User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Speed De's Deserve an Answer Bort
Page:
 
AnTiNiNjA
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Snark

Agreed. As agile, fast, and generally dominant as Magnus may be, there were sacks recorded in that game on plays in which basic tactics by the OT and QB should've been able to give the QB time to get rid of the ball. Not saying Magnus could've been completely stymied, but there did appear to be more room for balance. I realize that working this out may take time and trial and error, though ~ and thanks for implementing this so quickly, Bort!



Yeah, it's a tough balancing act.

One thing I've been thinking about: People want to see their players get sacks, but the top sack guys in the NFL only get like 14-15 sacks in a season. We had guys in GLB get 30-40 or more sacks last year, even in top leagues, which maybe spoiled them a little? I'd like to see things maybe a little more down to earth.


I'd just like to point out that the NFL doesn't have gutted teams. You don't see "Peewee" players playing on any pro team.
 
CRich
offline
Link
 
Well, first of all, the game should allow a dominantly built player to well dominate. I think there should be a formula. A OT that needs strength, blocking, agility, speed, and vision to block a great speed DE. A DE needs speed, agility, vision, and perhaps confidence. I think there should be a formula to balance them out. Most O-linemen focus on strength and blocking first. This makes sense, and I think their should be a a formula to allow a OT that has 70% of the agility, and speed of a DE to block well. Something like this.

The fact is some owners recruit better, and this leads to better builds and higher levels. If you have a DE that should dominate b/c of this, let him. It's not fair to the D to punish a DE that is built well b/c he is built to well. Put the pressure on the o-line to get the agility, speed, and vision up.

Don't let the "very well" built DEs be punished b/c other guys arn't well built. If a DE is a stud, let him get the 30 sacks. It's not realistic, but then you won't be punishing the majority.

EX: have an average for each level of player. Say the average level 25 DE should average 7 sacks a season. Great, don't punish the well built players, b/c then the average player will suffer down to 3-4 sacks a season.
 
dfitzo53
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by eljefedelamancha


As a DE owner, I would be happy if my player got 2-4 hurries a game even without a sack. At least I'd know he put pressure on the QB, maybe even hit him after the throw. That is really what is missing here. The QB only gets hit when he gets sacked. If the pass rushers could still hit the QB, cause some morale/energy problems, without getting a sack necessarily, that would be a realistic upgrade. Something to think about for season 5. Adding QB hits along with sacks/hurries would provide more realism to the pass rush.


That's a good idea - # of knockdowns.


I really like this idea too, and I think it would be cool if higher strength/tackling DEs had a bigger chance of delivering a bone-rattling knockdown even if they don't get a sack.
 
Voltron
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Snark

Yup. I think at least part of the issue is that football fans hope something exciting will happen every play ~ and when they do happen, those exciting moments are the memories they take away from games, and what they associate with their favorite players. It's natural for all of the "boring" plays to fade into the background.

In his best year, Dwight Freeney recorded 16 sacks. Charles Haley? Also 16. In fact, there are only 35 individual seasons on record in modern NFL history in which a player's recorded *more* than 16 sacks...


Yeah, I know...everybody wants their player to be a superstar in every game. I understand that feeling of wanting to be able to talk about how awesome your guy is, but they really shouldn't get 5 sacks and 10 hurries in every game, just like a WR sometimes only gets targeted once in a game.

Sack numbers in season 2 were probably more in line with what was reasonable. I think that in season 3 we started to see higher level guys find holes in the system that didn't really show up when players only had 40/50 in a stat, instead of having 80+ like a lot of guys do.


Or some are just built well. My guy just hit 70 in an ability last season.
 
seven7
offline
Link
 
i think de's are to powerful , and need balanceing myself , just saying, there speed to the qb's is just unreal , they are faster than lighting =(
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by seven7
i think de's are to powerful , and need balanceing myself , just saying, there speed to the qb's is just unreal , they are faster than lighting =(


Some of them have 70+ speed and agility. I'd think you'd be pretty quick.
 
Motiak
offline
Link
 
I think the biggest problem is that there are so many people on the OL who built their guys as:

1. Strength
2. ...
3. Profit!!
 
Voltron
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Motiak
I think the biggest problem is that there are so many people on the OL who built their guys as:

1. Strength
2. ...
3. Profit!!


QFT.
 
seven7
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by seven7

i think de's are to powerful , and need balanceing myself , just saying, there speed to the qb's is just unreal , they are faster than lighting =(


Some of them have 70+ speed and agility. I'd think you'd be pretty quick.


ugh , ok , i give up de's can be the fastest players in the game =/
Last edited Aug 2, 2008 20:39:54
 
Guru25
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Example of what "elusive" can help you do:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=88491&pbp_id=910050

Of course, magnus is pretty good. I'm still making minor adjustments to make sure it's not overpowering.


