Originally posted by Bort
I'm kinda asking: if you were determine how the formula worked, what would you think goes into it?
Opinions vary widely and I want to see where they are.
I would think agility would be key, to be able to make those last tenth-of-second adjustments to put a shoulder into his waist... sort of a combination of tackling skill and agility. Someone who's good at tackling but not agile won't be able to get in position very frequently to wrap up... someone agile but not good at tackling can get in the guys way and will slow him down, but may not be great at converting that to a wrap... too many arm tackles, etc.
Then the impact you have and the ability to drag the guy to the ground would be based on speed and strength... not speed attribute, but actual in-game speed of the defender when making the tackle. Simple physics, you're going to knock him more off balance if you're flying a shoulder into him vs. standing there and basically "catching" him (although your legs are planted at that point, so then strength is more of a factor in low-speed tackles).
So basically two major parts... D-players agility and tackling (and perhaps even vision to a degree... determining whether you got juked and your ability to predict his next step... and also jumping for diving tackles) are going to impact the "quality" of the tackle... a dead-on hit, a decent wrap-up, an arm tackle, a shoestring tackle, etc. Of course, the RB's agility and juke abilities will modify the impact. Oh, and if the D player is being blocked at the time, that clearly is a factor too. But put it all together somehow and you end up with the "quality of tackle", perhaps on a scale of 1 to 10, along with a few "special" tackles like a lights-out hit on the good side (essentially unbreakable, high chance of FF, etc.) and a shoestring/diving tackle on the bad side (in which case it probably goes to an agility roll rather than strength roll for the RB). But for most attempted tackles not falling into these special categories, you calculate the quality of tackle.
You then take the quality of tackle as a significant modifier to the opposed "break tackle" roll. Speed of the impact (and perhaps player weight) also would be a modifier for this roll... because for a dead-on, high-speed tackle you aren't going to need much strength to bring the guy down just due to the energy and accuracy of the impact. For a lesser quality, low-impact tackle, then the opposed strength roll is going to come much more into play, perhaps even favor the RB... and this is where strength (and attributes) come into play.
Also the higher the quality of the tackle, then even if the RB breaks the tackle, there should be a "hold on" roll for the D player based on quality of tackle and strength... you might not have brought him down, but he's now carrying your weight with him like a sled, and his speed should be reduced accordingly now that you're "clamped on"... until/unless one of his teammates comes and knocks you off by executing a block (a block that also runs the risk of taking the runner down with it... kinda hard to block someone gang tackling without also hitting your own guy). In this way, unless he has downfield blockers, you'll see the gang tackle take effect... but the RB will often benefit with an extra 1-10 yards (depending how quickly other defenders can get there)... and obviously their tackle rolls will be modified easier since the RB is now also much less agile and they have more-or-less a free shot at him (and similarly run a small risk of nailing their own player while missing the RB, thus freeing him).
So how much strength does a D player need to consistently make the tackle (solo), not just slow them down? Probably very high strength (80) to consistently bring Bort's RB down with a quality 3 tackle... 60 strength for a quality 5 tackle to be consistent (I'm thinking consistent = 9 out of 10)... 40 strength for a quality 7 tackle, etc... a quality 9 or 10 tackle is going to be pretty consistent regardless of strength, the player is just flying in and nailing the guy dead-on, that's enough to bring down most power RBs IRL.
Carrying is just the ability to hold onto the ball and maybe fall forward a few yards IMHO (reaching out with the ball, etc.), but should NOT factor into break tackles, and thus shouldn't factor in. It's a "carrying" skill, not a "rushing" skill.