User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > GLB - aren't you removing the fun out of the game?
Page:
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kelownamadden
+1

I couldn't explain better, though I will try to add my own point of view.

I think this is just another of the common mistakes this game makes from time to time. I kinda agree with the reason but plainly disagree on the way to enforce it. You cannot punish people for doing whatever they can (and the game allow) to try to compete with other people who is constantly exploiting the game, and this is something that has been happening on all 14 seasons of the game.

I have been here since day 15 Season 1, owned a team since day 1 season 2 and I have seen all the stories that happened on this game. I have been trying to run my team for 8 seasons they way it was meant to be played, first with some friends I brought into the game from a forum, with pretty bad results if you compare with other teams that started at the same time, getting tired that season after season there was a team on my league who had the "smartest guy of the class" to exploit the WR Screen, the HB Slam, the Powerbacks, the AEQ, the custom D-plays... every season something has happened that put teams who can't spend their lifes into the forums looking for the magic play or the season-exploit in a disadvantage that translate on poor winning records, which translates on not getting enough money Oand finally translates on not being able to pay equipment for your players which puts you in a difficult situation to compete against ultra-organized farm systems.

At first, during the 3-4 first seasons of this game, the key to be successful was having or not having enough money to boost and buy CE, now even spending a fucking bunch of money on this game you are screwed because you can't keep up with teams who are taking advantage (or did in the past) of loopholes on the system.

And I don't think that punishing people retroactively for this will ever help the game, you cannot play God by saying I will punish you if you do this when there are people still getting unfair advantages of past mistakes, so if a single team is punished for trying to compete on the game, in my opinion all the trophies that have been awarded for teams using sim bugs, exploits and dirty tricks should also be removed and all the results of all leagues should be reviewed and all the money awarded to teams who won trophies in an unfair manner should also be removed. Since I don't think this is ever going to be into consideration, you better think twice what you are going to do to fix this issue but I honestly think the solution you have proposed on the announcement is clearly not a good one.

Finally, if you accept a piece of advice, on online games, the key for fun is to allow an even level field for EVERYONE, or at least, as even as possible, since the perfect balance doesn't exist, but if you keep punishing people arbitrarily for your mistakes and poor designs you will soon run out all your customer base which at once was pretty amazing and that is the reason why this game still exists.


I think you're dead on about people trying to keep pace with others who cheated.....

The biggest exploit/cheaters in the game were the playoff ticket exploiters who got such a huge financial advantage over all newer teams that you literally had to have 3 farm teams to keep up with teams who cheated the game... I.e las Vegas gamblers... Catch needs to look inthe mirror on this crap and fix the system...
 
Adamsfore.org
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PierreThomas
Hey Bort and Catch, do you know why people slow build?

They slow build because BORT, not the players, came up with the idea of auto leveling gains which benefits players to build a set way in order to maximize points. Your customers don't want to pay $10 a year to have a player that is better than average in a high league next January. Unfortunately you Bort set the game up this way.

Do you know why teams merge?

They merge because the tactics, game management, player management, agent management, financial management and daily stress of owning a team is far too much for 2-3 people at high levels and most importantly because they watched merging teams win multiple championships at high levels and quickly realized unless just a few people own all the players on a team winning it all becomes impossible without merging. Team owners don't want to start a team build it up for 10 seasons with loyal agents they become friends with and then combine their baby with another team just to cut loose half the agents that got them to the spot they were at but they just realize it becomes a necessity.

Do you know why people shell out 400 flex a season to own a farm team or cash team?

They set up farm teams because Bort made equipment too expensive and didn't have the foresight to see that the way equipment is set up a team has to have home field advantage in the playoffs just about every season. Teams that don't get this can't fully upgrade equipment and can't lure free agents to the team and in the teams 10th season they may be being punished for something that happened in season 5. This sets up unbalanced play and teams quickly scramble to find other ways to level the playing field. This game isn't the NFL but you can blow smoke up everyone's ass and try to claim it isn't based on professional football because the last time I checked college players don't have contracts. Every NFL team is on an equal playing field with finances every season. In fact, the teams that spend less and lose one season typically have more to spend the next. This system is so bad it is like it was created with one too many chromosomes.

