User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Coaches - ideas for them to spend money on (and other ideas)
Page:
 
DL24
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Phil Jackson
Coachs need to be available to EVERYONE not 440 day players for this to ever work. There is no legit reasoning behind the 440 day thing other than to appeal to the s1 players. VA's were at least lvl 25, this is just flat out ridiculous.

If someone just joined the game today, they would have to create a player and have that player not technically play any games but rot on his home screen for almost A YEAR AND 3 MONTHS.

How is this going to help bring new users to the game?

This is a bullshit addition that only caters to specific agent's agendas.


You sound exactly like dpride

"I joined too late, now I'm bitter!!!!!!!"
 
Captain Kaos
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by crazy454

Make the Coaches that are 440 days old start with more Pts and XP

Make the younger coaches start with less.


I personally like this. The ability is open to everyone, but the longer you wait, the better of a coach you can be. More experience playing will result in more experience to coach your players from.

EDIT: Should create a scale, though. Not just 440 days or not. Need to create certain steps to start with a certain amount of points/xp.
Edited by cwisler on Sep 7, 2009 14:46:55
 
ramart103
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DL24
Originally posted by Phil Jackson

Coachs need to be available to EVERYONE not 440 day players for this to ever work. There is no legit reasoning behind the 440 day thing other than to appeal to the s1 players. VA's were at least lvl 25, this is just flat out ridiculous.

If someone just joined the game today, they would have to create a player and have that player not technically play any games but rot on his home screen for almost A YEAR AND 3 MONTHS.

How is this going to help bring new users to the game?

This is a bullshit addition that only caters to specific agent's agendas.


You sound exactly like dpride

"I joined too late, now I'm bitter!!!!!!!"


how many S1 players do you have waiting in retierment?

 
DL24
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ramart103
Originally posted by DL24

Originally posted by Phil Jackson


Coachs need to be available to EVERYONE not 440 day players for this to ever work. There is no legit reasoning behind the 440 day thing other than to appeal to the s1 players. VA's were at least lvl 25, this is just flat out ridiculous.

If someone just joined the game today, they would have to create a player and have that player not technically play any games but rot on his home screen for almost A YEAR AND 3 MONTHS.

How is this going to help bring new users to the game?

This is a bullshit addition that only caters to specific agent's agendas.


You sound exactly like dpride

"I joined too late, now I'm bitter!!!!!!!"


how many S1 players do you have waiting in retierment?



My highest level player was created in season 5...

Just tired of hearing the same old refrain from that pair, and pointing out how similar they sound.
 
HEY YOU GUYS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DL24
You sound exactly like dpride

"I joined too late, now I'm bitter!!!!!!!"


I've been here longer than you have. I had s1 players just retired them back in s7 or s8 i think.

But back to my argument.

What logic can you provide that makes having to wait 440 days a good idea?

This is just building a wall preventing new users from ever wanting to commit long-term to GLB. For someone to have a coach in this game they should not have to wait nearly a year 1/2 before having that option available to them.

Not to mention it WILL widen the gap between upcoming AAA teams etc that are planning their run for the pros and one already in the World League and Pro Leagues. World League and Pro League teams that exist now will have farm teams to feed into them (which is smart, not knocking it) and a STABLE of coach's to choose from and develop. This is just going to create another 10 seasons of s1 player dominance.
 
HEY YOU GUYS
offline
Link
 
I just see no reason why Coaches cannot be implemented like Players. Create a Player and there would be a tab for Coach, only up the FP price to like 500-1000 or so to create one.

Even if this was done, I would not 100% support coaches as I think it is going to cause a plethora of problems next season. But this is just one major flaw with how the current coach scheme is going to work.
 
ramart103
offline
Link
 
DL24, do you really think that coaching implementation won't favor early season players? I don't see how it couldn't. I'm not against the idea per say, just don't think that it's well thought out.
If this were implemented in S13 intead of S12, there would be time to discuss all the issues that so many people seem to be voiceing. If not, how about a test league to work out the kinks?
 
DL24
offline
Link
 
No, I actually am partially in agreement with you. It sucks that season 1 guys will get another chance to stay on top when I thought it was finally my turn But I was just pointing out how you sound so alike, and you two changed your usernames to match old guys associated with the NBA. How cute
 
DL24
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ramart103
DL24, do you really think that coaching implementation won't favor early season players? I don't see how it couldn't. I'm not against the idea per say, just don't think that it's well thought out.
If this were implemented in S13 intead of S12, there would be time to discuss all the issues that so many people seem to be voiceing. If not, how about a test league to work out the kinks?


plz read post above
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DL24
You sound exactly like dpride

"I joined too late, now I'm bitter!!!!!!!"


