. At this point the software will go from being, for example, “version 4.0b” (for beta), to “version 4.0.” It might also operate under a code name while in beta release.
A beta release can be open or closed. An open beta release is normally available to the general public to download and test. A closed beta release is available only to a specific group of beta testers.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Software_release_life_cycleBeta
"Beta" is a nickname for software which has passed the alpha testing stage of development and has been released to users for software testing before its official release. It is the prototype of the software that is released to the public. Beta testing allows the software to undergo usability testing with users who provide feedback, so that any malfunctions these users find in the software can be reported to the developers and fixed. Beta software can be unstable and could cause crashes or data loss.
A "beta version" is the first version released outside the organization or community that develops the software, for the purpose of evaluation or real-world black/grey-box testing. The process of delivering a beta version to the users is called beta release. Beta level software generally includes all features, but may also include known issues and bugs of a less serious variety.
The users of a beta version are called beta testers. They are usually customers or prospective customers of the organization that develops the software. They receive the software for free or for a reduced price, but act as free testers.
Beta versions test the supportability of the product, the go-to-market messaging (while recruiting Beta customers), the manufacturability of the product, and the overall channel flow or channel reach.
http://searchcio-midmarket.techtarget.com/sDefinition/0,,sid183_gci211654,00.htmlIn software development, a beta test is the second phase of software testing in which a sampling of the intended audience tries the product out. (Beta is the second letter of the Greek alphabet.) Originally, the term alpha test meant the first phase of testing in a software development process. The first phase includes unit testing, component testing, and system testing. Beta testing can be considered "pre-release testing." Beta test versions of software are now distributed to a wide audience on the Web partly to give the program a "real-world" test and partly to provide a preview of the next release.
http://www.macmillandictionary.com/dictionary/british/beta-testa test in which a new computer product is given free to customers to use so that they can find mistakes
-------------------
Apparently, GLB redefines the definition of the beta phase. GLB is an open beta where beta testers become full-price paying customers instead of being your typical potential/prospective customers. As beta testers, we don't get the final release at a free or discounted price (not a requirement but that's how it generally works), we're already paying full price for the unfinished version, which is unheard of... find me an example of another beta version that you have to pay for. Also, feedback isn't required from
any beta testers, which points to GLB not being a beta but a fully released game (not to mention feedback is actually ridiculed). There is no timetable or apparent plan to release a "bigger, more public" final release because GLB is already as big and public as it can get. More demand? Add more leagues! Nevermind that we're still in testing phase and it's "not complete"! Many games are released as final versions and are subject to fixes and revisions, but GLB has yet to reach that point because...? Semantics? Fear? Not really sure. Seems to me that it'd make more sense to have users agree to a TOS or waiver that says the game is subject to any and all changes than to leave it in permabeta. I say permabeta because there has never been any indication that the game is moving forward towards a final version. Sure it's been said that that's the goal, but it's undergone some major changes since S2 when I joined up, and we're still in beta. It's not even in a more advanced state of beta, it's treading water... there's been no timeframe or mention of a final release other than when "beta testers" ask about it in the forums.
Using the word beta doesn't mean it's a beta. It doesn't fit the definition of beta testing phase. I'm calling a spade a spade.