User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Playoff Profit sharing...
Page:
 
McGruffHawk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tito716


No argument here.

But I guess my point is:

Do the lower seeds need more money or is this essentially a tax being imposed on teams for being too successful?

GLB can create money at will. Why does money need to come out of anyone else's income pool?


Lower seeds need more money. Without it, the disparity between the top 4 teams and the bottom 12 will continue to grow.
 
Joe_B
offline
Link
 
Something i posted in another forum, i'll post it again here


*************************************************

You are giving up revenue, allowing other teams a cut of ticket sales from YOUR stadium means that YOU ARE NOT receiving all the revenue from that game played at ,again, YOUR STADIUM. Personaly i don't agree that other teams, my competition, should benefit from my fanacial planning. I've balanced and juggled my money for 5 seasons to max my stadium. It's not fair.

Here is something else that is not fair about it,
I will make more than 5 mil from a playoff home game this season, lets say i'm the #1 seed and that the revenue sharing is 25%, with me being the #1 seed that means the #8 seed would get, at a 25% share of revenue, with my max stadium and ticket pricing the ticket sales would be more than 5 mill and the #8 seed will get more that 1.25 mil.

Now lets assume that the # 2 seed is the warpath from my confrence, http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=390
they don't have a fully upgraded stadium and only do 4mil in ticket sales, that means the #7 seed would get a only 1 mil, again at 25% of home team revenue.

So the lower seed (the 8 seed) makes more money (than the 7th seed)...what is fair about that.


*****************************


the playoff revenue sharing from ticket sales is not a good idea, it's not even fair to the lower seeds. It definatly isn't fair to the higher seeds. It's MY STADIUM, if any profits are going to a lower seed from my stadium, i will set the ticket prices so low they won't make much money.

 
BP
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nixx
Originally posted by BP

Profit sharing is BS IMO...it was really the ONLY advantage to getting a top 4 playoff spot. Now a home game doesn't really mean anything cuz there is no home field advantage in the game.

Hey, why don't we do some Point sharing too..if your team sucks and I'm beating you by 40 in the 4th quarter, maybe Bort will make my team give your team 14 of our points....to make thing fairer even though you didn't earn them...


There is still an advantage to getting the home game, just not as much. 5 million versus 100K is a little unbalanced don't you think?

There is something like "point sharing", it's cruise control. It kicks in if a team is winning by 35 points.


a low seed getting 100K bonus League (GLB)...hell, have the game give you $1,000,000..but not at the expense of the home team. Maybe Bort needs to come up some with type of TV/CABLE revenue and then both teams can split that every game and make the concessions a little more realistic....but giving the away team ticket revenue doesn't make a lot of sense to me..
Last edited Oct 1, 2008 10:49:56
 
Tito716
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by McGruffHawk
Originally posted by Tito716



No argument here.

But I guess my point is:

Do the lower seeds need more money or is this essentially a tax being imposed on teams for being too successful?

GLB can create money at will. Why does money need to come out of anyone else's income pool?


Lower seeds need more money. Without it, the disparity between the top 4 teams and the bottom 12 will continue to grow.


OK. They need more money. Why does this money have to come from the higher seeds?

 
Crushr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tito716
Originally posted by McGruffHawk

Originally posted by Tito716




No argument here.

But I guess my point is:

Do the lower seeds need more money or is this essentially a tax being imposed on teams for being too successful?

GLB can create money at will. Why does money need to come out of anyone else's income pool?


Lower seeds need more money. Without it, the disparity between the top 4 teams and the bottom 12 will continue to grow.


OK. They need more money. Why does this money have to come from the higher seeds?



Better question is why do you feel that it has to come from somewhere else? Why do the 1-4 seeds need an extra 3-8 million(or more) than the other teams in their league? I guess you've been getting that much up until now and feel entitled. Remember that this is a Beta game and things will change as we have already seen. How much you get in the playoffs should change as well.
 
Tito716
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Crushr
Originally posted by Tito716

Originally posted by McGruffHawk


Originally posted by Tito716





No argument here.

But I guess my point is:

Do the lower seeds need more money or is this essentially a tax being imposed on teams for being too successful?

GLB can create money at will. Why does money need to come out of anyone else's income pool?


Lower seeds need more money. Without it, the disparity between the top 4 teams and the bottom 12 will continue to grow.


OK. They need more money. Why does this money have to come from the higher seeds?



Better question is why do you feel that it has to come from somewhere else? Why do the 1-4 seeds need an extra 3-8 million(or more) than the other teams in their league? I guess you've been getting that much up until now and feel entitled. Remember that this is a Beta game and things will change as we have already seen. How much you get in the playoffs should change as well.


