User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Prestige Attributes - A way to reduce the "stagnation plateau" for higher level players and add more differentiation among cookie cutter builds
Page:
 
NickTranOwnz
offline
Link
 
This idea is stupid in general, and ripping it off from Call Of Duty 4 makes it worse.

Too complicated with few superficial benefits.
 
Dannyg28
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NickTranOwnz
This idea is stupid in general, and ripping it off from Call Of Duty 4 makes it worse.

Too complicated with few superficial benefits.


in what way is it complicated......at all?
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter

EDITED ANNOUNCEMENT

This idea sparked an off topic debate/rant/extended whine by individuals who thought this would be a good place to complain about past ideas that had been rejected and air other assorted grievances they had with the game. Skip ahead to page 20 to pick up the discussion and brainstorming of additional ideas that fit under the original topic


We all know that there have been many, many comments about how higher level players are becoming bored with the game because of the slow down in levelling. This idea would add back the excitement of regular levelling and, as a bonus, would provide another way to differentiate between builds so that we don't look alike. This would not supercede by previous suggestion about Lockerroom attributes.

Basically, starting with Level 31 (approximately the mid-point of level gain of a 10 year career), players would have a 2nd type of experience and levels that would begin to accrue. We'll call them prestige levels.

These prestige levels would be figured separately from actual player levels and would accrue XP based on the usual XP chart BUT they would start at level 1 (at player level 31).

The player would continue to get his floor XP and gain regular player levels but would have a separately accrued Prestige XP towards their Prestige Level.

For example, a player hits level 31. He continues to get 25XP per day and 90 XP per game on his way to level 32 and so on. However, at the same time he is getting 100 Prestige XP per day and 600 Prestige XP per game towards Prestige Level 2 and so on. By the time the player hits Player Level 32, he'll probably be somwhere are Prestige Level 6 or 7. Boosting will continue to effect Player level but will have no effect on Prestige Level.

Each gain in prestige level will give the player Prestige Skill Points to assign to Prestige attributes. These attributes are as follows and are divided into two categories: Soft Cap Adjusters and Performance Boosters

Soft Cap Adjusters:

Gym Rat – Every 5 points raises the soft cap on Strength by 1. If the player has already spent points past the soft cap, it will raise their strength by that much. For example a player has a strength of 50 having spent 2 pts to raise strength from 49 to 50. A point in Stronger than average would raise the soft cap to 50 and raise this player’s actual strength to 51 for the points already spent.

Quick – As above with Agility

Track Star – As above with Speed

Laser Arm – As above with throwing

Technically Sound Blocker – As above with blocking

Textbook Tackler – As above with Tackling

Football Genius – As above with Vision

Marathoner – As above with Stamina

Cocky – As above with Confidence

High Jumper – As above with jumping

Strong Hands – As above with Catching

Soccer Star – As above with kicking and punting

Performance Boosters

Future Coach – Increases entire unit’s vision

Clutch – Increases performance in clutch situations (late in close game, OT)

Sure Tackler – Reduces the chance of a missed tackle when playing on balanced

Helmet on the ball – Increases the chance of a fumble when playing on balanced.

Hard to Beat – Less likely to get fooled by pump fakes and receiver moves

Slippery – Higher chance for a QB to break a tackle on a sack

GoTo Guy – Gives a boost to a receiver’s “open or not” read by the QB

Never Gives Up – Reduces the “downtime” by getting pancaked or beat by a move or a pump fake.

As I said, I believe this will add back in the excitement of regular levelling for higher level players AND will also provide a way for players to differentiate themselves even more from the standard cookie cutter builds.




Found: Re-thought naming ideas not syncing up with unchanged names.
Last edited Aug 30, 2008 23:16:37
 
Donner
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Originally posted by Donner


Number 3 is a nonstarter. There is a very limited number of slots open for players in Pro leagues, at this point. At roughly 40 players per Pro League team, 32 teams per Pro league, and 8 Pro Leagues, your looking at a little over 10,000 players out of the current 360,000 players that would have these skills. That's a little less than 3% of the players that would benefit from this addition. The current XP modifier works fine for encouraging players to play with similar competition and covers everyone because it based upon aggregate levels and therefor doesn't have to worry about a a constantly expanding player-base. There just isn't enough room in the Pro leagues for higher level players. The naming conventions are still one of the single worst decisions made by Bort and Co.

Aside from that, it makes sense for the skills to be available to all players. Pro players aren't the only ones with these types of skills.


