User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Coaches - ideas for them to spend money on (and other ideas)
Page:
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Phil Jackson
This is the first somewhat reasonable argument I have heard for the 440 day mark on coaches. It's not a jealously thing however it is blockade thing.

440 Days is a completely unreasonable number to wait in order for your player to become a coach. I would be fine if Bort wanted to make a 120-160 day minimum before able to retire and make a coach as that at least forces someone to participate in the player creation/management aspect of this game. But to make someone wait over a year before something becomes available, is like roping off a corner of GLB and making it the V.I.P. section.


As a compromise in return for players' aging as players, they get into the "V.I.P. section" when they play as long as is allowed before aging and retire. Let anyone in there and there will be far too many coaches, and the compromise will no longer be anything but steamrolling the game's most loyal customers.
 
HEY YOU GUYS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
A compromise for Season 1 players because most MMO's don't do aging at all.

I was very vocally pro-aging, due to both realism and the fact that newer players needed their turn in the spotlight. But there also had to be something so that people didn't completely lose their characters.


And they should be able to convert their players into coaches. However every user should also have the ability to Create a coach from scratch.

They won't be "losing" their characters as it is the same name and same player just as a coach now.

 
HEY YOU GUYS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
As a compromise in return for players' aging as players, they get into the "V.I.P. section" when they play as long as is allowed before aging and retire. Let anyone in there and there will be far too many coaches, and the compromise will no longer be anything but steamrolling the game's most loyal customers.


There won't be far too many coaches because there will simply not be enough room for them all.

EVERYONE KNEW THEIR PLAYER HAD A LIFESPAN WHEN CREATED. Just because someone is pissy the lifespan has reached its end doesn't mean they should leverage their declined player into an extra 5 season advantage.

These S1 Players had their "VIP Section" by having an enormous level advantage and being able to have players in the pro leagues for 10 SEASONS. No one who creates a player now will be even able to dream about 10 seasons in a Pro League, they will be lucky to get 3.
Edited by Phil Jackson on Sep 7, 2009 15:21:31
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Phil Jackson
And they should be able to convert their players into coaches. However every user should also have the ability to Create a coach from scratch.

They won't be "losing" their characters as it is the same name and same player just as a coach now.



But they will be, because anyone can create them. So, all the time spent on the 440 day players is made not to matter.

Bort needs to hold firm against the jealous whiners now as he did against the selfish whiners (who wanted no aging) then.
 
Staz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Phil Jackson
Originally posted by Ken1

A compromise for Season 1 players because most MMO's don't do aging at all.

I was very vocally pro-aging, due to both realism and the fact that newer players needed their turn in the spotlight. But there also had to be something so that people didn't completely lose their characters.


And they should be able to convert their players into coaches. However every user should also have the ability to Create a coach from scratch.

They won't be "losing" their characters as it is the same name and same player just as a coach now.



If there was an option to create a coach from scratch, then there should be some sort of reward for those that played out their careers and THEN became coaches, such a MUCH higher base skills, knowledge, abilities or whatever. I wouldn't be against a "Coach" option in the create a player menu, but I think those should be much lower in abilities than a player who just finished his career.

Perhaps give the "Player turned Coach" a few more options or abilities that a "Create-a-Coach" can't get? Make some incentive to play out the career?
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Phil Jackson
There won't be far too many coaches because there will simply not be enough room for them all.

EVERYONE KNEW THEIR PLAYER HAD A LIFESPAN WHEN CREATED.


Actually, not. Some of the arguments made against aging included that it wasn't prominently enough featured on the site and that the selfish whiners of the time said that they hadn't realized their player would age.

Note that some stopped spending flex at that point, and if no compromise (i.e. coaching) had been offered many more would have done the same thing. So to take away that privilege would essentially defraud them.

Originally posted by Phil Jackson
Just because someone is pissy the lifespan has reached its end doesn't mean they should leverage their declined player into an extra 5 season advantage.


People were pissy that there was a lifespan LONG before it reached its end. Note the dating on Drifter's epic suggestion. I was as strongly against their arguments then as I am against yours now.

Originally posted by Phil Jackson
These S1 Players had their "VIP Section" by having an enormous level advantage and being able to have players in the pro leagues for 10 SEASONS.


And deserved that VIP section for playing the game when it wasn't very well-developed at all. And deserve the lesser one they'll receive now for having to accept that their players will decline unlike other MMO's.
 
JcWildcat
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JcWildcat
I have added many, MANY things to the OP. If there are any others from THIS thread that needs to be added, please pm me with the quote/link. NO more threads, as the warning thread states (stickied and put up yesterday). Let us help you by helping Bort to see all your concerns here (which is why I'm editing the majority of stuff into the OP).



Quoting for relevancy, and also edited OP again.
 
Tim26
one
offline
Link
 
so you have to have a 440 day person you be a coach???
 
The Big House
offline
Link
 
I'm starting a Position Coaches Association for this(Already set up). So Position Coaches can talk and help out each other in times of need.
 
Draxius
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by goseattle
I'm starting a Position Coaches Association for this(Already set up). So Position Coaches can talk and help out each other in times of need.


WTF are you talking about. You have have 3 20th level players and nothing more. You will not be eligible to be a coach for another year. Why on earth would someone join a "coaches association" of a guy who is not even allowed to have a coach for something like 9 or 10 more seasons?
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Coaches should have to spend 2 seasons in the minors before coaching at the AA or higher level.
Minor league teams should be limited to 1 coach per team for season 12 and then see if more spots are needed.

You could have it so

Off season - Only minor league cloud teams can sign a coach
Day 0-10 - Cloud, 38 cap teams
Day 11-20 - Cloud, 38 cap teams, 31 cap teams
Day 21+ all minor league teams
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Here is another suggestion.

Before implementing coaches, test their effects on the test server. For instance, create 2 equal teams. Give 1 team 10 coaches, and the other team 0 coaches. Then test by altering the players on both teams as if they were influenced by different coaching effects.

Try it with 20 sp per coach
50 sp per coach
100 sp per coach

Run several different allocations of those sp
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tim26
so you have to have a 440 day person you be a coach???


That's the deal. There should be about 5-15 teams that have a coach on day 1 of next season.
 
butler312
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
That's the deal. There should be about 5-15 teams that have a coach on day 1 of next season.


Is coaching going to be ready by then?
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by butler312
Is coaching going to be ready by then?


I hope not
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.