User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > World League is coming
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by chronoaug
Originally posted by vike fan 4 life

my question with the format that some people have presented is that if all 8 teams that dont make the playoffs in the WL get replaced from someone from their original coference wouldnt that just be putting worse team in the World League? Lets say the Benitos somehow miss the playoffs in the WL, so they get replaced by MPHD or SOAP, both are great teams but just not on the level of the Benitos. If we do a World League shouldnt the very best teams be in it every year? My suggestion is a play in game, where if a team is up for demotion from the WL they have to play 1 play in game against the team trying to take their spot. This way we know we have the very best teams in the league. Maybe im way off base on this, but I think this would be a way we could insure the best of the best teams our in the WL.


If the benitos don't make the playoffs they are the best team that season


Well a play in game would make sense to make sure wouldnt it?
 
turnit643
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by vike fan 4 life
my question with the format that some people have presented is that if all 8 teams that dont make the playoffs in the WL get replaced from someone from their original coference wouldnt that just be putting worse team in the World League? Lets say the Benitos somehow miss the playoffs in the WL, so they get replaced by MPHD or SOAP, both are great teams but just not on the level of the Benitos. If we do a World League shouldnt the very best teams be in it every year? My suggestion is a play in game, where if a team is up for demotion from the WL they have to play 1 play in game against the team trying to take their spot. This way we know we have the very best teams in the league. Maybe im way off base on this, but I think this would be a way we could insure the best of the best teams our in the WL.


Why provide a 2nd opportunity to stay? ... or a 17th opportunity. They've already had an entire 16-game season to fight for a playoff spot by that point and missed out. I think they've proven at that time that they were not able to get it done. It's time for them to drop down, try to earn their way in again, and give another team a shot while they are working to get back. I understand your reasoning, but don't think we need to provide insurance for the original WL teams to help them stay. And, they may in fact be better than the new teams coming up to replace them, but if neither are good enough to do damage once in the league, does it matter that much which is there?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by vike fan 4 life
my question with the format that some people have presented is that if all 8 teams that dont make the playoffs in the WL get replaced from someone from their original coference wouldnt that just be putting worse team in the World League? Lets say the Benitos somehow miss the playoffs in the WL, so they get replaced by MPHD or SOAP, both are great teams but just not on the level of the Benitos. If we do a World League shouldnt the very best teams be in it every year? My suggestion is a play in game, where if a team is up for demotion from the WL they have to play 1 play in game against the team trying to take their spot. This way we know we have the very best teams in the league. Maybe im way off base on this, but I think this would be a way we could insure the best of the best teams our in the WL.


With Pro Leagues getting better and better depth having a play-in game is a bad idea. If the Benitos can't stay in the WL then so what? They can get back up there if they win their Pro League conference again. Having a play-in game is a really dumb way to decide it in my opinion.

Allowing teams that don't make the playoffs a chance to stay in a play-in game could result in a weaker team facing demotion from the World League pulling out a win in that game. The World League should be a privilege, and you shouldn't get a second chance to stay like that.

Why not give a team besides the Benitos a chance to prove themselves? They can even do that and be joined by the Benitos a season later.

If a team doesn't make the playoffs in the World League, they may be better than the team replacing them, but your reason for a play-in game is to have the "best of the best." They didn't make the playoffs, so even though they might be better than some teams in the World League, then they aren't the best of the best. With such a high turnover getting sent down from the World League is more of an eventual reality than it is a punishment. You are going back to a Pro League you have a trophy from, which doesn't seem so bad to me. Right now a trophy from it gets you nothing at all besides the trophy itself.
Edited by Mercaptopropyl on Jul 9, 2009 22:27:11
 
Link
 
Originally posted by vike fan 4 life
Originally posted by chronoaug

Originally posted by vike fan 4 life


my question with the format that some people have presented is that if all 8 teams that dont make the playoffs in the WL get replaced from someone from their original coference wouldnt that just be putting worse team in the World League? Lets say the Benitos somehow miss the playoffs in the WL, so they get replaced by MPHD or SOAP, both are great teams but just not on the level of the Benitos. If we do a World League shouldnt the very best teams be in it every year? My suggestion is a play in game, where if a team is up for demotion from the WL they have to play 1 play in game against the team trying to take their spot. This way we know we have the very best teams in the league. Maybe im way off base on this, but I think this would be a way we could insure the best of the best teams our in the WL.


If the benitos don't make the playoffs they are the best team that season


Well a play in game would make sense to make sure wouldnt it?


One game means nothing compared to a 16 game season.