I'm not saying that the high level Players in other leagues couldn't acquire the skills - I am only saying that they should not be able to use them. Without some sort of stipulation like this, the only thing this idea will do to the game is make the level disparities which exist - worse. You think that gutting is a problem now? Imagine the current system with level 32 Players in the A leagues.. now imagine making those level 32's even better - without making the level 24's better.

Without that stipulation, this entire idea is a nonstarter because the only thing it brings to the game is greater skill disparities within the leagues. As for your statement that there aren't enough Pro Teams - yes there are.. if you have a Player that wants to go Pro - go find Pro teams and tell them that you will gladly join as a backup.


Level 32s in A leagues will be gimping themselves, they are going to get zilch for XP. Look at those numbers again, do you think really wants to do all that work for 3% of the players?
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Originally posted by Donner


Number 3 is a nonstarter. There is a very limited number of slots open for players in Pro leagues, at this point. At roughly 40 players per Pro League team, 32 teams per Pro league, and 8 Pro Leagues, your looking at a little over 10,000 players out of the current 360,000 players that would have these skills. That's a little less than 3% of the players that would benefit from this addition. The current XP modifier works fine for encouraging players to play with similar competition and covers everyone because it based upon aggregate levels and therefor doesn't have to worry about a a constantly expanding player-base. There just isn't enough room in the Pro leagues for higher level players. The naming conventions are still one of the single worst decisions made by Bort and Co.

Aside from that, it makes sense for the skills to be available to all players. Pro players aren't the only ones with these types of skills.


I'm not saying that the high level Players in other leagues couldn't acquire the skills - I am only saying that they should not be able to use them. Without some sort of stipulation like this, the only thing this idea will do to the game is make the level disparities which exist - worse. You think that gutting is a problem now? Imagine the current system with level 32 Players in the A leagues.. now imagine making those level 32's even better - without making the level 24's better.

Without that stipulation, this entire idea is a nonstarter because the only thing it brings to the game is greater skill disparities within the leagues. As for your statement that there aren't enough Pro Teams - yes there are.. if you have a Player that wants to go Pro - go find Pro teams and tell them that you will gladly join as a backup.


So, "Keep the game boring for high levels because to fix it would give higher level players an advantage?" That doesn't resonate with me, at all. And I don't have any players yet over level 30.

A level 31 or 32 player won't have gained that many points to put into VA's anyway, and a VA with only a few points isn't very strong at all.

I'd rather that exp for VA's be easier to gain in higher level leagues (but possible to gain anywhere), but when it comes to extreme measures to ensure parity, I'm not with that. Small incentives, yes; but not extreme measures.
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
well, VAs will either: Improve players as they gain them or leave the Players the same power level but more specialized (like maybe a VA that adds to run blocking but subtracts from pass blocking)... Since we are going with the notion that there will be VAs that add to attributes - that means that the VAs will increase power level.

That means that the power between different level Players will increase as a result of VAs. If we then place no constraints upon where Players can use them - then in effect - we might as well just increase the SPs assigned to high level Players, or increase the experience gained, increase the attributes which are handed out.. or whatever.. the net effect would be the same.

Infact, if we just increased the SP gain from high levels - that atleast would increase the incentive to boost.. which would help Bort, even if it created further inequities between Players of different levels. With this system - Players will have a reduced incentive to boost, but will still increase in playing ability relative to lower level Players, than under the current system.

Now, why does any of this matter? Because a level 28 team is already stomping the hell out of level 18 teams in any random league you want to name (except the capped ones).. now fast forward 2 seasons when we have level 38 teams smashing level 28 teams in any random league... the VA system will create a much wider gap in the playing abilities of the two teams.. meaning it is even more likely that blowout scenarios will occur.

Anyways, I've said what I'll say on this idea - I have no desire to get Players up that high of level anyways.. just retire and start new ones to play in the capped leagues seems the best way to play the game for me.
 
NickTranOwnz
offline
Link
 
This idea is flawed. Not only does it rip off something awesome the best game ever, but it makes the best better and doesn't do anything for the lower levels. It's unfair to most players who are not level 31 and are not in top tier leagues.
 
Zadith
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
well, VAs will either: Improve players as they gain them or leave the Players the same power level but more specialized (like maybe a VA that adds to run blocking but subtracts from pass blocking)... Since we are going with the notion that there will be VAs that add to attributes - that means that the VAs will increase power level.

That means that the power between different level Players will increase as a result of VAs. If we then place no constraints upon where Players can use them - then in effect - we might as well just increase the SPs assigned to high level Players, or increase the experience gained, increase the attributes which are handed out.. or whatever.. the net effect would be the same.