This new rule isn't going to keep teams and agents from abusing cash, you are just simply making it harder and more time consuming which in the end is the reason people are leaving the game faster than they are coming in.

I would have loved this rule 8 seasons ago when the first collusion was going on instead of waiting 8 seasons to put your foot down and going back trying to penalize teams that are no longer competitive.


So the next time I get a player stuck on a bad team owner that promises equipment but doesn't deliver and when he becomes available he needs about 6.8 million to get equipment fully upgraded and he can't find a way to get that taken care of guess what I'm going to do?
Retire him

Guess what is going to happen with the cash teams that are out there you are collecting 400 flex a season on?
Sold back.



There is nothing worse in this game than slow building a player up for 8 seasons to finally have him ready to compete at a high level just to have the sim change completely away from the vision of your player. We now can't afford to switch equipment and your customer has thrown $40-100 down the drain because of your poor foresight. What should we do with these players?
Would you suggest retiring them or the agent just losing interest in the game and quitting because these are the only two options you leave the agent with.


This announcement is going to cause chaos. I know that my teams little move this season caused plenty of crying but we didn't steal money from my team before leaving, we spent it all trying to get fully equipped for the playoffs before even deciding it. Sad that a USA Pro team that has won multiple trophies along the way with an elaborate farm system and took a season off to rent players off for max cash raising over $75 million still wasn't fully equipped but it just goes to show how fucked up the financial part of this game is.

So what are you going to be doing about the teams that dropped down and started over with huge bank accounts prior to this announcement that will have a massive advantage on everyone else when they reach the top levels of the game in a few seasons?

Think before you act for christ's sake!


Ultimately do you know why I rented off my entire team in season 9? Do you know why I merged with the Blaze? Do you know why we've set up such an elaborate farm system? We did this to try and level the playing field with teams that used the playoff ticket sale glitch back in season 3 to create hundreds of millions in additional revenue. I raised hell about this yet you ignored it allowing them to keep the money and giving them a HUGE financial advantage season after season. Are you going to penalize them too if any of them are still around and haven't quit the game by now?


WINNER!
 
Ahrens858
offline
Link
 
PT with post of the year
 
Kevin Smith
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti
Bort did not intend for teams to be able to afford it for every player. Right or wrong that is what he has said.


The bolded is exactly what needs to be discussed.

This is a game mainly made up of dot making agents. Most of them do nothing but that, and even most GMs do nothing but make players.Originally posted by chronoaug
I don't really believe that for a second. I don't think bort really thought that through during season 1. I remember during i think season 4 i think bort talking about making money more useful for teams besides eq like having little side games and other money related things but i guess that fell through. I think money originally had a purpose but then kept getting put on the backburner. I'd be surprised if bort did all the calculations about how much money teams of various success levels would have, how many roster spots people would have, the various levels they'd have, and how much eq for those players would cost.

I think money was an afterthought in GLB and it's pretty apparent. There is no "game" to money. It's just build a stadium as fast as possible and then the most important thing to make more money is to get homefield advantage and go deep in playoffs for more cash. Not a lot of strategy to that. Money in GLB is pointless and boring.

I'd honestly rather there be no money, no salaries, no eq money. Would be just as much "strategy" as there is now only some paying customers wouldn't get screwed by being loyal to a consistent 10-6 team who doesn't get home playoff games or as tpaterni said, getting beat by teams with farm teams and equipment funnel teams. You really can't make rules that kill farm teams and equipment teams but also are still fair to the general public. I'd personally just get rid of money altogether until Bort and co. actually put some thought into it


You read my mind. Totally agree. Could someone pls explain what about the money side of the game is interesting/fun/challenging?
 
Jiddy78
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kevin Smith
You read my mind. Totally agree. Could someone pls explain what about the money side of the game is interesting/fun/challenging?


It isn't...It's a pain in the ass and not even rewarding like a typical RPG where you earn that fancy new sword of eternal smiting and whoop that ass...cuz all yer trying to do is stay on par with your opponent and not have your team upset that they are at a competitive disadvantage. It's not about "improvement" at all...but survival.

