User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > XP bonus for playing at or above your level
Page:
 
Revel8
offline
Link
 
^_^
Last edited Jun 10, 2008 01:26:19
 
Revel8
offline
Link
 
Ah never mind I read it wrong.
Last edited Jun 10, 2008 01:25:49
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JBM0723
I agree with thunder because i have 40 players that were made with bought flex points, none of my flex points were referals.


My guard joined a BBB team right when it was created as a level 4. That's not douchey at ALL. If anything, that was LOW for BBB. Now, if I boost at the beginning of this season, I will be a level 18, and SURELY see an XP punishment. Teams have been gutted, and horribly low-leveled teams have dropped into my league by no fault of my own.

This plan punishes innocent players and does NOTHING to stop jerkoffs from dropping down with horribly over-leveled players... because people like that won't care about this change.
 
Staners
offline
Link
 
Have I missed something here?

I thought that all Bort has done is said that XP will be effected for players who have players above the league average?

Surely this is fair. You still have higher level players, just they wont improve as quick as lower level players. Apart from the new WE league, it isnt stopping you or me having these players.

Lets be honest, there are no perfect answers when dealing with people who desperately want to cheat or play within the spirit of the game. Its a shame that the changes will effect some ppl who have done nothing wrong, but it will also effect all of those that have.
Last edited Jun 10, 2008 01:19:42
 
JBM0723
offline
Link
 
I had about 6-7 players i got from other teams I was with and the reast were created special for my team and now most are about level 12-16 and the average in my league is 10. Now once i boost most of the players will be 15-19. I don't want to be penalized for me being competetive.
 
kinglehr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rj414
I like the idea on a game to game basis. I dont think you should get less experience just because you outlevel your whole league - if you play teams that are significantly worse than you though I do think you should make practically no experience because quite simply you can't learn much from beating up lesser teams. Makes sense to me.


I like it too. The real key is what the gap allowed will be. Certainly, the gap before the modifier is employed should not be small (like a 1 or 2 Lvl difference). A 3 Lvl gap might still be too small, but perhaps a 4-5 Level gap would be good.
Last edited Jun 10, 2008 01:24:55
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Staners

Surely this is fair. You still have higher level players, just they wont improve as quick as lower level players. Apart from the new WE league, it isnt stopping you or me having these players.


This is ALREADY BEING DONE in the current XP leveling system. Now, people are actually being PUNISHED for boosting their players.

I hope there will be a way to buy back boosts and receive a refund.
 
atmays
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
Originally posted by Staners


Surely this is fair. You still have higher level players, just they wont improve as quick as lower level players. Apart from the new WE league, it isnt stopping you or me having these players.


This is ALREADY BEING DONE in the current XP leveling system. Now, people are actually being PUNISHED for boosting their players.

I hope there will be a way to buy back boosts and receive a refund.


I hope it is to.
 
kinglehr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
Originally posted by Staners


Surely this is fair. You still have higher level players, just they wont improve as quick as lower level players. Apart from the new WE league, it isnt stopping you or me having these players.


This is ALREADY BEING DONE in the current XP leveling system. Now, people are actually being PUNISHED for boosting their players.

I hope there will be a way to buy back boosts and receive a refund.


You are only being punished if other players aren't boosting. And if everyone is boosting in your league, then you will still be within the median.

You're not the one the penalty is targeting. It's this kind of player:

I won't say who it is, but I was recruiting a safety recently. Said all the nice things, etc. Level 16... right about my League's median. You wanna know who he signed with? Some team with Level 4 players... in a league with all single digit level players.
Last edited Jun 10, 2008 01:29:07
 
atmays
offline
Link
 
K with these new XP changes

I was with my team since like LVL 6. Now im hitting 18.

Question. So if my team never moves up out of AA. Me LVLing up will be a bad thing?

And is they suggesting leaving your current team so that the guy you created and SPENT MONEY ON can actually grow like he was attended to.

Not all teams can make it to pro. Not all teams can make it to AAA.
EDIT: Well not at the same time.

What about the teams that fall a League. From PRo to BBB or AAA.
Last edited Jun 10, 2008 01:32:26
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kinglehr


You are only being punished if other players aren't boosting. And if everyone is boosting in your league, then you will still be within the median.


1. Not everyone boosts. Not even close.

2. Innocent players who are trying to win will be punished if OTHER teams get worse in their conference. What is the option here? Demand to be released and try to get signed as a backup in a higher league? Leave the team that you have made friends on because you have leveled your player intellegently? The chemistry losses will be astronomical. The situation is so ridiculous, it's hard to take in all at once.

3. Almost ALL starters will be above the median, and we have no idea what Bort's cutoff is. But it's safe to assume that if you are good, you are being punished. So what's the point?
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
I have to cool down.
Last edited Jun 10, 2008 01:37:58
 
JBM0723
offline
Link
 
there should be more emphasis on how a player is built and the player you go against is built. My players are built well, but I have never dominated my competition because my builds are well rounded instead of concentrating on one thing. My point is that just because I have had higher level players does not mean I have won more. Out of all the teams I have GMed and the won I own my best record is 7-9. I don't feel I have had an advantage on any one team. There has to be a better idea.
 
kinglehr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
Originally posted by kinglehr



You are only being punished if other players aren't boosting. And if everyone is boosting in your league, then you will still be within the median.


2. Innocent players who are trying to win will be punished if OTHER teams get worse in their conference. What is the option here? Demand to be released and try to get signed as a backup in a higher league? Leave the team that you have made friends on because you have leveled your player intellegently? The chemistry losses will be astronomical. The situation is so ridiculous, it's hard to take in all at once.


EDIT DUE TO BAD MATH:
You are obviously misunderstanding what the word median means. Median DOES NOT MEAN average. The median is simply a number that separates the top half from the bottom half. In a 16-team league it will be the average between team 8 and team 9. A team getting getting significantly worse does not necessarily significantly affect the median.

For example, if team 10 at the bottom half of the league gets significantly worse, the median remains the same. If the number 1 team becomes the worst team in the league, the median changes to the average of team 9 and team 10 - which could go up or down.

You also seem to be ignoring the fact that Bort said "way too high". We don't even know what "way too high" means yet and you're complaining. Way too high could mean 8 levels higher than the median.
Last edited Jun 10, 2008 01:53:20
 
Beefeater
offline
Link
 
I think most people in this thread are just overreacting. The XP thing's going to be a small effect. It's not going to even up lower level players to higher level players, not even close. All it will do is narrow maybe 10% of the gap.

I think the way to do this right is to skip the bonus for lower level players, as we're trying to encourage parity, not incentivize players to play in leagues where they're totally overmatched. The "bonus" thing is just too exploitable.

However, you can still penalize the higher-level players a bit. Take the average level of all the players that are on the field when you're playing. If you're more than 3 levels above average, you starting losing XP you would have gained at 1 to 2 percent per level. Occasionally, you'll run into a gutted team and your XP will be seriously damaged for the game, but that's just bad luck and you'll have to deal with it. Maybe cap it at 20% of your XP you could lose.

I think this would actually make things a little more interesting for the players, since when they're playing "big games" against good teams, they'll get a little extra development. It's another dimension of realism and gives players another reason to get involved.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.