Originally posted by kelownamadden
+1
I couldn't explain better, though I will try to add my own point of view.
I think this is just another of the common mistakes this game makes from time to time. I kinda agree with the reason but plainly disagree on the way to enforce it. You cannot punish people for doing whatever they can (and the game allow) to try to compete with other people who is constantly exploiting the game, and this is something that has been happening on all 14 seasons of the game.
I have been here since day 15 Season 1, owned a team since day 1 season 2 and I have seen all the stories that happened on this game. I have been trying to run my team for 8 seasons they way it was meant to be played, first with some friends I brought into the game from a forum, with pretty bad results if you compare with other teams that started at the same time, getting tired that season after season there was a team on my league who had the "smartest guy of the class" to exploit the WR Screen, the HB Slam, the Powerbacks, the AEQ, the custom D-plays... every season something has happened that put teams who can't spend their lifes into the forums looking for the magic play or the season-exploit in a disadvantage that translate on poor winning records, which translates on not getting enough money Oand finally translates on not being able to pay equipment for your players which puts you in a difficult situation to compete against ultra-organized farm systems.
At first, during the 3-4 first seasons of this game, the key to be successful was having or not having enough money to boost and buy CE, now even spending a fucking bunch of money on this game you are screwed because you can't keep up with teams who are taking advantage (or did in the past) of loopholes on the system.
And I don't think that punishing people retroactively for this will ever help the game, you cannot play God by saying I will punish you if you do this when there are people still getting unfair advantages of past mistakes, so if a single team is punished for trying to compete on the game, in my opinion all the trophies that have been awarded for teams using sim bugs, exploits and dirty tricks should also be removed and all the results of all leagues should be reviewed and all the money awarded to teams who won trophies in an unfair manner should also be removed. Since I don't think this is ever going to be into consideration, you better think twice what you are going to do to fix this issue but I honestly think the solution you have proposed on the announcement is clearly not a good one.
Finally, if you accept a piece of advice, on online games, the key for fun is to allow an even level field for EVERYONE, or at least, as even as possible, since the perfect balance doesn't exist, but if you keep punishing people arbitrarily for your mistakes and poor designs you will soon run out all your customer base which at once was pretty amazing and that is the reason why this game still exists.
I think you're dead on about people trying to keep pace with others who cheated.....
The biggest exploit/cheaters in the game were the playoff ticket exploiters who got such a huge financial advantage over all newer teams that you literally had to have 3 farm teams to keep up with teams who cheated the game... I.e las Vegas gamblers... Catch needs to look inthe mirror on this crap and fix the system...
+1
I couldn't explain better, though I will try to add my own point of view.
I think this is just another of the common mistakes this game makes from time to time. I kinda agree with the reason but plainly disagree on the way to enforce it. You cannot punish people for doing whatever they can (and the game allow) to try to compete with other people who is constantly exploiting the game, and this is something that has been happening on all 14 seasons of the game.
I have been here since day 15 Season 1, owned a team since day 1 season 2 and I have seen all the stories that happened on this game. I have been trying to run my team for 8 seasons they way it was meant to be played, first with some friends I brought into the game from a forum, with pretty bad results if you compare with other teams that started at the same time, getting tired that season after season there was a team on my league who had the "smartest guy of the class" to exploit the WR Screen, the HB Slam, the Powerbacks, the AEQ, the custom D-plays... every season something has happened that put teams who can't spend their lifes into the forums looking for the magic play or the season-exploit in a disadvantage that translate on poor winning records, which translates on not getting enough money Oand finally translates on not being able to pay equipment for your players which puts you in a difficult situation to compete against ultra-organized farm systems.
At first, during the 3-4 first seasons of this game, the key to be successful was having or not having enough money to boost and buy CE, now even spending a fucking bunch of money on this game you are screwed because you can't keep up with teams who are taking advantage (or did in the past) of loopholes on the system.
And I don't think that punishing people retroactively for this will ever help the game, you cannot play God by saying I will punish you if you do this when there are people still getting unfair advantages of past mistakes, so if a single team is punished for trying to compete on the game, in my opinion all the trophies that have been awarded for teams using sim bugs, exploits and dirty tricks should also be removed and all the results of all leagues should be reviewed and all the money awarded to teams who won trophies in an unfair manner should also be removed. Since I don't think this is ever going to be into consideration, you better think twice what you are going to do to fix this issue but I honestly think the solution you have proposed on the announcement is clearly not a good one.
Finally, if you accept a piece of advice, on online games, the key for fun is to allow an even level field for EVERYONE, or at least, as even as possible, since the perfect balance doesn't exist, but if you keep punishing people arbitrarily for your mistakes and poor designs you will soon run out all your customer base which at once was pretty amazing and that is the reason why this game still exists.
I think you're dead on about people trying to keep pace with others who cheated.....
The biggest exploit/cheaters in the game were the playoff ticket exploiters who got such a huge financial advantage over all newer teams that you literally had to have 3 farm teams to keep up with teams who cheated the game... I.e las Vegas gamblers... Catch needs to look inthe mirror on this crap and fix the system...






