Thank God we have the oh-so-interesting ticket sale simulation to help alleviate this pain.
 
mlcaiazzo
offline
Link
 
I rented my team out for a season to get money ... went 5-25 ... had little fun. Rebuilt from the botttom up... level 1's and spend most of my team money on equipment JUST to find out that the builds are mediocre against teams who run the ball 95% of the time.

I agree with PT AND will still play the game for the forums and discussions like this ... good job felas!

Mike
Owner - ROME WOLVES
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by David Stern
I think you're dead on about people trying to keep pace with others who cheated.....

The biggest exploit/cheaters in the game were the playoff ticket exploiters who got such a huge financial advantage over all newer teams that you literally had to have 3 farm teams to keep up with teams who cheated the game... I.e las Vegas gamblers... Catch needs to look inthe mirror on this crap and fix the system...



Well maybe. There were other financial advantage early teams got.

1. The concession sales exploit of season 1. I know some teams were charging 5-6x suggested. I think there may have been a couple charging as much as 10x. I know one owner would change the prices 2 hours before the game, then lower them right after SIMs ran.

2. The season 1 teams that were signing all the FAs before the season 2 teams were released then selling all the extra FAs to season 2 teams who were unable to fill their rosters because some of the season 1 teams had as many as 85 players.

3. The rent a player system. Owner A was getting a team. He wanted a financial advantage. So he created 10-15 players who he never boosted or bought CE for. He simply signed them to 1 season contracts, signed them, traded them for cash. Then kept signing and trading the exact same players every single season.

4. Oh and let's not forget the cash funneling some of the first owner's who were able to own multiple teams were using.


The exploitation of in game cash is something that should have been addressed in season 2 or 3. Now it has become standard operating practice across GLB, just like many of us said it would back in seasons 3 and 4. It's kind of late in the game to decide you don't like it and retroactively punish people.

I'm glad it is finally being addressed, but I don't think this is the best way to address the problem. Something else needs to be done.

I think a better solution might be some sort of financial reset at the beginning of next season

1. Give every player enough cash to afford their next set of equipment upgrades if they only have 4 pieces of equipment (not counting CE)
2. Reset every team's cash after stadium upgrades next season based on level

WL teams - $50 million total
Pro teams - $40 million total
AAA teams - $30 million total
AA teams - $20 million total
Cap 46/42 - $10 million
Cap 38/34 - $7.5 million
Cap 30/26 - $5 million
Cap 22/18 -- $2.5 million
Cap 14/4 - starting cash

Then enforce rules from that point on.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by PierreThomas

Hey Bort and Catch, do you know why people slow build?

They slow build because BORT, not the players, came up with the idea of auto leveling gains which benefits players to build a set way in order to maximize points. Your customers don't want to pay $10 a year to have a player that is better than average in a high league next January. Unfortunately you Bort set the game up this way.

Do you know why teams merge?

They merge because the tactics, game management, player management, agent management, financial management and daily stress of owning a team is far too much for 2-3 people at high levels and most importantly because they watched merging teams win multiple championships at high levels and quickly realized unless just a few people own all the players on a team winning it all becomes impossible without merging. Team owners don't want to start a team build it up for 10 seasons with loyal agents they become friends with and then combine their baby with another team just to cut loose half the agents that got them to the spot they were at but they just realize it becomes a necessity.

Do you know why people shell out 400 flex a season to own a farm team or cash team?

They set up farm teams because Bort made equipment too expensive and didn't have the foresight to see that the way equipment is set up a team has to have home field advantage in the playoffs just about every season. Teams that don't get this can't fully upgrade equipment and can't lure free agents to the team and in the teams 10th season they may be being punished for something that happened in season 5. This sets up unbalanced play and teams quickly scramble to find other ways to level the playing field. This game isn't the NFL but you can blow smoke up everyone's ass and try to claim it isn't based on professional football because the last time I checked college players don't have contracts. Every NFL team is on an equal playing field with finances every season. In fact, the teams that spend less and lose one season typically have more to spend the next. This system is so bad it is like it was created with one too many chromosomes.

This new rule isn't going to keep teams and agents from abusing cash, you are just simply making it harder and more time consuming which in the end is the reason people are leaving the game faster than they are coming in.