Because I was never a #1-4. Now I am in line to be one. I want the extra money so I can give it to my players and still build my stadium like all the previous #1-4s have been able to do.
 
Joe_B
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Crushr
Originally posted by Tito716

Originally posted by McGruffHawk


Originally posted by Tito716





No argument here.

But I guess my point is:

Do the lower seeds need more money or is this essentially a tax being imposed on teams for being too successful?

GLB can create money at will. Why does money need to come out of anyone else's income pool?


Lower seeds need more money. Without it, the disparity between the top 4 teams and the bottom 12 will continue to grow.


OK. They need more money. Why does this money have to come from the higher seeds?



Better question is why do you feel that it has to come from somewhere else? Why do the 1-4 seeds need an extra 3-8 million(or more) than the other teams in their league? I guess you've been getting that much up until now and feel entitled. Remember that this is a Beta game and things will change as we have already seen. How much you get in the playoffs should change as well.


because the money comes my fanancial planning and other teams (my competition) should not benefit from it.
 
McGruffHawk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tito716
Originally posted by McGruffHawk

Originally posted by Tito716




No argument here.

But I guess my point is:

Do the lower seeds need more money or is this essentially a tax being imposed on teams for being too successful?

GLB can create money at will. Why does money need to come out of anyone else's income pool?


Lower seeds need more money. Without it, the disparity between the top 4 teams and the bottom 12 will continue to grow.


OK. They need more money. Why does this money have to come from the higher seeds?



I doesn't. But it needs to come from somewhere. Revenue Sharing is one proposal, and there have been others.
 
McGruffHawk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Joe_B
Originally posted by Crushr

Originally posted by Tito716


Originally posted by McGruffHawk



Originally posted by Tito716






No argument here.

But I guess my point is:

Do the lower seeds need more money or is this essentially a tax being imposed on teams for being too successful?

GLB can create money at will. Why does money need to come out of anyone else's income pool?


Lower seeds need more money. Without it, the disparity between the top 4 teams and the bottom 12 will continue to grow.


OK. They need more money. Why does this money have to come from the higher seeds?



Better question is why do you feel that it has to come from somewhere else? Why do the 1-4 seeds need an extra 3-8 million(or more) than the other teams in their league? I guess you've been getting that much up until now and feel entitled. Remember that this is a Beta game and things will change as we have already seen. How much you get in the playoffs should change as well.


because the money comes my fanancial planning and other teams (my competition) should not benefit from it.


Here's the key difference in perspective. I am less concerned about lining my pockets than I am about promoting a competitive league. I'm not saying the two are mutually exclusive, but if I have to sacrifice one for the other, I'll take the financial hit.

Of course, as has been mentioned numerous times, there may not be a need to sacrifice one for the other. Those options need to be considered.
 
ib_mr_ed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by robelder
"I think the current bonus system is flawed for just that reason. It is not based in reality."

Neither is the fact that a home game you don't get a bonus from the noise of your stadium giving your team the advantage and causing false starts, miscommunication on routes, wasted time outs, missed blitz pickups, etc.


AMEN BROTHER. There is no home field advantage at this point or if there is it is very small. The problem now is that the cash is the ONLY reason to try for a higher playoff seed. You gain nothing else by being a home team.
 
valakar
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Knightman
Same reasoning is being repeated over and over again because people are too lazy to read even a few pages prior to the last page. We aren't going to be able to have a decent discussion about this if people stay stuck in the rut of topics that have been addressed before. If you are too lazy or stupid to read the thread, then don't start up the same old shit. Specifically:

No arguments about how much effort was put into your team, or how little effort was put into another team. The game properly rewards RESULTS, not effort!

No straw man arguments about the disparity. There's no debate about that. Can we please move on to how to FIX it (and not just with some simpleminded regurgitation of a percentage split)?

Address the issue of whether revenue sharing which takes money away from the home team to give it to the visitors (forget about the details of exactly what the percentage should be for now, let's settle on the principle) is a better option than letting home teams keep what they've traditionally been given, but addressing the disparity by giving the lower seeds another way to generate income, the most well know of which are the "Jumbotron" option and the merchandising option. Ultimately, it's do we keep the pot of playoff money fixed and reapportion it, or do we increase the pot and give the increase to the lower seeds? BOTH options address the disparity, the only real difference being the amount of money being disbursed into the GLB "Universe."

This is a legitimate issue and there have been very good points made by different sides. Can we please move the debate FORWARD instead of backward?


