Originally posted by oldskool
Originally posted by Icespyder
Originally posted by oldskool
If the punter jogs out, kicks the ball, jogs back and sits on the bench for 10 minutes, he's not going to lose a lot of energy.
If a QB throws 19 passes, but is getting hit, getting pressured, forced to step up, scramble around, make a lot of deep passes, he's going to lose more energy.
I'm not saying it's flawless, mind you, there's just a lot more than the stat sheet involved when determining how tired somebody is.
The punter doesn't just jog in and out, he runs full speed ahead to try and tackle and no one ever puts stamina on a punter. The QB was in a fun first team, his job was to hand the ball of to a RB and make 3rd down passes. I fail to see any QBs getting tired after 19 passes thrown.
I love the game as much as anyone else as you may see, but something is really wrong here.
Even if the punter does sprint and make the tackle, he's still going to sit on the bench for a while afterwards because he's not needed again until the opposing offense is finished and his own offense fails to convert a third down outside of field goal range. The QB is still out on the field, making handoffs and throwing blocks and whatnot, and he only gets one possession's rest in between full drives while the punter gets two full possession's rest between punts.
I'm guessing you weren't here in the first season when a QB could throw 40 passes a game and only drop down 20 energy. They make a huge change to the QB yet nothing is done to the punter position. These positions aren't even as physically demanding as linemen either. My 0-linemen played the entire game with only 25 stam and they only drop down to 70 at most (they subbed out for about 10 snaps each). How can their be such a drastic difference?
Last edited Apr 27, 2008 23:42:49