This would never happen in a real game of football- where a DE runs right around the OT. The OT starts out a foot away from the DE. There is no way that someone could just run around the OT. The DE should have to make contact and do a spin/swim/bull-rush move to get past an OT. If more of these plays start cropping up it will show how people can make a completely unrealistic person and be successful. Speed + Agility will be the only thing you need in order to make a successful DE. So to counter people will make Speed + Agility OTs that are weak and unrealistic just to beat these overpowered DEs.
 
seven7
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Guru25
Originally posted by Bort

Example of what "elusive" can help you do:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=88491&pbp_id=910050

Of course, magnus is pretty good. I'm still making minor adjustments to make sure it's not overpowering.


This would never happen in a real game of football- where a DE runs right around the OT. The OT starts out a foot away from the DE. There is no way that someone could just run around the OT. The DE should have to make contact and do a spin/swim/bull-rush move to get past an OT. If more of these plays start cropping up it will show how people can make a completely unrealistic person and be successful. Speed + Agility will be the only thing you need in order to make a successful DE. So to counter people will make Speed + Agility OTs that are weak and unrealistic just to beat these overpowered DEs.


i agree 100% they nerfed speed for wr's but not de's , humm looks like they got a boost
 
Darthmattino
offline
Link
 
Makes me sad that these weren't implemented in my game. I walked into the O-line over and over, like a small child.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Guru25
Originally posted by Bort

Example of what "elusive" can help you do:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=88491&pbp_id=910050

Of course, magnus is pretty good. I'm still making minor adjustments to make sure it's not overpowering.


This would never happen in a real game of football- where a DE runs right around the OT. The OT starts out a foot away from the DE. There is no way that someone could just run around the OT. The DE should have to make contact and do a spin/swim/bull-rush move to get past an OT. If more of these plays start cropping up it will show how people can make a completely unrealistic person and be successful. Speed + Agility will be the only thing you need in order to make a successful DE. So to counter people will make Speed + Agility OTs that are weak and unrealistic just to beat these overpowered DEs.


Er, that's why I've been tweaking it and it's not live in all leagues.
 
Voltron
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by seven7
Originally posted by Guru25

Originally posted by Bort


Example of what "elusive" can help you do:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=88491&pbp_id=910050

Of course, magnus is pretty good. I'm still making minor adjustments to make sure it's not overpowering.


This would never happen in a real game of football- where a DE runs right around the OT. The OT starts out a foot away from the DE. There is no way that someone could just run around the OT. The DE should have to make contact and do a spin/swim/bull-rush move to get past an OT. If more of these plays start cropping up it will show how people can make a completely unrealistic person and be successful. Speed + Agility will be the only thing you need in order to make a successful DE. So to counter people will make Speed + Agility OTs that are weak and unrealistic just to beat these overpowered DEs.


i agree 100% they nerfed speed for wr's but not de's , humm looks like they got a boost


How do you know that? Agility = Acceleration. DEs have high agility and speed. They have to go all of 7 yards to get to the QB.
 
seven7
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Voltron
Originally posted by seven7

Originally posted by Guru25


Originally posted by Bort



Example of what "elusive" can help you do:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=88491&pbp_id=910050

Of course, magnus is pretty good. I'm still making minor adjustments to make sure it's not overpowering.


This would never happen in a real game of football- where a DE runs right around the OT. The OT starts out a foot away from the DE. There is no way that someone could just run around the OT. The DE should have to make contact and do a spin/swim/bull-rush move to get past an OT. If more of these plays start cropping up it will show how people can make a completely unrealistic person and be successful. Speed + Agility will be the only thing you need in order to make a successful DE. So to counter people will make Speed + Agility OTs that are weak and unrealistic just to beat these overpowered DEs.


i agree 100% they nerfed speed for wr's but not de's , humm looks like they got a boost


How do you know that? Agility = Acceleration. DEs have high agility and speed. They have to go all of 7 yards to get to the QB.


true true voltron , but bort is still tweaking them so i shouldn't be so crazy and be more understanding ,
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.