I would have loved this rule 8 seasons ago when the first collusion was going on instead of waiting 8 seasons to put your foot down and going back trying to penalize teams that are no longer competitive.


So the next time I get a player stuck on a bad team owner that promises equipment but doesn't deliver and when he becomes available he needs about 6.8 million to get equipment fully upgraded and he can't find a way to get that taken care of guess what I'm going to do?
Retire him

Guess what is going to happen with the cash teams that are out there you are collecting 400 flex a season on?
Sold back.

There is nothing worse in this game than slow building a player up for 8 seasons to finally have him ready to compete at a high level just to have the sim change completely away from the vision of your player. We now can't afford to switch equipment and your customer has thrown $40-100 down the drain because of your poor foresight. What should we do with these players?
Would you suggest retiring them or the agent just losing interest in the game and quitting because these are the only two options you leave the agent with.


This announcement is going to cause chaos. I know that my teams little move this season caused plenty of crying but we didn't steal money from my team before leaving, we spent it all trying to get fully equipped for the playoffs before even deciding it. Sad that a USA Pro team that has won multiple trophies along the way with an elaborate farm system and took a season off to rent players off for max cash raising over $75 million still wasn't fully equipped but it just goes to show how fucked up the financial part of this game is.

So what are you going to be doing about the teams that dropped down and started over with huge bank accounts prior to this announcement that will have a massive advantage on everyone else when they reach the top levels of the game in a few seasons?

Think before you act for christ's sake!

Ultimately do you know why I rented off my entire team in season 9? Do you know why I merged with the Blaze? Do you know why we've set up such an elaborate farm system? We did this to try and level the playing field with teams that used the playoff ticket sale glitch back in season 3 to create hundreds of millions in additional revenue. I raised hell about this yet you ignored it allowing them to keep the money and giving them a HUGE financial advantage season after season. Are you going to penalize them too if any of them are still around and haven't quit the game by now?


I don't really agree w/ the majority of this post. It seems as if you are generalizing a bit based off your own personal experience. While what you have posted may hold true for you, it does not hold true for everyone.
 
willtopps
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wombat killer
Perhaps the problem is equipment costs too much.


+1
 
refguru
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard

Well maybe. There were other financial advantage early teams got.

1. The concession sales exploit of season 1. I know some teams were charging 5-6x suggested. I think there may have been a couple charging as much as 10x. I know one owner would change the prices 2 hours before the game, then lower them right after SIMs ran.

2. The season 1 teams that were signing all the FAs before the season 2 teams were released then selling all the extra FAs to season 2 teams who were unable to fill their rosters because some of the season 1 teams had as many as 85 players.

3. The rent a player system. Owner A was getting a team. He wanted a financial advantage. So he created 10-15 players who he never boosted or bought CE for. He simply signed them to 1 season contracts, signed them, traded them for cash. Then kept signing and trading the exact same players every single season.

4. Oh and let's not forget the cash funneling some of the first owner's who were able to own multiple teams were using.


The exploitation of in game cash is something that should have been addressed in season 2 or 3. Now it has become standard operating practice across GLB, just like many of us said it would back in seasons 3 and 4. It's kind of late in the game to decide you don't like it and retroactively punish people.

I'm glad it is finally being addressed, but I don't think this is the best way to address the problem. Something else needs to be done.

I think a better solution might be some sort of financial reset at the beginning of next season

1. Give every player enough cash to afford their next set of equipment upgrades if they only have 4 pieces of equipment (not counting CE)
2. Reset every team's cash after stadium upgrades next season based on level

WL teams - $50 million total
Pro teams - $40 million total
AAA teams - $30 million total
AA teams - $20 million total
Cap 46/42 - $10 million
Cap 38/34 - $7.5 million
Cap 30/26 - $5 million
Cap 22/18 -- $2.5 million
Cap 14/4 - starting cash

Then enforce rules from that point on.


We've worked too hard to give any money away. Not a dime back!

