User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Season 4 changes ARE going to cost this game alot of dedicated players.
Page:
 
chief31
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay


Damn I wish I could quote like that lol,

Anyways, as far as O-Line vs D-Line it is not about Strength now, Blocking plays a MUCH MUCH MUCH more key role, kinda of like how speed and agility are linked now, Strength and Blocking is linked.

As far as changes affecting Season 12, I don't see how anyone could foretell that, how do you know Bort hasn't btw? He is the only one that I know of that can tell you what might happen in season 12, not that he is going to, nor should he, nor would I want him to, that is half the fun in playing the game.


So BLOCKING kills all? Seems fair.

How about if I add that the o-lineman with 50 STRENGTH has 60 BLOCKING, and the DT with 90 STRENGTH, has 60 AGILITY?

Not that it matters, I have seen how you do this. You just move on to the next attribute, and then to SAs.

But under no circumstances, shouls a guy with 50 STRENGTH be shoving a guy with 90 STRENGTH backward, consistently.

 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chief31
Originally posted by oldskool
Originally posted by chief31
Nope. The value of SPEED was obvious. So obvious that they felt the need to make major changes.


Originally posted by TOS


Cheating includes, but is not limited to: using automated account creation or log-in tools (i.e. "bots"), exploiting a bug without bringing it to the attention of GoalLineBlitz.com administrators, attempting to hack into any GoalLineBlitz.com server, and gaining Flex Points through fake referrals.


So now SPEED was a bug?

You? The one who likes to tell everybody that they are wrong about any complaint that they have? How many people did you mouth-off to about their "whining" on the subject of SPEED?

Get the f*** outta here!

SPEED wasn't a bug. It was just causing those who neglected SPEED to think that it was wrong.


The speed to acceleration ratio was busted, so that speed > * (that means greater than everything!) when it came to flat-out running. That would be a BUG, as agility was supposed to play a much larger factor and it did not; deliberately altering your build to capitalize on that BUG would be exploitation of a bug, would it not?
 
chief31
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by chief31

Originally posted by oldskool


Originally posted by chief31



Nope. The value of SPEED was obvious. So obvious that they felt the need to make major changes.


Originally posted by TOS



Cheating includes, but is not limited to: using automated account creation or log-in tools (i.e. "bots"), exploiting a bug without bringing it to the attention of GoalLineBlitz.com administrators, attempting to hack into any GoalLineBlitz.com server, and gaining Flex Points through fake referrals.


So now SPEED was a bug?

You? The one who likes to tell everybody that they are wrong about any complaint that they have? How many people did you mouth-off to about their "whining" on the subject of SPEED?

Get the f*** outta here!

SPEED wasn't a bug. It was just causing those who neglected SPEED to think that it was wrong.


Considering Bort called it a bug, yea. I would go with that.


Good of him to let everyone know, right? If everyone invested in a "bug" without having any idea that it was being considered a "bug", then he was selling it.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chief31
Originally posted by sjmay

Originally posted by chief31


Originally posted by oldskool



Originally posted by chief31




Nope. The value of SPEED was obvious. So obvious that they felt the need to make major changes.


Originally posted by TOS




Cheating includes, but is not limited to: using automated account creation or log-in tools (i.e. "bots"), exploiting a bug without bringing it to the attention of GoalLineBlitz.com administrators, attempting to hack into any GoalLineBlitz.com server, and gaining Flex Points through fake referrals.


So now SPEED was a bug?

You? The one who likes to tell everybody that they are wrong about any complaint that they have? How many people did you mouth-off to about their "whining" on the subject of SPEED?

Get the f*** outta here!

SPEED wasn't a bug. It was just causing those who neglected SPEED to think that it was wrong.


Considering Bort called it a bug, yea. I would go with that.


Good of him to let everyone know, right? If everyone invested in a "bug" without having any idea that it was being considered a "bug", then he was selling it.


Are you intentionally being obtuse?

How do you know it was considered a bug from the start of the sim?
How do you not know that it was discovered mid season 2, begin season 3, and he had to test it out?

Seriously, using your logic, we would all be up shit's creek without a paddle.
 
chief31
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
Originally posted by chief31

Originally posted by oldskool

Originally posted by chief31

Nope. The value of SPEED was obvious. So obvious that they felt the need to make major changes.


