I agree that winning a Pro league in the seasons following the creation of a WL will not be the same as it was before, and I do think the play-in idea has some merit, primarily in bumping the fun factor. I just don't agree that the 17-32 WL teams should be considered naturally better than the possible replacements, especially considering the initial set-up of the league that will likely be taking the final four from each league rather than just the top 2.
Besides, the logistics of the play-in idea as presented are mucky. When would the play-in games take place? In the off-season? In the Pre-season after leagues have already been shuffled? When would the match-up selections you mentioned happen? I just don't think it's a viable option.
The cleaner, much more GLB-friendly method is the straight playoffs-or-drop format. It's built to demand a lot from WL teams, maintain league alignment and a regular refresh of the WL, and provides a min guaranteed number of reps from each region. It's predictable, easy to implement, and it can be done at the same time as usual league processing during the off-season without need for extra discussion and games.
I want the WL to be as strong and competitive as possible too, but it has to fit within the established framework and be automated in order to succeed, IMO.
Besides, the logistics of the play-in idea as presented are mucky. When would the play-in games take place? In the off-season? In the Pre-season after leagues have already been shuffled? When would the match-up selections you mentioned happen? I just don't think it's a viable option.
The cleaner, much more GLB-friendly method is the straight playoffs-or-drop format. It's built to demand a lot from WL teams, maintain league alignment and a regular refresh of the WL, and provides a min guaranteed number of reps from each region. It's predictable, easy to implement, and it can be done at the same time as usual league processing during the off-season without need for extra discussion and games.
I want the WL to be as strong and competitive as possible too, but it has to fit within the established framework and be automated in order to succeed, IMO.






























