User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Test Server Discussion > Potential Changes (things we're testing)
Page:
 
ChicagoTRS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tjsexkitten82
Well the numbers are now more in line, but you're right the variability needs to be largely based on the returner ability and the ST blocking ability. Then again, it's a little early to say they're not dontcha think?


I do not think it is too early...watched around 40 kickoff returns from the WL teams I coordinate today. Seeing a bunch of the same...5-10 coverage players are going unblocked or immediately defeating the block and getting to the BW/returner at the same time.

I am really not sure why people think returns were overpowered last season?...neither of my main WL teams (Korb & Indy) gave up a return TD last season. There was some skill and strategy to setting up coverage/blocking last season and if you had good STOPs it was entirely possible to shutdown an opponents return game.

I think the change made this season to not vary kickoffs as much would have been enough to slow down the return game. Most kickoff return TDs last season were from kickoffs to the sideline or very short kickoffs.

This also nerfs STOPs since now they are going to competing with more defenders to make tackles. My first thought is STOPs are probably not worth taking a roster spot if STs is going to be like this and add to the fact FFs are down.

Not needed garbage change imo...but I guess not my game and it seems the powers that be had it in their mind that STs needed to be nerfed further. Remove the skill from the game...remove the affects of good builds...a lot of people want to be able to ignore STs...they got their wish.
Edited by ChicagoTRS on Feb 16, 2012 14:16:34
 
rawss
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ninja turtles
Originally posted by rawss

Those of that care about STs care about coverage and returns.

With what has been done to the Kick Return game, turning it into look out blocks and kill the guy with the ball, you've taken away half of our game.

good news is that if you have a KR at the top of the HOF, no one will ever catch him

#31 is not high enough.
 
rawss
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ChicagoTRS
Originally posted by tjsexkitten82

Well the numbers are now more in line, but you're right the variability needs to be largely based on the returner ability and the ST blocking ability. Then again, it's a little early to say they're not dontcha think?

I do not think it is too early...watched around 40 kickoff returns from the WL teams I coordinate today. Seeing a bunch of the same...5-10 coverage players are going unblocked or immediately defeating the block and getting to the BW/returner at the same time.

I am really not sure why people think returns were overpowered last season?...neither of my main WL teams (Korb & Indy) gave up a return TD last season. There was some skill and strategy to setting up coverage/blocking last season and if you had good STOPs it was entirely possible to shutdown an opponents return game.

I think the change made this season to not vary kickoffs as much would have been enough to slow down the return game. Most kickoff returns last season were from kickoffs to the sideline or very short kickoffs.

This also nerfs STOPs since now they are going to competing with more defenders to make tackles. My first thought is STOPs are probably not worth taking a roster spot if STs is going to be like this and add to the fact FFs are down.

Not needed garbage change imo...but I guess not my game and it seems the powers that be had it in their mind that STs needed to be nerfed further. Remove the skill from the game...remove the affects of good builds...a lot of people want to be able to ignore STs...they got their wish.

+1
 
millertime31
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ChicagoTRS
Originally posted by tjsexkitten82

Well the numbers are now more in line, but you're right the variability needs to be largely based on the returner ability and the ST blocking ability. Then again, it's a little early to say they're not dontcha think?


I do not think it is too early...watched around 40 kickoff returns from the WL teams I coordinate today. Seeing a bunch of the same...5-10 coverage players are going unblocked or immediately defeating the block and getting to the BW/returner at the same time.

I am really not sure why people think returns were overpowered last season?...neither of my main WL teams (Korb & Indy) gave up a return TD last season. There was some skill and strategy to setting up coverage/blocking last season and if you had good STOPs it was entirely possible to shutdown an opponents return game.

I think the change made this season to not vary kickoffs as much would have been enough to slow down the return game. Most kickoff return TDs last season were from kickoffs to the sideline or very short kickoffs.

This also nerfs STOPs since now they are going to competing with more defenders to make tackles. My first thought is STOPs are probably not worth taking a roster spot if STs is going to be like this and add to the fact FFs are down.

Not needed garbage change imo...but I guess not my game and it seems the powers that be had it in their mind that STs needed to be nerfed further. Remove the skill from the game...remove the affects of good builds...a lot of people want to be able to ignore STs...they got their wish.