Originally posted by TOS



Cheating includes, but is not limited to: using automated account creation or log-in tools (i.e. "bots"), exploiting a bug without bringing it to the attention of GoalLineBlitz.com administrators, attempting to hack into any GoalLineBlitz.com server, and gaining Flex Points through fake referrals.


So now SPEED was a bug?

You? The one who likes to tell everybody that they are wrong about any complaint that they have? How many people did you mouth-off to about their "whining" on the subject of SPEED?

Get the f*** outta here!

SPEED wasn't a bug. It was just causing those who neglected SPEED to think that it was wrong.


The speed to acceleration ratio was busted, so that speed > * (that means greater than everything!) when it came to flat-out running. That would be a BUG, as agility was supposed to play a much larger factor and it did not; deliberately altering your build to capitalize on that BUG would be exploitation of a bug, would it not?


No. Where is my PM telling me that this was being considered a "bug"?

How was anyone supposed to know that they were being considered "cheaters"?

Oh, I know. They are supposed to spend three months sifting through all of the 44,000 threads, (many with hundreds of posts) to try and figure out rather they are cheaters?

But seriously. How many "whiners" did you tear into for their complaints about SPEED?
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
If you exploit a bug (regardless of intent or knowledge on the subject), and then whine about it when that bug is fixed so that exploit is no longer dominant, you deserve to be torn into. Nobody with half a brain could think that 90 speed/10 agility was a "correct" build for a football simulation.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chief31
Originally posted by oldskool

Originally posted by chief31


Originally posted by oldskool


Originally posted by chief31


Nope. The value of SPEED was obvious. So obvious that they felt the need to make major changes.


Originally posted by TOS




Cheating includes, but is not limited to: using automated account creation or log-in tools (i.e. "bots"), exploiting a bug without bringing it to the attention of GoalLineBlitz.com administrators, attempting to hack into any GoalLineBlitz.com server, and gaining Flex Points through fake referrals.


So now SPEED was a bug?

You? The one who likes to tell everybody that they are wrong about any complaint that they have? How many people did you mouth-off to about their "whining" on the subject of SPEED?

Get the f*** outta here!

SPEED wasn't a bug. It was just causing those who neglected SPEED to think that it was wrong.


The speed to acceleration ratio was busted, so that speed > * (that means greater than everything!) when it came to flat-out running. That would be a BUG, as agility was supposed to play a much larger factor and it did not; deliberately altering your build to capitalize on that BUG would be exploitation of a bug, would it not?


No. Where is my PM telling me that this was being considered a "bug"?

How was anyone supposed to know that they were being considered "cheaters"?

Oh, I know. They are supposed to spend three months sifting through all of the 44,000 threads, (many with hundreds of posts) to try and figure out rather they are cheaters?

But seriously. How many "whiners" did you tear into for their complaints about SPEED?


LMFAO you expect Bort to PM everyone about something that should have been obvious from the get go?

Again, I ask you, who in the hell builds a running back, with speed only and ignores, strength, agility, vision, carrying?
 
chief31
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by chief31

Originally posted by sjmay


Originally posted by chief31



Originally posted by oldskool




Originally posted by chief31





Nope. The value of SPEED was obvious. So obvious that they felt the need to make major changes.


Originally posted by TOS





Cheating includes, but is not limited to: using automated account creation or log-in tools (i.e. "bots"), exploiting a bug without bringing it to the attention of GoalLineBlitz.com administrators, attempting to hack into any GoalLineBlitz.com server, and gaining Flex Points through fake referrals.


So now SPEED was a bug?

You? The one who likes to tell everybody that they are wrong about any complaint that they have? How many people did you mouth-off to about their "whining" on the subject of SPEED?

Get the f*** outta here!

SPEED wasn't a bug. It was just causing those who neglected SPEED to think that it was wrong.


Considering Bort called it a bug, yea. I would go with that.


Good of him to let everyone know, right? If everyone invested in a "bug" without having any idea that it was being considered a "bug", then he was selling it.


Are you intentionally being obtuse?

How do you know it was considered a bug from the start of the sim?
How do you not know that it was discovered mid season 2, begin season 3, and he had to test it out?

