User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Serious Question: How much strength/tackling do you think SHOULD be required to stop a very strong power back?
Page:
 
RIP Al Davis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by Kira

Originally posted by Bort


Let's say I have a power back with:

100 STR
70 Carrying
50/60ish Spd/Agi
8-10 in Power Through and Lower Shoulder type skills
15 in +brk tackle VA's
perhaps some AEQ with +brk tackle type stuff too


I think you should need about 100 or more tackling to bring that monster down consistently. He's basically built just to break tackles no? Well then you should have to build a guy just to bring him down. I also don't think someone with less than 50 should ever be able to bring that monster down (assuming they have the same energy/morale settings) I bet a lot of people would complain a lot if you made it that high, but that's what I think.


This...sort of.

80 TKL
80 STR
A comparable amount of EQ and SAs/VAs in tackling:HB's Break TKL

The above should give you a >50% chance to bring him down imo.

yeah 80/80 would be good too, but I don't really think a lot of 100 strength backs are too common either so I was thinking kinda in the future.
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by THE PWNER
Read the first few pages, seems like all the suggestions would take us back to the pre-nerf of the power back builds in season 3 or 4. The requirements people are stating are not going to happen at all. TBH, I think the current formula is probably about right because it is what we are used to. To continually change this type of formula is what throws people off of this game.


inb4gameisbetaargument

The sim is not perfect. That's why adjustments are made.
 
Negronic
offline
Link
 
tackling should all be situational. there should be no "you need XXX tackling and XXX strength to tackle a RB with XXX stats."

it should all depend on the momentum of the runner, the momentum and skills of the defender, and the angle at which they meet.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16

And do people realize that nobody will ever get their tackling to 100? Pretty much ever?


It's probably stupid of me...but I'd really like getting ANY attribute to 100 to give some sort of benefit. I don't like usefulness topping out at 50.
 
Vagrant God
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Negronic
tackling should all be situational. there should be no "you need XXX tackling and XXX strength to tackle a RB with XXX stats."

it should all depend on the momentum of the runner, the momentum and skills of the defender, and the angle at which they meet.


Another very good point.
 
britdevine316
offline
Link
 
In GLB's current state a player getting a clean hit on this type of HB should take him down 95% of the time with 60 STR and 60 TKL.

 
RIP Al Davis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Undead Merchant
Originally posted by Negronic

tackling should all be situational. there should be no "you need XXX tackling and XXX strength to tackle a RB with XXX stats."

it should all depend on the momentum of the runner, the momentum and skills of the defender, and the angle at which they meet.


Another very good point.


 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sirmixalotswass
honestly i would think many things would factor, first off should proximity of defender to the ball carrier(farther distance should amke a diving tackle and a tackle penalty) next should be tackle to see if you can latch on to the offensive player. these would be to see if you are able to talke the player.

Then angle of persuit should come into play, its obvious that if you do a leg tackle on someone from behind and they fall forward thats 2-3 more yards. Then strength to see how far you can carry the defensive person before they get you down. The longer you drag the player the more chance a fumble should occur.

over all id say power backs with 100 str should take atleast 75+ tackle to take down consistently and atleast 50+ to be able to make 50% of all tackles on that player.

STR should determine how quickly you bring them down or if you can reverse their momentum. in this case 80+ to stop them cold and atleast 50 to stop them within 2-3 yards.

speed should be used to see if you can close the gap enough to make a tackle and agility should be to avoid fakes, cuts, falling players and blocks.


Agree with the above except needing 75 tackling to stop 100 strength. Strength should be used to determine how quickly they get brought down or yards after contact, but it shouldn't be the sole criteria for breaking tackles. Maybe carry should be a better attribute there. Carry vs tackle to determine break tackle, and strength vs strength to determine yards gained after contact.
 
WestbrookFTW
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by WestbrookFTW


Hmmm...Lets do Matchups WRs Vs CBs

WRs Need: Catching, VIsion, Jumping, Speed, Agility, Carrying
CBs Need: Speed, Agility, Vision, Tackling, Jumping, (They don't need strength, but for run support could add it)

Number of skills to focus on for WR/CB? 6/6

Sound pretty even.


WR sweeps aren't in the game yet.


Then these WRs are going to start fumbling the ball alot more often. Pretty much no CB has softcapped Tackling / Strength, but if pure speed/agility who have sub 20 strength / carrying WRs catch the ball and start to run with it, they'll get pummeled by these CBs that invested in Tck / Str. This will cause them to lose a lot of stamina, morale, more turnovers.

Then the WRs will need to counter.
 
Negronic
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Undead Merchant
Originally posted by Negronic

tackling should all be situational. there should be no "you need XXX tackling and XXX strength to tackle a RB with XXX stats."

it should all depend on the momentum of the runner, the momentum and skills of the defender, and the angle at which they meet.


Another very good point.


a weak CB can horse collar a firebreathing power back from behind, but head up is going to probably get rolled unless he gets some kind of ankle tackle.
 
thehazyone
NFL Replacement Refs SUCK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by britdevine316

Tackling should be more important than Str in the tackling equation for sure.


It already is. Quite a bit more. STR mostly helps you hold them back when you make the tackle.


That's probably the biggest problem then. Very few people have tackling at anything more than 50-60.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Robbnva
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by britdevine316


Tackling should be more important than Str in the tackling equation for sure.


It already is. Quite a bit more. STR mostly helps you hold them back when you make the tackle.


I have already given you my answer and my results for LBs. 5 of my 10 tackles were against an HB who had almost 100 broken tackles last season, you want answers yet you ignore posts by people trying to provide advice.
my LB had NO missed tackles and 3 TFL


He's a high tackling dude, correct? That's the general idea - get high tackling and you will barely ever miss tackles. I guess the question is what should be considered high tackling?

Perhaps I should just do like people always end up suggestions - do what I think is right and people will figure it out and adjust, etc.

I do like the idea of gang tackles though.
 
THE PWNER
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by Iceman16

Bort, imo, strength and tackling should be at 60 to make about 80% of tackles. The more tackling you add, the more likely you are to take guys down. 75 tackling should be about 97% tackling success.


And do people realize that nobody will ever get their tackling to 100? Pretty much ever?


If they had to in order to stop power backs and strong receiving TEs, they would. Imagine a team that handed the ball to a power HB and/or FB, and threw the ball to a TE with 100+ str. Unstoppable with most of the suggestions people threw out for what would be required to make a tackle and the current set of builds people have across every league (spd/agi/vis)
 
bhall43
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by THE PWNER
Read the first few pages, seems like all the suggestions would take us back to the pre-nerf of the power back builds in season 3 or 4. The requirements people are stating are not going to happen at all. TBH, I think the current formula is probably about right because it is what we are used to. To continually change this type of formula is what throws people off of this game.


it would throw people off of this game if their HB was only getting 1800 yards instead of 3000-5000 yards in a season?
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Iceman16


And do people realize that nobody will ever get their tackling to 100? Pretty much ever?


It's probably stupid of me...but I'd really like getting ANY attribute to 100 to give some sort of benefit. I don't like usefulness topping out at 50.


Getting physical attributes to higher levels is exponentially beneficial. I said I think a good LB should have tackling at 75. Unless Bort give 30 SP per level, 100 isn't a number most people will reach.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.