User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
soulellis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mat McBriar
Originally posted by soulellis

do any of you actually receive a reply from an admin about these problems ?

I rarely bother with the forums but i actually came to look for AI problems because i have noticed this season particularly that the teams i coach are not following exactly the AI.

I own and coach my own team and i then headcoach as a GM for another.

I have noticed that there are some random plays that are been run that are not in my AI whatsoever.

It is not all of the time for each quarter. 80 % of the time it works ok but i would say this season 20 % of the time bizarre random plays have been happening that are not in my AI.

What is going on ?


Check that you don't have any holes in your AI. You can always have 'catch alls' at the bottom of a defensive AI (or even an offensive AI for FG or 'Go for it' situations ).

For example a common mistake is to have your inputs broken by yardage and listing them 0-3, 4-7, 8-10, etc. They're leaving gaps and should have it set 0-3, 3-7, 7-10, 10+.



Thank you for your reply

I do know about the gaps in yardage as i have had that problem in the past.

I have come back to the thread just to say i have actually discovered the problem and other people should also check this too.

The problem i realised was that the actual play i was wanting to run was not actually one of the plays in my my offensive playbook.

I know this might seem a basic error on my part but its something that others could also be overlooking. They may think or assume the play has been included in the playbook but it may be missing.

 
West Coast
offline
Link
 
my team today had a game

and in its first drive it had 4th and 9.5

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=612002&pbp_id=8094668

we did not go for it another time

but i tested my AI and it said punt

same for this other game

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=620989&pbp_id=7681042

4th and long and we still went for it?
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
I have another example of the DAI not being followed. Our D is entirely custom with all inputs covered, and I have nothing in my DPC that looks like this: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=614115&pbp_id=9518143

Tested the situation and it came back with my normal first down singleback set of inputs, none of which are remotely similar to what's on the screen. As I've noted previously in this thread, these bugs usually only crop up once or twice a season, and don't happen repeatedly in the same game. Still, the fact that it happens at all is concerning.
 
Chris Hansen
offline
Link
 
0 replies
 
GlobalX39
offline
Link
 
Casual team here, simple AI right? I set it to 100% run in a scrim this morning with auto adjust off and we had 18 pass attempts. Somethings not right here.
 
backstop
offline
Link
 
+1

No shit!
 
Headbutt
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Echrest
Casual team here, simple AI right? I set it to 100% run in a scrim this morning with auto adjust off and we had 18 pass attempts. Somethings not right here.


That does happen in causal teams with the basic AI and it's not necessarily a bug. Check the game and see exactly where those passing plays happened. End of the second and fourth quarters you will see passing as clock management comes in to play.

You will also see passes on third and long and possibly second and long too no matter what you set the run % too because those situations are passing situations and arise when the running isn't working well to start with.

I've tested this with the basic AI because I also do the game planning for a casual league team. It's frustrating that it doesn't do exactly what you want but if you look to see what it is doing, it does make sense.

The run % setting in the basic AI has the biggest effect on first down and second and less the 6-8 yards and third and short. Other situations will start to deviate from that setting.
Edited by Headbutt on Aug 3, 2009 20:30:07
Edited by Headbutt on Aug 3, 2009 20:29:38
 
Cryptotich
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Headbutt
That does happen in causal teams with the basic AI and it's not necessarily a bug. Check the game and see exactly where those passing plays happened. End of the second and fourth quarters you will see passing as clock management comes in to play.

You will also see passes on third and long and possibly second and long too no matter what you set the run % too because those situations are passing situations and arise when the running isn't working well to start with.

I've tested this with the basic AI because I also do the game planning for a casual league team. It's frustrating that it doesn't do exactly what you want but if you look to see what it is doing, it does make sense.

The run % setting in the basic AI has the biggest effect on first down and second and less the 6-8 yards and third and short. Other situations will start to deviate from that setting.


Headbutt is correct, the Basic AI, does take into account down, and distance, on casual teams. In 3rd and long situations it will more than likely call a long pass to try to get you the first down. If you want more control of this as an OC, you should shoot for a OC job on a regular league team.
 
CardinalX
offline
Link
 
I apologize if this has been addressed before. 300+ posts and 23 pages... i don't have the patience to search.

Casual League team

settings:

Automatically Adjust In-Game Strategy to What's Working and away from What's Not Working?

NO, STICK WITH MY SETTINGS

Deviation setting: 0%

Run/Pass Pct:

100% Run 0% Pass


ok, that's my settings.... 1st play of the game.....


Q1 10:37 1st & 10 on OWN 35.5
PW QB1 pass to PW TE1 over the middle (dropped - incomplete)

what the hell????? why is there a pass play called??????

IF it's 3rd and long.... and/ or down by alot... i could understand that.

but under what circumstances is this called for?

help me out someone?

thanks

btw, what are 1% settings for then? 1% should mean a slim chance... but a chance.

a 0% chance SHOULD mean... under no circumstances should any passes be made. 3rd and 45... down by 105... whatever.


NO MEANS NO!! at least, that's what my gf tells me


but let's not lose sight of the main issue here:




it was 1st and 10. Zero - Zero score

and i had everything set to 100% run.








and it passed
Edited by CardinalX on Aug 10, 2009 23:37:52
Edited by CardinalX on Aug 10, 2009 23:36:23
 
kuaggie
offline
Link
 
Is anyone having an issue w/ teams ignoring gameplan and package issues?

The play in question http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=716501&pbp_id=5580266

yeah we scored a TD wohoo! but i'm utterly confused as to how this play was called.

My input in the AI tester is

4th Q
78 seconds

opponent's 11
2nd & 10
trailing by 11

0 TO left for me, 3 for opponent and clock is running

I get the appropriate output which consists of 4 packages.

Next to all the packages there's something in parantheses that says "(run/pass)" which may be the source of the problem but i can't figure it out O_O.

not a single one of these packages has a run play in them. Hopefully a mod can take a look at this and verify it....or point out my mistake (although i've been looking at it for the last hour and REALLY don't see it).
 
Hikariu
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.