User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > World League is coming
Page:
 
turnit643
offline
Link
 
I agree that winning a Pro league in the seasons following the creation of a WL will not be the same as it was before, and I do think the play-in idea has some merit, primarily in bumping the fun factor. I just don't agree that the 17-32 WL teams should be considered naturally better than the possible replacements, especially considering the initial set-up of the league that will likely be taking the final four from each league rather than just the top 2.

Besides, the logistics of the play-in idea as presented are mucky. When would the play-in games take place? In the off-season? In the Pre-season after leagues have already been shuffled? When would the match-up selections you mentioned happen? I just don't think it's a viable option.

The cleaner, much more GLB-friendly method is the straight playoffs-or-drop format. It's built to demand a lot from WL teams, maintain league alignment and a regular refresh of the WL, and provides a min guaranteed number of reps from each region. It's predictable, easy to implement, and it can be done at the same time as usual league processing during the off-season without need for extra discussion and games.

I want the WL to be as strong and competitive as possible too, but it has to fit within the established framework and be automated in order to succeed, IMO.
 
StoutOne
offline
Link
 
Is everyone disregarding the fact that no matter which teams go to the World League they will p much have their pick of FA's?
 
griffin8r
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by StoutOne
Is everyone disregarding the fact that no matter which teams go to the World League they will p much have their pick of FA's?


And when the bottom teams drop out, they'll lose that pick...
 
StoutOne
offline
Link
 
I was referring to the USAPL vs. the rest of the Pro leagues quantity of teams moving to the World Pro league.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Rodion
Originally posted by turnit643

Originally posted by Rodion



I think vike's idea is really fair.

The ideal World League should have teams 1-32. Assuming we ever reach that sweet spot, the way the current format works will remove teams 17-32 from that list and will fill those 16 spots with teams 33-48 (not necessarily, as we are having 2 from each league and there are weaker leagues and stuff, but you guys can get my point). That means the leaguewith the 32 best teams would feature teams 1-16 and 33-48, thus not having the best 32 teams.

The idea of allowing a non-playoff WL team to defend its spot against a "mere" (when the best Pro teams leave their league for a World one, Pro league values will be diminished) Pro champion sounds fair, as the winner should be the best and thus the most able to represent the WL.

To make things most fair, I believe WL teams should pick which Pro Conference Champion they want to defend their spots against, starting from the 17th best WL team having all 16 choices and ending at the 32nd team having to play whichever team was not picked by the other 15 non-playoff teams. By doing that, the closer to the playoffs a WL team got to would mean they have a better chance at keeping their spot, while the worst WL teams would have to face the best Pro champions and would have a lower staying chance. If you think one game means nothing, then make it a best of three during days 39-40-41 or 41-42-43.

The problem with this idea is that there would be no guaranteed representation from the World Leagues, as teams from a certain region could lose both challenging and defending games and be left out. I don't see that as something bad, though.


So, the first set of WL teams would get a second chance to stay in the league simply because they were there first? ... and the next group has to earn their way in twice? That doesn't sound fair at all to me.

Why make it harder than it has to be? If you miss the WL playoffs, you drop back to your league and the next group gets a shot to see if they can get the job done like you couldn't. After you've dropped, you can get to your league title game again and earn another chance at the WL the following season. By not qualifying for the playoffs, you've already proven that you are not among the best in the WL, why would you automatically get to defend your spot?



Because not making the WL playoffs only means you're not a top 16 team. It doesn't mean you're not a top 32 team. And the WL should have the top 32 teams.
The system gart and I debated some months ago and you explained/improved has the flaw which vike brought to light. This system will replace the 17th best team of the game for a team on the 30s-40s. And that is what I consider unfair.

I think a team should only join the WL to make it stronger. And the proper way to prove you'll make it stronger is by beating a current WL team, not by simply winning it all in the inferior tier.


The entire concept is unfair to teams. A tournament w/ each Pro league conference winner is the only way you will ever be able to have the best teams competing for a title. If a World League/one giant bracket system is implemented it will be worse than what we currently have.
 