Seriously, using your logic, we would all be up shit's creek without a paddle.


How would anyone have known?

I have to go to work now, but... Where was that info on the homepage?

Where was it at on the SP distribution page?

Or was it buried in those thousands of threads in "Goal Line Blitz" forums?
 
chief31
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
If you exploit a bug (regardless of intent or knowledge on the subject), and then whine about it when that bug is fixed so that exploit is no longer dominant, you deserve to be torn into. Nobody with half a brain could think that 90 speed/10 agility was a "correct" build for a football simulation.


First, I never had SPEED without AGILITY. (Early in their build, as I build one att at atime.) So this argument isn't even about me.

Secondly, tell me what actual player would be labeled as 90 SPEED, and run a 6.20 40-time?

Is it reasonable to assume that a real person who qualifies as 90 SPEED would run a good 4.-something?

NO. We are supposed to assume that guys with 90 SPEED will be slower than everyone else. Right?

Gotta go. Work.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chief31
Originally posted by oldskool

If you exploit a bug (regardless of intent or knowledge on the subject), and then whine about it when that bug is fixed so that exploit is no longer dominant, you deserve to be torn into. Nobody with half a brain could think that 90 speed/10 agility was a "correct" build for a football simulation.


First, I never had SPEED without AGILITY. (Early in their build, as I build one att at atime.) So this argument isn't even about me.

Secondly, tell me what actual player would be labeled as 90 SPEED, and run a 6.20 40-time?

Is it reasonable to assume that a real person who qualifies as 90 SPEED would run a good 4.-something?

NO. We are supposed to assume that guys with 90 SPEED will be slower than everyone else. Right?

Gotta go. Work.


Oh they could run all right, they couldn't carry the ball, cut to change lanes, see the lanes to cut into,

But hell, they can run,

Yea, ya got me there, helluva football player.
 
Revel8
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by Revelation

Originally posted by sjmay


Originally posted by Revelation



Originally posted by sjmay




Originally posted by RunningMn9





Originally posted by sjmay






You either are, or you aren't, you have said you are both, doesn't quite work that way.


It does when I'm being incredibly sarcastic when I claim to be one of the two ways.


LOL,

True, I've been staring at a spread sheet all day so I didn't catch it.

But the point remains You can't claim that the game should be about beta testing, which you are doing, and then turn around and complain about all the money you are spending on it


I see nothing wrong with doing both. We are his beta testers and customers at the same time. It's a very good system for making money while you develop a game IMO and I'm sure others will follow this example. However, it will be found out eventually by someone that you can't keep changing a game and not freely allow your customers to change with it to the extent of your changes. Sure it makes Bort more money now, but it will not in the long run and makes the beta version of this game much more expensive than the full version for those who would like to be competitive in every season.


Besides making the game more realistic, what changes were there?

If the people clamoring for a respec, had thought they were building a football player, just tell me this then, what football player relies soley on speed, or solely on strength, what defensive player ignores tackling?

All Bort did was make the game realistic, it is a much much better game now than it was, and the ONLY people who are whining about it, are the ones who got hit hard because they didn't build a realistic football player.


Every change now seems to make the game more realistic, your question is a closed one which only allows for one answer. That is not the issue and I'm not dumb bud.

No it is not the only those people who got hit hard who are bringing this issue up. My own players have weathered these changes relatively fine an were mostly balanced from the beginning.

Having owned 2 businesses I have the insight needed to know that not allowing a respec is bad business, plain and simple. I'm even entertaining the thought of a third business (if I get the time), a game that competes with this one, because I'd have a much better business plan which in all likelihood would take players away from this game. A game like this can be done for so much cheaper than Bort is charging it isn't funny.


Can't remember, where you a programmer? I would think not with having owned 2 businesses, but you never can be sure, if not, how do you know exactly how Bort is overcharging? Comparing it to other games? Comparing it to the cost of business, servers, employees, etc?



I owned a computer hardware business before joining in the gold mine that is web development. Bort makes it sound like servers are expensive...they're not as long as you know where to get one or build one yourself. Even with conservative estimates, this game is likely making over 50% pure profit right now.