Infact, if we just increased the SP gain from high levels - that atleast would increase the incentive to boost.. which would help Bort, even if it created further inequities between Players of different levels. With this system - Players will have a reduced incentive to boost, but will still increase in playing ability relative to lower level Players, than under the current system.

Now, why does any of this matter? Because a level 28 team is already stomping the hell out of level 18 teams in any random league you want to name (except the capped ones).. now fast forward 2 seasons when we have level 38 teams smashing level 28 teams in any random league... the VA system will create a much wider gap in the playing abilities of the two teams.. meaning it is even more likely that blowout scenarios will occur.

Anyways, I've said what I'll say on this idea - I have no desire to get Players up that high of level anyways.. just retire and start new ones to play in the capped leagues seems the best way to play the game for me.



That would be my fear. Having the random teams with players that are on average 5-10+ levels ahead of everyone else dominating forever with this new system. I understand teams move up when they win but yet some how every season there is at least one team that out levels all the others in their league.
 
Dannyg28
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NickTranOwnz
This idea is flawed. Not only does it rip off something awesome the best game ever, but it makes the best better and doesn't do anything for the lower levels. It's unfair to most players who are not level 31 and are not in top tier leagues.


who cares if its something similar to whats in another game honestly??? Should we just stop playing this entire game because everything thats in this game has in one form or another been in another game.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dannyg28
Originally posted by NickTranOwnz

This idea is flawed. Not only does it rip off something awesome the best game ever, but it makes the best better and doesn't do anything for the lower levels. It's unfair to most players who are not level 31 and are not in top tier leagues.


who cares if its something similar to whats in another game honestly??? Should we just stop playing this entire game because everything thats in this game has in one form or another been in another game.


Great point.

I don't have anyone who's Level 31 yet, but it will keep some excitement in the game once one does reach that level, rather than only leveling once a season or whatever.
 
Knicksfan20
offline
Link
 
Definatly a great idea...i have only grown 1 level THIS WHOLE ENTIRE SEASON


it sucks
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NickTranOwnz
This idea is stupid in general, and ripping it off from Call Of Duty 4 makes it worse.

Too complicated with few superficial benefits.


Wasn't ripped off from COD at all as I've never once played COD4 - I'm boycotting Activision for their actions surrounding the Rock Star patch to make use of their guitar from Guitar Hero.

In fact, if anything COD4 ripped off the idea of high level "Prestige" gains from AD&D 2nd edition. They first introduced the idea of high level Prestige classes about 20 years ago.

Oh, and it's only complicated if you're a mouth breather.
Last edited Aug 31, 2008 19:16:56
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NickTranOwnz
This idea is flawed. Not only does it rip off something awesome the best game ever, but it makes the best better and doesn't do anything for the lower levels. It's unfair to most players who are not level 31 and are not in top tier leagues.


Unfair? How is it unfair? Everyone will have the same options once they get to level 31. It's not like players are stuck at level 25 for their entire careers. That makes no sense at all
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Im glad people are speaking up about the flaws in this idea.

1. Creates an even bigger disparity.
2. To band-aid that disparity, a rule would be brought in that only pro-leaguers can have prestige skills.
3. Hence, only a tiny percentage of people will be involved in this idea.
4. Therefore, the level of boredom for a vast majority of players will amplify due to reaching prestige level but not/never being able to have them due to not being in pro-league.
4b. A lot of people will not boost therefore as it would be pointless.
5. You'll have hundreds of thousands of level 50's one day, who will retire never being able to gain prestige skills because they could never crack it into the pros.
6. And it will create another level of disparity in the pros, when you DO get a bunch of players finally enter pro-league 5 seasons after established starters, and find themselves 20-30 prestige levels behind those established starters who've been there since day one. So level 50 prestige level 30 players/teams destroying level 50 prestige level 1 players/teams 100-0.

Imo, better than a prestige skill idea is an idea like creating a whole new free-form buffet style SA area where people can specialize and individualize their players like the idea I called 'New SA'.

Basically, all the kinds of prestige attributes people are thinking up in this thread could be turned into SAs, added to all the existing SAs, then splitting them all up into position specific ones (or skill specific: throwing, running, tackling, blocking, receiving), and then re-doing the SA page so that players from day one must select something like 10 out of a possible 50 position/skill specific SAs and those SAs become the way players can specialize their players. With each SA maxing out at something like 100 SPs, not 10. You could even make it that once players reach every 10 incremental levels they unlock the ability to add another SA to their player.

 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Take a hike
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.