User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > I suggest the next thing implimented in GLB is Scrambling for QBs
Page:
 
al0x
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by turnerhero


That one is the only one where he clearly leaves the pocket, unfortunately it's a running scramble, but a scramble nonetheless.


We don't have a play in the AI for the QB to rush, he must have decided to himself. If that is the case then it is probably because none of the WRs were open.
Last edited Oct 13, 2008 12:08:24
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Yes, scrambling QB's don't work very well right now. I had a version that worked ok a while ago, but QB's were getting stupidly sacked when they scrambled sometimes so I had to remove it.

Keep in mind that any sim updates beyond horrible problems that break everything will only go in during off-season, since otherwise we get a bitch-fest.
 
al0x
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Yes, scrambling QB's don't work very well right now. I had a version that worked ok a while ago, but QB's were getting stupidly sacked when they scrambled sometimes so I had to remove it.

Keep in mind that any sim updates beyond horrible problems that break everything will only go in during off-season, since otherwise we get a bitch-fest.


Can the QB decide to rush himself like on the first play I linked to? Or was it in the AI for some reason?
 
G.O.D Turner
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Yes, scrambling QB's don't work very well right now. I had a version that worked ok a while ago, but QB's were getting stupidly sacked when they scrambled sometimes so I had to remove it.

Keep in mind that any sim updates beyond horrible problems that break everything will only go in during off-season, since otherwise we get a bitch-fest.


All I've wanted through this entire thread was to see something about this from you, Bort, or an Admin who was 'in the know' about what's happening - if you're aware that it's not going on, etc etc...

I'm glad to see you in here...I'm going to basically hope that this was a hint that something may come this offseason about fixing it.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by alex2544
Originally posted by Bort

Yes, scrambling QB's don't work very well right now. I had a version that worked ok a while ago, but QB's were getting stupidly sacked when they scrambled sometimes so I had to remove it.

Keep in mind that any sim updates beyond horrible problems that break everything will only go in during off-season, since otherwise we get a bitch-fest.


Can the QB decide to rush himself like on the first play I linked to? Or was it in the AI for some reason?


It was an increased likelyhood to roll out. Unfortunately, rolling out often got him caught by one of those really fast DE's.
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
wow.... I guess that's the end of me saying nobody's ever in suggestions.

Tbh I'm glad
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by alex2544

Originally posted by Bort


Yes, scrambling QB's don't work very well right now. I had a version that worked ok a while ago, but QB's were getting stupidly sacked when they scrambled sometimes so I had to remove it.

Keep in mind that any sim updates beyond horrible problems that break everything will only go in during off-season, since otherwise we get a bitch-fest.


Can the QB decide to rush himself like on the first play I linked to? Or was it in the AI for some reason?


It was an increased likelyhood to roll out. Unfortunately, rolling out often got him caught by one of those really fast DE's.


What about this from GGs suggestion thread individual player tactics.
specifically the QB target priority and scrambling target priority

------------------------------------------------------------------

THROWING
scramble frequency -- to mean how often they leave the pocket -- (never, sometimes, often)
tuck-run frequency -- to mean abandoning throw and taking off -- (never, sometimes, often)
dump pass frequency -- (never, sometimes, often)
pass style -- each one is available for 'short', 'medium', and 'long' -- (favor bullet, favor medium, favor lofty)
pass technique -- (favor low, favor chest, favor high)
pass length -- (favor long, favor medium, favor short, favor none)
favorite target -- by name -- (list of names)
favorite target -- by position -- (WR, WR-1, WR-2, WR-3, TE, HB, FB)
qb target priority -- sortable order list -- (1. to WR, 2. to TE, 3. dump to RB, 4. scramble, 5. tuck and run)
qb scramble priority -- sortable order list -- (1. to TE, 2. to WR, 3. tuck and run, 4. dump to RB

So with the sortable list scrambling is an option (better work than target for this example) that the QB can have control of the priority level. So it only helps/hurts the QB as much as the priority level allows.

Some mike vick type QBs might put scrambling as their first option. Where most QBs that are pocket passers will probably choose to never scramble. This way the agent has the ability to choose how much risk to take with scrambling.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Yes, scrambling QB's don't work very well right now. I had a version that worked ok a while ago, but QB's were getting stupidly sacked when they scrambled sometimes so I had to remove it.

Keep in mind that any sim updates beyond horrible problems that break everything will only go in during off-season, since otherwise we get a bitch-fest.


Glad to hear from you. Happy Birthday.
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Yes, scrambling QB's don't work very well right now. I had a version that worked ok a while ago, but QB's were getting stupidly sacked when they scrambled sometimes so I had to remove it.

Keep in mind that any sim updates beyond horrible problems that break everything will only go in during off-season, since otherwise we get a bitch-fest.


YES YES YES YES YES! Recognition at long last Happy Bortday!
 
DL24
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dmfa41
Originally posted by Bort

Yes, scrambling QB's don't work very well right now. I had a version that worked ok a while ago, but QB's were getting stupidly sacked when they scrambled sometimes so I had to remove it.

Keep in mind that any sim updates beyond horrible problems that break everything will only go in during off-season, since otherwise we get a bitch-fest.


YES YES YES YES YES! Recognition at long last Happy Bortday!


this
 
G.O.D Turner
offline
Link
 
Well I guess there's no need to bump this now that the person I wanted to read it finally did (although I'm not sure how much of it haha) but anyway, let it die now I suppose, until next season
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by turnerhero
Well I guess there's no need to bump this now that the person I wanted to read it finally did (although I'm not sure how much of it haha) but anyway, let it die now I suppose, until next season


I've had a lot of fun with this thread... but to mark its death

Fuck the Police

lighters...
 
fakesanta
offline
Link
 
bump.

it seems the definition of "scrambling QB" is - quarterback who incorporates movement of himself and sometimes the pocket into his skill set, including (but not limited to) bootlegs, option runs, draws, sneaks, etc. this is probably difficult to code, and releasing a special abilities tree was perhaps premature.

no one is really going to expect a "rushing QB" yet - a QB who incorporates improvised movement of himself and the pocket, with throwing being a secondary priority. coding that would take a gibson computer.

perhaps a skill point respec should be given for any QB with more than 10 points in the "scrambling" SA tree?
Last edited Oct 13, 2008 22:25:41
 
G.O.D Turner
offline
Link
 
NO RESPEC
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by turnerhero
NO RESPEC


AGREED

god I hate having to type in all caps, but that is IMPERATIVE there
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.