I don't understand what is Bort is saying...a secret attribute would have to be secret or it would be a secret.
lukin83
offline
offline
Originally posted by Timetoshine-Beta
I don't understand what is Bort is saying...a secret attribute would have to be secret or it would be a secret.
Pretty much. In other words, it may exist but it wouldn't be a secret if I told you it existed. Statements like that make me believe it does exist. If it didn't why wouldn't he just come out and say so?
I don't understand what is Bort is saying...a secret attribute would have to be secret or it would be a secret.
Pretty much. In other words, it may exist but it wouldn't be a secret if I told you it existed. Statements like that make me believe it does exist. If it didn't why wouldn't he just come out and say so?
Saris
offline
offline
Originally posted by Jed
I know = Bort has said so. If you believe Bort is lying about things like that, then just quit now, since it's pointless to play a game where you need to rely on the higher ups to give some knowledge on things like that and can't believe them for some reason.
I don't care what proof you find in there being a difference, if Bort says there's nothing there intentionally, I believe him. The proof you find could very well be good evidence of a bug, but that's COMPLETELY different than an intentionally placed X-factor.
Bort has contradicted himself so many times that it's almost comical. If everyone who no longer takes Bort's word as gospel were to quit this game would be a ghost town.
I know = Bort has said so. If you believe Bort is lying about things like that, then just quit now, since it's pointless to play a game where you need to rely on the higher ups to give some knowledge on things like that and can't believe them for some reason.
I don't care what proof you find in there being a difference, if Bort says there's nothing there intentionally, I believe him. The proof you find could very well be good evidence of a bug, but that's COMPLETELY different than an intentionally placed X-factor.
Bort has contradicted himself so many times that it's almost comical. If everyone who no longer takes Bort's word as gospel were to quit this game would be a ghost town.
Edited by Saris on Sep 1, 2009 14:07:25
monsterkill
offline
offline
next step: figure out how fast a 48 speed guy with x factor can move so i can make a bunch of hbs and retire the duds before they would need to get boosted. and then script the entire process
Edited by monsterkill on Sep 1, 2009 14:09:04
Deathblade
offline
offline
Originally posted by monsterkill
next step: figure out how fast a 48 speed guy with x factor can move so i can make a bunch of hbs and retire before they would need to get boosted. and then script the entire process
I've already known of some people who have done that.
Though, the major one (over 20 players), had tried it with DT's, which would be crazy hard to tell.
next step: figure out how fast a 48 speed guy with x factor can move so i can make a bunch of hbs and retire before they would need to get boosted. and then script the entire process
I've already known of some people who have done that.
Though, the major one (over 20 players), had tried it with DT's, which would be crazy hard to tell.
These guys will all have the same builds on a team just for testing them out with three different QBs. They will all be built the same.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1660774
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1660784
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1662015
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1662016
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1662017
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1662020
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1662026
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1662064
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1662066
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1660774
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1660784
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1662015
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1662016
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1662017
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1662020
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1662026
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1662064
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1662066
tautology
offline
offline
Originally posted by Jed
I know = Bort has said so. If you believe Bort is lying about things like that, then just quit now, since it's pointless to play a game where you need to rely on the higher ups to give some knowledge on things like that and can't believe them for some reason.
I don't care what proof you find in there being a difference, if Bort says there's nothing there intentionally, I believe him. The proof you find could very well be good evidence of a bug, but that's COMPLETELY different than an intentionally placed X-factor.
Bort says a lot of things that can be interpreted as the reader sees fit, in my experience. And his (very rare) comments regarding x-factor always leave some room for ...something.
Here is a definitive statement that I suspect Bort would never make:
"If you take 2 players of the same height and weight with exactly the same profile, they will over the course of their career be identical in all ways in their playmaking ability."
He would never say this, because it is provably untrue.
As to what the differences are....apparently there are no "hidden attributes." I take that to mean that the attributes we see on the profile are the only attributes that are included in the algorithm (which is in mild disagreement with a statement i think he once made about getting training breakthroughs..."you may notice some players are luckier than others." I could be misremembering, but that's what I recall).
Regardless, this does not preclude:
-Certain players get bonuses to existing attributes
-Certain players get a bonus to existing SAs
-Certain players have inherent % bonuses to certain actions (break block, catching, faking, etc).
Just to name a few....
I know = Bort has said so. If you believe Bort is lying about things like that, then just quit now, since it's pointless to play a game where you need to rely on the higher ups to give some knowledge on things like that and can't believe them for some reason.
I don't care what proof you find in there being a difference, if Bort says there's nothing there intentionally, I believe him. The proof you find could very well be good evidence of a bug, but that's COMPLETELY different than an intentionally placed X-factor.
Bort says a lot of things that can be interpreted as the reader sees fit, in my experience. And his (very rare) comments regarding x-factor always leave some room for ...something.
Here is a definitive statement that I suspect Bort would never make:
"If you take 2 players of the same height and weight with exactly the same profile, they will over the course of their career be identical in all ways in their playmaking ability."
He would never say this, because it is provably untrue.
As to what the differences are....apparently there are no "hidden attributes." I take that to mean that the attributes we see on the profile are the only attributes that are included in the algorithm (which is in mild disagreement with a statement i think he once made about getting training breakthroughs..."you may notice some players are luckier than others." I could be misremembering, but that's what I recall).
Regardless, this does not preclude:
-Certain players get bonuses to existing attributes
-Certain players get a bonus to existing SAs
-Certain players have inherent % bonuses to certain actions (break block, catching, faking, etc).
Just to name a few....
Jed
offline
offline
Originally posted by Jed
I must be going nuts then, because I know I've seen you post that there isn't some secret attribute before.
How about post that there's no intentional hidden attribute that we can't affect? Because please, please, please tell me that there's no predetermined attributes we can't affect at all which more or less makes those of us with players without high #'s in those attributes banging our heads against the wall trying to get better not actually able to do so. That would just be horrible.
Originally posted by Bort
Nope, I've never said had and fast either way. Maybe these things exist, maybe they don't, or maybe I think it would be interesting to add someday so I don't want to officially strike it off the possibility list by giving a hard answer...
Also, even if an "attribute" were "hidden" like you describe, it doesn't mean you wouldn't be able to affect it somehow. Just sayin'.
Awesome. Well, I'm apparently nuts (I'll assume I was wrong and Bort didn't say something before) and now kinda pissed. If I wanted non-controllable stats and things to be that random, I'd play progress quest.
I must be going nuts then, because I know I've seen you post that there isn't some secret attribute before.
How about post that there's no intentional hidden attribute that we can't affect? Because please, please, please tell me that there's no predetermined attributes we can't affect at all which more or less makes those of us with players without high #'s in those attributes banging our heads against the wall trying to get better not actually able to do so. That would just be horrible.
Originally posted by Bort
Nope, I've never said had and fast either way. Maybe these things exist, maybe they don't, or maybe I think it would be interesting to add someday so I don't want to officially strike it off the possibility list by giving a hard answer...
Also, even if an "attribute" were "hidden" like you describe, it doesn't mean you wouldn't be able to affect it somehow. Just sayin'.
Awesome. Well, I'm apparently nuts (I'll assume I was wrong and Bort didn't say something before) and now kinda pissed. If I wanted non-controllable stats and things to be that random, I'd play progress quest.
Deathblade
offline
offline
Originally posted by Jed
Awesome. Well, I'm apparently nuts (I'll assume I was wrong and Bort didn't say something before) and now kinda pissed. If I wanted non-controllable stats and things to be that random, I'd play progress quest.
qfowned
Awesome. Well, I'm apparently nuts (I'll assume I was wrong and Bort didn't say something before) and now kinda pissed. If I wanted non-controllable stats and things to be that random, I'd play progress quest.
qfowned
fallingmercury
offline
offline
Originally posted by UMBF
I don't believe in an X Factor...I believe there's a bug in the max speed algorithm that has existed for over a year.
Amen.
I don't believe in an X Factor...I believe there's a bug in the max speed algorithm that has existed for over a year.
Amen.
Jed
offline
offline
Originally posted by Deathblade
qfowned
<shrug> At least I owned up to being wrong. My goal is to get the correct info out there, not be right all the time.
qfowned
<shrug> At least I owned up to being wrong. My goal is to get the correct info out there, not be right all the time.
tautology
offline
offline
Originally posted by Jed
<shrug> At least I owned up to being wrong. My goal is to get the correct info out there, not be right all the time.
Props for that, since you don't seem to get them too often
<shrug> At least I owned up to being wrong. My goal is to get the correct info out there, not be right all the time.
Props for that, since you don't seem to get them too often

