User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Announcements > Defense AI Interface
Page:
 
Faux Bear
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rudog
Originally posted by ahnonamis

Originally posted by thunderdoozer


Originally posted by scarletmbb



Originally posted by britdevine316




Can I choose which LB plays in Nickel and Dime or will it always default to MLB. I want my LOLB to play.

I dont see this option anywhere?


There is no option for that.


This is one of the biggest disappointments for me.


Agreed


Double agreed. LOLB usually lines over the TE in 4-3... so it's nice to have a more coverage based guy there (or at least the #2 LB there)... the same type I would want in a nickel.


what will it currently default to then? MLB?
 
demonicangel
offline
Link
 
haha.
 
jprietman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by demonicangel
Originally posted by jprietman

Originally posted by Sinyen


Maybe there could be some way to save presets to an external file? This would allow Coordinators to take their designs/playbooks with them if they ever decide to leave. The downside being that this would allow for possibility of playbook theft, but really not any different then taking screenshots of the playbook, it would just make it less work to steal. hmm


I think there already is a way to load and save your presets... But you also bring up "Playbook theft" which does seem like it would be a big concern. I wouldn't want to spend countless hours building up my playbook, only for it to be stolen by some untrustworthy GM if I decide to use it with another team. There should be a way to password-protect the file you save.

I have a feeling that playbook theft is going to be a big problem in this game. There's a lot of work that is gonna be going into these tactics.

Maybe only the defensive coordinator should be allowed to view the Defense AI page. An owner should have to make himself a GM and Defensive Coordinator if he wants to view the page.


I agree about theft being a super problem. Im not the Owner of the team, but Im a Gm.
We have a Dc. I trust them all, but not everyone has the same trust levels as we got. After 5 hours of playing with the tactics, Ive gotten about 300 diffrent plays and senerios, and Im not even half way done yet, with what I am wanting to do. Someone steals my plays, and Im going to be pissed off.


I wonder if Bort has something in mind. If my playbook gets stolen, I'm going to whine and complain a LOT.
 
DiMo28
offline
Link
 
This is cool and all, but won't it put the offense at a serious disadvantage if it is released before the advanced offense tactics?
 
Concinnity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jprietman
Originally posted by demonicangel

Originally posted by jprietman


Originally posted by Sinyen



Maybe there could be some way to save presets to an external file? This would allow Coordinators to take their designs/playbooks with them if they ever decide to leave. The downside being that this would allow for possibility of playbook theft, but really not any different then taking screenshots of the playbook, it would just make it less work to steal. hmm


I think there already is a way to load and save your presets... But you also bring up "Playbook theft" which does seem like it would be a big concern. I wouldn't want to spend countless hours building up my playbook, only for it to be stolen by some untrustworthy GM if I decide to use it with another team. There should be a way to password-protect the file you save.

I have a feeling that playbook theft is going to be a big problem in this game. There's a lot of work that is gonna be going into these tactics.

Maybe only the defensive coordinator should be allowed to view the Defense AI page. An owner should have to make himself a GM and Defensive Coordinator if he wants to view the page.


I agree about theft being a super problem. Im not the Owner of the team, but Im a Gm.
We have a Dc. I trust them all, but not everyone has the same trust levels as we got. After 5 hours of playing with the tactics, Ive gotten about 300 diffrent plays and senerios, and Im not even half way done yet, with what I am wanting to do. Someone steals my plays, and Im going to be pissed off.


I wonder if Bort has something in mind. If my playbook gets stolen, I'm going to whine and complain a LOT.



Yea I'd be pretty pissed if I was brought in to DC then I get treated unfairly and my playbook gets stolen. Maybe owners shouldn't get access to it unless they were the DC.
 
easycheez
offline
Link
 
As a high school defensive coordinator in real-life I am stoked about this update. Good work, Bort! I was up for about 6 hours last night breaking down the replays like I break down game film in the fall.
 
Charger
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by turnit643

Bort,

If we'd like to use a 3-4 base as our base D (for example), but in certain situations we'd prefer to use a plain 4-3 without adding CB's, can we do that? In the FORMATION drop down in the OUTPUT section I don't see the option - only Base and N, D, Q options.

Thanks.


Hm, no, that's not an option at the moment. Could probably be added, though.




That sounds like it would be a good addition.
 
kaygdanimal
offline
Link
 
Man am I ever stoked about this "soon-to-be" addition.

As for playbooks, I actually find myself agreeing that it would be great if we could save our configurations as external files so if we were to be hired as a Coordinator elsewhere, we could bring along our own configurations/playbook.

In the real world, coaches share play ideas but they guard their playbook with their life. I do the same thing even though I only coach Pee Wee right now. However, sharing plays is nothing new; it's just that I would like it if we had the ability, as Owner and/or Coordinator to save our configurations/playbooks so that we can take them whereever we end up coaching.
 
Substance911
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Just uploaded the latest version of the Defense AI Builder interface for everyone (team owners and DC's) to play with.

Building and testing the ridiculous number of plays required for all the possible settings is turning out to be the major time sink on this - there are a lot of combinations that can come up! I keep adding options as I go, too, making more plays I have to put in.

You should be able to play with the interface for now, and I'll make an announcement when it's actually ready to go for sims. It's be the sort of thing you can turn on and off to make the play calling algorithm call a different code path dependent on your settings (new vs old).

BTW, the offense AI builder will be similar: based on inputs/outputs so you build up your custom "AI."