Rodion
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by turnit643
I agree that winning a Pro league in the seasons following the creation of a WL will not be the same as it was before, and I do think the play-in idea has some merit, primarily in bumping the fun factor. I just don't agree that the 17-32 WL teams should be considered naturally better than the possible replacements, especially considering the initial set-up of the league that will likely be taking the final four from each league rather than just the top 2.

Besides, the logistics of the play-in idea as presented are mucky. When would the play-in games take place? In the off-season? In the Pre-season after leagues have already been shuffled? When would the match-up selections you mentioned happen? I just don't think it's a viable option.

The cleaner, much more GLB-friendly method is the straight playoffs-or-drop format. It's built to demand a lot from WL teams, maintain league alignment and a regular refresh of the WL, and provides a min guaranteed number of reps from each region. It's predictable, easy to implement, and it can be done at the same time as usual league processing during the off-season without need for extra discussion and games.

I want the WL to be as strong and competitive as possible too, but it has to fit within the established framework and be automated in order to succeed, IMO.


We can make it work, turnit.

I'll suggest two possibilities:

1 - After day 32, WL teams would be ranked from 17th to 32nd. They would then wait for day 38 so they know which are the 16 teams that may be promoted. 17th team makes its choice (in theory, the worst), then 18th, then 19th, up to 32nd sticking with whichever team is left (in theory, the best). We can think of ways to make the 16 teams decide fast, such as allowing GMs to make the choice in the absence of the owner, determining hours for them to pick (if you lose your hour, you get to pick whenever you want). Another way is to have each team submit a premade list of preferences and them use it to decide matchups. The 16 challenge games are simmed on day 41, with Bort considering their day 40 rosters (probably easy to code).

2 - After day 32, WL teams would be ranked from 17th to 32nd. They would then select which Conference Champion they want to play for the WL spot, regardless of which team it is. So, say 17th team decides they'll challenge OPL Alpha Champion, then 18th decides they'll challenge SEAPL Garuda and so on. The advantage of this idea over the first one is there will be a lot of time for the matchups to be decided, as we can start from day 32 rather than day 38. The 16 challenge games are simmed on day 39 if the conference champion accepts or on day 41 with day 40 rosters.
 
Rodion
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Originally posted by Rodion

Originally posted by turnit643


Originally posted by Rodion




I think vike's idea is really fair.

The ideal World League should have teams 1-32. Assuming we ever reach that sweet spot, the way the current format works will remove teams 17-32 from that list and will fill those 16 spots with teams 33-48 (not necessarily, as we are having 2 from each league and there are weaker leagues and stuff, but you guys can get my point). That means the leaguewith the 32 best teams would feature teams 1-16 and 33-48, thus not having the best 32 teams.

The idea of allowing a non-playoff WL team to defend its spot against a "mere" (when the best Pro teams leave their league for a World one, Pro league values will be diminished) Pro champion sounds fair, as the winner should be the best and thus the most able to represent the WL.

To make things most fair, I believe WL teams should pick which Pro Conference Champion they want to defend their spots against, starting from the 17th best WL team having all 16 choices and ending at the 32nd team having to play whichever team was not picked by the other 15 non-playoff teams. By doing that, the closer to the playoffs a WL team got to would mean they have a better chance at keeping their spot, while the worst WL teams would have to face the best Pro champions and would have a lower staying chance. If you think one game means nothing, then make it a best of three during days 39-40-41 or 41-42-43.

The problem with this idea is that there would be no guaranteed representation from the World Leagues, as teams from a certain region could lose both challenging and defending games and be left out. I don't see that as something bad, though.


So, the first set of WL teams would get a second chance to stay in the league simply because they were there first? ... and the next group has to earn their way in twice? That doesn't sound fair at all to me.

Why make it harder than it has to be? If you miss the WL playoffs, you drop back to your league and the next group gets a shot to see if they can get the job done like you couldn't. After you've dropped, you can get to your league title game again and earn another chance at the WL the following season. By not qualifying for the playoffs, you've already proven that you are not among the best in the WL, why would you automatically get to defend your spot?



