User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Speed De's Deserve an Answer Bort
Page:
 
Jason Cash
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Guru25
Originally posted by Bort

Example of what "elusive" can help you do:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=88491&pbp_id=910050

Of course, magnus is pretty good. I'm still making minor adjustments to make sure it's not overpowering.


This would never happen in a real game of football- where a DE runs right around the OT. The OT starts out a foot away from the DE. There is no way that someone could just run around the OT. The DE should have to make contact and do a spin/swim/bull-rush move to get past an OT. If more of these plays start cropping up it will show how people can make a completely unrealistic person and be successful. Speed + Agility will be the only thing you need in order to make a successful DE. So to counter people will make Speed + Agility OTs that are weak and unrealistic just to beat these overpowered DEs.


uh..if the DE is fast enough he could. And I guess you didnt pay attention cause the OT and DE touched... So it looked like the DE might have put a swim move or something on him .

 
AnTiNiNjA
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Guru25
Originally posted by Bort

Example of what "elusive" can help you do:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=88491&pbp_id=910050

Of course, magnus is pretty good. I'm still making minor adjustments to make sure it's not overpowering.


This would never happen in a real game of football- where a DE runs right around the OT. The OT starts out a foot away from the DE. There is no way that someone could just run around the OT. The DE should have to make contact and do a spin/swim/bull-rush move to get past an OT. If more of these plays start cropping up it will show how people can make a completely unrealistic person and be successful. Speed + Agility will be the only thing you need in order to make a successful DE. So to counter people will make Speed + Agility OTs that are weak and unrealistic just to beat these overpowered DEs.


If you put a 300 lb guy that runs a 10.5 you would see it all the time. Doesn't matter what he can bench if he can get in the way.

OTS don't make contact and hold it in football. They get in the path of the blocker and keep the player from getting past them. Making contact and grabbing them is called holding, and is a penalty.

If you want to see unrealistic, the NT would be on the qb quicker than anyone else, since you take distance from the qb during the snap...

Its not our problem if people think just blocking and strength makes a good blocker, which they do. A blocker than can hardly move that is.
 
slipknottin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Guru25

This would never happen in a real game of football- where a DE runs right around the OT. The OT starts out a foot away from the DE. There is no way that someone could just run around the OT. The DE should have to make contact and do a spin/swim/bull-rush move to get past an OT.


It happens in real life when a DE gets off the snap faster than the OT can react. Watch osi umenyiora against winston justice. Osi is, in my opinion, the quickest guy off the snap in the league. He blew past justice on multiple occasions that game. I believe twice Justice never even got a hand on him, and on a few other plays he barely touched him.


The reason that play that Bort linked to was successful was not because of the DE. Its easy for a DE to run a loop around the OT, just about any DE in the league can do that. The reason that play was successful was the push that the DT got. He shoved the center right back into the QB, preventing the Qb from stepping up. Had the Qb been able to step up into the pocket the OT could reach the DE in time and push him wide.
Last edited Aug 2, 2008 21:44:06
 
AnTiNiNjA
offline
Link
 
This thread grows by about 5 pages every day.

I just want to see how long it will eventually get haha.
 
t-money
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Snark
Originally posted by t-money

This fixation of focusing on the end result stats seems counter-productive. Until we have leagues that day in and day out match the best of the best against each other, the realism argument doesn't hold weight because in real life, you don't have pro-bowlers (which in the GLB world would be well-built high 20's and low 30's players) playing against pee wee teams (lvl 1's).


In the level-30-versus-level-1 scenario, you'd realistically expect a huge number of sacks, and there's only so much anyone can do about this situation emerging.

The larger concern is with situations like the one described earlier, in which a level 28 DE goes up against a level 26 RT and level 25 QB and comes away with 5 sacks in a half. Perhaps that can be attributed simply to poor builds and tactics, but I'm skeptical ~ and while I don't know how prevalent this is, it seems as if it's something to keep an eye on in terms of the in-game models.

I'll try to avoid being "fixated" on end-result stats, but when the simulation comprises lots of dots moving around a screen (and I'm not complaining about that!), it's a bit difficult to figure out how else to judge the dynamics of the game. What alternatives would you suggest?


Considering the changes to blocking this season already, I wouldn't suggest any further changes other than what is already contemplated. Speed DE's are already at a severe disadvantage due to the changes in run-blocking. Hell, I've seen DE's with over 70 STR get plowed over in the running game. I can only imagine what those poor bastards with 45 STR are dealing with.

