User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Playoff Profit sharing...
Page:
 
ib_mr_ed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by McGruffHawk
Originally posted by ib_mr_ed

Originally posted by Bill Jack


Originally posted by BerkeyTerps



Originally posted by Bill Jack




Playoff revenue sharing is overdue. I vote to split ticket revenue 50 / 50, then give all concessions to the home team.


okay so because i created a team from scratch, worked my ass off to recruit reasonable players and keep my salary low to minimize my roster costs to maximize my stadium building now i have to give a lower seeded playoff team half my ticket sales. i don't think so.


My team was on the top where I hosted every game except the final, made millions while the lower seeded teams made a few hundred thousand?

Don't think so.

Disparity is way too much between home and away team.


Yes there is a disparity that needs to be fixed for sure. I don't think taking away from the teams that worked their asses off to get there is the answer. I think changing the playoff bonus structure is a much better solution. As I have stated before in my other posts on this forum. Seeds 1-4 100K plus tix and concessions. Seeds 5-8 800K - 1.5mil depending on league, size, etc. That would close the gap for those teams that are run well and know how to manage that cash and get max benefit out of it. The teams that just skated into the playoffs and don't have a clue will still use that money in appropriately and not improve.


For the sake of realism, where do you propose that bonus money comes from? What revenue stream provides for teams receiving those large bonuses?


Where do the current bonuses come from? Do we have a revenue stream for it now? Doesn't Bort just hand out that playoff cash? Why could he just not hand out more cash? Why not let the money come from the bank of GLB, not my team's bank.




 
Knightman
offline
Link
 
Same reasoning is being repeated over and over again because people are too lazy to read even a few pages prior to the last page. We aren't going to be able to have a decent discussion about this if people stay stuck in the rut of topics that have been addressed before. If you are too lazy or stupid to read the thread, then don't start up the same old shit. Specifically:

No arguments about how much effort was put into your team, or how little effort was put into another team. The game properly rewards RESULTS, not effort!

No straw man arguments about the disparity. There's no debate about that. Can we please move on to how to FIX it (and not just with some simpleminded regurgitation of a percentage split)?

Address the issue of whether revenue sharing which takes money away from the home team to give it to the visitors (forget about the details of exactly what the percentage should be for now, let's settle on the principle) is a better option than letting home teams keep what they've traditionally been given, but addressing the disparity by giving the lower seeds another way to generate income, the most well know of which are the "Jumbotron" option and the merchandising option. Ultimately, it's do we keep the pot of playoff money fixed and reapportion it, or do we increase the pot and give the increase to the lower seeds? BOTH options address the disparity, the only real difference being the amount of money being disbursed into the GLB "Universe."

This is a legitimate issue and there have been very good points made by different sides. Can we please move the debate FORWARD instead of backward?
Last edited Oct 1, 2008 08:03:23
 
McGruffHawk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ib_mr_ed
Originally posted by McGruffHawk

Originally posted by ib_mr_ed


Originally posted by Bill Jack



Originally posted by BerkeyTerps




Originally posted by Bill Jack





Playoff revenue sharing is overdue. I vote to split ticket revenue 50 / 50, then give all concessions to the home team.


okay so because i created a team from scratch, worked my ass off to recruit reasonable players and keep my salary low to minimize my roster costs to maximize my stadium building now i have to give a lower seeded playoff team half my ticket sales. i don't think so.


My team was on the top where I hosted every game except the final, made millions while the lower seeded teams made a few hundred thousand?

Don't think so.

Disparity is way too much between home and away team.


Yes there is a disparity that needs to be fixed for sure. I don't think taking away from the teams that worked their asses off to get there is the answer. I think changing the playoff bonus structure is a much better solution. As I have stated before in my other posts on this forum. Seeds 1-4 100K plus tix and concessions. Seeds 5-8 800K - 1.5mil depending on league, size, etc. That would close the gap for those teams that are run well and know how to manage that cash and get max benefit out of it. The teams that just skated into the playoffs and don't have a clue will still use that money in appropriately and not improve.


For the sake of realism, where do you propose that bonus money comes from? What revenue stream provides for teams receiving those large bonuses?


Where do the current bonuses come from? Do we have a revenue stream for it now? Doesn't Bort just hand out that playoff cash? Why could he just not hand out more cash? Why not let the money come from the bank of GLB, not my team's bank.






I think the current bonus system is flawed for just that reason. It is not based in reality.
 
