User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Demotion Ideas for the WPL
Page:
 
jamz
offline
Link
 
Step 1: Promote inaugural teams to WPL
Step 2: Strip all pro leagues of title, make them a Cloud.
Step 3: Demote guts, Promote AAA teams
Step 4: Shuffle the cloud
Step 5: Prepare for forum warfare
Step 6: ????
Step 7: Profit

Seriously though, if theres a WPL, and thats the ultimate goal, who really cares which region / road you take to get there, as long as you get there.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
Originally posted by ICRockets

Originally posted by HULK


Honestly, I think you need to move the top teams around. Spread them out. Move teams from USA and Canada to leagues like Southeast Asia and Oceania. Otherwise, it will take like 8 season to even out.


If you move a WPL-eligible USAPL team to SEAPL right now they'd go 14-2 at worst, and more likely would run the table. How would that promote parity?


Bort needs to answer this question....

Is the plan to have the World League represent "the best of the best", or just to be "some of the best and the best of the rest"?

As it is right now, his top 4 teams from each conference is just going to be some of the best and the best of the rest. It's gonna leave out a whole lot of top teams that really won't have a realistic chance of making it to the World League for another 3-4 seasons if ever thanks to player decline and recruiting issues (from not being in the WL and not being in an easy league to get to the WL).

If Bort wants the World League to be the best of the best, he needs to start it out that way. Take a look at the "Top 25 Pro Teams", how many of those are missing from the current list of 32 teams? These are the teams that have poured their hearts and souls into build a GLB community. It would be a real shame if Bort screwed them because they play in a tougher league because there hasn't been a world league for the past 10 seasons.


I see you have a player on the washington wolfpack.

A little bias to USAPL are we?
Edited by ImTheScientist on Jul 27, 2009 19:58:05
 
Link
 
Really don't see what the problem w/ taking the top 4 from each league and having the non-playoff teams demoted to their original league. (think originally it was garts idea) Then the 2 conference champions from each pro league move up. You might have to demote some teams down but w/ cpu teams and teams starting over, it shouldn't be a problem. Also should help w/ the parity since free agents will go towards the path of least resistance and improve the lower leagues.
 
the man of doom
Miracles happen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jamz
Step 1: Promote inaugural teams to WPL
Step 2: Strip all pro leagues of title, make them a Cloud.
Step 3: Demote guts, Promote AAA teams
Step 4: Shuffle the cloud
Step 5: Prepare for forum warfare
Step 6: ????
Step 7: Profit

Seriously though, if theres a WPL, and thats the ultimate goal, who really cares which region / road you take to get there, as long as you get there.


+1
 
Link
 
Originally posted by jamz
Step 1: Promote inaugural teams to WPL
Step 2: Strip all pro leagues of title, make them a Cloud.
Step 3: Demote guts, Promote AAA teams
Step 4: Shuffle the cloud
Step 5: Prepare for forum warfare
Step 6: ????
Step 7: Profit

Seriously though, if theres a WPL, and thats the ultimate goal, who really cares which region / road you take to get there, as long as you get there.


If there is a WPL then its all just one bracket anyways. You are right jamz...but others would freak out. Although over half of GLB's teams have been stripped of identity and thrown into a cloud so why not just finish the job.
 
Octowned
offline
Link
 
I hate to hijack this, but speaking of DEMOTION..

how about PROMOTION

I have a suggestion that got moved to EPIC and needs to be seen within 2 days, Bort. Basically, promoting teams get 1 preferred region. Wtf? How about a few more...


Okay thanks, carry on
 
ryan_grant-25
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ryan_grant-25
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by ryan_grant-25


Here is how it should work. take the best 4 from each conference now. and if a team guts, just put them in the cloud. But next season (assuming we have a WPL), have a Pro league tournament going. The winner of that gets in, and if there is more room in WPL, then the 2nd team will get in, ect. ect. I think as long as the team has a .750 winning %, they should be eligible for this tournament. If a team doesn't enter the tournament, there is no chance they can get into WPL


Doesn't that make the playoffs in Pro leagues completely pointless other than a trophy?


ok, so you want to have it as the winner of the tournament has to make the conference finals at least? if he doesn't, then you go down the tournament chain..


thoughts bort?
 
lukin83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ryan_grant-25
Originally posted by ryan_grant-25

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by ryan_grant-25



Here is how it should work. take the best 4 from each conference now. and if a team guts, just put them in the cloud. But next season (assuming we have a WPL), have a Pro league tournament going. The winner of that gets in, and if there is more room in WPL, then the 2nd team will get in, ect. ect. I think as long as the team has a .750 winning %, they should be eligible for this tournament. If a team doesn't enter the tournament, there is no chance they can get into WPL


Doesn't that make the playoffs in Pro leagues completely pointless other than a trophy?


ok, so you want to have it as the winner of the tournament has to make the conference finals at least? if he doesn't, then you go down the tournament chain..


thoughts bort?


