User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Demotion Ideas for the WPL
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by beenlurken


Originally posted by HombreSinNombre2



Really don't see what the problem w/ taking the top 4 from each league and having the non-playoff teams demoted to their original league. (think originally it was garts idea) Then the 2 conference champions from each pro league move up. You might have to demote some teams down but w/ cpu teams and teams starting over, it shouldn't be a problem. Also should help w/ the parity since free agents will go towards the path of least resistance and improve the lower leagues.


You assume that of the 16 non-playoff teams there will be two of each region to go back to their respective region. Inevitably you will have teams losing league affiliation with this idea. You cant demote Pro teams down to AAA that earned the right to remain in their respective Pro leagues to demote teams from the WPL.


Well, you can, but they won't necessarily like it.



As long as the rules are clear, those teams will know it is coming. If it looks like a large swath will be coming your way from WL, then the scramble will be on to remain relevant in your Pro leagues. Maybe 6-10 won't cut it. So sack up and go 9-6.


Pretty much what its all about "SO SACK UP".
 
lukin83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
Originally posted by lukin83


The WL should give each region an equal shot and should be the best teams in the game. It should be both. If each region gets 4 teams into the WL, it will benefit the weaker regions with recruiting (players want a shot at the WL). Within 2-3 seasons, we will see parity across the pro leagues of GLB.

Think about what we do now will result in 2-3 or even 10 seasons down the road.


Except you will be screwing the most active teams that have desired to play in the best leagues in GLB. Screw going 16-0 four seasons in a row in OPL. The best teams don't want that. They wanted the WL, but instead they decided to play in USAPL.

Now, thanks to this the plan of 4 teams from each region, there will be a lot of great teams that will disappear because those agents want to play in the WL.

For the past 10 seasons, USAPL has been the WL. Like it or not. To ignore how strong USAPL and to some extent SAPL and CPL have become is to crap on all the agents that have wanted to play against the best of the best.


My team has wanted to play in USAPL since Day 1 but never had that option. Why should teams in "inferior leagues" not have a fair shot?
 
the man of doom
Miracles happen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by the man of doom
Originally posted by the man of doom

Originally posted by Saris

Originally posted by the man of doom

Originally posted by crazy454

Originally posted by Joebarber

Originally posted by Havoc

If you promote 2 teams from each Pro league you will have to demote half of the WPL each season (dont you think that is a lot?)... why not just promote the league champion from each region and demote only 8 of the 32 teams...

Do it like European soccer.

8 Pro champs auto promote and replace the bottom 8 WPL teams.

8 Pro runner ups play an additional playoff game against WPL teams #17-24. Winner plays in WPL the next season.

I really like this plan tbh

+1

+1
works IRL

should be fine here right?

That was one of the better suggestions in this thread Joe.

How would the matchups be decided for the play in game though? If it was random some people might find it unfair if the #17 team that just missed the playoffs had to face the USAP runner up, but the only alternative would be to somehow rank pro leagues. Where the top ranked pro league's runner up would play the #24 team and the #17 team would play the lowest ranked pro league's runner up etc.

random is the only fair way

if a playoff team guts
a 9 seed is safe and a random runner up team gets in


random will make parity to all leagues

do just not like it Bort

 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by turnit643
Originally posted by tautology

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by beenlurken



Originally posted by HombreSinNombre2




Really don't see what the problem w/ taking the top 4 from each league and having the non-playoff teams demoted to their original league. (think originally it was garts idea) Then the 2 conference champions from each pro league move up. You might have to demote some teams down but w/ cpu teams and teams starting over, it shouldn't be a problem. Also should help w/ the parity since free agents will go towards the path of least resistance and improve the lower leagues.


You assume that of the 16 non-playoff teams there will be two of each region to go back to their respective region. Inevitably you will have teams losing league affiliation with this idea. You cant demote Pro teams down to AAA that earned the right to remain in their respective Pro leagues to demote teams from the WPL.


Well, you can, but they won't necessarily like it.



As long as the rules are clear, those teams will know it is coming. If it looks like a large swath will be coming your way from WL, then the scramble will be on to remain relevant in your Pro leagues. Maybe 6-10 won't cut it. So sack up and go 9-6.


Beat me to it.


Your name is not "Havoc," clearly. I can't beat people named "Havoc" for some reason
 
lukin83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lukin83
Bort, thoughts on this idea??? - http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1164706


It creates parity, as players will migrate to the weaker leagues for a shot at playing in the WL. All 8 regions get equal representation and do not lose their league affiliation. I am pretty sure this takes care of most of the issues people have with the WL.


 
turnit643
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by beenlurken
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by beenlurken


Originally posted by HombreSinNombre2



Really don't see what the problem w/ taking the top 4 from each league and having the non-playoff teams demoted to their original league. (think originally it was garts idea) Then the 2 conference champions from each pro league move up. You might have to demote some teams down but w/ cpu teams and teams starting over, it shouldn't be a problem. Also should help w/ the parity since free agents will go towards the path of least resistance and improve the lower leagues.


You assume that of the 16 non-playoff teams there will be two of each region to go back to their respective region. Inevitably you will have teams losing league affiliation with this idea. You cant demote Pro teams down to AAA that earned the right to remain in their respective Pro leagues to demote teams from the WPL.


Well, you can, but they won't necessarily like it.


Well, make up your mind... who are we going to cater too? We have an idea that addresses everyones needs (except the delusional few that dont think each region deserves equal representation and fails to see that in the future with this system that the regions will be equal) but you refuse to go back and discuss it.


I still don't get how this system makes the regions more equal in the future than a system that allows for things to even out as they will on their own, without having a regional cap in the WL. Seriously not trying to beat this horse, I may be just missing something.
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lukin83

My team has wanted to play in USAPL since Day 1 but never had that option. Why should teams in "inferior leagues" not have a fair shot?


