User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > ATTN: Tying Flex Points to Contracts as an Incentive or Condition
Page:
 
Serenity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by awesome
Originally posted by Serenity


And don't forget that it's best to base your accusations of complete and utter bullshit.


Yes, utter bullshit. Let's review.

1. There are two groups of players: Mods/alphas and everyone else

2. Most mods/alphas have large interests in USA Pro teams as many are owners and/or players in this league

3. Most USA Pro teams have very high level players

4. In order to maintain high level players, one must boost every season

5. Boosting every season requires real-life money

6. Not everyone wants to continue to spend real-life money to boost every season

7. The owners of USA Pro teams want to win and continue to compete in the USA Pro league

8. In order to do this, they will need to keep the highest level players

9. One option that they have is to send FP "gifts" to these players so they can continue to boost and help the team.

10. The supply of higher level players is small

11. A new owner with aspirations of competing in USA Pro will need higher level players to compete

12. This owner will not be able to acquire players on par with the current USA Pro teams from the existing FA market until the current USA Pro players start to decline as they are still boosting

13. One option that this new owner had previously was to offer FP contracts to higher level players with the hope that they would sign with her and provide the new owner with the ability to compete in USA Pro

14. If this is allowed, there is a higher chance that current USA Pro players will be wooed away from their current teams

15. The majority of the GLB community does not want this game to become "whoever spends the most money wins"

16. In response, the mods drafted a rule prohibiting FP contracts

17. This rule does not prevent FP gifts to current players

18. We are left with a situation where current USA Pro owners can spend as much money as they want to keep their current higher level players, effectively closing the market for the rest of the community for these caliber players for at least 7 more seasons.

Thus, as it stands now, the current owners of teams with the highest level players will be able to keep them as long as they want to continue to spend money on them. New owners will be banned for trying to offer the same exact "gifts" to these players so they can be spread around to other teams. The rule was drafted by those with the greatest interest in keeping this retention ability permissible.

Therefore, instead of drafting a rule that prevents "owners who are willing to spend the most money from gaining an advantage," the established owners (mods) drafted a rule that prevents "new owners who are willing spend the most money from gaining an advantage."

As long as you were here early enough to sign players and have kept them until now, you are free to buy them as many FP as you want. Unfortunately, if you aren't in USA Pro, but would like to be, you will have to wait 7 seasons before you will be able to get comparable players.


Considering how most of his accusations were on how certain players have "inside information", then yes it was all bullshit.

as to your arguments

1. Only in that people make it out to be that way. In reality there is very little difference especially between the alpha testers.

2. And plenty of mods/alphas have interest in other leagues as well, not just USA Pro

3. Most pro teams have very high levels

4. Obviously

5/6. True depending on how many players you own.

7. Well who wouldn't?

8. Or the best built, not just highest level

9. Or get out there and recruit.

10. There are 904 pages of players at level 22+. You can compete with some level 22's on your team

11. If you work your way up you will gain XP faster then players in the pros

12/13/14. Players do leave USA Pro even without asking for flex points

15/16/17. So it's written

18. I doubt it's as common as you seem to want to make it out to be. A large reason the Pro teams stay together is because we know one another and we like each other.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by jrry32



That's actually pretty sad then...my RB on Caps team is averaging 5.7 yards and we run up the middle.(and to the outside of course)


If that is true, then I'm guessing that you play against alot of inferior teams.

Across Canada Pro, teams are averaging about 1-2 yards per carry against other playoff teams. Ask Serenity. Only by getting 5-6 yards per carry aganst bad/gutted teams does the ypc even get to the low to mid 3 range.



Yep. Take out the yards against the teams that you beat by 45+ points (your two 300 yard games were against teams you beat by 100+)... then you are down to less than 3 yards per carry. Don't worry. You won't get 3 yards per carry in the playoffs and wonder why...lol.
 
Serenity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by jrry32



That's actually pretty sad then...my RB on Caps team is averaging 5.7 yards and we run up the middle.(and to the outside of course)


If that is true, then I'm guessing that you play against alot of inferior teams.

Across Canada Pro, teams are averaging about 1-2 yards per carry against other playoff teams. Ask Serenity. Only by getting 5-6 yards per carry aganst bad/gutted teams does the ypc even get to the low to mid 3 range.


I dunno. If you look at the Dong/CCC game the ypc for the HB's was 3.1, 3.7, 3.7, 4.6
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Serenity


18. I doubt it's as common as you seem to want to make it out to be. A large reason the Pro teams stay together is because we know one another and we like each other.