+1

this totally reflects my thoughts
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ChicagoTRS
I do not think it is too early...watched around 40 kickoff returns from the WL teams I coordinate today. Seeing a bunch of the same...5-10 coverage players are going unblocked or immediately defeating the block and getting to the BW/returner at the same time.

I am really not sure why people think returns were overpowered last season?...neither of my main WL teams (Korb & Indy) gave up a return TD last season. There was some skill and strategy to setting up coverage/blocking last season and if you had good STOPs it was entirely possible to shutdown an opponents return game.

I think the change made this season to not vary kickoffs as much would have been enough to slow down the return game. Most kickoff return TDs last season were from kickoffs to the sideline or very short kickoffs.

This also nerfs STOPs since now they are going to competing with more defenders to make tackles. My first thought is STOPs are probably not worth taking a roster spot if STs is going to be like this and add to the fact FFs are down.

Not needed garbage change imo...but I guess not my game and it seems the powers that be had it in their mind that STs needed to be nerfed further. Remove the skill from the game...remove the affects of good builds...a lot of people want to be able to ignore STs...they got their wish.


This sounds exactly like me talking about DEs in the infancy of GLB. Solid, non-exploity speed rusher DEs were getting 70 sacks a season, but it was because people were building pancake machine tackles with no agility or speed. They could be shut down by well built Ts, but nobody wanted to build Ts properly so Bort went for crowd pleasing and nerfed DEs and speed rushers were never the same (until today, perhaps). You make a lot of good points and obviously know more about this than I do, so I will defer.

I will say, though, that blocking SHOULD be more important than it has been for a long time, so increasing its importance is a good thing, and 300 lb STOPS shouldn't be blocking 200lb speed gunners regularly. Realism does require a decently athletic STOP.
Edited by tjsexkitten82 on Feb 16, 2012 14:23:30
 
merenoise
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Disastermaster
Originally posted by Catch22

We want it to be realistic, not ridiculous. So to answer your question as bluntly as I can. Yes.


so that means that all STOPS and returner are worthless right now and can be retired?


Only until they knee jerk back the other way in a couple of seasons tbh.

Originally posted by ChicagoTRS
This also nerfs STOPs since now they are going to competing with more defenders to make tackles. My first thought is STOPs are probably not worth taking a roster spot if STs is going to be like this and add to the fact FFs are down.


Pretty accurate, I would expect WL teams to make that adjustment next season and drop most of those guys from their rosters in exchange for dots that will account for more than 2-3 TDs a season or 5-6 fumbles a season. Special teams were a legitimate third phase of the game in the past few seasons where an elite group could be game changers, looks like that is a dynamic they want to remove.

STOPs were a necessity in the last few seasons but if this change sticks I wouldn't expect them to really be any kind of commodity. Also probably means that KR/PRs are going to be in the same boat as kickers in terms of MVP equipment. What WL team in their right mind would want to lose an endorsement that could be used on offense or defense where points are actually being scored to a KR/PR that might score 2-3 times a season if he is elite?

Ultimately teams will adjust to the new special teams paradigm, if it stays this way most likely by just dropping the dead weight STOPs and not placing any emphasis on bringing in elite returners since even they won't be scoring enough points to actually be important to their teams.
 
rawss
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by merenoise
Originally posted by Disastermaster

Originally posted by Catch22

We want it to be realistic, not ridiculous. So to answer your question as bluntly as I can. Yes.

so that means that all STOPS and returner are worthless right now and can be retired?

Only until they knee jerk back the other way in a couple of seasons tbh.

I'm all for the knee jerk back the other way to happen at rollover tonight.
 
Longhornfan1024
HOOD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by merenoise
Pretty accurate, I would expect WL teams to make that adjustment next season and drop most of those guys from their rosters in exchange for dots that will account for more than 2-3 TDs a season or 5-6 fumbles a season. Special teams were a legitimate third phase of the game in the past few seasons where an elite group could be game changers, looks like that is a dynamic they want to remove.

STOPs were a necessity in the last few seasons but if this change sticks I wouldn't expect them to really be any kind of commodity. Also probably means that KR/PRs are going to be in the same boat as kickers in terms of MVP equipment. What WL team in their right mind would want to lose an endorsement that could be used on offense or defense where points are actually being scored to a KR/PR that might score 2-3 times a season if he is elite?