Edit by scarletmbb:

I've posted up screenshots over here:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=408231

I'm currently working on a guide on how to use it because some people are overwhelmed right now. I'm aiming to post it later tonight.


Checked it out and......*Brain Explodes*

 
Charger
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by Draven


Bort- in the 3-4 will both ILBers get the benefit of the Defense General Special Ability?


Sort of...only one at a time and it's random which one.


This seems a little weak/unfair....should it not pick the one with the larger bonus, or perhaps just specify side? Let teams have a defensive captain! No 50/50 stuff for that particular ability, please...


I agree with you on that.
 
Charger
offline
Link
 
Good stuff Bort!
This is truly a job well done. Bless your little Red Vest!
 
Sinyen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Concinnity
Originally posted by jprietman

Originally posted by demonicangel


Originally posted by jprietman



Originally posted by Sinyen




Maybe there could be some way to save presets to an external file? This would allow Coordinators to take their designs/playbooks with them if they ever decide to leave. The downside being that this would allow for possibility of playbook theft, but really not any different then taking screenshots of the playbook, it would just make it less work to steal. hmm


I think there already is a way to load and save your presets... But you also bring up "Playbook theft" which does seem like it would be a big concern. I wouldn't want to spend countless hours building up my playbook, only for it to be stolen by some untrustworthy GM if I decide to use it with another team. There should be a way to password-protect the file you save.

I have a feeling that playbook theft is going to be a big problem in this game. There's a lot of work that is gonna be going into these tactics.

Maybe only the defensive coordinator should be allowed to view the Defense AI page. An owner should have to make himself a GM and Defensive Coordinator if he wants to view the page.


I agree about theft being a super problem. Im not the Owner of the team, but Im a Gm.
We have a Dc. I trust them all, but not everyone has the same trust levels as we got. After 5 hours of playing with the tactics, Ive gotten about 300 diffrent plays and senerios, and Im not even half way done yet, with what I am wanting to do. Someone steals my plays, and Im going to be pissed off.


I wonder if Bort has something in mind. If my playbook gets stolen, I'm going to whine and complain a LOT.



Yea I'd be pretty pissed if I was brought in to DC then I get treated unfairly and my playbook gets stolen. Maybe owners shouldn't get access to it unless they were the DC.


Well, but wouldn't you also be pissed if you spent all those countless hours making your playbook and then some disgruntled DC went through and deleted them all?? A way to save them would also allow you to back them up. I like the idea of password protecting the backup.
 
Hubedi
offline
Link
 
I agree with you guys, there should be a way to save those selected plays with you, so you'd be able to cary them with you if you go to another team.

By tghe Way, I loved it, Tomorrow I'll spend like 6 hours trying to build some plays to my teams ^^

Also, I'll improve as a DC and will be better-suited to make a try-out for a brazilian team soon
 
demonicangel
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Hubedi
I agree with you guys, there should be a way to save those selected plays with you, so you'd be able to cary them with you if you go to another team.

By tghe Way, I loved it, Tomorrow I'll spend like 6 hours trying to build some plays to my teams ^^

Also, I'll improve as a DC and will be better-suited to make a try-out for a brazilian team soon


lol 6 hours wont get your much other than a headache. So many formations and situations. Ahhhhhhh Its crazy.

But as someone mentioned earlier, saving to a external file would be great. For instance im not the owner, but a gm if we ever have a problem and I move on, I wont lose my plays, but im not a computer guru, but if you have to upload files into the server so you can move your playbook, wont that take a chance of some jackoff uploading a virus into the server?
Last edited Jun 17, 2008 16:43:31
 
Themuffinman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Concinnity
Originally posted by jprietman

Originally posted by demonicangel


Originally posted by jprietman



Originally posted by Sinyen




Maybe there could be some way to save presets to an external file? This would allow Coordinators to take their designs/playbooks with them if they ever decide to leave. The downside being that this would allow for possibility of playbook theft, but really not any different then taking screenshots of the playbook, it would just make it less work to steal. hmm


I think there already is a way to load and save your presets... But you also bring up "Playbook theft" which does seem like it would be a big concern. I wouldn't want to spend countless hours building up my playbook, only for it to be stolen by some untrustworthy GM if I decide to use it with another team. There should be a way to password-protect the file you save.

I have a feeling that playbook theft is going to be a big problem in this game. There's a lot of work that is gonna be going into these tactics.

Maybe only the defensive coordinator should be allowed to view the Defense AI page. An owner should have to make himself a GM and Defensive Coordinator if he wants to view the page.


I agree about theft being a super problem. Im not the Owner of the team, but Im a Gm.
We have a Dc. I trust them all, but not everyone has the same trust levels as we got. After 5 hours of playing with the tactics, Ive gotten about 300 diffrent plays and senerios, and Im not even half way done yet, with what I am wanting to do. Someone steals my plays, and Im going to be pissed off.


I wonder if Bort has something in mind. If my playbook gets stolen, I'm going to whine and complain a LOT.



Yea I'd be pretty pissed if I was brought in to DC then I get treated unfairly and my playbook gets stolen. Maybe owners shouldn't get access to it unless they were the DC.


come on an owner not knowing how his own defense is run? thats bull and thats coming from a DC. Theres a solution to this...its called not being an idiot. Owners shouldnt just simply give someone the DC position they should prove to the owner they are all about the team succeding ect ect and If DCs get an offer as DC they should get feedback from the owner's team's players to see if hes a good owner or not but not allowing an owner to see how his own defense is run is flat out unfair.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.