User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Game Changes Discussion > Archived Changes > The Archetype Discussion Thread
Page:
 
NY
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nixa
So how did you know that nothing major would change in terms of sim mechanics? It happens all the time and can easily neuter a once great build. If that happened, would you stick it out with every single guy, or might you consider retiring a few? I don't know. I just don't understand why in the world you put almost 30,000 FP into something you weren't going to be using for over a month, especially knowing that if something went wrong you couldn't get a full refund.


Dude..there all level 1s..if something in the Sim changed he could've easilly fixed it..and
you want to know "why in the world u put almost 30,000 FP into something you weren't going to be using for over a month"...Its called preparation...if you knew how long that takes you would understand

 
Eagle0415
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TxSteve
Originally posted by Eagle0415

Scace i did as you asked however i only did defense players only as it is time consuming they will be coming back off shortly


In that case - my advice to you would be to file a ticket with support - be calm - be reasonable - and explain that you purchased 48 sets of custom equipment - in preparation of a 11 + season career - and now, because of the changes to player creation - you'd really like to get a full refund now (as opposed to 90% in 40 days).

I don't know what they will do - but you certainly make a VERY compelling case for a 'bend the rules' type scenario


Thanks TX glad finally someone understands my issue i won't be opposed to rebuilding them next season and starting over but i just felt losing so much was unfair to me and i know there are others out there in my sistuation
 
TxSteve
Not A Mod
offline
Link
 
Take it to the other thread - Catch 22 answering questions for the next 2 hours ---->
 
TxSteve
Not A Mod
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3762875
 
NY
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
I see -- and I support a full refund should you choose to retire and recreate. The tough thing is the PeeWee leagues where players actually use CE and would expect the same treatment. So while I support you, I think you are SOL on this one.


He's not in a peewee league tho
 
nixa37
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by King Of NY
As his Head Coach i know he has it on all players..I have seen it on all of them when he first set the team up and then we decided he wasn't gonna win so he un-equipped them all..Like Honestly..you go build 55 Players and put them in a 14 Cap..so that's Level 1's V.s. Level 14's...CE Equipment is not really needed for that season so why should he have to pay for it if now we are going to have a new system?


Show me one person who suggested he should have to pay for it (and remember by pay for it we're only talking about 10% of the actual cost to begin with) if he wasn't using it. I know I've tried to give some advice as to what he could do to possibly get the full amount back if he didn't plan on using it. I haven't noticed anyone suggesting otherwise.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nixa37
Well I addressed the post you quoted, though I still don't quite understand why it was necessary. The archetypes we're getting are essentially balanced with different strengths and weaknesses. If you allow people to choose whatever they want, at most positions its obvious what's best, so they end up with the strengths of the other archetypes combined without the weaknesses. Why is this so hard to understand?

As for the issue with your system, well its not really backwards compatible with existing players. Without redoing a lot of stuff, there is no way to let already created players go back and create custom SA trees, and if you did they'd have unfair knowledge as to what AEQ they already rolled, thus allowing them to better leverage their AEQ with compatible custom SA's. That's the difference between what's happening and what you're proposing. The only thing that changes for current players is a new one time option to switch over to the new system by simply choosing an archetype and an SA. You're system requires them to undo all the SA's they've already done, completely rebuild their SA tree's, and then refill them with SP's they may or may not get back. See the difference in complexity?


It is really only complex if you feel you need to allow older players to adjust. There is nothing written in stone that says this has to happen. We hear all the time that "this is a beta". The game changes every season, multiple times per season.

That is very weak reasoning not to do something that would allow far more creativity.

But I'll play the game -- why not have different SA trees for the different archetypes? That still keeps things in a nice, tidy little box for the people worried about exploits, but offers more variation based on archetype chosen.

Now get out of the box, and allow different sets of SA's to be chosen (trees built) based on archetypes. Now get further out of the box and have the trees built over the course of a players career (levels unlocking the next part of the tree). -- and depending on how you chose to build within the archetype, certain SA's would be available and certain ones would not.

See where I'm going here. Far more fun than the current method and would lead to great customization among builds.
 
Catch22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TxSteve
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3762875


Discuss here for the next two hours. I'll unlock this thread when I lock the other one.
 
Catch22
offline
Link
 
ok use this thread again for Archetype talk
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Honestly, what should have been done, is the development team should have made players at plateau level that each have a different role within their position. Then reverse engineer the builds to determine how to set-up the archetypes.

As for balancing, specialty archetypes should get 3 majors and 3 minors (the price of being a specialist), meanwhile balanced/combo archetypes should get 4 majors and 4 minors (the price of being a generalist). This way the specialty archetypes would be less well-rounded and the balanced/combo archetypes would be more well-rounded but not as good at any one area as a specialist.

Something like...

Power HB
Majors: strength, carrying, stamina (0.67)
Minors: speed, agility, confidence
Bonuses: Power tree SAs, all of them
Penalties: Elusive tree SAs, all of them

Combo HB
Majors: strength, speed, agility, carrying (0.5)
Minors: confidence, catching, stamina, vision
Bonuses: None
Penalties: None

Elusive HB
Majors: Speed, agility, vision (0.67)
Minors: carrying, confidence, catching
Bonuses: Elusive tree SAs, all of them
Penalties: Power tree SAs, all of them

The balance would be in the fact that specialists can push their key attributes considerably higher than balanced/combos, but in exchange they would be one trick ponies. The balanced/combos would be more well-rounded, but lack attaining the same level in key attributes... this being a contested build driven game, would be more than enough balance.
 
Link
 
To the "casual" player that doesn't want to spend hours reading all the Forums, guides, threads, etc. this will either make or break it for them..

For the hardcore gamer, that wants ALL the information, %'s, and likes to break everything down to find that perfect player or exploit, then this is great.

It's going to happen so go with it.. Will it help fix the SIM ? Will this benefit the game overall? Time will tell.

 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Warlock
As for balancing, specialty archetypes should get 3 majors and 3 minors (the price of being a specialist), meanwhile balanced/combo archetypes should get 4 majors and 4 minors (the price of being a generalist).


Yep.
 
throg420 DTD
offline
Link
 
My suggestion is simple, let's try 2 put this thing 2 a vote.
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ken-in-rockwall
Will it help fix the SIM ?



Here's what's going to happen. More imbalanced players are going to result. This will take most of a year to play out and truly take effect. Instead of being able to fix the sim to be more fundamentally solid such that imbalance only works strategically, Bort will be forced to heed the cries of those who built a specialty archetype and don't want to see it nerfed. In a sense, it won't be much different than the first generation of players with nerfs on top of nerfs on top of nerfs, but it just means we'll be back to square one a year from now.
 
Catch22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo

Here's what's going to happen. More imbalanced players are going to result. This will take most of a year to play out and truly take effect. Instead of being able to fix the sim to be more fundamentally solid such that imbalance only works strategically, Bort will be forced to heed the cries of those who built a specialty archetype and don't want to see it nerfed. In a sense, it won't be much different than the first generation of players with nerfs on top of nerfs on top of nerfs, but it just means we'll be back to square one a year from now.


Except we're actually going to be testing end game builds based on the archetypes and making adjustments as needed. But go ahead and keep thinking we have no clue what we're doing. I do things differently, the old testing system isn't the new testing system.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.