Take how many teams there are, how many boosters there are on the average team, minus an approximation of free flex points, plus the approximate revenue from new referrals, minus server cost, minus general cost of living expenses and employees salary (estimated around 5 at $50k a year).

As a pretty conservative estimate, this game is probably bringing in at least $200 grand a season while the total cost per season I can't see being much above $100 grand. My not so conservative estimates put revenue at about a half a million dollars every season and even that may be low.

It's not much of a mystery to me why Bort could quit his day job in season 2.
 
Zadith
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Revelation
Originally posted by sjmay

Originally posted by Revelation


Originally posted by sjmay



Originally posted by Revelation




Originally posted by sjmay





Originally posted by RunningMn9






Originally posted by sjmay







You either are, or you aren't, you have said you are both, doesn't quite work that way.


It does when I'm being incredibly sarcastic when I claim to be one of the two ways.


LOL,

True, I've been staring at a spread sheet all day so I didn't catch it.

But the point remains You can't claim that the game should be about beta testing, which you are doing, and then turn around and complain about all the money you are spending on it


I see nothing wrong with doing both. We are his beta testers and customers at the same time. It's a very good system for making money while you develop a game IMO and I'm sure others will follow this example. However, it will be found out eventually by someone that you can't keep changing a game and not freely allow your customers to change with it to the extent of your changes. Sure it makes Bort more money now, but it will not in the long run and makes the beta version of this game much more expensive than the full version for those who would like to be competitive in every season.


Besides making the game more realistic, what changes were there?

If the people clamoring for a respec, had thought they were building a football player, just tell me this then, what football player relies soley on speed, or solely on strength, what defensive player ignores tackling?

All Bort did was make the game realistic, it is a much much better game now than it was, and the ONLY people who are whining about it, are the ones who got hit hard because they didn't build a realistic football player.


Every change now seems to make the game more realistic, your question is a closed one which only allows for one answer. That is not the issue and I'm not dumb bud.

No it is not the only those people who got hit hard who are bringing this issue up. My own players have weathered these changes relatively fine an were mostly balanced from the beginning.

Having owned 2 businesses I have the insight needed to know that not allowing a respec is bad business, plain and simple. I'm even entertaining the thought of a third business (if I get the time), a game that competes with this one, because I'd have a much better business plan which in all likelihood would take players away from this game. A game like this can be done for so much cheaper than Bort is charging it isn't funny.


Can't remember, where you a programmer? I would think not with having owned 2 businesses, but you never can be sure, if not, how do you know exactly how Bort is overcharging? Comparing it to other games? Comparing it to the cost of business, servers, employees, etc?



I owned a computer hardware business before joining in the gold mine that is web development. Bort makes it sound like servers are expensive...they're not as long as you know where to get one or build one yourself. Even with conservative estimates, this game is likely making over 50% pure profit right now.

Take how many teams there are, how many boosters there are on the average team, minus an approximation of free flex points, plus the approximate revenue from new referrals, minus server cost, minus general cost of living expenses and employees salary (estimated around 5 at $50k a year).

As a pretty conservative estimate, this game is probably bringing in at least $200 grand a season while the total cost per season I can't see being much above $100 grand. My not so conservative estimates put revenue at about a half a million dollars every season and even that may be low.

It's not much of a mystery to me why Bort could quit his day job in season 2.


that is not too far from the truth I am afraid. Honestly Bort(and crew if he pays them) have made a shit load of cash off this game and will continue to for a few more months before it hits the fan....

You could probably run a game just like GLB for half the price Bort does if not less and still make a good profit and if you have good customer service you would eventually make more than GLB because you would have more business...
Last edited Aug 14, 2008 21:42:49
 
dberner30
offline
Link
 
could should but may not...

fix or it or burn it to the ground...
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zadith
Originally posted by Revelation

Originally posted by sjmay


Originally posted by Revelation



Originally posted by sjmay




Originally posted by Revelation





Originally posted by sjmay






Originally posted by RunningMn9







Originally posted by sjmay








You either are, or you aren't, you have said you are both, doesn't quite work that way.


It does when I'm being incredibly sarcastic when I claim to be one of the two ways.


LOL,

True, I've been staring at a spread sheet all day so I didn't catch it.