McGruffHawk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Knightman
Same reasoning is being repeated over and over again because people are too lazy to read even a few pages prior to the last page. We aren't going to be able to have a decent discussion about this if people stay stuck in the rut of topics that have been addressed before. If you are too lazy or stupid to read the thread, then don't start up the same old shit, specifically:

No arguments about how much effort was put into your team, or how little effort was put into another team. The game properly rewards RESULTS, not effort!

No straw man arguments about the disparity. There's no debate about that. Can we please move on to how to FIX it (and not just with some simpleminded regurgitation of a percentage split)? Address the issue of whether revenue sharing which takes money away from the home team to give it to the visitors (forget about the details of exactly what the percentage should be for now, let's settle on the principle) is a better option than letting home teams keep what they've traditionally been given, but addressing the disparity by giving the lower seeds another way to generate income, the most well know of which are the "Jumbotron" option and the merchandising option. Ultimately, it's do we keep the pot of playoff money fixed and reapportion it, or do we increase the pot and give the increase to the lower seeds? BOTH options address the disparity, the only real difference being the amount of money being disbursed into the GLB "Universe."

This is a legitimate issue and there have been very good points made by different sides. Can we please move the debate FORWARD instead of backward?


Thank you for the reminder.
 
robelder
offline
Link
 
"I think the current bonus system is flawed for just that reason. It is not based in reality."

Neither is the fact that a home game you don't get a bonus from the noise of your stadium giving your team the advantage and causing false starts, miscommunication on routes, wasted time outs, missed blitz pickups, etc.
 
Tito716
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by robelder
"I think the current bonus system is flawed for just that reason. It is not based in reality."

Neither is the fact that a home game you don't get a bonus from the noise of your stadium giving your team the advantage and causing false starts, miscommunication on routes, wasted time outs, missed blitz pickups, etc.


Or that you can build a Nose Tackle thats as fast as the fastest Wide Receiver.

I mean, GLB is completely based in reality.
 
McGruffHawk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tito716
Originally posted by robelder

"I think the current bonus system is flawed for just that reason. It is not based in reality."

Neither is the fact that a home game you don't get a bonus from the noise of your stadium giving your team the advantage and causing false starts, miscommunication on routes, wasted time outs, missed blitz pickups, etc.


Or that you can build a Nose Tackle thats as fast as the fastest Wide Receiver.

I mean, GLB is completely based in reality.


SO, pointing out problems in other areas justifies neglect in this area?
 
Tito716
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by McGruffHawk
Originally posted by Tito716

Originally posted by robelder


"I think the current bonus system is flawed for just that reason. It is not based in reality."

Neither is the fact that a home game you don't get a bonus from the noise of your stadium giving your team the advantage and causing false starts, miscommunication on routes, wasted time outs, missed blitz pickups, etc.


Or that you can build a Nose Tackle thats as fast as the fastest Wide Receiver.

I mean, GLB is completely based in reality.


SO, pointing out problems in other areas justifies neglect in this area?


No, but it does make the "magical" creation of money to reward lower playoff seeds or playoff game winners reasonable.

 
Knightman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by McGruffHawk
Originally posted by ib_mr_ed

Originally posted by McGruffHawk


For the sake of realism, where do you propose that bonus money comes from? What revenue stream provides for teams receiving those large bonuses?


Where do the current bonuses come from? Do we have a revenue stream for it now? Doesn't Bort just hand out that playoff cash? Why could he just not hand out more cash? Why not let the money come from the bank of GLB, not my team's bank.



I think the current bonus system is flawed for just that reason. It is not based in reality.


OK, I agree with ib's point about where the money is coming from. As far as being based in reality, there will always be concessions to practicality in an online game versus faithful reproduction of the real world. If this proposal addresses all the practical issues of disparity of income, rewarding performance, etc., then the fact that it isn't reality doesn't really bother me. There are a LOT of things about GLB that will never mirror reality but are probably necessary, to wit:

(a) Promotion/relegation and the whole tiered system concept. Nowhere in pro football is such a system in place, but nowhere is there enough money to support over a hundred thousand professional football players either. This was a necessary diversion from reality to allow many people to play.
(b) We don't have a salary cap in place, and that's a whole 'nother debate, but when Bort floated that idea there was nearly a riot!
(c) The lifespan of a player's career is much less than 10 years. GLB makes that concession in order for players to retain interest.
(c) And I guess more to the point, in REAL football, players get injured. Sometimes career ending injuries. I think there's pretty much universal consensus that the GLB community does NOT want this implemented into the online game. Why spend months and months building up your player, and then *POOF!* all your money and time and effort are gone because of an ACL tear! Yes, it would mimic real life better, but it would KILL the game!