Don't hold your breath. I am still waiting for his thoughts from about 12 pages ago...
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Octowned
I hate to hijack this, but speaking of DEMOTION..

how about PROMOTION

I have a suggestion that got moved to EPIC and needs to be seen within 2 days, Bort. Basically, promoting teams get 1 preferred region. Wtf? How about a few more...


Okay thanks, carry on


Promotion is the easy part of the equation. Take the top 4 teams from each Pro league and move up.
 
DM
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DM
This thread will be f*cking huge.

FIRST PAGE GUYS.


didn't dissapoint
 
ShotPutNC
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
Originally posted by ICRockets

Originally posted by HULK


Honestly, I think you need to move the top teams around. Spread them out. Move teams from USA and Canada to leagues like Southeast Asia and Oceania. Otherwise, it will take like 8 season to even out.


If you move a WPL-eligible USAPL team to SEAPL right now they'd go 14-2 at worst, and more likely would run the table. How would that promote parity?


Bort needs to answer this question....

Is the plan to have the World League represent "the best of the best", or just to be "some of the best and the best of the rest"?

As it is right now, his top 4 teams from each conference is just going to be some of the best and the best of the rest. It's gonna leave out a whole lot of top teams that really won't have a realistic chance of making it to the World League for another 3-4 seasons if ever thanks to player decline and recruiting issues (from not being in the WL and not being in an easy league to get to the WL).

If Bort wants the World League to be the best of the best, he needs to start it out that way. Take a look at the "Top 25 Pro Teams", how many of those are missing from the current list of 32 teams? These are the teams that have poured their hearts and souls into build a GLB community. It would be a real shame if Bort screwed them because they play in a tougher league because there hasn't been a world league for the past 10 seasons.


Not what you want to hear but there is no way Bort would create something like the WPL based on Agent driven rankings. If anything like this were to happen, it would be bort creating a forumla like the BCS to select the top 32 and do we really want that? Region biases occur and while this may not be the best for competition, it will promote parity. And honestly its those teams fault who can't make it out of the second round of their own PL playoffs.

I honestly think the 4 divisions in each conference would be the best. If you make it divisions by league you can preserve some regional rivalries and each season you can drop the worst two teams from each league this coming year and promote the two teams in each PL's conference championship. Then you can send those two back to the PL they came from because they are already separated by league. The only issue would be then which leagues are in which conference.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Originally posted by Octowned

I hate to hijack this, but speaking of DEMOTION..

how about PROMOTION

I have a suggestion that got moved to EPIC and needs to be seen within 2 days, Bort. Basically, promoting teams get 1 preferred region. Wtf? How about a few more...


Okay thanks, carry on


Promotion is the easy part of the equation. Take the top 4 teams from each Pro league and move up.


Think he means promotion from the cloud....?
 
Hikariu
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by ryan_grant-25

Here is how it should work. take the best 4 from each conference now. and if a team guts, just put them in the cloud. But next season (assuming we have a WPL), have a Pro league tournament going. The winner of that gets in, and if there is more room in WPL, then the 2nd team will get in, ect. ect. I think as long as the team has a .750 winning %, they should be eligible for this tournament. If a team doesn't enter the tournament, there is no chance they can get into WPL


Doesn't that make the playoffs in Pro leagues completely pointless other than a trophy?


Tournament entry is dumb.
 
the man of doom
Miracles happen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lukin83
Originally posted by ryan_grant-25

Originally posted by ryan_grant-25


Originally posted by Bort



Originally posted by ryan_grant-25




Here is how it should work. take the best 4 from each conference now. and if a team guts, just put them in the cloud. But next season (assuming we have a WPL), have a Pro league tournament going. The winner of that gets in, and if there is more room in WPL, then the 2nd team will get in, ect. ect. I think as long as the team has a .750 winning %, they should be eligible for this tournament. If a team doesn't enter the tournament, there is no chance they can get into WPL


Doesn't that make the playoffs in Pro leagues completely pointless other than a trophy?


ok, so you want to have it as the winner of the tournament has to make the conference finals at least? if he doesn't, then you go down the tournament chain..


thoughts bort?


Don't hold your breath. I am still waiting for his thoughts from about 12 pages ago...


he never commented on the soccer idea?
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ryan_grant-25
Originally posted by ryan_grant-25

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by ryan_grant-25



Here is how it should work. take the best 4 from each conference now. and if a team guts, just put them in the cloud. But next season (assuming we have a WPL), have a Pro league tournament going. The winner of that gets in, and if there is more room in WPL, then the 2nd team will get in, ect. ect. I think as long as the team has a .750 winning %, they should be eligible for this tournament. If a team doesn't enter the tournament, there is no chance they can get into WPL


Doesn't that make the playoffs in Pro leagues completely pointless other than a trophy?


ok, so you want to have it as the winner of the tournament has to make the conference finals at least? if he doesn't, then you go down the tournament chain..


thoughts bort?


I don't think we want to do a tournament and a world league both. There's enough to work with from wins in league play IMO.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.