This game has become more work than fun lately. Why are we paying to work? I am so sick of gutted teams. Am sick of basics of pro football that we can't even see in this sim yet. I am sick of dealing with issues that are more fluff than actual nuts and bolts to this game. I'm tired of working so hard and recruiting for a top team and you can't find squat. I've been asked to merge my team with a few top teams. Yet my team members want to stay together. Win together. Do things the right way. You want to make new rules--then retroactively enforce them? That's gonna be some weird stuff right there.

PT's post was right on but it goes even deeper than that. I am so sick of overpaying for flex and then have my plans and hard worked destroyed by major sim changes. Tired of hearing about Beta too. Way too expensive for that copout. Our group prob brought in 40 guys and several have already left. All it would take is one of the top guys to quit to make it too much for any of us to continue.

I'm tired of people strategizing how best to survive given the state of the game and then being called out as supposedly acting in an unfair way. I'm not saying I condone breaking rules at all--but I am not sure what some of these teams supposedly did that were against the rules.

Condense the leagues!
Remove Inactive owners!
Get basic football shit fixed like 2 pt conversions, 4 WR sets, blocked kicks/punts, running out of bounds to stop clock when nec., quit breaking stuff like returner (who runs in a straight line?!?!), and so much more easily imped oft used tactics!!!
Chill out with the cost of high end EQ!
Stop penalizing players when the sim majorly changes!
Refund 100% flex when you force retirement re: archtypes

Man there is a lot more I'd like to write but I have real work I have to do, err GLB planning.
 
reddogrw
HOOD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kevin Smith
Originally posted by tpaterniti

Bort did not intend for teams to be able to afford it for every player. Right or wrong that is what he has said.


The bolded is exactly what needs to be discussed.

This is a game mainly made up of dot making agents. Most of them do nothing but that, and even most GMs do nothing but make players.Originally posted by chronoaug

I don't really believe that for a second. I don't think bort really thought that through during season 1. I remember during i think season 4 i think bort talking about making money more useful for teams besides eq like having little side games and other money related things but i guess that fell through. I think money originally had a purpose but then kept getting put on the backburner. I'd be surprised if bort did all the calculations about how much money teams of various success levels would have, how many roster spots people would have, the various levels they'd have, and how much eq for those players would cost.

I think money was an afterthought in GLB and it's pretty apparent. There is no "game" to money. It's just build a stadium as fast as possible and then the most important thing to make more money is to get homefield advantage and go deep in playoffs for more cash. Not a lot of strategy to that. Money in GLB is pointless and boring.

I'd honestly rather there be no money, no salaries, no eq money. Would be just as much "strategy" as there is now only some paying customers wouldn't get screwed by being loyal to a consistent 10-6 team who doesn't get home playoff games or as tpaterni said, getting beat by teams with farm teams and equipment funnel teams. You really can't make rules that kill farm teams and equipment teams but also are still fair to the general public. I'd personally just get rid of money altogether until Bort and co. actually put some thought into it


You read my mind. Totally agree. Could someone pls explain what about the money side of the game is interesting/fun/challenging?


I enjoy it

Building the stadium as fast as possible, dialing in ticket prices, etc.

Just because you don't like a part of the game doesn't mean others don't
 
reddogrw
HOOD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Originally posted by David Stern

I think you're dead on about people trying to keep pace with others who cheated.....

The biggest exploit/cheaters in the game were the playoff ticket exploiters who got such a huge financial advantage over all newer teams that you literally had to have 3 farm teams to keep up with teams who cheated the game... I.e las Vegas gamblers... Catch needs to look inthe mirror on this crap and fix the system...



Well maybe. There were other financial advantage early teams got.

1. The concession sales exploit of season 1. I know some teams were charging 5-6x suggested. I think there may have been a couple charging as much as 10x. I know one owner would change the prices 2 hours before the game, then lower them right after SIMs ran.

2. The season 1 teams that were signing all the FAs before the season 2 teams were released then selling all the extra FAs to season 2 teams who were unable to fill their rosters because some of the season 1 teams had as many as 85 players.

3. The rent a player system. Owner A was getting a team. He wanted a financial advantage. So he created 10-15 players who he never boosted or bought CE for. He simply signed them to 1 season contracts, signed them, traded them for cash. Then kept signing and trading the exact same players every single season.