Nevertheless, you have a distinct advantage over everyone else because you can offer your players FP to boost and stay on the team. No one else can do this. You were the ones who drafted this rule.

Let's cut through the crap: you are essentially admitting that this rule was created to reinforce the already large advantage that mods/alphas have in competing in USA Pro. Since that is the case, I doubt very many people are going to want to continue to spend money on this site if they have any aspirations of competing in, and winning USA Pro since they will not be able to match the levels of the players who are already in there for 7 more seasons.

7 seasons > 10 months real time.

My point has been highlighted and confirmed by your statement: there was an obvious conflict of interest in the drafting of this rule. It should be either all fp transactions are banned or none of them. By allowing fp "gifts" you are ensuring that NO ONE will be able to compete with you for almost an entire YEAR.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Serenity
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

Originally posted by jrry32




That's actually pretty sad then...my RB on Caps team is averaging 5.7 yards and we run up the middle.(and to the outside of course)


If that is true, then I'm guessing that you play against alot of inferior teams.

Across Canada Pro, teams are averaging about 1-2 yards per carry against other playoff teams. Ask Serenity. Only by getting 5-6 yards per carry aganst bad/gutted teams does the ypc even get to the low to mid 3 range.


I dunno. If you look at the Dong/CCC game the ypc for the HB's was 3.1, 3.7, 3.7, 4.6


We'll see I guess. I should be preparing for Dong instead of wasting time here.
 
Serenity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by awesome
Originally posted by Serenity



18. I doubt it's as common as you seem to want to make it out to be. A large reason the Pro teams stay together is because we know one another and we like each other.


Nevertheless, you have a distinct advantage over everyone else because you can offer your players FP to boost and stay on the team. No one else can do this. You were the ones who drafted this rule.

Let's cut through the crap: you are essentially admitting that this rule was created to reinforce the already large advantage that mods/alphas have in competing in USA Pro. Since that is the case, I doubt very many people are going to want to continue to spend money on this site if they have any aspirations of competing in, and winning USA Pro since they will not be able to match the levels of the players who are already in there for 7 more seasons.

7 seasons > 10 months real time.

My point has been highlighted and confirmed by your statement: there was an obvious conflict of interest in the drafting of this rule. It should be either all fp transactions are banned or none of them. By allowing fp "gifts" you are ensuring that NO ONE will be able to compete with you for almost an entire YEAR.


No it wasn't. Don't try and make it that I was saying something that I wasn't saying at all.

If there are people in USA Pro the chances of them being the non alpha testers/mods is probably higher then the chances of them being the alpha testers and mods.
Last edited Jul 14, 2008 06:43:25
 
Link
 
Originally posted by awesome
Originally posted by Serenity



18. I doubt it's as common as you seem to want to make it out to be. A large reason the Pro teams stay together is because we know one another and we like each other.


Nevertheless, you have a distinct advantage over everyone else because you can offer your players FP to boost and stay on the team. No one else can do this. You were the ones who drafted this rule.

Let's cut through the crap: you are essentially admitting that this rule was created to reinforce the already large advantage that mods/alphas have in competing in USA Pro. Since that is the case, I doubt very many people are going to want to continue to spend money on this site if they have any aspirations of competing in, and winning USA Pro since they will not be able to match the levels of the players who are already in there for 7 more seasons.

7 seasons > 10 months real time.

My point has been highlighted and confirmed by your statement: there was an obvious conflict of interest in the drafting of this rule. It should be either all fp transactions are banned or none of them. By allowing fp "gifts" you are ensuring that NO ONE will be able to compete with you for almost an entire YEAR.


your solution wouldn't solve the problem.

2 teams would just merge into one team full of boosters.

The needed solution might be to give all the earliest testers and players a stretch of time of about 8-10 games where they don't get any XP's or training. Once they get to the point where there is a large supply of players near the top, demand for such players will go down and no one will be trying/needing to buy them with flex points.

Then you could let owners buy FP's for their players and no one would care.
Last edited Jul 14, 2008 06:46:36
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
There are 19 level 22+ players that are active free agents. Only 3 are level 24.

How many teams are going after every free agent over level 18 with a decent build?

How many teams are going after every free agent over level 20 with a decent build?


If you adjust from 22 to 24, there are only 247 pages of active players in the entire game.

Adjust it to 26 and there are only 16 2/3 pages or 417 players. That is barely enough for 10 minimum rosters.