Because not making the WL playoffs only means you're not a top 16 team. It doesn't mean you're not a top 32 team. And the WL should have the top 32 teams.
The system gart and I debated some months ago and you explained/improved has the flaw which vike brought to light. This system will replace the 17th best team of the game for a team on the 30s-40s. And that is what I consider unfair.

I think a team should only join the WL to make it stronger. And the proper way to prove you'll make it stronger is by beating a current WL team, not by simply winning it all in the inferior tier.


The entire concept is unfair to teams. A tournament w/ each Pro league conference winner is the only way you will ever be able to have the best teams competing for a title. If a World League/one giant bracket system is implemented it will be worse than what we currently have.


Why?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
If they implement a World League the Cobra Kai is moving to OPL.

Which brings up another issue with the system. The leagues are not all equal. OPL, SEA, & Africa are weak. Why should a weak team from there get into the World League at the expense of a more deserving team? If you have a world league it eliminates the need to have leagues because its just one bracket that funnels the world league.

ghey


After hearing both sides of the arguement I changed my mind from my initial stance on the WPL. I made that first post out of a knee jerk reaction. I could have stuck to my arguement "just because", but I am an open minded person who believes that opinions can change and should change if right. Obviously I would not agree with my post above after hearing all the facts and issues.

I still think that the WPL is not the best format (A tournament was my preference), however my team & co-owner skanker irl feels strongly that the WPL is best. The GLB community feels that the WPL is best, so instead of crying or whining like many do I have decided to put forth the effort to make the WPL the best it can be and further GLB while doing so.

Edited by ImTheScientist on Jul 29, 2009 00:08:57
Edited by ImTheScientist on Jul 29, 2009 00:08:46
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Rodion
Originally posted by ImTheScientist

Originally posted by Rodion


Originally posted by turnit643



Originally posted by Rodion





I think vike's idea is really fair.

The ideal World League should have teams 1-32. Assuming we ever reach that sweet spot, the way the current format works will remove teams 17-32 from that list and will fill those 16 spots with teams 33-48 (not necessarily, as we are having 2 from each league and there are weaker leagues and stuff, but you guys can get my point). That means the leaguewith the 32 best teams would feature teams 1-16 and 33-48, thus not having the best 32 teams.

The idea of allowing a non-playoff WL team to defend its spot against a "mere" (when the best Pro teams leave their league for a World one, Pro league values will be diminished) Pro champion sounds fair, as the winner should be the best and thus the most able to represent the WL.

To make things most fair, I believe WL teams should pick which Pro Conference Champion they want to defend their spots against, starting from the 17th best WL team having all 16 choices and ending at the 32nd team having to play whichever team was not picked by the other 15 non-playoff teams. By doing that, the closer to the playoffs a WL team got to would mean they have a better chance at keeping their spot, while the worst WL teams would have to face the best Pro champions and would have a lower staying chance. If you think one game means nothing, then make it a best of three during days 39-40-41 or 41-42-43.

The problem with this idea is that there would be no guaranteed representation from the World Leagues, as teams from a certain region could lose both challenging and defending games and be left out. I don't see that as something bad, though.


So, the first set of WL teams would get a second chance to stay in the league simply because they were there first? ... and the next group has to earn their way in twice? That doesn't sound fair at all to me.

Why make it harder than it has to be? If you miss the WL playoffs, you drop back to your league and the next group gets a shot to see if they can get the job done like you couldn't. After you've dropped, you can get to your league title game again and earn another chance at the WL the following season. By not qualifying for the playoffs, you've already proven that you are not among the best in the WL, why would you automatically get to defend your spot?



Because not making the WL playoffs only means you're not a top 16 team. It doesn't mean you're not a top 32 team. And the WL should have the top 32 teams.
The system gart and I debated some months ago and you explained/improved has the flaw which vike brought to light. This system will replace the 17th best team of the game for a team on the 30s-40s. And that is what I consider unfair.

I think a team should only join the WL to make it stronger. And the proper way to prove you'll make it stronger is by beating a current WL team, not by simply winning it all in the inferior tier.


The entire concept is unfair to teams. A tournament w/ each Pro league conference winner is the only way you will ever be able to have the best teams competing for a title. If a World League/one giant bracket system is implemented it will be worse than what we currently have.