The should! I'm not arguing against that.

My plan.

* Top 2 teams from each region (league championship participants)
* Take the remaining 16 from the Elite 8 of the PWT and Hazy's. Those are active teams looking to make GLB better and promote competition against the best.
* If not up to 32, take from the teams with the highest ranking in LARS and Colley's compute ranking systems.

That gives every league an initial two teams minimum and gives the WL a true best of the best representation. If it's heavy toward one league or another it's because of their exploits on the field and their involvement in the community.
 
Hikariu
offline
Link
 
Giving a Choice of Divisions = Good Teams always picking the weakest division hoping they can make it back to the pros. You should always send them back to where they started. At least for the first few seasons of WL
 
ryan_grant-25
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by ryan_grant-25


Originally posted by ryan_grant-25



Originally posted by Bort




Originally posted by ryan_grant-25





Here is how it should work. take the best 4 from each conference now. and if a team guts, just put them in the cloud. But next season (assuming we have a WPL), have a Pro league tournament going. The winner of that gets in, and if there is more room in WPL, then the 2nd team will get in, ect. ect. I think as long as the team has a .750 winning %, they should be eligible for this tournament. If a team doesn't enter the tournament, there is no chance they can get into WPL


Doesn't that make the playoffs in Pro leagues completely pointless other than a trophy?


ok, so you want to have it as the winner of the tournament has to make the conference finals at least? if he doesn't, then you go down the tournament chain..


thoughts bort?


I don't think we want to do a tournament and a world league both. There's enough to work with from wins in league play IMO.


Cosign


well lets say all 4 USA Pro teams do really well, like... top 2 seeds both sides, and an OPL team guts, and the next best team is a USA pro team, would they get to go or would it be an OPL team?
 
walker1
offline
Link
 
Here is what I would do:

Season 11
Take the top 4 teams from each region that made the conferance championship game. Alpha teams play in the Alpha league, Zeta teams play in the Zeta league.

Teams staying

16 playoff teams.

Teams demoted
16 non playoff team.

Promotion
Conference champions

Demotion

Balance it out. 17-32 go to region A, 18-31 to region B, 19-30 to region C, etc. Let the top teams choose what region they want to go in. The bottom teams (25-32) can swap regions if the both agree on it.


This way all the Pro, AAA and AA teams that deserve to stay in their leagues stay.
 
jamz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Your name is not "Havoc," clearly. I can't beat people named "Havoc" for some reason


Yes, I've heard. Havoc wins dotball games by the hundreds. And if HE were here, he'd consume the WPL with fireballs from his eyes, and bolts of lightning from his arse.
 
lukin83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
Originally posted by lukin83


My team has wanted to play in USAPL since Day 1 but never had that option. Why should teams in "inferior leagues" not have a fair shot?


The should! I'm not arguing against that.

My plan.

* Top 2 teams from each region (league championship participants)
* Take the remaining 16 from the Elite 8 of the PWT and Hazy's. Those are active teams looking to make GLB better and promote competition against the best.
* If not up to 32, take from the teams with the highest ranking in LARS and Colley's compute ranking systems.

That gives every league an initial two teams minimum and gives the WL a true best of the best representation. If it's heavy toward one league or another it's because of their exploits on the field and their involvement in the community.


It is still not an equal opportunity for the inferior regions and leaves USAPL as the cream of the crop league (which it should not be).
 
Hikariu
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
Originally posted by lukin83


My team has wanted to play in USAPL since Day 1 but never had that option. Why should teams in "inferior leagues" not have a fair shot?


The should! I'm not arguing against that.

My plan.

* Top 2 teams from each region (league championship participants)
* Take the remaining 16 from the Elite 8 of the PWT and Hazy's. Those are active teams looking to make GLB better and promote competition against the best.
* If not up to 32, take from the teams with the highest ranking in LARS and Colley's compute ranking systems.

That gives every league an initial two teams minimum and gives the WL a true best of the best representation. If it's heavy toward one league or another it's because of their exploits on the field and their involvement in the community.


You can't use PWT or Hazy's a ton of teams don't even bother with scouting AI in scrimmages.
 
lukin83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lukin83
Originally posted by lukin83

Bort, thoughts on this idea??? - http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1164706


It creates parity, as players will migrate to the weaker leagues for a shot at playing in the WL. All 8 regions get equal representation and do not lose their league affiliation. I am pretty sure this takes care of most of the issues people have with the WL.




 
beenlurken
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
Originally posted by lukin83


The WL should give each region an equal shot and should be the best teams in the game. It should be both. If each region gets 4 teams into the WL, it will benefit the weaker regions with recruiting (players want a shot at the WL). Within 2-3 seasons, we will see parity across the pro leagues of GLB.

Think about what we do now will result in 2-3 or even 10 seasons down the road.


Except you will be screwing the most active teams that have desired to play in the best leagues in GLB. Screw going 16-0 four seasons in a row in OPL. The best teams don't want that. They wanted the WL, but instead they decided to play in USAPL.

Now, thanks to this the plan of 4 teams from each region, there will be a lot of great teams that will disappear because those agents want to play in the WL.

For the past 10 seasons, USAPL has been the WL. Like it or not. To ignore how strong USAPL and to some extent SAPL and CPL have become is to crap on all the agents that have wanted to play against the best of the best.


Come on... you want to settle on a less adequate solution to cater to current teams instead of implementing a solution that is best GLB in the long run

Guys stop being selfish and thinking only about your current teams. No matter how you cut it, teams are going to get screwed in the short term. We need to focus on the system that is best for the long term.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.