I would hate to go 20-0 in my Pro League, and then lose a close game to a great team like the Benitos and not even be able to join the World League just because we couldn't win one play-in game. One game should never be so decisive for something so important, and if you think differently then tell me why you don't see more teams going 16-0 or 19-0 (I mean, you should win any rematches, right?) in Pro Leagues very often.

edit: Also, in your scenario, my situation sucks even more because the Benitos didn't even make the playoffs. If they had made the playoffs my team would have automatically been promoted to the World League. No team should ever be punished because the Benitos or any other team didn't have a good enough season. That has absolutely nothing to do with them. They earned the right to move up by winning their Pro League conference. The Benitos didn't earn the right to stay by not making the playoffs.
Edited by Mercaptopropyl on Jul 9, 2009 22:32:40
 
Link
 
^^^^^^^^^^

valid points
 
Bladnach
offline
Link
 
The Benitos don't get some kind of rights or respect for being good way back when (assuming they ever falter haha). It's a cut throat world. You win, you stay, you lose you go home. If you're good enough against the other 16 teams in your conference, you can stay, if you don't perform, you're gone and can try to get back there the next year (which probably will happen).


Whatever, who knows if this will ever happen. I think it'd be better as the tournaments should be more for fun than a necessary way for teams to prove themselves despite playing 16 league games as well.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by chronoaug
The Benitos don't get some kind of rights or respect for being good way back when (assuming they ever falter haha). It's a cut throat world. You win, you stay, you lose you go home. If you're good enough against the other 16 teams in your conference, you can stay, if you don't perform, you're gone and can try to get back there the next year (which probably will happen).


Whatever, who knows if this will ever happen. I think it'd be better as the tournaments should be more for fun than a necessary way for teams to prove themselves despite playing 16 league games as well.


i was just using them as an example, it stands for any team, guess i should of made that more clear
 
Gronert
offline
Link
 
sticky?
 
kuaggie
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by vike fan 4 life
my question with the format that some people have presented is that if all 8 teams that dont make the playoffs in the WL get replaced from someone from their original coference wouldnt that just be putting worse team in the World League? Lets say the Benitos somehow miss the playoffs in the WL, so they get replaced by MPHD or SOAP, both are great teams but just not on the level of the Benitos. If we do a World League shouldnt the very best teams be in it every year? My suggestion is a play in game, where if a team is up for demotion from the WL they have to play 1 play in game against the team trying to take their spot. This way we know we have the very best teams in the league. Maybe im way off base on this, but I think this would be a way we could insure the best of the best teams our in the WL.


but you'd have to implement it for every team being demoted- no picking favorites. Don't get me wrong, it's a good idea I just don't see how it would be effectively implemented. And it might be a little off base to question the competitiveness of a team that wins a pro trophy. Also before you say it, i don't think i have too much personal bias in this matter as we don't have plans for the world league any time soon, lol.
 
Rodion
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kuaggie
Originally posted by vike fan 4 life

my question with the format that some people have presented is that if all 8 teams that dont make the playoffs in the WL get replaced from someone from their original coference wouldnt that just be putting worse team in the World League? Lets say the Benitos somehow miss the playoffs in the WL, so they get replaced by MPHD or SOAP, both are great teams but just not on the level of the Benitos. If we do a World League shouldnt the very best teams be in it every year? My suggestion is a play in game, where if a team is up for demotion from the WL they have to play 1 play in game against the team trying to take their spot. This way we know we have the very best teams in the league. Maybe im way off base on this, but I think this would be a way we could insure the best of the best teams our in the WL.


but you'd have to implement it for every team being demoted- no picking favorites. Don't get me wrong, it's a good idea I just don't see how it would be effectively implemented. And it might be a little off base to question the competitiveness of a team that wins a pro trophy. Also before you say it, i don't think i have too much personal bias in this matter as we don't have plans for the world league any time soon, lol.


I think vike's idea is really fair.

The ideal World League should have teams 1-32. Assuming we ever reach that sweet spot, the way the current format works will remove teams 17-32 from that list and will fill those 16 spots with teams 33-48 (not necessarily, as we are having 2 from each league and there are weaker leagues and stuff, but you guys can get my point). That means the leaguewith the 32 best teams would feature teams 1-16 and 33-48, thus not having the best 32 teams.

The idea of allowing a non-playoff WL team to defend its spot against a "mere" (when the best Pro teams leave their league for a World one, Pro league values will be diminished) Pro champion sounds fair, as the winner should be the best and thus the most able to represent the WL.

To make things most fair, I believe WL teams should pick which Pro Conference Champion they want to defend their spots against, starting from the 17th best WL team having all 16 choices and ending at the 32nd team having to play whichever team was not picked by the other 15 non-playoff teams. By doing that, the closer to the playoffs a WL team got to would mean they have a better chance at keeping their spot, while the worst WL teams would have to face the best Pro champions and would have a lower staying chance. If you think one game means nothing, then make it a best of three during days 39-40-41 or 41-42-43.

The problem with this idea is that there would be no guaranteed representation from the World Leagues, as teams from a certain region could lose both challenging and defending games and be left out. I don't see that as something bad, though.
 
Jakemall
offline
Link
 
So let me get this straight...

If I'm in the USAPL WEST and the USAPL West team in the world league keeps coming in 8th place, I'll never have a chance to go world even if I win the USAPRO championship each season?


Doesn't seem right to me if that's how it works. Perhaps only the Champions of the alpha and zeta should be able to stay.
Edited by Jakemall on Jul 10, 2009 13:36:52
 
Rodion
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jakemall
So let me get this straight...