But the point remains You can't claim that the game should be about beta testing, which you are doing, and then turn around and complain about all the money you are spending on it


I see nothing wrong with doing both. We are his beta testers and customers at the same time. It's a very good system for making money while you develop a game IMO and I'm sure others will follow this example. However, it will be found out eventually by someone that you can't keep changing a game and not freely allow your customers to change with it to the extent of your changes. Sure it makes Bort more money now, but it will not in the long run and makes the beta version of this game much more expensive than the full version for those who would like to be competitive in every season.


Besides making the game more realistic, what changes were there?

If the people clamoring for a respec, had thought they were building a football player, just tell me this then, what football player relies soley on speed, or solely on strength, what defensive player ignores tackling?

All Bort did was make the game realistic, it is a much much better game now than it was, and the ONLY people who are whining about it, are the ones who got hit hard because they didn't build a realistic football player.


Every change now seems to make the game more realistic, your question is a closed one which only allows for one answer. That is not the issue and I'm not dumb bud.

No it is not the only those people who got hit hard who are bringing this issue up. My own players have weathered these changes relatively fine an were mostly balanced from the beginning.

Having owned 2 businesses I have the insight needed to know that not allowing a respec is bad business, plain and simple. I'm even entertaining the thought of a third business (if I get the time), a game that competes with this one, because I'd have a much better business plan which in all likelihood would take players away from this game. A game like this can be done for so much cheaper than Bort is charging it isn't funny.


Can't remember, where you a programmer? I would think not with having owned 2 businesses, but you never can be sure, if not, how do you know exactly how Bort is overcharging? Comparing it to other games? Comparing it to the cost of business, servers, employees, etc?



I owned a computer hardware business before joining in the gold mine that is web development. Bort makes it sound like servers are expensive...they're not as long as you know where to get one or build one yourself. Even with conservative estimates, this game is likely making over 50% pure profit right now.

Take how many teams there are, how many boosters there are on the average team, minus an approximation of free flex points, plus the approximate revenue from new referrals, minus server cost, minus general cost of living expenses and employees salary (estimated around 5 at $50k a year).

As a pretty conservative estimate, this game is probably bringing in at least $200 grand a season while the total cost per season I can't see being much above $100 grand. My not so conservative estimates put revenue at about a half a million dollars every season and even that may be low.

It's not much of a mystery to me why Bort could quit his day job in season 2.


that is not too far from the truth I am afraid. Honestly Bort(and crew if he pays them) have made a shit load of cash off this game and will continue to for a few more months before it hits the fan....

You could probably run a game just like GLB for half the price Bort does if not less and still make a good profit and if you have good customer service you would eventually make more than GLB because you would have more business...


In all honesty, has anyone considered that this isn't the case? Granted, he should and probably does make money off of the game, but if this was such the cash cow that you guys are making it out to be, answer me one question.

HOW COME NOT ONE OF THE "BIG GAMING" COMPANIES, have done it? It can't be they don't have the programmers, it can't be they don't have the resources, it can't be they never thought of it, cmon, think realistically here, big game companies, PAY PEOPLE to create games and ideas, you don't think ONE of them out of the thousands, didn't think of this beforehand?

 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chief31
Originally posted by sjmay

Originally posted by chief31


Originally posted by oldskool



Originally posted by chief31




Nope. The value of SPEED was obvious. So obvious that they felt the need to make major changes.


Originally posted by TOS




Cheating includes, but is not limited to: using automated account creation or log-in tools (i.e. "bots"), exploiting a bug without bringing it to the attention of GoalLineBlitz.com administrators, attempting to hack into any GoalLineBlitz.com server, and gaining Flex Points through fake referrals.


So now SPEED was a bug?

You? The one who likes to tell everybody that they are wrong about any complaint that they have? How many people did you mouth-off to about their "whining" on the subject of SPEED?

Get the f*** outta here!

SPEED wasn't a bug. It was just causing those who neglected SPEED to think that it was wrong.


Considering Bort called it a bug, yea. I would go with that.


Good of him to let everyone know, right? If everyone invested in a "bug" without having any idea that it was being considered a "bug", then he was selling it.


Minmaxers who didn't build real football players got hosed. I take that as a good thing.

I like that if you don't build a real football player you'll get hosed. It's a deterrent against exploiting imbalances.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.