My take on the USA Pro results. I'm looking at 8 games from the Western Conference, mostly analyzing stats but I did watch film on some specific TD catches and interceptions.
Overall I think the offense is finally close to being accurate to real football. I still think that without a few minor tweaks we may be a little too much on the side of WR's and QB's, but again, I think some of those would go down with better settings by the DB's and people putting points for their DB's into tackling. The current en-vogue GLB cornerback build based on what Serenity posted awhile back is a CB with tons of speed, agility, vision, and no strength or tackling. Those CB's should be burnt when they try to jam WR's and they should miss tackles occasionally. And if they're always going for the interception they should miss occasionally and get burned for a TD. (See one of my links below)
I'm thrilled with these updates as a team owner. Numbers-wise with what I've seen today the SIM is probably producing what's closer to NCAA Div1 for offensive numbers now than the NFL, but we're FINALLY in the right ballpark. I know some people are going to be in a tizzy because their defense is getting clobbered, but honestly, most NFL teams rack up 300-400 yards of combined offense in a game. GLB users have just gotten used to numbers in the 200 range when two similar teams meet up. It should probably be scaled back a little, but I think we're closer to a real football sim now than we've ever been.
Breakdown by games:
Columbus v. Oakland - Both QB's in the 73-75% completion range. Both close to 400yards passing. 13.2 and 9.4 yards per attempt. Gaudy numbers.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=83454&pbp_id=2002859The CB on the left side of the field did a great job sticking with his man, the right side the WR looks like he juked or faked the CB out. That WR also has superior speed by the looks of it.
Kailua vs. Las Vegas - Both teams threw a lot. One QB was around 53%, the other 80% completion percentage. Lots of passes to the WR's. TE's and HB's still involved, but WR heavy. 6.1 and 7.9 yards per attempt. These look to be the kind of numbers you expect. Maybe a bit heavy offensively, but Kailua only ran the ball 16 times so they didn't grind much clock so you'd expect a lot of offensive plays.
Galaxy vs. Tecmo - Qb's at 60, 68, and 60 percent completions. 9.8 and 5.7 yards per attempt. A little heavy on the total yardage again, but I like these numbers.
San Jose vs. San Antonio - 54 and 71 percent completion for the QB's. 4.3 and 8.1 yards per attempt. 210 and 250 yards passing. These are exactly the kind of numbers I'm personally hoping for. This play here is exactly what I think should be happening once or twice a game if all CB's are playing tight/aggressive coverage. CB attempts to jam the WR, WR gets by, makes the catch, CB misses a diving tackle and WR scampers in for a score.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=83425&pbp_id=2010653Detroit vs. Saginaw - 61.7 and 61.5 percent completion percentage. 7 and 9.6 yards per attempt. 330 and 250 yards passing. Both teams matched up pretty well and the score was in the 20's. Exactly what I'd want to see although the overall passing yardage and yards per attempt seem to be a bit high across the board in all these games. (Note that the rushing ypc is about perfect too at 3.9 and 3.8ypc) In the play I'm linking to the CB attempts to jam, the WR gets by, and you can explicitly see the CB attempting the interception and missing. If he doesn't attempt the INT he probably makes the tackle.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=83440&pbp_id=2009630Dayton vs. Denver - 66.7 and 70 percent completion percentages. 8.2 and 6.9 yards per attempt. 269 and 274 yard passing. Again, very realistic numbers.
Bourbon vs. Washington - Both teams are in the 60% completion range. 6.3 and 6.4 yards per attempt. 252 and 254 yards passing. Perfect NFL type numbers.
Minnesota vs. Golden State - This one was a blowout and had 67.6 and 55.2 percent passing. 7.5 yards per attempt versus 3.8. 256 versus 112 yards passing. Both teams ran the ball really well and these are good passing numbers again.