Exactly.

It's like what stalkers often say, "If I can't have her, nobody can!!!!"

I remember when the idea was conceived over a year ago (Don't believe me about the time frame? Check the date stamps on Drifter's epic thread).

People, then arguing out of self-interest, wanted there to be no decline or even plateau, that players would go on forever. The main argument they gave was that was how MMO's work. Be glad Bort held firm with them, and I and others who realized the need for aging helped get "no decline" added to the NGTH list.

If I were God, I'd however force today's whiners into an alternate universe where Bort folded to the "Don't kill my players!" crowd and their players would never be as good as the Season 1 players (none of my players played before Season 2, btw).

But, very wisely, Bort held firm on aging and the best players will be players created later. I created some players much later so that I could still have some near the top when aging took out my first batch.

However, Bort was also open to ideas for what players could do when they aged, and coaching was the least controversial.

A fleshed out idea as Bort has laid out is necessary so that they're still fun to play. As for those who would be fine with coaches, if only they could make them, I say, "Jealous, much?" I won't be able to make them until Season 13 myself. And coaches won't be the stars of the game; players will remain the stars of the game, and the best players will be those created later. I agree with that, but you won't find that in other MMO's.
 
HEY YOU GUYS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DL24
No, I actually am partially in agreement with you. It sucks that season 1 guys will get another chance to stay on top when I thought it was finally my turn But I was just pointing out how you sound so alike, and you two changed your usernames to match old guys associated with the NBA. How cute


More for added humor factor. But I will agree with that statement, we tend to see eye to eye on a lot of topics. I think our posting styles are VERY different however.

But lets keep this on topic.

The only logic that I see for having 440 day old coaches is to benefit s1 players.

If someone else can enlighten me as to more reasoning behind it I'm more than willing to listen with an open mind.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ramart103
DL24, do you really think that coaching implementation won't favor early season players?


Of course it will, and in what way is that a problem? Later-created players will still be the best players, and players will be the main focus of the game as always. The stars of the game will be those created later, because coaches won't be stars in the same way that top players are.
 
HEY YOU GUYS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
However, Bort was also open to ideas for what players could do when they aged, and coaching was the least controversial.

A fleshed out idea as Bort has laid out is necessary so that they're still fun to play. As for those who would be fine with coaches, if only they could make them, I say, "Jealous, much?" I won't be able to make them until Season 13 myself. And coaches won't be the stars of the game; players will remain the stars of the game, and the best players will be those created later. I agree with that, but you won't find that in other MMO's.


This is the first somewhat reasonable argument I have heard for the 440 day mark on coaches. It's not a jealously thing however it is blockade thing.

440 Days is a completely unreasonable number to wait in order for your player to become a coach. I would be fine if Bort wanted to make a 120-160 day minimum before able to retire and make a coach as that at least forces someone to participate in the player creation/management aspect of this game. But to make someone wait over a year before something becomes available, is like roping off a corner of GLB and making it the V.I.P. section.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Phil Jackson
The only logic that I see for having 440 day old coaches is to benefit s1 players.

If someone else can enlighten me as to more reasoning behind it I'm more than willing to listen with an open mind.


A compromise for Season 1 players because most MMO's don't do aging at all.

I was very vocally pro-aging, due to both realism and the fact that newer players needed their turn in the spotlight. But there also had to be something so that people didn't completely lose their characters.
 
Staz
offline
Link
 
That just makes sense to me. Very rarely do you see a player leave in the middle of his career to become a "coach". If you want your PLAYER to become a COACH, isn't it best to let him play out his career? Coaches will have more of a behind the scenes style approach and will work in conjunction with the players. Those guys on the field will inevitably determine the outcome of the game. Those Season 4, 5, 6 players will rise to the top while those S1 players "decay" and eventually become coaches. However, they'll still have to train and what not to become WORTH anything. They won't automatically become a top notch addition to the front office. Just like the players, too, those who become coaches later on in the game will have more information available to them and will be able to build better coaches. S1 guys will always be the guinea pigs, and you will no doubt see changes in how coaches perform.

Not sure what the big deal is...
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.