The easiest league to recruit to is USA Pro. Then comes USA AAA leagues and the other Pro leagues, but still you see a lot more threads with players saying they want to play in USA Pro league than any other conference.

Players over level 22 that name 1 league they most want to play in, name USA pro more than all others combined.

USA Pro owners have a vested interest in banning any activity that would help other owners compete against them for these players.

 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by jrry32



That's actually pretty sad then...my RB on Caps team is averaging 5.7 yards and we run up the middle.(and to the outside of course)


If that is true, then I'm guessing that you play against alot of inferior teams.

Across Canada Pro, teams are averaging about 1-2 yards per carry against other playoff teams. Ask Serenity. Only by getting 5-6 yards per carry aganst bad/gutted teams does the ypc even get to the low to mid 3 range.


Hmm...not quite...how about this, his first 2 carries of the game against one of the best teams in the league:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=10273830
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=10275307
 
Cybershot
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by awesome
Originally posted by Serenity



18. I doubt it's as common as you seem to want to make it out to be. A large reason the Pro teams stay together is because we know one another and we like each other.


Nevertheless, you have a distinct advantage over everyone else because you can offer your players FP to boost and stay on the team. No one else can do this. You were the ones who drafted this rule.

Let's cut through the crap: you are essentially admitting that this rule was created to reinforce the already large advantage that mods/alphas have in competing in USA Pro. Since that is the case, I doubt very many people are going to want to continue to spend money on this site if they have any aspirations of competing in, and winning USA Pro since they will not be able to match the levels of the players who are already in there for 7 more seasons.

7 seasons > 10 months real time.

My point has been highlighted and confirmed by your statement: there was an obvious conflict of interest in the drafting of this rule. It should be either all fp transactions are banned or none of them. By allowing fp "gifts" you are ensuring that NO ONE will be able to compete with you for almost an entire YEAR.



I'm neither an Alpha nor a US Pro player, and I can assuredly tell you that this had absolutely NOTHING to do with some kind of "Alpha conspiracy to dominate".

The conversation (in the Mod forum) was entirely based around fair and equal play for all. We understand that players of all kinds play GLB: old, young, rich and poor, and everything in between. Allowing FP based contracts would cripple the market for a large percentage of players.

Admittedly I haven't read this entire thread, so I don't know if any Mods stuck their foot in their mouths and misled you, but there is no conspiracy of any kind. This rule was meant to help the average user, not hurt him.
Last edited Jul 14, 2008 06:51:03
 
Serenity
offline
Link
 
Oh and feel free to go through the USA Pro teams owned by Alpha testers/mods
Other then the Pushovers it's obvious that they all have players who have missed boosts, so you can't really justify that they're paying off people to stay on the team.
And the Pushovers had to replace guys who didn't boost so it's not like Jed is buying anyone flex points either.
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cybershot


Admittedly I haven't read this entire thread, so I don't know if any Mods stuck their foot in their mouths and misled you, but there is no conspiracy of any kind. This rule was meant to help the average user, not hurt him.


Most of us agree that this rule should be implemented, but only if you also ban giving fp to players already on a team as well. The argument we are making is all or none. I don't give fp contracts, so I will benefit from this rule. However, I see how ludicrous it is to make a rule saying you can't give out fp contracts, but you can pay for fp for someone already on your team.

I am also opposed to several other practices taking place in this game which are turning this into a "he with the most cash wins". One such practice is the rent a player tactic that many owners are starting to resort to.

 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

Originally posted by jrry32




That's actually pretty sad then...my RB on Caps team is averaging 5.7 yards and we run up the middle.(and to the outside of course)


If that is true, then I'm guessing that you play against alot of inferior teams.

Across Canada Pro, teams are averaging about 1-2 yards per carry against other playoff teams. Ask Serenity. Only by getting 5-6 yards per carry aganst bad/gutted teams does the ypc even get to the low to mid 3 range.


Hmm...not quite...how about this, his first 2 carries of the game against one of the best teams in the league:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=10273830
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=10275307


He said averaging against good teams. How has that RB done overall against good competition?
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cybershot

This rule was meant to help the average user, not hurt him.


Then why are FP "gifts" still allowed? Every single mod has dodged this question. This is the WHOLE REASON that we are pissed off about this. If the rule was a complete ban on all FP transactions, fine. But it isn't. It has loopholes the size of Texas which serve to benefit the established highest level teams.
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
No, I take that back. One moderator confronted this question head on.

Originally posted by LJ
stop trying to find loopholes.


Translation: Oh crap, they're gonna figure us out.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.