If I'm in the USAPL WEST and the USAPL West team in the world league keeps coming in 8th place, I'll never have a chance to go world even if I win the USAPRO championship each season?


Doesn't seem right to me if that's how it works. Perhaps only the Champions of the alpha and zeta should be able to stay.


My idea fixes that flaw. Please read above.
 
turnit643
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jakemall
So let me get this straight...

If I'm in the USAPL WEST and the USAPL West team in the world league keeps coming in 8th place, I'll never have a chance to go world even if I win the USAPRO championship each season?


Doesn't seem right to me if that's how it works. Perhaps only the Champions of the alpha and zeta should be able to stay.


No.

The conference winners will go up each season no matter what. If the rep from your conference makes the playoffs, they stay and you join them. Over time, your conference can keep sending teams if they keep earning the right to stay by making the WL playoffs.
 
turnit643
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rodion

I think vike's idea is really fair.

The ideal World League should have teams 1-32. Assuming we ever reach that sweet spot, the way the current format works will remove teams 17-32 from that list and will fill those 16 spots with teams 33-48 (not necessarily, as we are having 2 from each league and there are weaker leagues and stuff, but you guys can get my point). That means the leaguewith the 32 best teams would feature teams 1-16 and 33-48, thus not having the best 32 teams.

The idea of allowing a non-playoff WL team to defend its spot against a "mere" (when the best Pro teams leave their league for a World one, Pro league values will be diminished) Pro champion sounds fair, as the winner should be the best and thus the most able to represent the WL.

To make things most fair, I believe WL teams should pick which Pro Conference Champion they want to defend their spots against, starting from the 17th best WL team having all 16 choices and ending at the 32nd team having to play whichever team was not picked by the other 15 non-playoff teams. By doing that, the closer to the playoffs a WL team got to would mean they have a better chance at keeping their spot, while the worst WL teams would have to face the best Pro champions and would have a lower staying chance. If you think one game means nothing, then make it a best of three during days 39-40-41 or 41-42-43.

The problem with this idea is that there would be no guaranteed representation from the World Leagues, as teams from a certain region could lose both challenging and defending games and be left out. I don't see that as something bad, though.


So, the first set of WL teams would get a second chance to stay in the league simply because they were there first? ... and the next group has to earn their way in twice? That doesn't sound fair at all to me.

Why make it harder than it has to be? If you miss the WL playoffs, you drop back to your league and the next group gets a shot to see if they can get the job done like you couldn't. After you've dropped, you can get to your league title game again and earn another chance at the WL the following season. By not qualifying for the playoffs, you've already proven that you are not among the best in the WL, why would you automatically get to defend your spot?

 
Rodion
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by turnit643
Originally posted by Rodion


I think vike's idea is really fair.

The ideal World League should have teams 1-32. Assuming we ever reach that sweet spot, the way the current format works will remove teams 17-32 from that list and will fill those 16 spots with teams 33-48 (not necessarily, as we are having 2 from each league and there are weaker leagues and stuff, but you guys can get my point). That means the leaguewith the 32 best teams would feature teams 1-16 and 33-48, thus not having the best 32 teams.

The idea of allowing a non-playoff WL team to defend its spot against a "mere" (when the best Pro teams leave their league for a World one, Pro league values will be diminished) Pro champion sounds fair, as the winner should be the best and thus the most able to represent the WL.

To make things most fair, I believe WL teams should pick which Pro Conference Champion they want to defend their spots against, starting from the 17th best WL team having all 16 choices and ending at the 32nd team having to play whichever team was not picked by the other 15 non-playoff teams. By doing that, the closer to the playoffs a WL team got to would mean they have a better chance at keeping their spot, while the worst WL teams would have to face the best Pro champions and would have a lower staying chance. If you think one game means nothing, then make it a best of three during days 39-40-41 or 41-42-43.

The problem with this idea is that there would be no guaranteed representation from the World Leagues, as teams from a certain region could lose both challenging and defending games and be left out. I don't see that as something bad, though.


So, the first set of WL teams would get a second chance to stay in the league simply because they were there first? ... and the next group has to earn their way in twice? That doesn't sound fair at all to me.

Why make it harder than it has to be? If you miss the WL playoffs, you drop back to your league and the next group gets a shot to see if they can get the job done like you couldn't. After you've dropped, you can get to your league title game again and earn another chance at the WL the following season. By not qualifying for the playoffs, you've already proven that you are not among the best in the WL, why would you automatically get to defend your spot?



Because not making the WL playoffs only means you're not a top 16 team. It doesn't mean you're not a top 32 team. And the WL should have the top 32 teams.
The system gart and I debated some months ago and you explained/improved has the flaw which vike brought to light. This system will replace the 17th best team of the game for a team on the 30s-40s. And that is what I consider unfair.

I think a team should only join the WL to make it stronger. And the proper way to prove you'll make it stronger is by beating a current WL team, not by simply winning it all in the inferior tier.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.