+1 We already know there is a problem now discuss solutions.
 
robelder
offline
Link
 
My solution:
- Make changes to structure in the offseason, not midseason
- Promote more teams up and down that is what will bring balance not who makes more money. Money is irrelevant in why teams are winning games. Recruiting, building your guy properly, and using your AI well is.
- Fix bugs and plays that don't work during the season as needed
- Keep all teams in the same region
- Add a home field advantage to games
- Add a raise to the current seasons playoff bonus.
Last edited Oct 1, 2008 14:56:32
 
valakar
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by robelder
My solution:
- Make changes to structure in the offseason, not midseason
- Promote more teams up and down that is what will bring balance not who makes more money. Money is irrelevant in why teams are winning games. Recruiting, building your guy properly, and using your AI well is.
- Fix bugs and plays that don't work during the season as needed
- Keep all teams in the same region
- Add a home field advantage to games
- Add a raise to the current seasons playoff bonus.


Okay your 2nd point of money being irrelevant in why teams are winning games. I disagree because you then said recruiting as one of the things that does help you win. In your honest assessment do you believe it is easier or more difficult to recruit with more money?

I agree with a offseason change not midseason that is why we are discussing it now. From the sounds of borts announcement they decided this past offseason they were implementing something just either have not come up with a consensus or are allowing discussions like this to weigh into that decision.

I totally agree about changing and fixing plays and bugs, etc as needed. Increasing bonuses would be a step in the right direction but I am hoping we do not settle for an easy answer because it is a difficult debate and actually really iron out a good system fair for everyone yet addresses the issue.
 
Knightman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by joemalaka
Going to be Devil's Advocate here.

What happens if a team has mucho dinero, and extra playoff money doesn't mean much to their % of net worth. They are the #1 seed and the #8 seed they are playing needs money very badly. Team #1 decides to be jerks and puts their tickets either extremely low for sale, so that team #8 doesn't get much money. Team #8 gets hurt more than Team #1 because it would mean more to their bottom line.

The above would somewhat make it like it was before. BUT could only happen with the extreme rich teams.

Probably need a min and max ticket price for playoff games.


Please go back and read the "Jumbotron" proposal in one of my posts a while back (it also refers back to Bort's original post suggesting this idea). It would make your objection moot as each team would benefit only from its own ticket sales at its own stadium. That way revenue is more of a positive "let's generate as much as we can for ourselves" rather than a negative "I don't mind getting screwed as long as I can screw my opponent more". Also eliminates the corresponding personal conflicts that would inevitably arise out of the scenario you describe.

Yet one more reason why the Jumbotron option is superior to revenue sharing.
 
Knightman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GMathiasf
What drives me crazy in this thread is that people continue to drive this point that playoff money IS the home playoff team's money and that dispersing playoff income is "taking" from or "taxing" them? I've provided evidence to how sickening the amount of money home playoff teams can make and people ignore that argument and attempt to manipulate people with emotional appeals to their Republican/Capitalist beliefs. Seriously, someone show me some kind of proof that running the table with home field provides a REASONABLE amount of income, not an exorbinant amount of income.


This is probably the most reasonable argument against the Jumbotron argument---the idea that the amount that the home team acquires is so exorbitant that it needs to be reduced to maintain balance of the game. I don't agree with it, but it at least makes sense.

The problems I see are that it requires someone to make an assessment of what is "exorbitant" and what is "reasonable." I think it can be argued that since teams will be competing with other teams that had the advantage of getting all the home game revenue in the past, that they should be allowed to get the same privilege, if at all possible, going forward. That would be "fair" as they may well be getting promoted and facing teams that have already used a full home playoff share to upgrade their teams.

The teams that suffer from this are those who don't make the playoffs, for whom I philosophically have no sympathy, and the 5-8's whom Bort has provided with an alternative method of generating income to reduce the gap between the 1-4's and the 5-6's significantly.

You ask for proof that running the table provides a "REASONABLE" amount of income, but I say that "reasonable" is a matter of opinion. My team "ran the table", so to speak, last season and I am quite concerned that I won't be able to keep up with my players' equipment needs. I can give them all their L32 stuff, but in less than 3 seasons they're going to need L40 stuff--likely to be on the order of $3-4 MILLION each!!! That translates to around $120 MILLION dollars, and a full stadium will only generate about $50-60 million a year. Take away operating expenses like salaries and it's going to be pretty tight in a few years. So to me, running the table provides a VERY "reasonable" amount of income. Some of my guys will be able to afford equipment while some of the teams that get promoted without having home playoff revenue won't. That's the reward for being the regular season champion and I have no problem with that. 'Course, YMMV.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.