Why?


http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2958954
 
Buxx
offline
Link
 
You guys would be much better off deciding who goes ... scrimmage disputes
Dont automate it ... thatd be a waste of intelligent and willing brain power that would create the coolest league in the game
1st year .. just set up an extra free scrimmage league for a test drive
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Rodion
Originally posted by turnit643

Originally posted by Rodion



I think vike's idea is really fair.

The ideal World League should have teams 1-32. Assuming we ever reach that sweet spot, the way the current format works will remove teams 17-32 from that list and will fill those 16 spots with teams 33-48 (not necessarily, as we are having 2 from each league and there are weaker leagues and stuff, but you guys can get my point). That means the leaguewith the 32 best teams would feature teams 1-16 and 33-48, thus not having the best 32 teams.

The idea of allowing a non-playoff WL team to defend its spot against a "mere" (when the best Pro teams leave their league for a World one, Pro league values will be diminished) Pro champion sounds fair, as the winner should be the best and thus the most able to represent the WL.

To make things most fair, I believe WL teams should pick which Pro Conference Champion they want to defend their spots against, starting from the 17th best WL team having all 16 choices and ending at the 32nd team having to play whichever team was not picked by the other 15 non-playoff teams. By doing that, the closer to the playoffs a WL team got to would mean they have a better chance at keeping their spot, while the worst WL teams would have to face the best Pro champions and would have a lower staying chance. If you think one game means nothing, then make it a best of three during days 39-40-41 or 41-42-43.

The problem with this idea is that there would be no guaranteed representation from the World Leagues, as teams from a certain region could lose both challenging and defending games and be left out. I don't see that as something bad, though.


So, the first set of WL teams would get a second chance to stay in the league simply because they were there first? ... and the next group has to earn their way in twice? That doesn't sound fair at all to me.

Why make it harder than it has to be? If you miss the WL playoffs, you drop back to your league and the next group gets a shot to see if they can get the job done like you couldn't. After you've dropped, you can get to your league title game again and earn another chance at the WL the following season. By not qualifying for the playoffs, you've already proven that you are not among the best in the WL, why would you automatically get to defend your spot?



Because not making the WL playoffs only means you're not a top 16 team. It doesn't mean you're not a top 32 team. And the WL should have the top 32 teams.
The system gart and I debated some months ago and you explained/improved has the flaw which vike brought to light. This system will replace the 17th best team of the game for a team on the 30s-40s. And that is what I consider unfair.

I think a team should only join the WL to make it stronger. And the proper way to prove you'll make it stronger is by beating a current WL team, not by simply winning it all in the inferior tier.


Are you serious? "the flaw which vike brought to light?" Everyone in support of the idea you're against is aware of this "flaw."

It's not a "flaw." You are kidding yourself if you think that one game will prove who the better team is every time like you are saying.

"The WL should have the top 32 teams" is jst a vision. The sim changes from year to year, teams change from year to year.

"This system will replace the 17th best team of the game for a team on the 30s-40s. And that is what I consider unfair."

What you are proposing is a system that's going to keep causing problems each and every season. Bring us a better idea first before suggesting one like this. We've already come up with something that has a built-in method of guaranteeing the World League not only stays fresh and exciting but as competitive as possible.

Allowing teams a second chance to stay because they "aren't a top 16 team but might be a top 32 team" is really stupid. I agree that it should have the best 32 teams, but even if we have the perfect way to hand pick the top 32 teams it's still an impossible task

"not by simply winning it all in the inferior tier." You do realize that you are talking about teams that win their Pro League not being deserving of only one guaranteed season in the World League, don't you?
 
StoutOne
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
If they implement a World League the Cobra Kai is moving to OPL.