So I'm not quite as married to the idea that the more the game represents real life, the better it is. I think there has to be a consideration of relative benefits and costs--one with a bias towards TRYING to represent real football, but not slavishly devoted to realism.

'Course, that's obviously just my opinion.
 
Knightman
offline
Link
 
With regard to the "magical" comment....my players and yours also "magically" suffer no injuries that carry over from one game to the next. No sprained toe (guess who has LDT in his Fantasy league), no back spasms, no concussions, etc. Even when injuries DO get implemented into GLB, it's very clear that they are leaning heavily towards making injuries affect a single game only. This is so human agents won't lose interest as their player is sitting on the sidelines with an injured whatever. It's NOT realistic. It IS magical. And I would argue it's absolutely necessary for the health of the game. No one wants to pay money to see their player do nothing for a season for the sake of "realism."
 
Tito716
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Knightman
With regard to the "magical" comment....my players and yours also "magically" suffer no injuries that carry over from one game to the next. No sprained toe (guess who has LDT in his Fantasy league), no back spasms, no concussions, etc. Even when injuries DO get implemented into GLB, it's very clear that they are leaning heavily towards making injuries affect a single game only. This is so human agents won't lose interest as their player is sitting on the sidelines with an injured whatever. It's NOT realistic. It IS magical. And I would argue it's absolutely necessary for the health of the game. No one wants to pay money to see their player do nothing for a season for the sake of "realism."


No argument here.

But I guess my point is:

Do the lower seeds need more money or is this essentially a tax being imposed on teams for being too successful?

GLB can create money at will. Why does money need to come out of anyone else's income pool?
 
Knightman
offline
Link
 
Well, I would guess that you and I are in agreement that the generation of alternative revenue for the lower seeds is the way to go. It reduces the disparity and gives the lower seeds a reward for getting to the playoffs without taking money that higher seeds have come to expect.

The most convincing argument (IMHO) against this is that it will dump so much money into the GLB Universe that the playoff teams, higher and lower seeds, will have too much of an advantage, and a potentially compounding advantage, over the non-playoff seeds.

To me, this is the exact same argument except it's replaced "high seeds" with "playoff teams" and "low seeds" with "non-playoff teams" and I still don't buy it. If this puts the non-playoff teams at a disadvantage, then they need to get better. I know that sounds simplistic, but asking a team to get to the playoffs is only asking them to be in the top HALF of their league. That's not nearly as large a burden as asking them to go through the season with just 2 losses, as many #4 seeds are required to do. Most #8 seeds are barely 0.500 teams, and with a number of teams in virtually every league being of the gutted/rebuilding type, I think 0.500 is not an unreasonable thing to ask of a team for it to get a "reward." I don't think saying "get good enough to be 8-8" is nearly as harsh as saying "go 13-3 in your league to get any decent money".

SUMMATION: I think teams should get rewarded for their success. Higher seeds are already getting rewarded handsomely. They don't need more. Lower seeds are getting shafted. They do need more. Non-playoff teams haven't earned the right to a reward, and will either get relegated to a league where they can compete, or will improve and go to the playoffs. 0,500 isn't too much to ask of a team for it to get a cash infusion.
 
joemalaka
offline
Link
 
Going to be Devil's Advocate here.

What happens if a team has mucho dinero, and extra playoff money doesn't mean much to their % of net worth. They are the #1 seed and the #8 seed they are playing needs money very badly. Team #1 decides to be jerks and puts their tickets either extremely low for sale, so that team #8 doesn't get much money. Team #8 gets hurt more than Team #1 because it would mean more to their bottom line.

The above would somewhat make it like it was before. BUT could only happen with the extreme rich teams.

Probably need a min and max ticket price for playoff games.
 
GMathiasf
offline
Link
 
For that reason, the visiting team would get a ticket allotment to sell at their prices to their fans. Something like 1/3 of the stadium. I know 20 some pages is a lot to read, but I'm pretty sure we can agree that the ticket allotment is better than just a percentage of ticket revenues because of the reason above.
 
GMathiasf
offline
Link
 
What drives me crazy in this thread is that people continue to drive this point that playoff money IS the home playoff team's money and that dispersing playoff income is "taking" from or "taxing" them? I've provided evidence to how sickening the amount of money home playoff teams can make and people ignore that argument and attempt to manipulate people with emotional appeals to their Republican/Capitalist beliefs. Seriously, someone show me some kind of proof that running the table with home field provides a REASONABLE amount of income, not an exorbinant amount of income.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.