pottsman
offline
offline
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Bort
Have never confirmed nor denied such rumors tbh. If there were secret attributes, they would be secret, no?
Though yes, random situations could appear to make one player play better than another from time to time, and certain skill combos might work better than others.
There's Bort's post about it, from the past 60 seconds.
That first line doesn't exactly put me at ease.
Originally posted by Bort
Have never confirmed nor denied such rumors tbh. If there were secret attributes, they would be secret, no?

Though yes, random situations could appear to make one player play better than another from time to time, and certain skill combos might work better than others.
There's Bort's post about it, from the past 60 seconds.
That first line doesn't exactly put me at ease.
Timetoshine-Metta
offline
offline
Originally posted by pottsman
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Bort
Have never confirmed nor denied such rumors tbh. If there were secret attributes, they would be secret, no?
Though yes, random situations could appear to make one player play better than another from time to time, and certain skill combos might work better than others.
There's Bort's post about it, from the past 60 seconds.
That first line doesn't exactly put me at ease.
Basically confirmed imo
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Bort
Have never confirmed nor denied such rumors tbh. If there were secret attributes, they would be secret, no?

Though yes, random situations could appear to make one player play better than another from time to time, and certain skill combos might work better than others.
There's Bort's post about it, from the past 60 seconds.
That first line doesn't exactly put me at ease.
Basically confirmed imo
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.




