Ultimately teams will adjust to the new special teams paradigm, if it stays this way most likely by just dropping the dead weight STOPs and not placing any emphasis on bringing in elite returners since even they won't be scoring enough points to actually be important to their teams.


And this basically means I have to retire almost all of my younger dots. ggGLB. Fix something that isn't broke. Or maybe it's break something that is already fixed.
 
merenoise
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Longhornfan1024
Originally posted by merenoise

Pretty accurate, I would expect WL teams to make that adjustment next season and drop most of those guys from their rosters in exchange for dots that will account for more than 2-3 TDs a season or 5-6 fumbles a season. Special teams were a legitimate third phase of the game in the past few seasons where an elite group could be game changers, looks like that is a dynamic they want to remove.

STOPs were a necessity in the last few seasons but if this change sticks I wouldn't expect them to really be any kind of commodity. Also probably means that KR/PRs are going to be in the same boat as kickers in terms of MVP equipment. What WL team in their right mind would want to lose an endorsement that could be used on offense or defense where points are actually being scored to a KR/PR that might score 2-3 times a season if he is elite?

Ultimately teams will adjust to the new special teams paradigm, if it stays this way most likely by just dropping the dead weight STOPs and not placing any emphasis on bringing in elite returners since even they won't be scoring enough points to actually be important to their teams.


And this basically means I have to retire almost all of my younger dots. ggGLB. Fix something that isn't broke. Or maybe it's break something that is already fixed.


tbh Special teams needed to be tweaked a bit, the fumbles were a little too over the top at the WL and Pro level and returns were a little too frequent. Sadly, rather than dial it back a little bit they went and made special teams nearly irrelevant.
 
Longhornfan1024
HOOD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by merenoise
tbh Special teams needed to be tweaked a bit, the fumbles were a little too over the top at the WL and Pro level and returns were a little too frequent. Sadly, rather than dial it back a little bit they went and made special teams nearly irrelevant.


Look back at my previous post comparing WL returners to NFL returners. The yardage averages for returners in WL were actually lower than those from the NFL. The main reason TDs are higher in WL than the NFL is because there are just so many more return opportunities in GLB. When just looking at kick returns, there were approximately 500 more kick return opportunities in WL last season than in the NFL. Add in punts, and there's a good reason you see more return TDs.
 
CaptainUniverse
Moderator
offline
Link
 
I can't believe they've decided to make STs almost worthless. There's a difference between balancing out something and killing it completely.

2-3 return TDs for an elite returner only? That's incredibly laughable.
 
dagwood13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Longhornfan1024
Look back at my previous post comparing WL returners to NFL returners. The yardage averages for returners in WL were actually lower than those from the NFL. The main reason TDs are higher in WL than the NFL is because there are just so many more return opportunities in GLB. When just looking at kick returns, there were approximately 500 more kick return opportunities in WL last season than in the NFL. Add in punts, and there's a good reason you see more return TDs.


I did not see where you posted this, but can you do a comparison of the TD per return?
 
Monty Burns
Crusty Old Fart
offline
Link
 
The vast majority of S Teams return TD's that I saw last season were either against out leveled opponents or poor S Teams depth chart setups, not against teams who paid close attention to S Teams....if this change goes thru, like has been already pointed out by others, might as well do away with STOPs on your roster and add depth to other positions....
 
ChicagoTRS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Monty Burns
The vast majority of S Teams return TD's that I saw last season were either against out leveled opponents or poor S Teams depth chart setups, not against teams who paid close attention to S Teams....if this change goes thru, like has been already pointed out by others, might as well do away with STOPs on your roster and add depth to other positions....


imo STs were already pretty balanced last season and if you paid attention to your STs at all it was not much of a problem to shutdown an opponents return game.

If there were too many kickoff TDs last season. The simple fix was do away with the far sideline kickoffs and the very short kickoffs...the highest percentage of TDs happened in those two scenarios...and they were the hardest to defend.

Just do not understand why GLB is choosing to do away with the STs portion of the game?

 
Link
 
just for clarifications sake when you say "New OL VA's (not usable on ST's, TE's, FB's and HB's can use):" does this mean a TE FB or HB won't see the effects of these VA's if they are on the field during ST or they won't see the effects of these VA's if they have a ST archetype?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.