4. Oh and let's not forget the cash funneling some of the first owner's who were able to own multiple teams were using.


The exploitation of in game cash is something that should have been addressed in season 2 or 3. Now it has become standard operating practice across GLB, just like many of us said it would back in seasons 3 and 4. It's kind of late in the game to decide you don't like it and retroactively punish people.

I'm glad it is finally being addressed, but I don't think this is the best way to address the problem. Something else needs to be done.

I think a better solution might be some sort of financial reset at the beginning of next season

1. Give every player enough cash to afford their next set of equipment upgrades if they only have 4 pieces of equipment (not counting CE)
2. Reset every team's cash after stadium upgrades next season based on level

WL teams - $50 million total
Pro teams - $40 million total
AAA teams - $30 million total
AA teams - $20 million total
Cap 46/42 - $10 million
Cap 38/34 - $7.5 million
Cap 30/26 - $5 million
Cap 22/18 -- $2.5 million
Cap 14/4 - starting cash

Then enforce rules from that point on.


why should teams that did not gut or exploit give cash back? that's just dumbing down the game for those that screwed up
 
Link
 
Originally posted by reddogrw
why should teams that did not gut or exploit give cash back? that's just dumbing down the game for those that screwed up


Those that screwed up are Bort and Co.
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by reddogrw
Originally posted by Rage Kinard

Originally posted by David Stern


I think you're dead on about people trying to keep pace with others who cheated.....

The biggest exploit/cheaters in the game were the playoff ticket exploiters who got such a huge financial advantage over all newer teams that you literally had to have 3 farm teams to keep up with teams who cheated the game... I.e las Vegas gamblers... Catch needs to look inthe mirror on this crap and fix the system...



Well maybe. There were other financial advantage early teams got.

1. The concession sales exploit of season 1. I know some teams were charging 5-6x suggested. I think there may have been a couple charging as much as 10x. I know one owner would change the prices 2 hours before the game, then lower them right after SIMs ran.

2. The season 1 teams that were signing all the FAs before the season 2 teams were released then selling all the extra FAs to season 2 teams who were unable to fill their rosters because some of the season 1 teams had as many as 85 players.

3. The rent a player system. Owner A was getting a team. He wanted a financial advantage. So he created 10-15 players who he never boosted or bought CE for. He simply signed them to 1 season contracts, signed them, traded them for cash. Then kept signing and trading the exact same players every single season.

4. Oh and let's not forget the cash funneling some of the first owner's who were able to own multiple teams were using.


The exploitation of in game cash is something that should have been addressed in season 2 or 3. Now it has become standard operating practice across GLB, just like many of us said it would back in seasons 3 and 4. It's kind of late in the game to decide you don't like it and retroactively punish people.

I'm glad it is finally being addressed, but I don't think this is the best way to address the problem. Something else needs to be done.

I think a better solution might be some sort of financial reset at the beginning of next season

1. Give every player enough cash to afford their next set of equipment upgrades if they only have 4 pieces of equipment (not counting CE)
2. Reset every team's cash after stadium upgrades next season based on level

WL teams - $50 million total
Pro teams - $40 million total
AAA teams - $30 million total
AA teams - $20 million total
Cap 46/42 - $10 million
Cap 38/34 - $7.5 million
Cap 30/26 - $5 million
Cap 22/18 -- $2.5 million
Cap 14/4 - starting cash

Then enforce rules from that point on.


why should teams that did not gut or exploit give cash back? that's just dumbing down the game for those that screwed up



How much would anyone really be giving back? Sure you may not have 40 mil in bank and 40 mil in equipment fund so you drop down some, but all players will have been given cash to pay for their next set of equipment. So you won't have to buy equipment the following season unless you want to change some players equipment around.

I have a feeling that when you account for not having to pay for anyone's equipment the following season, virtually no team will lose out.

Edited by Rage Kinard on Feb 19, 2010 13:28:57
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Also, wondering

Is Bort going to take a look at all the players who signed with teams as level 1s, loaded up on cash, either in pee wee or before heading to D-league. Then came to a 14 cap team with enough cash to pay for their level 16 upgrades giving their initial team a break in not having to pay for equipment the first season?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.