Which brings up another issue with the system. The leagues are not all equal. OPL, SEA, & Africa are weak. Why should a weak team from there get into the World League at the expense of a more deserving team? If you have a world league it eliminates the need to have leagues because its just one bracket that funnels the world league.

ghey


True, but as I mentioned above, these teams will have their pick of FA's during that off season, which should make them better than non World Pro League teams.....but won't always be true of course.
 
turnit643
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rodion
Originally posted by turnit643

I agree that winning a Pro league in the seasons following the creation of a WL will not be the same as it was before, and I do think the play-in idea has some merit, primarily in bumping the fun factor. I just don't agree that the 17-32 WL teams should be considered naturally better than the possible replacements, especially considering the initial set-up of the league that will likely be taking the final four from each league rather than just the top 2.

Besides, the logistics of the play-in idea as presented are mucky. When would the play-in games take place? In the off-season? In the Pre-season after leagues have already been shuffled? When would the match-up selections you mentioned happen? I just don't think it's a viable option.

The cleaner, much more GLB-friendly method is the straight playoffs-or-drop format. It's built to demand a lot from WL teams, maintain league alignment and a regular refresh of the WL, and provides a min guaranteed number of reps from each region. It's predictable, easy to implement, and it can be done at the same time as usual league processing during the off-season without need for extra discussion and games.

I want the WL to be as strong and competitive as possible too, but it has to fit within the established framework and be automated in order to succeed, IMO.


We can make it work, turnit.

I'll suggest two possibilities:

1 - After day 32, WL teams would be ranked from 17th to 32nd. They would then wait for day 38 so they know which are the 16 teams that may be promoted. 17th team makes its choice (in theory, the worst), then 18th, then 19th, up to 32nd sticking with whichever team is left (in theory, the best). We can think of ways to make the 16 teams decide fast, such as allowing GMs to make the choice in the absence of the owner, determining hours for them to pick (if you lose your hour, you get to pick whenever you want). Another way is to have each team submit a premade list of preferences and them use it to decide matchups. The 16 challenge games are simmed on day 41, with Bort considering their day 40 rosters (probably easy to code).

2 - After day 32, WL teams would be ranked from 17th to 32nd. They would then select which Conference Champion they want to play for the WL spot, regardless of which team it is. So, say 17th team decides they'll challenge OPL Alpha Champion, then 18th decides they'll challenge SEAPL Garuda and so on. The advantage of this idea over the first one is there will be a lot of time for the matchups to be decided, as we can start from day 32 rather than day 38. The 16 challenge games are simmed on day 39 if the conference champion accepts or on day 41 with day 40 rosters.


Thanks Rodion, yeah I guess you could make it work if you were determined to give that 2nd chance game. I still prefer the other method and the simpler playoffs-or-go-home format.
 
Link
 
If the world league does come, should they get more media revenue than pro teams?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by turnit643
I agree that winning a Pro league in the seasons following the creation of a WL will not be the same as it was before, and I do think the play-in idea has some merit, primarily in bumping the fun factor. I just don't agree that the 17-32 WL teams should be considered naturally better than the possible replacements, especially considering the initial set-up of the league that will likely be taking the final four from each league rather than just the top 2.

Besides, the logistics of the play-in idea as presented are mucky. When would the play-in games take place? In the off-season? In the Pre-season after leagues have already been shuffled? When would the match-up selections you mentioned happen? I just don't think it's a viable option.

The cleaner, much more GLB-friendly method is the straight playoffs-or-drop format. It's built to demand a lot from WL teams, maintain league alignment and a regular refresh of the WL, and provides a min guaranteed number of reps from each region. It's predictable, easy to implement, and it can be done at the same time as usual league processing during the off-season without need for extra discussion and games.

I want the WL to be as strong and competitive as possible too, but it has to fit within the established framework and be automated in order to succeed, IMO.


I completely agree with everything I've heard from you so far on the World League. I think we need to start cutting down on the voices, and put a few people like you who actually know what they are talking about and can be open-minded about the idea to charge with working on coming up with a finalized idea.

I thought we had one with the non-playoff teams drop, allowing a Pro League to gain up to two additional spots in the World League each year (though only if all of their orld League teams make the playoffs). It maintains a minimum of two teams representing each region and gives them the ability to have more if they earn it. Also people who are concerned about how much a league like USAPL might dominate the World League can be comforted by knowing under this system that while they could have up to 18 teams, that's only if they can maintain all 16 playoff spots every single season, which we all know is not going to happen.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.