If I see a bunch DE's running around the OT to get to the qb, guess what I'm going to do when I play that team? That's right, I'm going 85% run and plowing my way through to victory. And that's exactly what a NFL coach would do if he saw a bunch of glorified 225 lb OLB's playing DE in a 4-3.
 
cptafw163
offline
Link
 
Yeah, the DEs are running around the tackles, ebcause the tackles aren't fast enough to make a pocket. We are experiencing that. So it looks like OTs need to train speed and put FPs into speed.

We are gonna see a lot less long passes and more running
--Dan
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by slipknottin

The reason that play that Bort linked to was successful was not because of the DE. Its easy for a DE to run a loop around the OT, just about any DE in the league can do that. The reason that play was successful was the push that the DT got. He shoved the center right back into the QB, preventing the Qb from stepping up. Had the Qb been able to step up into the pocket the OT could reach the DE in time and push him wide.


I think the Center falling back like that is part of the play...I watch our center with over 85 STR and 5 points in the appropriate SAs do exactly the same thing many times today...and I am fairly certain the NT was nothing terribly special in that game.
 
cptafw163
offline
Link
 
I really thing that the main problem is the "Pocket route" that the OTs take. They are way too close to the guard. The OTs need to drop back at a wider angle.

Here is our OT:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=90509&pbp_id=1035968
1 play later
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=90509&pbp_id=1036030

It doesn't help when the QB is fast, either. That means he drops out of the pocket faster.

I think the fault is not in the edge rushing, lets be fair. But the route of the OTs needs to be wider. In pass blocking the first step the OT takes is back. he isn't supposed to rush forward and meet the DE.

Does that sound about right?

--Dan
 
cptafw163
offline
Link
 
The speed thing needs to change. I don;t care if you are 1 300 lb OT, it should not take you 4 seconds to move back 7 yards.

I think when players are being created, they should start with a minimum in less important attributes. Now we are seeing that OTs need to match speed with the DEs. That doesn't need to happen in real football.

But, it seemed like that didn't happen the whole game, just 2 sacks in the first 3 offensive plays. So i guess the players "learn" as the game goes on.

--Dan
 
vikingspwr
offline
Link
 
My LDE went from getting 2 to 3 hurries a game and FFum's to just a few tackles against a ROT that was 5 levels lower than my DE and my DE has Strength and Agility pretty high with some speed. WTF!
 
seven7
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by vikingspwr
My LDE went from getting 2 to 3 hurries a game and FFum's to just a few tackles against a ROT that was 5 levels lower than my DE and my DE has Strength and Agility pretty high with some speed. WTF!


the OT put skills in speed/agility/strength , they no longer need blocking just speed and agility to keep up with the de's =) , problem fixed
 
vikingspwr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by seven7
Originally posted by vikingspwr

My LDE went from getting 2 to 3 hurries a game and FFum's to just a few tackles against a ROT that was 5 levels lower than my DE and my DE has Strength and Agility pretty high with some speed. WTF!


the OT put skills in speed/agility/strength , they no longer need blocking just speed and agility to keep up with the de's =) , problem fixed


lol yeah well then that OT would be pancaked, hope this gets fixed by the next game, coz i'm tired of watching my DE go right to the guard.
 
Jason Cash
offline
Link
 
..it's being fixed. Bort put in some new pass rushing things. Your DE shouldnt be going straight through the tackle...depending on which pass rush setting you have your DE playing at
 
vikingspwr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jason Cash
..it's being fixed. Bort put in some new pass rushing things. Your DE shouldnt be going straight through the tackle...depending on which pass rush setting you have your DE playing at


He is set to Evasive, so he should go around not to the right and into the guard and ROT
 
AnTiNiNjA
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cptafw163
The speed thing needs to change. I don;t care if you are 1 300 lb OT, it should not take you 4 seconds to move back 7 yards.

I think when players are being created, they should start with a minimum in less important attributes. Now we are seeing that OTs need to match speed with the DEs. That doesn't need to happen in real football.

But, it seemed like that didn't happen the whole game, just 2 sacks in the first 3 offensive plays. So i guess the players "learn" as the game goes on.

--Dan


Speed doesn't matter one bit when you are this close in anymore. its all Agility, which can be considered reaction time even.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.